Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we've lost something by not having a standard funeral outfit

195 replies

Sleeptightnightlight · 19/11/2022 22:15

So, this is musing really. Over the last couple of years I've been to a few funerals and at all there has been the request for no black/dark colours. (Several specifically asking for bright colours etc).

I'm not in any way criticising the individual choices of the bereaved people (frankly if they'd asked me to turn up in a gimp suit and tutu I would have if I thought it would help them through the day). I absolutely think people should choose whatever dress code they want.

But I can't help wondering if this move to colour/'normal clothes' means we lose something in terms of other people recognising people who are in mourning.

For example I remember being at a service station barely holding it together and it occured to me that being dressed in what was basically festival garb no one serving me etc had any idea we were on the way to a funeral.

I think in the past people would wear a black armband on their suit so everyone would know and perhaps that person would be treated more kindly/gently?

AIBU to think having recognizable 'mourning clothes' had a social function that we have lost/are losing? Maybe on a society level we need some new sign that someone has suffered a loss?

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 08:33

YANBU and personally, I’d prefer to wear a big black hat with a big black lacy veil that comes down to my elbows like a Victorian widow.

Goldenboysmum · 20/11/2022 08:29

When my son died we all wore black, but as I always loved him in red we asked people to wear something red.

So the women wore red scarves and the men red ties. Even the funeral directors wore red ties at my request.

Everyone also wore odd socks as my son never wore matching socks.

Due to covid rules at the time, we could only have 20 people at the service, but at the burial there was a few hundred, there was even one of his friends dressed as a chicken! They had some silly pact, and he asked me beforehand if it would be ok and i said yes!

makenomistake · 20/11/2022 08:25

I've always told my husband that I want people to wear black at my funeral.

BeautifulWar · 20/11/2022 08:21

People are sad whatever they wear though. I don't believe in forced solemnity. People who are grieving go through a range of emotions which we carry around every day, not just on funeral say. Grieving is the real, devastating process of losing someone, 'mourning' is for show.

BackOnTheBandWagon · 20/11/2022 08:14

People obviously feel differently and strongly about this, but my take is that there's nothing wrong with wearing jeans to a funeral, what matters is that you care and you honour the person in your own way, you're not putting on a show. We had some people who didn't come to my Dad's funeral as they don't like funerals. No issue. Doesn't mean they care any less.

Squeezedsquash · 20/11/2022 08:08

When I was a toddler, my parents had friends whose same aged child to me died.

Members of the youth club that the Dads worked at turned out. These were, in my mum’s words, “tough lads” who strayed either side of the law. My mum always talks about the guy who turned up in full eighties black ripped jeans, black leather jacket, etc… “because it was the only black stuff I had, and I wanted to do it proper, do you think she’ll (the deceased toddler) mind?”.

Bring the attitude you need to the funeral, whatever that looks like, in a way that it as respectful as possible.

WaddleAway · 20/11/2022 08:03

And it was most definitely a celebration of his short life, Im sorry if that offends anyone.

WaddleAway · 20/11/2022 08:02

2pinkginsplease · 19/11/2022 23:12

Surely it doesn’t matter what anyone wears to a funeral? It’s the paying of respects that’s more important rather than what the person wears.

I do tend to wear black but my grans favourite colour was green and my mum, aunt and I wore that colour of top or coat as a mark of respect.

Exactly this. When my brother died in horrific circumstances I couldn’t have cared less what anyone wore to the funeral. I didn’t even notice. Can’t remember what I wore either. I was just so grateful to everyone who came to pay their respects.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 20/11/2022 08:00

When my Dad died I couldn't tell you what people wore to the funeral. It didn't bother me in the slightest. It was a massive funeral with over 500 people there and we had a service of thanksgiving after his cremation. Going on what people here have said all of that is disrespectful, however, it was what my Dad wanted.

If you are concentrating on what people are wearing then it just seems petty to me.

meditrina · 20/11/2022 07:56

Funerary and mourning rituals grew up because they help people - it happens across cultures. Doing things like arranging funerals and answering sympathy letters gives people something to do (plus there's practical admin as well)

And gestures of mourning (such as clothing, armbands or hair ornaments) can show the world who is in mourning, giving a chance of extra consideration

I think there is still a point in life when you decide you need a good black coat.

Energeticenoch · 20/11/2022 07:54

I totally disagree. We are a country of many cultures religions and traditions. Some cultures wearing black simply isn’t on our radar. Funerals are organised quickly, often with just a couple of hours confirmation of the exact time. People come as they are. It might be in formal wear, it might be in a football kit if you’ve come from training, or in jeans or your gym gear, whatever. Nobody cares. It matters that you come and you support the bereaved. I’ve never worn black to even a family funeral, last one I wore a lovely flowery dress and a fake fur jacket.

DesignerRecliner · 20/11/2022 07:51

Some of the judgemental posts on this thread are revolting, and @HeddaGarbled suggesting that funerals go with 'fashion' is outrageous.

