Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open book degree exams

35 replies

KathySeldon · 19/11/2022 18:44

Been to a Uni open day today, and was shocked to find out that the degree course - psychology - is assessed by a series of open book exams done on a computer.

Am I just out of date? Is this how degrees are now? No formal paper exams in a hall??
Do all universities do this?
I would say the Uni we were visiting is a lower tariff uni if that makes any difference.
Does this form of assessment devalue the degree??
I'm suddenly really confused. I thought all degrees were assessed the same way.

Should dd avoid such a degree?? Is it ok to do a degree like this??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SarahAndQuack · 19/11/2022 22:01

KathySeldon · 19/11/2022 20:54

Does it matter which uni your degree comes from? Is it ok to look at the course modules, then look for unis by the coast (dd wants to be by the sea), then visit and meet the staff?
Are we doing this right?

Definitely look at course modules. I'd also see if you can find information on graduate jobs that students get.Universities will often make this information accessible, but they all dress it up massively so you need to hack through the bullshit, but if you compare one with another, you soon get a sense of what actually sounds good. You can also look at rankings, eg. in the Times or the Guardian. These rankings will vary and you need to take them with a big pinch of salt, but they can help you get a bit of a sense of things.

Have you/ your DD been on The Student Room? That can be useful too.

RunLolaRun102 · 19/11/2022 21:39

In the UK a lot of professional degrees have some exams that are open book - they aren’t easier. If anything they can be a lot tougher and a single question may make you cover concepts across the course. They do this to test comprehension skills because many overseas students come from countries where facts are memorised by rote & they can memorise but not apply what they learned - this is well known in India (it’s why many Indian IT / Medical / Pharmacy professionals end up in management because they can’t learn new technical skills).

Funandgamestill · 19/11/2022 21:22

KathySeldon · 19/11/2022 20:54

Does it matter which uni your degree comes from? Is it ok to look at the course modules, then look for unis by the coast (dd wants to be by the sea), then visit and meet the staff?
Are we doing this right?

It does matter where you study if the career is competitive . yes . It doesn’t matter if the degree leads to a standard qualification that’s a credited by an exterior agency like NHS for instance - no one will care where you qualified .
for a standard Bachelors to really open doors though the networking is important which is why it’s worth comparing a few .
Your DD sounds a lot like me , I loved the coast so wanted to study at a seaside uni .
fact is though May - October when the weathers okay to enjoy the beach uni is off anyway so she could study in London but take a summer job in Plymouth or wherever ?

M0rT · 19/11/2022 21:16

It depends what your DD wants to study.
There are some degrees which have a better perception then others but it is not automatically "top" uni is best.
It can be more related to a specific course.
So your DD should do her best to research which courses have the best reputation in her desired field, then narrow them down to near the sea and which look most interesting to her.
Best of luck to her, it's an exciting time.

AlfiesGirl · 19/11/2022 21:12

DD is in her final year at a RG Uni and has been entirely assessed by essay or timed essay (given a title and 48 hours to submit). At first I assumed it was because of Covid and not being allowed to have all students in an exam hall but it seems there will be no proper finals either.

KathySeldon · 19/11/2022 20:54

Does it matter which uni your degree comes from? Is it ok to look at the course modules, then look for unis by the coast (dd wants to be by the sea), then visit and meet the staff?
Are we doing this right?

OP posts:
lieselotte · 19/11/2022 20:54

KrisAkabusi · 19/11/2022 19:10

In real life you don't have to remember equations, formulae, citations, etc. They are all easily available. Open book exams better reflect the real world, not just the ability to remember things. Also, while the information may be available, you still have to know how to use it, assess what's important, what is relevant etc. You still need to be able to make an argument and defend your position. I don't have an issue with open-book exams. Remembering a book isn't important, it's understanding what it means.

Exactly this!

FictionalCharacter · 19/11/2022 20:53

Don’t think open book exams are easier. They can be really hard! You’re expected to apply what you’ve learned to interpret and solve problems- much harder than regurgitating facts.

2ndMrsdeWinter · 19/11/2022 20:47

Agree with others that it’s all about application. I did an allied health degree where we were assessed with majority open book exams and no amount of googling could diagnose a simulated client or tell me what intervention they would need. Fact regurgitation is a fairly useless way to assess application of knowledge.

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2022 20:45

Just finished law degree then masters at an rg. Exams over the 3 years all 24 hour open book. I thibk they will go back to being 4 hours but stlll online and open book.

Think of the advantages for marking -all typed scripts that are legible!

24 hours was knackering though -they said do it in normal 3 but most people worked through the night. I would have spent 15 hours I reckon. Much time spent trying to reduce words down to the word limit to be fair!

KathySeldon · 19/11/2022 20:40

OK.

