Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we've lost something by not having a standard funeral outfit

195 replies

Sleeptightnightlight · 19/11/2022 22:15

So, this is musing really. Over the last couple of years I've been to a few funerals and at all there has been the request for no black/dark colours. (Several specifically asking for bright colours etc).

I'm not in any way criticising the individual choices of the bereaved people (frankly if they'd asked me to turn up in a gimp suit and tutu I would have if I thought it would help them through the day). I absolutely think people should choose whatever dress code they want.

But I can't help wondering if this move to colour/'normal clothes' means we lose something in terms of other people recognising people who are in mourning.

For example I remember being at a service station barely holding it together and it occured to me that being dressed in what was basically festival garb no one serving me etc had any idea we were on the way to a funeral.

I think in the past people would wear a black armband on their suit so everyone would know and perhaps that person would be treated more kindly/gently?

AIBU to think having recognizable 'mourning clothes' had a social function that we have lost/are losing? Maybe on a society level we need some new sign that someone has suffered a loss?

OP posts:
noctu · 20/11/2022 16:26

I think it's respectful to wear black to a funeral. My grandfather died last year, he was a lovely man who was always smart in a shirt and tie come rain or shine. I wore black as did my husband as I knew this would have been important to him. His (other) granddaughter turned up in a short dress, leopard print coat and strappy high heels - full on night out attire complete with heavy makeup and big hair. Granddad would have been devastated if he'd seen.
A friend also lost her father very suddenly in his 60s, absolutely horrendous, and her friend turned up to the funeral in a full on flowery summer dress with big wedge summer shoes.
Both people stood out like a sore thumb, which I think is probably what they wanted ...

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 20/11/2022 16:24

I hosted my grandfather's funeral. At this point my granny and both their daughters, my mother and my aunt, had predeceased him. All his life he loved bright colour and cheer and wasn't keen on dull, drab or dark colours. This whole preference is indicative of the type of personality he had.

I came downstairs on the day of his funeral in a dress in bright red (his favourite). Then I wobbled, went back up, and came down again in a black one. My cousin, who knew my grandfather very well, told me to get back upstairs and put it back on: 'He'll love it!', she said. So I did. Nor do I regret it for a second; it was a lovely way to honour the man I'd loved as a father all my life. Might not be the right choice for everyone, and those who knew him less well may have disapproved. But it was right for him, and right for me.

There is no rule book on how to grieve and I'm very uncomfortable with trying to force everyone into a one size fits all approach. Grieving is hard enough as it is. Unless I'm instructed otherwise I will wear black, but just as happy not to if a family's way of honouring their loved one requires something different.

I do hope this thread isn't making anyone feel awful about the decisions they've made. You didn't get it wrong. There is no right or wrong way.

generalh · 20/11/2022 16:24

RambamThankyouMam · 19/11/2022 22:48

Agreed.

I find it insufferable all this "celebrate life" and wear bright colours to funerals. It's cringeworthy. We ought to have dignity in mourning.

When it is my time I want everyone to wear black.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 20/11/2022 16:20

My mum's funeral had a black dress code. I was 12 and my older brothers girlfriend took me shopping for the day to find a suitable outfit. We went to topshop etc and she encouraged me to try on tops and dresses and I just felt numb. Like what does it matter what colour I wear, my mum has just dropped dead? In the end we bought a black top in the sales and I wore my school trousers. I don't remember much else from that time, but I remember that shopping trip, my brothers girlfriend tried to make it a girly day but I was just a bit numb.

I think I will specify wear what you want for my own funeral. Black or not, up to you. Some people like to dress up for funerals, get a blow dry, make up etc, and some struggle with the idea of putting on day clothes. You do you.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 20/11/2022 16:17

bloodywhitecat · 19/11/2022 23:14

It seems I did DH's funeral all wrong.

No you didn't. You did what was right for your husband and you. Who could ever be better-placed than his wife to honour him in the best, most personal and meaningful way for him?

I'm sorry about your awful loss Flowers

Vatofrose · 20/11/2022 16:15

I agree. I live in Liverpool which obviously has a strong Irish heritage and we do grieve more formally. Friends from the south were coming up for a funeral and the women said they were going to dress in happy colours. I suggested they might want to rethink. They didn’t and ended up feeling self conscious amid the sea of black. One of the men in the group said as the cortège passed by, a young guy waiting to cross the road took off his baseball cap and bowed his head. He found that unusual.

CakeCrumbs44 · 20/11/2022 16:10

I went to my husband's grandma's funeral earlier this year. No dress code was mentioned on the invitation, so I assumed standard funeral dress and bought a dark blue dress to wear, and black shoes.

