Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dubious about shepherd's pie

156 replies

PickyEaters · 19/11/2022 19:41

OH and I are embarking on a healthy eating plan to lose weight. He has suggested shepherd's pie to go on the meal list as he "can't eat salad every day" (I like salad). I have never eaten shepherd's pie (I'm an immigrant) but it doesn't look very healthy to me (minced fatty lamb, potatoes and gravy with a few overcooked peas thrown in?), not to mention it sounds like it would taste disgusting! Isn't this something that featured heavily inschool dinners of the 1970s and should be banished to memory?

OP posts:
SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:36

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 15:26

I think it comes from it being an affordable food for people who lived in cottages - i.e. working farmhands, peasants etc.

Slaughtering a cow wasn't an easily affordable thing. Better to keep it kicking about producing milk for cheese. Assuming a peasant could afford a cow at all which is doubtful. A farm hand might have been given the worst cuts when a cow was slaughtered. Like when in Scotland they'd get the worst of the sheep which enabled them to make haggis perhaps?

viques · 20/11/2022 15:34

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:21

Oh and a question from another immigrant.....

I understand why shepherd's pie is called that but why is a version with beef called cottage pie? Not like your average UK cottage always had a cow chewing it's cud in the back garden. More likely to have chickens I would have thought. But there aren't any versions made with chicken that I've ever seen. And why isn't there??

I think because both shepherds pie and cottage pie are traditionally ways of using up left over meat, when we were kids they were always made with left over Sunday roast meat, my mum would not have bought uncooked mince specially, she would have got out her mincing machine and minced up cooked meat. We didn’t often eat chicken, amazing to think but in my long ago childhood chicken was a treat meat , not the relatively cheap mass produced everyday food it is now. And there isn’t much left on a chicken after a family has has a Sunday lunch and a late night sandwich, so a chicken carcass would probably have ended up as a soup on Monday.

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/11/2022 15:32

I like cottage pie better, and it's easier to make that low fat. (Tho a good shepherds pie is great too.)

The hairy bikers have a good cook book which makes lots of traditional dishes lower fat.

If he tries to eat salad all winter the healthy eating plan won't last very long.. tray bake are also good and easy.

Oldraver · 20/11/2022 15:30

I think the best Sheperds Pie is made from leftover roast lamb, I cut off any visible fat and mix it with any leftover gravy (that was made with the meat juices), top it with potato mash with added carrot or swede.

Though the ultimate mash is made with leftover onion sauce 9probably not diet friendly)

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 15:27

Chickens would have been kept primarily for eggs, and only eaten when they got beyond laying!

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 15:26

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:21

Oh and a question from another immigrant.....

I understand why shepherd's pie is called that but why is a version with beef called cottage pie? Not like your average UK cottage always had a cow chewing it's cud in the back garden. More likely to have chickens I would have thought. But there aren't any versions made with chicken that I've ever seen. And why isn't there??

I think it comes from it being an affordable food for people who lived in cottages - i.e. working farmhands, peasants etc.

BosaNova · 20/11/2022 15:25

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:21

Oh and a question from another immigrant.....

I understand why shepherd's pie is called that but why is a version with beef called cottage pie? Not like your average UK cottage always had a cow chewing it's cud in the back garden. More likely to have chickens I would have thought. But there aren't any versions made with chicken that I've ever seen. And why isn't there??

That is a good question!😂

Blip · 20/11/2022 15:24

I make with mashed sweet potato and swede instead of potato which makes it healthier. It's yummy.

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:21

Oh and a question from another immigrant.....

I understand why shepherd's pie is called that but why is a version with beef called cottage pie? Not like your average UK cottage always had a cow chewing it's cud in the back garden. More likely to have chickens I would have thought. But there aren't any versions made with chicken that I've ever seen. And why isn't there??

Creamcrackersandricecakes · 20/11/2022 15:20

RJnomore1 · 20/11/2022 14:42

Make it with turkey mince and sweet potato mash (old body building recipe I used to do)

Yes! Was just going to suggest this, it's delicious! Lots of chicken stock / gravy in the mince for flavour and plenty of pepper in the sweet potato mash - yum 🤤

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:17

VladmirsPoutine · 19/11/2022 21:00

Whether or not you think shepherd's pie is suitable for your dietary needs describing it as "sounds like it would taste disgusting" is frankly disgusting.

As opposed to poutine which these days does sometimes taste disgusting. Basic poutine is fine but the newer trendier variations are getting ridiculous. Why mess with a classic?

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 14:58

viques · 20/11/2022 14:52

I meant it in the sense that it is a meat and carb dish, not that it is a replica!

