Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we've lost something by not having a standard funeral outfit

195 replies

Sleeptightnightlight · 19/11/2022 22:15

So, this is musing really. Over the last couple of years I've been to a few funerals and at all there has been the request for no black/dark colours. (Several specifically asking for bright colours etc).

I'm not in any way criticising the individual choices of the bereaved people (frankly if they'd asked me to turn up in a gimp suit and tutu I would have if I thought it would help them through the day). I absolutely think people should choose whatever dress code they want.

But I can't help wondering if this move to colour/'normal clothes' means we lose something in terms of other people recognising people who are in mourning.

For example I remember being at a service station barely holding it together and it occured to me that being dressed in what was basically festival garb no one serving me etc had any idea we were on the way to a funeral.

I think in the past people would wear a black armband on their suit so everyone would know and perhaps that person would be treated more kindly/gently?

AIBU to think having recognizable 'mourning clothes' had a social function that we have lost/are losing? Maybe on a society level we need some new sign that someone has suffered a loss?

OP posts:
MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 11:47

I wore a big hat and veil to my DPs funeral in March. So that I could slug from a hip flask of neat vodka throughout the service. He would have approved.

TirisfalPumpkin · 20/11/2022 11:30

Agree. Funerals should be personal, but not ‘individual’ - they serve a social function in helping the living process their grief. I’d also respect the wishes of the family if that’s what they wanted, but I wouldn’t find dressing like I was going to Glastonbury conducive to that. Maybe for a memorial a bit further down the line but not when the loss is recent and you’re in the midst of it. Forced party spirit would make things worse imo.

my Gran had a direct cremation, didn’t want a fuss made. We respected her wishes, but it felt abrupt and impersonal, didn’t help the grieving process.

Bluevelvetsofa · 20/11/2022 11:20

We went to the funeral of DH’s uncle last week. He was 92 and very definitely old school. We checked with DH’s cousin, who said the majority of people would be in dark or black clothes, so that’s what we did.

His daughter in law was dressed casually, some of the mourners wore suits, but there were a good number in jeans and very casual wear. These were older people too and exactly why we asked for the dress code, thinking they'd be wearing a dark suit.

Greengagesnfennel · 20/11/2022 11:19

TooHotToRamble · 19/11/2022 23:12

I agreed completely. Funerals are to help the living with the process of mourning. All this wear bright colours, celebrate life is a little too "toxic positivity" to me. It's sad. People will be sad. Someone they love has died. Pretending it should be a happy event is a bit gaslighty and invalidating of people's negative emotions. There's nothing wrong with feeling sad. Why are we trying to "happy" it away.

This

lovelyweathertoday · 20/11/2022 11:07

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 08:33

YANBU and personally, I’d prefer to wear a big black hat with a big black lacy veil that comes down to my elbows like a Victorian widow.

My children are well aware that I want as close to full Victorian mourning outfits as possible.

Teder · 20/11/2022 10:32

Twillow · 20/11/2022 00:15

Quite obviously the OP is talking about what is, or was, the norm for white British culture. No offence intended here that I can see.
Funnily enough, I went to a funeral this week where the family and most of the guests wore mainly black, but one elderly neighbour wore a bright pink jumper that seemed to me a rather odd choice.

I’m white British - that’s my ethnicity. My religion and culture is different.

It also wasn’t obvious at all!

SomeBeings · 20/11/2022 10:30

I followed a hearse the other day. It was driving extremely slowly between two towns for about 7 miles. The queue behind the hearse seemed endless by the time it reached the destination. Obviously I didn't overtake as that would be 'disrespectful' but it does seem like a really strange and outdated way to honor someone who had died.

SomeBeings · 20/11/2022 10:27

AuntieMarys · 20/11/2022 09:06

I'm not having a funeral, but a direct cremation. I dislike " tradition" intensely.
Let people wear what they want if the family are happy with that.

We had a direct-to-crem funeral with no service at all for my Dad when he died. The funeral people dealt with the ashes too. He died in hospital then was whisked away and that was that. I can imagine how 'disrespectful' some people on this thread would find that. When he died I went on my iPad and booked everything online.