My sister in law was wearing a denim jacket and skirt. My husband's cousin was wearing leggings and an oversized t shirt. Loads of people were just wearing jeans and polo shirts. It was really bizarre. I felt like I was overdressed or had missed some sort of memo that grandma wanted us all to dress like we were going to the pub!

Goodoldvera · 20/11/2022 16:05

Sleeptightnightlight · 20/11/2022 14:28

I was a bit unsure whether to come back into this thread. Several people have said they 'agree' with me then stated something I completely disagree with about 'disrespect' or appropriateness of certain colours/outfits. That's really not what I was saying. I am sorry if this thread made anyone feel judged about choosing whatever worked best for them, I tried to make it clear that was not my intention.

Completely seriously, I wish we had some kind of rule where we could wear black for X amount of time or something to signify mourning.

This is what I'm getting at (and no, it doesn't have to be black, and yes, obviously people wear black all the time now so it doesn't work as a grief signifier). I see several posters have said they don't want people to know they are mourning, which is fair enough, but I wasn't thinking it would be mandatory. (I suppose in the past not wearing mourning would have been judged so it's good we have moved away from that).

Personally I do want people to know I'm grieving. I can't bring myself to say the words most of the time. It's too heavy to drop on people making normal chatty smalltalk, but not saying anything and trying to carry on the conversation feels awful to me.

Someone asked Why would they need to know? I was going to a funeral. I don't think other people 'need to know' but I personally would like it if they did without me having to explain, 'sorry my world is falling apart right now and simple stuff like returning a smile or remembering what I'm supposed to be doing are really fucking hard.'

I'm glad some people got was I was trying to say and sorry again if this thread stirred anything up.

I agree and I think when someone is offhand or behaving 'rude' within an everyday situation (even if they are the one serving) they should be given some tolerance rather than being the subject of a complaint on social media...there are so many who are having to get on with their lives who have been through or still experiencing grief or a really stressful situation. I think when you've been through it you realise and find a bit more empathy for everyone, not knowing what they are dealing with...while carrying on

IfOnlyOCould · 20/11/2022 16:03

OP, please don't worry about stirring things up. I can see you wrote you OP carefully. One of the reasons Mumsnet is useful is that it helps everyone see that there are a million and one different opinions and a million and one ways to do things. Everyone just needs to be understanding and respectful of other peoples views.

There isn't a rule book on grieving. You have to work out what works for you and your family.

Sleeptightnightlight · 20/11/2022 14:28

I was a bit unsure whether to come back into this thread. Several people have said they 'agree' with me then stated something I completely disagree with about 'disrespect' or appropriateness of certain colours/outfits. That's really not what I was saying. I am sorry if this thread made anyone feel judged about choosing whatever worked best for them, I tried to make it clear that was not my intention.

Completely seriously, I wish we had some kind of rule where we could wear black for X amount of time or something to signify mourning.

This is what I'm getting at (and no, it doesn't have to be black, and yes, obviously people wear black all the time now so it doesn't work as a grief signifier). I see several posters have said they don't want people to know they are mourning, which is fair enough, but I wasn't thinking it would be mandatory. (I suppose in the past not wearing mourning would have been judged so it's good we have moved away from that).

Personally I do want people to know I'm grieving. I can't bring myself to say the words most of the time. It's too heavy to drop on people making normal chatty smalltalk, but not saying anything and trying to carry on the conversation feels awful to me.

Someone asked Why would they need to know? I was going to a funeral. I don't think other people 'need to know' but I personally would like it if they did without me having to explain, 'sorry my world is falling apart right now and simple stuff like returning a smile or remembering what I'm supposed to be doing are really fucking hard.'

I'm glad some people got was I was trying to say and sorry again if this thread stirred anything up.

OP posts:
OrangePomander · 20/11/2022 13:15

I agree with@LBOCS2 that for me it’s about simplifying decisions.
If I’m going to a funeral, particularly someone close, then deciding what I’m going to wear isn’t something I want to have to think about.

After a couple of funerals where I was rushing around trying to find an appropriate outfit and worrying I wouldn’t find anything at short notice I now have the basics that are smart and I feel like ‘me’ in, iykwim, in my wardrobe so I don’t have to think about it and can concentrate on what matters.

Sympathies to everyone who’s currently going through this.

