Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dubious about shepherd's pie

156 replies

PickyEaters · 19/11/2022 19:41

OH and I are embarking on a healthy eating plan to lose weight. He has suggested shepherd's pie to go on the meal list as he "can't eat salad every day" (I like salad). I have never eaten shepherd's pie (I'm an immigrant) but it doesn't look very healthy to me (minced fatty lamb, potatoes and gravy with a few overcooked peas thrown in?), not to mention it sounds like it would taste disgusting! Isn't this something that featured heavily inschool dinners of the 1970s and should be banished to memory?

OP posts:
lljkk · 19/11/2022 22:42

I can't get my head around the idea of putting veg in shepherd's/cottage pie. Just no. Don't do that.

Lots veg on the side fantastic, but not in the baked item. Wrong.

My cottage pie is not low calorie. Ha!

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 19/11/2022 21:54

Do a variant of it with Turkey mince and sweet potato. Prob won't taste as nice but fewer calories.

BeautifulWar · 19/11/2022 21:54

What's disgusting about lamb? Drain off the fat after frying it, add veg in and on the side - I don't understand what is unhealthy...but then I don't think 'diet' food is healthy.

fallfallfall · 19/11/2022 21:52

Wikipedia has a lovely entry on shepherds pie.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shepherd%27s_pie
where i'm from the filling is usually sweet corn: ground beef; sweet corn; mashed potato. really pretty when cut with three distinctive layers.

again with all things "healthy" count the calories and adjust the portion size.

2bazookas · 19/11/2022 21:37

No, its a traditional comfort food. Make it right and its both healthy and tasty.

Georgeskitchen · 19/11/2022 21:30

The slimming world vegetarian one with lentils is awesome.

NosyNeighbour22 · 19/11/2022 21:28

i prefer cottage pie, and use half normal half sweet potatoes for the topping.

TwoBlueFish · 19/11/2022 21:25

I’ve been doing the keema shepherds pie on BBC food website, very tasty and uses sweet potatoes.

LaughingCat · 19/11/2022 21:21

Make it with lentils or turkey mince. Lighten up the mashed potatoes on top (so maybe semi-skimmed milk instead of cream or full fat milk and butter). Boost it with plenty of peas and carrots.

It’s a very healthy, filling and reasonably priced meal if you know how to make it right, which is why it’s so popular in the first place.

DM me if you want a good recipe for it (I make it once every few weeks in autumn/winter!).

OnlyFannys · 19/11/2022 21:01

VladmirsPoutine · 19/11/2022 21:00

Whether or not you think shepherd's pie is suitable for your dietary needs describing it as "sounds like it would taste disgusting" is frankly disgusting.

We dont have much "british cuisine" but by god we will defend what we have with our lives 😂

50isthenew20 · 19/11/2022 21:01

Well, there's portion control... TBH, it sounds more like you have nothing better to do in a boring November Saturday eve.

YABU, or course! But you surely know that.

VladmirsPoutine · 19/11/2022 21:00

Whether or not you think shepherd's pie is suitable for your dietary needs describing it as "sounds like it would taste disgusting" is frankly disgusting.

Oysterbabe · 19/11/2022 20:54

I top with swede and carrot mash to lower the calories and it's great.

CorvusPurpureus · 19/11/2022 20:54

This is genuinely the most 'hacked' traditional dish out there.

Iterations in my house have included beef mince, lamb mince, every veggie mince going, black eyed beans, green lentils, red lentils, leftover quinoa...

...& that's before topping it with potatoes. Sweet potatoes. Random root collection including celeriac or salsify, & radishes that were looking a bit sorry - they turned out to be a fantastic addition.

We've mostly settled on a vegetarian version, but it's still basically a 'mince' layer topped with a 'root vegetables, mashed then baked until crispy' layer.

It's a really healthy meal! Just pile the plate with more veg.

OnlyFannys · 19/11/2022 20:53

I love cottage pie and shepherd's pie. As others have said you can make healthier versions. You could even try turkey mince maybe instead of beef? I've done the mash as sweet potato mash before because you dont need to add butter to it. You could also do a nice hearty stew which can be very healhy

PeloFondo · 19/11/2022 20:46

I prefer cottage pie, and just have a small (I weigh it as I batch cook!) 350g portion with a load of veg on the side

Cactuslove · 19/11/2022 20:39

IToldYouAmillionTimesAlready · 19/11/2022 19:46

Cottage pie is nicer. Minced, low-fat beef. Carrots, onions, peas, thick stock, chopped tinned tomatoes, all with fluffy mashed potatoes on top.

🙌🙌 I just got some mince out freezer to do this tomorrow! Thanks for the inspiration. Never put tomatoes in before but will give it a go.

Oysterbabe · 19/11/2022 20:38

It's lovely. I tend to make cottage pie with lean beef and lentils. My kids absolutely love it.

PiggyInTheLidl · 19/11/2022 20:34

Here is a recipe from Jamie Oliver. Not traditional, but likely to be tasty and…. 436 Cals per portion. Can’t see what’s wrong with that ad part of a healthy diet.

www.jamieoliver.com/recipes/lamb-recipes/super-shepherd-s-pie/

MarmiteCoriander · 19/11/2022 20:24

Where are you from OP? There might be foods from your country that others would see as disgusting, but until you try something- can shouldn't make such a rude and sweeping statement!

To cut calories I make cottage pie with 3% or 5% beef mince. Add plenty of vegetables to bulk it up- you could include grated carrots, grated courgettes, celery and peas.

I also use either cauliflower mash on top, or sweet potato or sweet potato/potato mix

userxx · 19/11/2022 20:17

I add garlic and chilli to mine. Its far from disgusting.

Lcb123 · 19/11/2022 20:17

I don’t like lamb mince but I make a vegetarian cottage pie using a tin of lentils and lots of veg. You can use other root veg for the mash mixed with potato.

Talia99 · 19/11/2022 20:14

So don’t overcook the peas and add more veg? I do prefer cottage pie (with beef) but that’s a personal taste. I use one of the packet mixes for the seasoning and the left overs freeze well.

I’ve just sat down after getting the mince out of the freezer to defrost overnight to do a cottage pie, oddly enough.

If you are genuinely eating salad every day, I can see why your DH is fed up. My last diet involved no salad whatsoever (OK, maybe the odd tomato) - ending up starving and therefore snacking on biscuits would not have been helpful!

Saisong · 19/11/2022 20:14

I made shepherd's pie this very evening, or rather the veggie version with veggie mince (not quorn) which I believe is called shepherdess' pie.

Flavoured with mushroom ketchup and homegrown tomato sauce, plenty of carrots and peas (plus onion, red pepper and mushrooms). Topped with potato + sweet potato mash, small sprinkling of cheese.

Delicious!!

Branleuse · 19/11/2022 20:13

Like most foods, it can be made leaner quite easily. Youve made it sound gross in your description, but its a traditional dish and its delicious.
I would use as lean meat as i could find, and bulk out with soya,red lentils, chopped carrots, peas, celery, onion, garlic, mint, worcestershire sauce.
Id do the mash topping with mix of normal potatoes and sweet potatoes.

I love salad too, but would bore me to tears to eat it every day.
If you dont think youd like it, maybe have a day where you both sort your own food