Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help re sons girlfriend s behaviour? Really unsure what to do here.

132 replies

Busytimes · 19/11/2022 22:13

Ds girlfriend , 24 is having a really hard time . I cannot go into detail .

We went with ds and his serious girlfriend to a christmas market today and i think I saw her take a small item and didn't pay for it .

I asked her later did she have a good day and she replied saying that she got something for free. she is very frugal and likes to get deals and freebies so i didn't react.

At the time I didn't say anything as lots of people in our group were talking and I didnt think anything of it

. Later this evening, I saw the item which I thought I saw her take .

I feel like she may think this is nothing / small item but it has really disturbed me .

I feel like I cant accuse her , but I am concerned re what ds may be getting himself into . -they have just moved in together.
I feel very confused what to do . / how to deal with it ?
This is not ok.I dont want to estrange our ds , but this feels wrong .
I feel like if i ask her were the item was from , what if she lies ? Were would we go from there. I am a very honest person and I feel really anxous about this .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsThimbles · 21/11/2022 14:43

Newwardrobe · 21/11/2022 09:19

I would be worried too , but for now I think you should leave it , just keep the information tucked away and keep an eye on her if you're out shopping in the future.

If you do have it out with her and she admits she stole it, what then ? Would you just tell her off or report her ? You need to think about what your objective is ?

I’d tell her I knew she was a thief. Nothing else. Because let’s face it - there’s only a few other things that are worse than being a thief.

Newwardrobe · 21/11/2022 09:19

I would be worried too , but for now I think you should leave it , just keep the information tucked away and keep an eye on her if you're out shopping in the future.

If you do have it out with her and she admits she stole it, what then ? Would you just tell her off or report her ? You need to think about what your objective is ?

HortensiaBlogs · 21/11/2022 08:04

The good thing is now you know, and forewarned is forearmed. Those freebies she talks about getting through work are likely to have been pilfered too.

If you are helping them finance a house purchase then ringfence the deposit. Don't leave valuables lying around at home - hide them well. Don't try to discuss your concerns with your son, you've already seen how he'll react. He'll defend her and it will drive a wedge between you. My brother's (ex)girlfriend stole some of my mother's jewellery and when we told my brother he was confused, then defensive and then said he'd taken it to give her.

You've repeatedly said she's stressed - aren't we all? It's no excuse. She's a common or garden liar and a thief.

toomuchlaundry · 21/11/2022 08:02

I don’t know how you get free stuff on expenses unless you are fiddling them

TheaBrandt · 21/11/2022 07:34

My concern would be that someone who does that as an adult is slightly disturbed doesn’t have a conscience about stealing and gets a kick out of transgressing boundaries. Not ideal qualities in a child’s life partner really…

Pompomsfantastix · 20/11/2022 20:29

I think the issue is, she really didn’t need the thing, she did it for a kick even though she’s a grown-ass woman. It seems like some kind of weird sociopathic thing to do tbh.

TheaBrandt · 20/11/2022 20:07

Op doesn’t need further proof she flipping saw her do it!

Very concerning that your child is going to throw their lot in with someone of low morals. That said hard to know what to actually do about it. Tricky.

AlbertaAnnie · 20/11/2022 19:47

You have no proof she did anything wrong - she may had paid without you noticing - leave her to it - it’s not your business

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/11/2022 19:01

@Busytimes you’ve said what you think they’ve responded. You need to leave it now. Otherwise you’ll end up arguing, son will defend his partner and you’ll be the baddie. I’m afraid this is a bit of long game, see what happens, how is she overall etc. As you say maybe they will marry, you want to be involved this is a sensitive topic to navigate.
I don’t think she’s necessarily overall shifty or globally light fingered but she may have a pattern of retail shoplifting. Maybe a stress reaction? A diversion from other trauma?
Don’t do anything rash

Endwalker · 20/11/2022 18:54

You've said that you think she took it and didn't pay, they've responded, leave it there.

They are adults and if you continue to push this issue over a small, cheap trinket then - at best - you're going to find yourself gradually cut out of their lives. If you go for the nig confrontation then there will be no gradually about it.

There is literally nothing more you can do here without alienating your DS and making yourself look like the one in the wrong. Step back, see how it plays out, say nothing more about this particular event.

FavouritePi · 20/11/2022 18:54

I would be worried too, it doesn't sound like an accident if she's bragging about a free item. However, I'd not be so quick to think your son is so innocent yet with him downplaying it the way he has done. Although, I'd just ignore it as there's nothing else you can do. Actions have to have consequences eventually.

My DD put shoes in a bag when I was in a shoe shop once, I was mortified that it would look intentional. It was miles away from where we lived so I made sure months later when I was in the area that I took them back and explained.

Jackie246 · 20/11/2022 18:53

Please be compassionate. I started shoplifting when I was in my late 20’s (40’s now!). It was as a result of horrible extreme trauma, and doing it was a mixture of having control, but also a huge ‘the worst has happened to me now, why the shouldn’t I do bad things’. I also deeply loathed myself and thought I’m a bad person and bad people do bad things so again, why the hell not. It took a lot of time in therapy and a decade of medication to help me change and I no longer recognise that person I was. However, I can’t blame myself for what I did, I was so damaged that I just feel so sad that I felt that was the only way I could cope. So, basically, you don’t know her reasons, you already say she’s under extreme stress, go in very gently. It would have destroyed me to have been treated with contempt if someone had found out what was doing back then.

