Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dubious about shepherd's pie

156 replies

PickyEaters · 19/11/2022 19:41

OH and I are embarking on a healthy eating plan to lose weight. He has suggested shepherd's pie to go on the meal list as he "can't eat salad every day" (I like salad). I have never eaten shepherd's pie (I'm an immigrant) but it doesn't look very healthy to me (minced fatty lamb, potatoes and gravy with a few overcooked peas thrown in?), not to mention it sounds like it would taste disgusting! Isn't this something that featured heavily inschool dinners of the 1970s and should be banished to memory?

OP posts:
Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 21:30

There are lots of healthy shepards pie recipes. I prefer cottage pie.

but as others have said bulk it up with lots of vegetables. But as part of a balanced diet, low fat mince, carrots, peas, onion, celery and potatoes is not particularly unhealthy.

girlmom21 · 20/11/2022 21:19

PickyEaters · 20/11/2022 21:01

This version looks particularly appetising...

Don't use Rate My Plate for meal inspo

TwoMonthsOff · 20/11/2022 21:10

@Oysterbabe
dried lentils are good at absorbing the stock arent they? im always a bit scared to use dry ones in case the lentils stay but hard or firm ....so i add pre cooked ones in when it looks the right consistency, nothing worse that the potato sinking in if the filling is too wet, i guess its all experimentation

TwoMonthsOff · 20/11/2022 21:04

Then on the other side of the coin ....

Dubious about shepherd's pie
Oysterbabe · 20/11/2022 21:03

I use dried green lentils but I cook mine in the pressure cooker so just sling them in dry.

PickyEaters · 20/11/2022 21:01

This version looks particularly appetising...

Dubious about shepherd's pie
OP posts:
TwoMonthsOff · 20/11/2022 20:58

@Towcester
red lentils are too soft and more suited to dahl so they lose their texture in a cottage pie the best ones to use in a cottage pie are Puy lentils like the 'merchant gourmet' pouches (pre - cooked) or the canned green ones ( unless you can be bothered to soak which i cant) the canned green ones just need a rinse and are a lot less expensive than puy - i have used both an to be honest cant really tell much difference, just need to make sure they go in towards the end - at the final stage of simmering as you don't want to end up with mushy lentils (if using pre-cooked)

BlackForestCake · 20/11/2022 20:50

What does being an immigrant have to do with it?

To avoid questions about how a person could possibly have grown up in this country and never have eaten shepherd's pie, I would think.

Towcester · 20/11/2022 20:45

ClownSchool · 19/11/2022 19:44

Can also chuck in a handful of lentils or beans to bulk it out and up the protein content without adding more fat.

Might try that. Lentils go in the frying pan with onions and veg? Red split lentils? Thanks

Cas112 · 20/11/2022 20:35

Your missing out

BlackeyedGruesome · 20/11/2022 17:50

Nah, you are right, it's horrible.

ithoughtisawapuddycat · 20/11/2022 17:44

Try cottage pie with a 3% mince beef. You could also use carrot and swede mash on top instead of potatoes.

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 17:39

TwoMonthsOff · 20/11/2022 17:35

Slightly off topic but I read that fish pie originated in Alaska - but with rice on top,instead of potatoes, I guess it’s hard to grow potatoes in that climate though and of course they get the best fish there, Regional food is interesting I think. Cottage/shepherds pie and veggie versions now have been a staple and a favourite UK meal for years, I think it’s nice to carry on the traditions it’s obviously loved it it would have vanished from menus by now

That sounds lovely (fish pie with rice topping) - I wonder why it hasn't caught on here? Not that fish pie with potatoes isn't lovely, but as a change. You could cook the rice in a cheese sauce.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/11/2022 17:39

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:21

Oh and a question from another immigrant.....

I understand why shepherd's pie is called that but why is a version with beef called cottage pie? Not like your average UK cottage always had a cow chewing it's cud in the back garden. More likely to have chickens I would have thought. But there aren't any versions made with chicken that I've ever seen. And why isn't there??