It's what my Dad wanted and what all my family are going to do too. To us the memories and sadness are associated with the person when they were alive not with their physical body.

Not having had any funeral and service hasn't had any bad effects and we don't regret it at all. People talk about funerals and closure but, for us, the act of my Dad dying was closure adding a ceremony where everyone stands around wearing black wouldn't have made it feel like it was more final.

We obviously still miss him a lot and we chat about him and feel sad but I think it's in a emotionally healthy and natural way.

BeautifulWar · 20/11/2022 10:12

I don't really understand who it is disrespectful to, too come to a funeral wearing either colour or, casual clothes. The deceased or the family?

I didn't particularly want to be on display when I was recently bereaved. I didn't want people to treat me differently, or worse, for strangers to find my grief triggering. I didn't want family and family fork out for specific clothing that makes no difference to their grief or mine.

My world has shattered regardless whether people wear black or whether it's the funeral day or the day, week, month after that.

Goodoldvera · 20/11/2022 10:09

BogRollBOGOF · 20/11/2022 09:13

I've been to far too many funerals this year alone I'll wear whatever is requested and default to black/ purple if no direct request is made.

When I went back through the airport part-way through a family member's funeral earlier this year, I was still in my black funeral outfit. No body would have had a clue why I was wearing a black formal outfit. I could easily have been wearing it for work purposes.

Grief doesn't end. In some ways you live with it forever. Every grief is individual.

The worst news I've had this year was about a younger family member. My reaction was to lace up my trainers and run out that initial wave of shock by running like Forrest Gump. Wearing something like a black arm band sounds like it would just bring out extreme British awkwardness and make most people feel worse. Many want to cling to shreds of normality to drag them through the early days of raw bereavement.

For my own funeral, I want people to be comfortable and be able to laugh and cry as they need. I like colour, but there'd be no right or wrong.

I'm glad you mentioned purple. One person upthread was offended that an Aunt wore it I was pretty sure it was a traditional funeral colour. I think smart should be the default, but people I know wear black the majority of the time through choice, or for work so wouldn't stick out as someone in mourning. I've experienced people returning smart clothes, worn for an occasion because it's obviously not something they feel they need in their wardrobe, which I find just rude, and not respectful whatsoever to anyone

PickleBottom · 20/11/2022 09:58

I honestly couldn't care less what someone would wear to my funeral or that of a close family member. Funerals are usually held on working days and require someone to take a day unpaid off work. If they turn up dressed in jeans and a fleece, I could not care less as I would appreciate the time they took out of their day to support me. Also, not everyone has the funds to buy something black and formal if they don't already have something. I have never in my grief looked around at what someone is wearing at a close family member's funeral and thought to myself, "I'm never going to acknowledge them again because they're not dressed how I want," like a couple of posters have stated they have done.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/11/2022 09:13

I've been to far too many funerals this year alone I'll wear whatever is requested and default to black/ purple if no direct request is made.

When I went back through the airport part-way through a family member's funeral earlier this year, I was still in my black funeral outfit. No body would have had a clue why I was wearing a black formal outfit. I could easily have been wearing it for work purposes.

Grief doesn't end. In some ways you live with it forever. Every grief is individual.

The worst news I've had this year was about a younger family member. My reaction was to lace up my trainers and run out that initial wave of shock by running like Forrest Gump. Wearing something like a black arm band sounds like it would just bring out extreme British awkwardness and make most people feel worse. Many want to cling to shreds of normality to drag them through the early days of raw bereavement.

For my own funeral, I want people to be comfortable and be able to laugh and cry as they need. I like colour, but there'd be no right or wrong.

bloodywhitecat · 20/11/2022 09:11

@SunsetandCupcakes your post was carefully and thoughtfully worded, you have nothing to apologise for Flowers.