Buteverythingsfine · 20/11/2022 13:13

@ilovepixie I'm so sorry. No-one wants to be a part of that club. Hope the funeral goes well, it sounds great and as you say, in line with his own wishes.

ilovepixie · 20/11/2022 13:01

My OH died on Tuesday. He wants to be cremated in his football shirt and jeans. He wants the mourners to wear whatever they feel comfortable in. If people want to wear suits that's fine, if they don't that's fine too.

It will bring me comfort to see his last wishes are being observed.

TimBoothseyes · 20/11/2022 12:48

I don't thinks it's for others to decide what people should wear to a funeral, it's the families choice and to argue against their wishes is ,IMO, disrespectful.

DuplicateUserName · 20/11/2022 12:41

For example I remember being at a service station barely holding it together and it occured to me that being dressed in what was basically festival garb no one serving me etc had any idea we were on the way to a funeral.

And? Why would they need to know? Confused

But more importantly, how could they tell whether you're on your way to a funeral or on your way to the office?

LBOCS2 · 20/11/2022 12:37

I don't think it's about not wearing all black to a funeral - I think that's neither here nor there; do what will help those grieving the most.

But I do feel like we've lost a lot of the ritual around death which was designed for those left behind. I would have welcomed the opportunity to go into mourning after DM died, if it meant I had to make fewer decisions about everything and there was an unspoken signal that I would probably be struggling a bit. That's what it would have helped with; not having to explain to people that you're feeling raw and exposed (and why).

lollipoprainbow · 20/11/2022 12:32

I wore all black to my mums funeral I felt it was appropriate and respectful.

SequinsandStilettos · 20/11/2022 12:28

Funerals are for the living. The closest to the one being buried gets to choose what they want or go with the request of their loved one. Bright colours are needed if that is their preference, especially if we are looking at the death of a child. Crass to suggest otherwise.

DWMoosmum · 20/11/2022 12:23

We're off to a childs funeral next week, we will be wearing hints of pink, her favourite colour. We're always guided by what the family wish. If it's not stated then we wear dark colours.

balalake · 20/11/2022 12:20

The idea of a mourning period may be right for some people, but the most difficult period of grief can often come later. The day that would have been their next birthday, going to an event without them that you always went together, Christmas, to think of three.

I'm not sure a symbol be it clothing colours or something else to signify recently deceased relative or friend would achieve what the OP wants to see.

Those who have posted about direct cremation and no service, if it is their choice, then fine by me. One aspect of funerals that is more usual over the last 20-25 years which I welcome is giving thanks for the life of the deceased and celebrating it, more than simply mourning their death.

Stuffin · 20/11/2022 12:17

I honestly didn't care what the mourners at my DMs funeral wore because all that mattered was they turned up.

And I can't even remember the clothes but that is probably because I wasn't looking at them deciding if they were appropriate or not.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 12:15

@Notanotherusername4321

I hear you.

It appears we are in the same shitty club.

Unmumsnetty hug coming your way.

And to everyone thrown into the upside down.

Notanotherusername4321 · 20/11/2022 12:13

Surely it doesn’t matter what anyone wears to a funeral? It’s the paying of respects that’s more important rather than what the person wears

conversely to most I find the idea of a “mourning period” too time limiting.

in the immediate aftermath people know you’re grieving, are kind, bring flowers, food, gifts. Black and blinds down make no difference.

the time I found hardest was after the funeral, when everyone went back to their own lives, carried on as normal, and I felt I was expected to discard the black, to cheer up and move on.

my life was disrupted forever. Weeks, months, even years later and sometimes I want to scream at people I had this huge loss and my life is profoundly different to what it should have been, while everyone else seems to have forgotten

so no, wearing black for one day to show grief is not enough. People should wear whatever helps them feel better. Wear black, red, white, i don’t care. Just remember.

FuckabethFuckor · 20/11/2022 12:10

I think funerals are personal, insofar as they need to reflect the person who has died within the context of their family and friends.

And when skilfully arranged, this can have room for both sadness and celebration, because what is a person’s life if not a blend of those two things?

I find some of the comments here… if not odd, exactly, then distinctly at odds with my own experiences. In my culture a funeral is collaborative and relatively casual; yes, some people will wear black but ultimately it would be more insulting/inappropriate not to go than to show up in a pink fluffy jumper or glittery DMs. You quite often get people locally ‘popping in’ on their way back from work so it’s not unusual to see people in work uniforms or ‘normal’ clothes. Ultimately, going and being together is more important than what attire you go in.

Hbh17 · 20/11/2022 11:58

I can add the debate about what to wear to the very long list of reasons why I absolutely will not be having any kind of funeral when I pop my clogs. Just hope that whoever is my executor follows my instructions!