Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should siblings share shoes?

59 replies

Redcrocodile · 19/11/2022 21:15

Just that really.

My DH says yes and he wants us to keep all shoes from our DD and pass them to DS who is 2years younger, as long as they don’t have holes and they are not severely damaged.

I would happily keep things like crocs, wellies, slippers etc. but to keep proper shoes sound weird to me.

We normally have 1-2 pairs of shoes for our DD per size (i.e. per year) and although they are properly worn and look tired, they are not severely damaged.

Would it be ok for another kid to wear them in the future?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
zingally · 20/11/2022 12:33

Nope.

Things like wellies, crocs and slippers I've passed onto other people, but other shoes, no.
I have twins, so don't pass things between my own kids, but I've never taken on secondhand shoes for either of them, apart from wellies.
I grew up fairly poor, but my mum always insisted on getting our feet measured, and were wearing decent shoes up until we were teenagers. So I do similar for my own two.

yikesanotherbooboo · 20/11/2022 10:11

My DC only had one pair of shoes at a time plus wellies and slippers . I used to get their feet measured and buy to fit. I would keep and reuse wellies etc but the shoes or trainers tended to wear out. I only once was able to pass on a pair from DC1 to 2.

Caterina99 · 20/11/2022 10:05

My eldest seems to destroy his trainers so there’s not much to be passed on

But yes, wellies, slippers, snow boots or barely worn shoes have all been passed on to DC2. Sometimes you just need a spare pair and old ones are handy for that.

RudsyFarmer · 20/11/2022 09:13

I have flat feet as does my mother as does one of my children. My mother is still fit as a fiddle in her eighties and was bought up poor as a church mouse. I would doubt very much a pair of Clark’s made their way onto her feet.

I’m actually one of the few parents who still has their year 6 in made to measure shoes. Most kids have been wearing trainers to school for years. So I won’t be flagellating myself down the streets just yet.

Aria999 · 20/11/2022 00:48

I am passing down the very occasional pair that are not completely trashed.

But even new shoes I get off the internet. Shoe shops where I am are very expensive and have a tiny, really boring range.

Also the occasional times I have done a shoe shop fitting, the shoes have quite often turned out to not actually fit that well.

SkankingWombat · 20/11/2022 00:30

ChristmasisRuined · 19/11/2022 23:40

You can whisper about your kids feet being 'functional' all you like but as someone with permanent plantar fascia injuries from wearing flat 'ballet' style shoes so much in the early 2000s, I now need to use a mobility scooter outdoors, a knee scooter & zimmaframe in the house. At 38.

It's not about secondhand shoes necessarily it's about not having arch support and wearing secondhand shoes will affect the arch support! That is why you MUST have shoes properly fitted. I know it's not financially viable for everyone but at the very least, get insoles with arch support.

DO NOT EVER WALK AROUND BAREFOOT OR WEAR COMPLETELY FLAT SHOES! 🥿 Yes, barefoot is how god made us but feet are a design fault. Please don't assume foot health is some hippy/fad like nonsense, or you'll end up like me and unable to walk holding your child's hand

Not everyone has need of so much support and my experience has been the polar opposite. I've been barefoot as much as I can be my whole life (I hate wearing shoes), and for nearly 10 years I have worn 'barefoot' shoes wherever possible when it isn't practical to be barefoot (my walking boots and work boots do not have a barefoot-friendly option sadly). I have good arches and no pain despite walking a good number of miles every day.
I agree ballet pumps are the work of the devil though... they offer no support but are also deforming and prevent your foot working as it should both in flex and allowing your toes to splay. It is the worst of both worlds.

Ericaequites · 20/11/2022 00:29

I went to a private school with some very wealthy girls. Most of us had a couple of pairs of dress shoes, Birkenstocks, tennis shoes, and trainers. Generally we wore our school shoes on weekends as well.
New properly fitted shoes are vital to long term foot health. Everything else but underwear can be secondhand, but shoes need to be bought with careful measurements.

Deadringer · 20/11/2022 00:10

Does your dh wear second hand shoes op? My feet are completely fucked from wearing hand-me-down and cheap, ill fitting shoes as a child, so it's a no from me.

LemonSwan · 19/11/2022 23:56

Absolutely not.

One of my croc flip flops got stolen by DPs parents dog. DPs mum is the same size and has the same pair of crocs so gave me her half while she found mine.

As kind as this was now we both have unwearable pairs of shoes because the shoes change to the shape of your foot!!!!

A cheap pair is better than someone else pair.

JockTamsonsBairns · 19/11/2022 23:56

I have a DS who is just a year and a half older than DD so, unfortunately, passing down of footwear has been quite limited.
In saying that, I've been happy to pass down wellies, crocs, and walking boots if they've been in reasonable condition.
School shoes have always been measured and bought new. Not only are school shoes pretty much done in by the end of the summer term, DD would not have appreciated wearing her brother's old shoes to school.

Now they're young teens, there's been a bit more passing on - mainly PE trainers and football boots. They are required to have football boots with studs suitable for grass for the 6 weeks of the year that they do football in PE.
Like fuck am I going out and forking out for a new pair of football boots for DD, to play a sport she's not interested in, when there's a pair of DS's in the cupboard that have been worn 6 times.

*Caveat - I'm the youngest of 6, four older brothers and an older sister. I clearly remember a childhood of wearing what everyone was finished with, whether it fitted me or not. I was never allowed clothes of my own that I liked, so I try to be mindful of DD and her individual tastes.

ConfusedBear · 19/11/2022 23:47

Missing the point of the thread:-
Shoes are gendered from a very young age*. So, regardless of the condition of the shoes I would expect that your DS will very quickly stop liking your DD's shoes.

If either finances or reducing waste are behind your DH's thinking it would probably be better to sell all wearable shoes from DS and DD.