Tigerstripe20 · 20/11/2022 18:50

I would be very wary of her, something isn’t right whether it be mentally or something else.
Unless she is very very good at her job I would be surprised if she is getting so many freebies on expenses.
Our expenses are tracked and can and will be audited at any time.
she didn’t get the item for free she put it in her pocket, if she was looking at something else she could easily have still had it in her hand or handed to the stall holder and said she was still browsing.
She is getting a thrill out of stealing, she isn’t getting stuff for free.
We can’t have a family member at our house, they have no issues they just love the thrill of stealing , our take on it is when they get caught they pay the consequences.
Lock down the money you are lending them.
If she is under such immense stress as you say, it maybe an idea she gets some sort of counselling.
Or is stress going to be used as an excuse when she finally gets caught ?

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/11/2022 18:49

MissEnolaHolmes · 20/11/2022 17:01

I would face it head on I’m afraid. It’s theft.

I would either (if they are both there ask to see them in the kitchen together) or (text them both together and say the following)

I am worried and anxious about what I saw today

huge pause and don’t fill in

there is right and wrong adult and children over about 7/8 KNOW not to put items in their pocket without paying

no I know that I saw I offered to pay and I know what happened

big pause

don't insult my intelligence or gaslight me

big pause

you lied - you said it was free it wasn’t

big pause

you lied - you said it was free it wasn’t

big pause

its a crime the stall holder will be out of pocket and might have very limited means of making any sort of margin - you stole from someone working to make a living

it’s unacceptable

you are enabling her and minimising it

you took a deliberate criminal action ? Why? It wasn’t accidentally done it was deliberate?

what are you going to do to put it right?

20 or 10
doesn’t matter - I think her actions are vile

if you let it go you become her enabler !

Did that honestly play out well in your head,the verbosity and big pause. You cross examining like a criminal barrister.
You really do seem to have a complete lack of common sense if you think that little speech and righteous indignation is going to end well.
Big pause all you want they won’t remain passive and contrite during that speech

ilovemotorways · 20/11/2022 18:45

I used to shoplift occasionally when under stress as a teenager. I think I did it to try and regain a sense of control over my life as my home was quite chaotic at the time. That's no excuse of course but obviously there's normally a reason why people might behave in these ways.

If I were you I'd stay out of it but be available to offer support if needed, either to your son or his gf :)
X

Fleurdaisy · 20/11/2022 18:42

Oh come on, who puts things in their pocket when they’re shopping if they don’t intend to pay for them? I’ve never walked around a store, supermarket, market, craft fair picking up stuff and putting it in my pocket. He excuse if “ doing something else on the stall” was a cover for stealing.
Hopefully she’ll get caught one day soon, get a police caution and that will jolt her into remembering right from wrong.

burnoutbabe · 20/11/2022 18:23

I am sure we have all managed to do that or forget to scan something when we do shop and scan in saibsburies.

But if we realised after I'd probably have a debate with myself on should I go back and pay? Would that be more hassle than worth for say one tin of beans at Sainsbury’s ?

What I can't think I'd do is happily tell people OH I GOT THIS FREE. I'd feel awkward and if a big supermarket maybe donate similar to the food bank there (if a small stall I'd return if possible/pay)

NancyJoan · 20/11/2022 18:21

If you don’t want to talk to either of them about it, I’m not sure what you can do. You know she put it in her pocket. She was pleased she got a freebie, not appalled that she had accidentally pocketed it, which suggests she’s a habitual thief.

You can talk to your DS, and tell him you are worried about her. Or about him.
I would be worried about what she’ll be like once they are living together.
Are you happy to have her in your home again?

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/11/2022 18:19

I put nappies under my pram once on a day out and only realised when we got back to the car. Whoops. And then we all forgot about it. I certainly wasn't mortified.

Just leave it be now OP.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 20/11/2022 18:17

Tbh I'd just ask her. Be blunt. Why not?

Nuggetss · 20/11/2022 18:17

I used to shoplift , I have never stolen from anybodies house or personal belongings. Have a good job it's because it gave me a high. I used to get annoyed at spending £100s a week not feeling like I was being rewarded so I'd do it on the scan as you go thing. It would be like 2-3 items low cost things. I stopped because well it wasn't good !! It was a mix of entitlement, stick it to the man and getting a high . I wouldn't have shop lifted from a small business owner either. I think you should tell your DS to have a word she would probably be mortified and stop.

Don't turn it into a massive thing it's probably more common than people think.
Just because someone has shoplifted from a shop doesn't mean they would do it to a person.

Tekkentime · 20/11/2022 18:15

Typical mumsnet overreaction, get over it.

oakleaffy · 20/11/2022 18:13

@Busytimes
If you are helping buy their home, please protect the money you put in, legally, if it all goes wrong.
You don’t want her waltzing off with your deposit money if they split.

Bananagirl23 · 20/11/2022 18:13

A friend of mine hired her boss’s daughter as babysitter once and she took some reasonably expensive toiletries from her bathroom - not highly valuable but enough expense to notice they were gone. Turned out she had past form for doing this sort of thing so you are right to be a bit wary

oakleaffy · 20/11/2022 18:10

Busytimes · 20/11/2022 17:43

She is very very motivated to get free food via aps , freebies, not spend anything but save for the future.
could this be linked at all.
has a very good job ( gets lots of free stuff on expenses) its not lack of money .
I dont understand .
I feel really unsettled . Was look forward to her being our daughter in law and now I simply feel
worried that our ds will get hurt. she seems so nice .( as well as obsessive)

The theft would entirely change my view of her, too.
Everyone knows stealing is wrong.
Everyone.
If she was desperately poor, and stealing to eat, it would be more understandable, but many struggling people would be too honest to steal.
What next? Embezzling her company?
Dishonesty is a thing that undermines trust, sadly.