Ah, get what you mean now, sorry.

viques · 20/11/2022 14:52

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 14:47

Shepherds pie is lasagne under a different name

I always think of lasagne as being layers of pasta and mince, rather than potato (or similar) topped mince.

I meant it in the sense that it is a meat and carb dish, not that it is a replica!

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 14:47

Shepherds pie is lasagne under a different name

I always think of lasagne as being layers of pasta and mince, rather than potato (or similar) topped mince.

viques · 20/11/2022 14:44

Shepherds pie is lasagne under a different name, or lamb meatballs with pasta , or a lamb tagine, or a goat curry, or lamb pasanda, or lamb kebabs.

The world eats lamb, I suggest if you want to experience British lamb cookery at its glorious best you forget the shepherds pie and make Lancashire hot pot,

RJnomore1 · 20/11/2022 14:42

Make it with turkey mince and sweet potato mash (old body building recipe I used to do)

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 20/11/2022 14:36

Minced fatty lamb, potatoes and gravy with a few overcooked peas thrown in?

The version we make is very healthy - we use a relatively lean mince and fry it off in its own fat rather than using oil. Our gravy is made from stock and tinned tomatoes with lots of seasoning (but not salt), lovely mashed potato on the top, maybe a little cheese - we use the light mature cheddar. We don't put peas in because I also don't like them when they've been ovencooked, but we do put in carrots and onions and sometimes some pepper or courgette that is lying around, finely cut up. It's nice served with lightly cooked peas though.

Humans do need fats so it's fine so long as you don't have too many other fats in that day's meal plan. You can also make a nice version with very lean turkey or pork mince which technically isn't a shepherd's pie any more of course, or use the same recipe to make cottage pie with 5% lean beef. All nice.

I agree with your partner that salad every day could be a bit much. I love salad but I prefer to have hot vegetables at dinner time in the winter. But most dishes can have some lovely broccoli, green beans, peas etc. served alongside. Stirfries are another way of getting lots of veg into a meal.

Heronatemygoldfish · 20/11/2022 14:15

I make my base out of rehydrated soya mince, fried onions, peas, and instant onion gravy! (Don't eat beef or lamb). It gets topped with whatever mashed root veg is to hand, or even Smash if I get desperate. Major comfort food.

For those of you saying to use 5% fat mince of whatever source, it's not cost effective. I read somewhere that if you buy much higher fat mince then fry it and pour off the fat it still works out much cheaper per kg and has no appreciable difference in taste. I'll see if I can find the source...

WiddlinDiddlin · 20/11/2022 14:05

Anythings rank if you over cook it and use really fatty meat... mm.

I do cottage pie as I cannot stand lamb, it just tastes faintly sweet and sweaty to me.

Our cottage pie has paprika, chili, loads of veg and cheesey mash (sometimes its a sweet potato/normal potato mash, but ive done swede and potato, carrot, cauli and potato... whatever we have to hand really). It's so far from a cottage pie it isn't called cottage pie here, just PIE! We know what we mean.

Hobbesmanc · 20/11/2022 14:03

Lentil base. Sweet potato or carrot and swede topping. Yum and low cal and carb.

Livpool · 20/11/2022 13:54

LoveAngelLove · 20/11/2022 12:32

Just make sure there aren't any pages missing in the recipe book.

😂😂

"Meat good. Custard good"

Bunnynames101 · 20/11/2022 13:54

Swap the potato for sweet potato, use a leaner meat like turkey and do a tomato base instead of gravy, and add in loads of veg to the base. Still not a salad but much healthier.

FakingMemories · 20/11/2022 13:43

What does being an immigrant have to do with it? Fair enough you may not have grown up with it but that doesn’t mean you can’t try it as an adult. Maybe just try it before you write it off. It’s not particularly good for losing weight but it needn’t be fatty or as awful as you seem to think. Like most recipes, you can use it as a base or a suggestion and modify it to your taste. I add more vegetables when I make it, for example.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/11/2022 13:40

ilovepixie · 20/11/2022 13:39

I call it shepherds pie but it's

Low fat beef mince cooked with stock, carrots and onions. Thicken mince with bisto when cooked. Put in dish. Mashed potato on top. Brown under grill and serve with cabbage. It's lovely.

That's cottage pie

ilovepixie · 20/11/2022 13:39

I call it shepherds pie but it's

Low fat beef mince cooked with stock, carrots and onions. Thicken mince with bisto when cooked. Put in dish. Mashed potato on top. Brown under grill and serve with cabbage. It's lovely.