Times change, funerals do not have to be somber and depressing, it's what the living family of the deceased choose. I've unfortunately been to many funerals these last 2 years & the ones with everyone in black and a wake back at the local village hall have been quiet and respectful. The 'colourful' ones have been quiet and respectful too. Clothing doesn't change the grief being experienced but it may help to make the funeral feel more personal to the family who have lost someone

Hidingawaytoday · 20/11/2022 07:49

bloodywhitecat · 19/11/2022 23:14

It seems I did DH's funeral all wrong.

No. You didn't. A funeral is for the living, and should bring comfort to those closest to the deceased. If what you did was right for you and your joint families then you did it absolutely right.

And I'm very sorry for your loss Flowers

Wishawisha · 20/11/2022 07:47

VestaTilley · 19/11/2022 23:00

YANBU; I always wear smart black clothes to funerals (unless specially requested to wear colours, but that’s not happened yet).

I think we’re losing a lot as a society by becoming more informal in every sense. No sense of occasion anymore, formality, what’s appropriate behaviour in different situations (all those people holding phones up in the King’s face when the Queen died!) - it’s just a mess.

I’m not sure there’s any solution, but I don’t think our very relaxed society now is that good really.

Oh all of this.

I’ve never been to a “wear bright colours” funeral and I would comply but otherwise it’s always black.

We likely have a funeral in the next year that I’d like to take my DC to. I’ll dress them in dark colours too.

Still.. it just makes you look like you’re going to work doesn’t it? I do quite like that in the past you were expected to wear black for a defined period - a month or two - and that was that.

As a society we are so much more casual now. I find it funny to think that when my kids go up to high school they’ll be wearing a tie every day when DH doesn’t even wear one to work.

luckylavender · 20/11/2022 07:44

I agree

Wherediditallgo · 20/11/2022 07:42

I agree but the clothes are a symptom of something deeper. We are so busy “celebrating the life” of someone the grief is often not processed properly. I know someone who is still struggling 5 years on and is still in the very raw phase of it all. We bottle up our emotions so tightly in this country that the anguish we see in other cultures seems strange to us but I wonder if they work through it better?

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 07:41

People grieve differently.

Personally I prefer to wear dark colours to a funeral and I like the traditional and rites of passage because it's comforting. I would feel very awkward in bright colours, but wearing bright colours might help someone else.

RampantIvy · 20/11/2022 07:35

A few years ago two brothers nearby were murdered by their father. Their favourite colour was yellow so everyone was asked to wear something yellow to the funeral. One of the boys had been a pupil at DD's school so all the pupils were asked to do the same on the day of the funeral.

It was such an awful time.

MissHavershamReturns · 20/11/2022 05:29

I prefer to wear black. I went to a funeral recently where the widow asked that no one cry at any point in the day. I obviously tried very hard to adhere to this for her but it was so difficult

onlythreenow · 20/11/2022 05:01

As for recognising that people are mourning - I wouldn't actually want people to recognise that I am mourning. Everybody loses someone they love at some stage of their life, I don't feel the need for special treatment when it's my turn. Anyone close would know, that's all that matters.

fruktsoda · 20/11/2022 03:09

I think people should just do what they want/what the family has requested. It shouldn't have to be one-size-fits-all, and the further we move from judging others for wearing certain colours to certain events, the better. As others have said, unless someone looks particularly formally dressed and downcast, I wouldn't assume that black clothes mean they're dressed for a funeral.

Losing someone is horrible, but unless we go back to the customs of going into very visible mourning for longer periods of time, clothing isn't an effective social signal of bereavement for more than the day of the funeral.

AffIt · 20/11/2022 02:44

My family is from the Gàidhealtachd (basically the Gaelic-speaking regions of the Highlands and Islands).

My father died very suddenly and unexpectedly when I was a teenager and, with hindsight, I'm very pleased that we had very well-trodden traditions to note (such as wearing black, keeping the curtains closed etc) because we were all so shocked and grief-ridden that we wouldn't have had the head space to deal with somebody asking what the dress code is: what do you mean, what's the dress code? Black, obviously.

Mouers such as wearing black to a funeral help 'lubricate' social interactions and take the pressure off those most likely to be affected.

Nanof8 · 20/11/2022 02:34

When my younger brother passed several years ago.
People came dressed in all sorts from full on black, to casual, to old jeans and t-shirts.
We didn't care what they wore, we were just glad to see them there.

MNMH · 20/11/2022 01:34

Dintananadinta · 20/11/2022 01:27

Wearing black could mean going to work or court. Why would you want people to know you’re in mourning?

That's what I don't get. First there's "people dress differently for attention" then "wear black so people know you're mourning."

An odd set of arbitrary rules that are clearly personal preferences.

sashh · 20/11/2022 01:34

Funerals and mourning are cultural events.

I actually think some of the Jewish customs such as Shiva having a defined timeline for mourning.

For those who do not know Shiva is seven days following the funeral. People come to the home of the deceased family for a week to pay respects and to pray.

The deceased close family may tear their clothing and not wash / shave / do laundry for that week.

My next door neighbour died yesterday. I live on a cul-de-sac and there have been several deaths since I have been here. I don't think I will go to the funeral but I do know that day the curtains at the front of the houses will be closed.