Sheep were out on the Moor with the Shepherds and the cows were closer to home for milking?

Chickens were used for chicken pie - it tends to need the moisture of a sauce - and peas and carrots - when encased in pastry. My mother used to make a version with white sauce and choux pastry as well.

Depending upon background, the OP could make something in keeping with her tastes (so spices, herbs and tomatoes) and then top with mashed vegetables. Not a Shepherds or Cottage Pie, but a close approximation. Or top with sliced potatoes (carrots, swede, turnip, daikon, sweet potato, etc) instead.

TwoMonthsOff · 20/11/2022 17:35

Slightly off topic but I read that fish pie originated in Alaska - but with rice on top,instead of potatoes, I guess it’s hard to grow potatoes in that climate though and of course they get the best fish there, Regional food is interesting I think. Cottage/shepherds pie and veggie versions now have been a staple and a favourite UK meal for years, I think it’s nice to carry on the traditions it’s obviously loved it it would have vanished from menus by now

TrentCrimm · 20/11/2022 16:56

I have never eaten shepherd's pie (I'm an immigrant) but it doesn't look very healthy to me

Well to be fair, you didn't pack on those pounds eating quinoa salad Grin

LordEmsworth · 20/11/2022 16:51
  1. A meal made up of meat, potatoes, veg & gravy is not even remotely unhealthy... Much more nutritious than a salad 🙄
  2. You know who says "I don't like that" before they've tried it? 5 year olds. Not grown adults
Sunnydays0101 · 20/11/2022 16:47

What recipe said you need over-cooked peas???

RoachPussy · 20/11/2022 16:12

Delia Smith’s shepherd’s pie with cheese crusted leeks is my favourite recipe but I put a lot more veg in it.

AbreathofFrenchair · 20/11/2022 16:04

PickyEaters · 19/11/2022 19:41

OH and I are embarking on a healthy eating plan to lose weight. He has suggested shepherd's pie to go on the meal list as he "can't eat salad every day" (I like salad). I have never eaten shepherd's pie (I'm an immigrant) but it doesn't look very healthy to me (minced fatty lamb, potatoes and gravy with a few overcooked peas thrown in?), not to mention it sounds like it would taste disgusting! Isn't this something that featured heavily inschool dinners of the 1970s and should be banished to memory?

You have very strong opinions on food that you've never tried and declared a food immigrants wouldn't eat?!

Maybe learn to cook, make one properly and then given an opinion?

maddy68 · 20/11/2022 15:52

Strain the fat off when eating and it's reasonably healthy. (and delicious!)

RoseValleyRambles · 20/11/2022 15:44

They the spiced parsnip one off BBC good food.. It's amazing.

DelilahBucket · 20/11/2022 15:42

Make a cottage pie instead. Lean mince beef, pad it out with lots of veg and/or lentils, sweet potato topping.
On a side note, if you deem everything bar salad to be unhealthy and you are cutting these things out of your diet completely, you are not going to last long on your new regime. Everything in moderation is key and weigh stuff.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 20/11/2022 15:41

It's a poverty food - made of the leftovers of a roast, traditionally, and padded out with spuds as they became a very cheap crop in the UK and ireland. My mum used to make it with leftover braised steak.

There are male calves born to a dairy herd who are often killed for meat where the females build the herd size; the beef us a byproduct of running a traditional dairy. Ditto chickens - you'd not kill a layer but the male chicks could be reared for meat.

Cottage pie is delicious and easy to make healthy, especially if you rice your spuds for mash, and mix your meat with lentils.

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 15:40

SmudgeButt · 20/11/2022 15:36

Slaughtering a cow wasn't an easily affordable thing. Better to keep it kicking about producing milk for cheese. Assuming a peasant could afford a cow at all which is doubtful. A farm hand might have been given the worst cuts when a cow was slaughtered. Like when in Scotland they'd get the worst of the sheep which enabled them to make haggis perhaps?

I'm guessing it wouldn't have been their own cow; like you say, more likely to be the 'off cuts' being sold cheaply to the farm workers.