AuntieMarys · 20/11/2022 09:06

I'm not having a funeral, but a direct cremation. I dislike " tradition" intensely.
Let people wear what they want if the family are happy with that.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 20/11/2022 09:06

I'm not so bothered on colours (although I always wear black to a funeral unless the family request something else), but it is a formal occasion to me. I was shocked when DHs uncle died and there were people at the funeral in jeans and those massive fleece tops with wild animals/wolves printed on which you only seem to see for sale at country fairs... it just seems really disrespectful to me - like you've just popped into the funeral on the way to Tesco or something, not that it's an important event.

gogohmm · 20/11/2022 09:06

I attend lots (occupational hazard) and wear black. If colour is requested I have a variety of silk scarves to accessorise with

SunsetandCupcakes · 20/11/2022 09:05

@bloodywhitecat

I'm sorry I didn't mean it like that, I just wanted the world to know mine had ended whilst everyone else was going about their normal day. I couldn't believe that people were doing mundane things like shopping and walking and driving when my son was dead. I like the idea of an armband, or a formality like they did in the past to mark a grieving period wearing a black veil would have made my interactions with others seem less false.
But it is personal and a funeral needs to suit the family. I am sorry for your loss.

kingtamponthefurred · 20/11/2022 08:58

Direct cremation for me.

GreenWillowAndFireworks · 20/11/2022 08:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for personal reasons.

megletthesecond · 20/11/2022 08:57

Our family don't do black at our funerals. It would be considered wasting money to get specific clothes. We just wear something smart. I wore a cream top to my dads funeral with grey trousers.

Although as I'm getting older and go to non family funerals that do require black I have had to get a black coat and bag from primark, but they'll last me for decades.

HeddaGarbled · 20/11/2022 08:45

Well, the funeral business talks about “funeral fashions”:

assets.ctfassets.net/iqbixcpmwym2/5v6n2gA1yGR5BCDRJ4kNKu/93696c8e8e2f9e260795c941fa96c6c9/3876_1_Funeralcare_Media_pack_artwork_SML_v4.pdf

Prescottdanni123 · 20/11/2022 08:42

@onlythreenow

Would you criticize other countries for wearing red/white/purple/orange to a funeral? Or are you only going to insult England's traditions.

It is not your place to tell us that our customs or culture it outdated, weird or wrong.

People should wear black if it is what makes them feel comfortable. Likewise, if they want to wear bright colours, again it comes down to what they feel comfortable in. And obviously the family of the deceased feelings need to be taken into account as well.

OP was merely saying that having a specific outfit or armband to signal to the rest of the world that someone is grieving and needs a bit of sensitivity and compassion might be beneficial to some people.

PermanentTemporary · 20/11/2022 08:40

Thank you for the word purvy, that's a new one to me.

What I'm taking from this thread is that when people ask for colours/no black at a funeral, it's very deeply felt and you should comply willingly if you possibly can (not that I didn't think that before).

I did actually wear a kind of mourning after dh died, though I don't think anyone else would have noticed much. There were clothes and colours I didn't wear for months, and then about six months after he died I did start wearing some of them again. It wasn't very conscious, I just didn't want to wear those things in the early days, but I found it comforting. I've also never worn again a couple of things I wore in the first days after his death.

I've heard the view that people would treat the bereaved better if we still had visible mourning customs before, but I'm not sure it's true. I think it broke down after WWI/the 1919 flu pandemic because everyone was in mourning. The entire country. The fact is that loss is terrible and very painful and it feels like you're being ignored. A dress code wouldn't really help in my view.

Daisymae55 · 20/11/2022 08:38

My Gran died after injuries sustained in a care home. The whole incident was very traumatic, especially for my df. She hated block and loved colourful florals. The men at the funeral wore dark suits and df wore a floral tie (a nice small print in a dark navy like his suit, not a naff one). Dm and I wore black dresses with florals. That get right. Wearing plain black would have felt wrong for her.

my dsil’s father died during covid. For that funeral I wore all black as that get right.

it depends on the person/situation/ the deceased preferences if made known.

Prescottdanni123 · 20/11/2022 08:37

@MNMH

I can't help but feel that this thread has taken a bit of an different cultures wearing different cultures is fine, people wearing bright colours is fine, but people wearing black are fair game for snide comments about being all doom and gloom and somber spin.

There is no wrong answer on what to wear as long as respect is being shown to the deceased and their family.

Swipe left for the next trending thread