  • I know all shoes, provided they fit, could be worn by someone of any sex or any gender, but that's not what marketing tells us and marketing is very powerful.
Girasoli · 19/11/2022 23:45

I pass down wellies/snow boots/slippers etc. and some pairs of shoes as spares (good for if things get soaked at nursery/the park).

Not school shoes - they have always been broken by the end of the year!

ChristmasisRuined · 19/11/2022 23:40

RudsyFarmer · 19/11/2022 21:51

This thread reads very much like the mumsnet chicken threads of old. My child can only possibly wear properly fitted leather shoes from the finest artisan independent shoe shop as that’s my priority. If we have to live on turnips that month then so be it!!

well I’m going to make your heads spin. Even though we have a six figure income I put my children in a mixture of new and second hand. Even second hand that dirty strangers have worn!

whispers my children still have functional feet and are still alive and well 😱

You can whisper about your kids feet being 'functional' all you like but as someone with permanent plantar fascia injuries from wearing flat 'ballet' style shoes so much in the early 2000s, I now need to use a mobility scooter outdoors, a knee scooter & zimmaframe in the house. At 38.

It's not about secondhand shoes necessarily it's about not having arch support and wearing secondhand shoes will affect the arch support! That is why you MUST have shoes properly fitted. I know it's not financially viable for everyone but at the very least, get insoles with arch support.

DO NOT EVER WALK AROUND BAREFOOT OR WEAR COMPLETELY FLAT SHOES! 🥿 Yes, barefoot is how god made us but feet are a design fault. Please don't assume foot health is some hippy/fad like nonsense, or you'll end up like me and unable to walk holding your child's hand

DelurkingAJ · 19/11/2022 23:37

We keep them as spares (soaking wet trainers or trainers that his brother wore half a dozen times before his feet grew again seems like a no-brainer to me).

UsingChangeofName · 19/11/2022 23:34

As others have said, we would pass down wellies, walking boots, football boots, beach sandals etc but inevitably proper shoes were worn out by the time they were grown out so it never really came into consideration.

I also suspect that most shoes you would buy for your dd would be likely to look quite different from most of the shoes you would buy for a ds, despite what logic tells you. I know some people like to make a point but most parents compromise along the way.

Then, it will depend on your budget. I have worked with many children over the years who have shoes that are completely the wrong size for them where the families are not in a position to afford new, fitted shoes for growing children.

notdaddycool · 19/11/2022 23:32

We had some school shoes bought before lockdown and worn for about 2 weeks our youngest wore for the last few weeks of the summer term. We’ve kept some virtually unworn trainers but otherwise it’s crocs/wellies/slippers only for us.

BogRollBOGOF · 19/11/2022 23:20

Occasional shoes for light use, I've passed down. Not the daily school shoes/ trainers.

DS2 swerves the quandary by being the same size as DS1 so I have to buy duplicates.

While they are the same size, their feet are differently proportioned.

SkankingWombat · 19/11/2022 23:19

Celeryfavour · 19/11/2022 21:31

I hand down shoes. Even if the second DC don't wear them as their main shoes, it's amazingly useful to have the next size up waiting for them when they suddenly have a growth spurt/ need a spare pair to leave at school/ wear in the garden etc.

Yup, this. Spares were a lifesaver during the nightmarishly long time both DCs took to potty train too!
Also, my DCs seem to have so many shoes for different things (Crocs for going swimming, wellies, school shoes, indoor school shoes, trainers, snow boots in winter and sometimes fashion trainers if we see some going very cheap in the sales) plus they are mostly barefoot at home, so all bar the trainers get very little use per pair. Once school age, the trainers are falling to bits by the time they're outgrown and not in a fit state to pass on IME.

Coolhand2 · 19/11/2022 23:14

Mine share, I didn't know that people don't share shoes till this thread. As long as they are in good shape I keep them. My ds2 is wearing ds1's shoes. It keeps cost down.

Pallisers · 19/11/2022 22:45

No. and my mother ( a war baby) was the same. you got one pair of shoes that were yours. I think shoes shape to your feet and shaping your foot to someone else's shoe isn't good. My sister and I are the same size and when we were in our teens would steal a borrow off each other's fancy shoes sometimes. I always knew when she had worn mine as they felt different.

Growing up my kids got one pair of shoes at a time (we didn't have the school shoe thing - any shoe worked). We were lucky enough to be able to afford that. If we couldn't then of course I would have put a second hand shoe on my child. But when we could afford it, shoes were the one thing that never got handed down.

MelchiorsMistress · 19/11/2022 22:45

Crocs, wellies, special party shoes are all fine to share, but not proper shoes they wear all day every day.

underneaththeash · 19/11/2022 22:42

I keep them (and we’re high earners), we’d only use school shoes as a back up - but trainers are fine.

NanooCov · 19/11/2022 22:40

I passed some shoes from DS1 to DS2 that had barely been worn, along with wellies. But other than that no. Although mainly because DS2 had much wider feet than his brother. They're almost 3 yrs apart in age and now have the same shoe size so doesn't apply at all now.

ThreeFeetTall · 19/11/2022 22:38

Yes mine wear second hand but I make sure they are adjustable (ie two Velcro straps) and no really worn ones.
I read something when mine were babies which I can't now find online but this article is similar:
www.freeourkids.co.uk/the-truth-about-second-hand-shoes-cont-interview-with-a-kids-podiatrist/

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 19/11/2022 22:33

All of mine had hand me down shoes, unless they were trashed. They got new as well but it was useful to have them share shoes. They all wear minimal shoes pretty much exclusively with wide toe boxes - so pretty much the opposite of the fitted Clark’s line. No moulding of shoes to feet here!

Swipe left for the next trending thread