So just to explain where I'm coming from, dh and I both did performance diplomas at music college, and dc1 is at Oxford doing science/maths stuff. All quite different experiences to the usual uni degree dd wants to do. Despite being pretty clever, sit down, long exams are not her forte.

OP posts:
slashlover · 19/11/2022 20:38

I'm doing Psychology with the OU, only had one exam which wasn't open book but was a partially seen exam.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 19/11/2022 20:29

My first degree had most of its assessment via closed book traditional exams. They were too much of a memory test and good grades were skewed to those people who had better memories, or quite good ones and worked extremely hard to get things to stick. If you didn't, it was very tough indeed and not a measure of your ability in the subject and whether you could apply it in the real world (or do much in the real world). And I say this as one of the former group (very good memory and naturally performed well in exams without much anxiety - well, in my youth not now!!), not because I'm bitter about getting lower grades as I did not.

Sindonym · 19/11/2022 20:27

Many years ago I went to Oxford - finals held over 4 days decided the entire degree - obviously no open book exams.

Have recently completed a degree (lower tariff uni) where the classification was decided from (a lot of) work submitted over 2 years. Coursework was the most common means of assessment, but also had closed book and open book exams & vivas. I found open book hard because you end up trying to write a coursework standard piece of work, but don’t have the time.

I think the lower tariff uni approach provided a
much more accurate representation of someone’s ability. I personally found it really stressful because I couldn’t spend my second year doing fuck all or sat in the pub (Oxford experience). The coursework/open book approach really isn’t easier and I think it leads to students working harder. In fact at the end of my degree my feedback to the uni was that they needed to replace some coursework with exams to reduce the workload.

Lolreally · 19/11/2022 20:23

@SarahAndQuack beautiful 👌

Chomolungma · 19/11/2022 20:23

Open book exams test understanding rather than just pure memory. I think there is a place for both.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 19/11/2022 20:23

I already have a degree, but my accounting course now is assessed by open book exams. It doesn’t really help. The time pressure is huge, and the questions are more about applying knowledge, so reading a textbook during the exam won’t give the right answer.

^^This. The way the exam is set and how much is expected in the time takes into account the open book nature. I have done an open book exam for health statistics, and I even had 25% extra time due to disability, and it was really tough. I'd prepared for ages beforehand, labelled relevant bits with post-it tabs and a couple of short pages of notes, but you had to know exactly what you were looking up and why, to get a benefit, and there was only time to do this once or twice. (I'm good at maths and passed well but many said it was the hardest exam they've ever done, in both the +25% room and main hall and I can totally understand why.)

daisychain01 · 19/11/2022 20:22

When you have to answer questions under exam conditions and to a strict timescale eg 1 hour or 9 mins, it's just as difficult as a closed book exam in my experience. You don't have time to waste flicking through a book or file of your notes. You have to know the subject inside out, and any materials you take into the exam can only ever be memory joggers, in case your mind goes completely blank.

you may also be given restrictions such as you can only bring certain materials in with you, not 4 books, a folder of notes plus plus plus, You also won't get access to the internet so you can't Google anything and you won't have time anyway. I've found that I needed to study and prepare more for an open book exam.

SarahAndQuack · 19/11/2022 20:21

houselikeashed · 19/11/2022 20:13

Golly ok.

I have always been under the impression that a degree was an academic qualification, and therefore assessed via formal exams.
I feel very out of touch now.

Confused

Why do you think these aren't formal exams?

Don't worry about being out of touch - it is really hard figuring out how university works, especially if you didn't go yourself, because it's surprisingly different from school. But don't jump to assuming that, just because the exams don't look like what you remember from school, they are therefore not academic or not as rigorous. It doesn't work like that.

M0rT · 19/11/2022 20:19

I've sat open book exams and find them much harder.
Because you have the formulae/standard etc with you the questions are all about application.
It's still a memory game and also an organisation challenge, you need to know exactly where in a book a piece of information is so you can access it in seconds because of the time pressure.
I think the degrees where the vast majority of the marks are attendence/participation and continuous assessment are probably much more reflective of the working world.

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 19/11/2022 20:18

A degree is an academic qualification but that doesn't nec mean exams :)

houselikeashed · 19/11/2022 20:13

Golly ok.

I have always been under the impression that a degree was an academic qualification, and therefore assessed via formal exams.
I feel very out of touch now.

FurAndFeathers · 19/11/2022 20:09

Open book exams are more aligned with how you’ll apply knowledge in the real world.

they’re usually application-based rather than fact-regurgitation and so require a deeper understanding of the subject material

Cottagegarden11 · 19/11/2022 20:06

Just make sure the degree is BPS accredited, but sounds very normal to only have open book.

superdupernova · 19/11/2022 19:59

The uni where I worked did this as a covid measure. We're back to normal closed book exams now but a lot of lecturers have swapped to assignments anyway.