Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to think it’s a bit tight & embarrassing to haggle on some things?

442 replies

NellesVilla · 19/11/2022 18:32

Hello all,

I was due to cat and dog sit over Xmas for about 3 x weeks. It had been booked since last Xmas. I’ve worked for the for years and already offer them a mates’ rate discount- relevant.I was also their nanny several years’ ago whilst at uni.

Last night the family called me to ask for another discount just over 2 weeks’ before the start date, plus asking if I’d contribute to bills for my ‘stay’. Not that it matters but they are loaded, are flying to the states to a v expensive Christmassy city, and will be spending shitloads- they do every year.

So they want a discount on the already crazily reduced bargain rate I give them; money that I need and forms part of my meagre current income. Additionally, they’d like something towards bills- when they have asked me to care for their home and cherished pets.

Wtaf? Is this normal? Do I tell them to take a long walk off a short pier or what?! Please vipers; I need to grow a pair as I find this type of thing- money-orientated issue- challenging at the best of times!!

OP posts:
LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 19/11/2022 20:00

I certainly wouldn't blame most people, even if they look quite well off (often there's a huge mortgage or other expenses that you don't know about), for being "tight" at this point in the proceedings!

They are quite CF-ish but in many cultures haggling and rehaggling is just par for the course.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 19:59

oldbrownjug · 19/11/2022 18:51

Agree - keep it simple and professional. I like "That won't be possible" - neutral.

What are your cancellation terms? And could you afford to drop them? If you can I'd be tempted to do that. Bills over Christmas will be high as you'll be in the house all day and it's likely to be cold. You don't want any awkwardness either when they get back over how much you had the heating on.

If you could do it in a professional manner I'd be thinking of cancelling altogether.

Eh?

OP isn't a GUEST.

If you work indoors for an employer, do you expect to contribute to workplace heating costs @oldbrownjug?

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 19/11/2022 19:59

It's fine for them to try it on, it's fine for you to firmly say no. Without excess explanation.

Momo8 · 19/11/2022 19:59

I'd agree to the reduction, but the day before they're due to leave, I'd double your normal price.

MatronicO6 · 19/11/2022 19:59

They are taking advantage of your goodwill. They are not doing you a favour, you are providing a service at a good deal cheaper than the market rate. Agree with PP's and call them out on it and tell them you cannot drop the rate any lower or contribute to bills as that is the nature of the service, if problematic, they can find an alternative.

And do yourself a favour and increase your rates next time you sit for them. If they were willing to take advantage of your good nature, they aren't very deserving of mates rates.

Fireballxl5 · 19/11/2022 19:59

We have a dog sitter who works from her home.
When we drop off our ddog we always pay in advance and always add a bit extra because we know ddog is happy there.

LumpyandBumps · 19/11/2022 19:57

How about

’ It is such a relief that you have raised the matter of renegotiating fees as mine have increased and I didn’t know how to broach the subject with you as I thought our deal was set in stone and I didn’t want to go back on that. My new fees are £x and I also now need to ask for payment in advance’

user1471453601 · 19/11/2022 19:52

As an atheist, I still think there are many phrases in the bible that ring true for me. Not least of which is that a labourer is worthy of his wages.

unless you are in need of the money, I would cancel your arrangements, no discussion, no negotiation. In other words, drop them in it

Piffle11 · 19/11/2022 19:49

Finding someone trustworthy to housesit and/or pets it can be incredibly difficult.I have recently been fortunate enough to have had a really wonderful woman referred to me by a friend: I agreed to pay her the price she charges, and I agreed to pay her upfront as she requested.

I really think you need to say to these people – as others have suggested – no, that will not be possible. You need to cover your expenses: you need to start realising the value of your service. What will these people do, if you decline their offer? Will they be able to find someone else at short notice, who they can trust? Probably not. They are really relying on your good nature… Chances are they know the sort of person you are, and think that they can manipulate you into accepting less money. I think that you need to start telling people that you need the money upfront: that way, they cannot return from their holiday and basically tell you that they will be paying you less than originally agreed.

I don't know where in the country you live, but where I am, good pet sitting services are in huge demand. you don't need to get into an argument, you don't need to confront them. Just tell them, No: this is what I charge for my service, and it is non-negotiable.

The cost of living is rising… Most services are increasing their prices. Call their bluff, refuse to work for less than what you would usually charge. Good luck!

Secretboringsister · 19/11/2022 19:48

Absolutely shocking! If you end up cancelling DM me I know about 3 family friends who are desperately looking for house and pet sitters for 4-5 weeks who have beautiful homes and lovely older pets here in London who are happy to pay market rates for an amazing, caring, responsible and referenced person and everyone is booked! (Also the people I know aren’t complete ass hats like these cheeky FRS!!)

DWMoosmum · 19/11/2022 19:45

@badbaduncle Oh my days, that's ridiculous but sadly doesn't surprise me.

My old boss was a multi millionaire but haggled over literally every single thing. He'd cut corners in favour of having something done cheaply, even if it meant having it done twice! 🤬

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 19/11/2022 19:45

FriedDuck · 19/11/2022 19:14

This is a tough one. While I appreciate that this is income that has been agreed for a while, I do think everyone is having to look at efficiencies and ways they can save money while maintaining their lifestyle as far as possible.

We’ve had to reduce our cleaner’s hours given the current cost of living and I know a neighbour has asked their gardener to take a pay cut.

On a different scale, DH’s wealthy cousin rents a yacht every year for the winter and this year, they are having to run with just 2 crew members instead of 4 due to try and keep costs down.

So the poor gardner has to take a pay cut to fund the owners lifestyle. Nice.Capitalism explained really well here.
Screw efficiencies of yacht owners. What if there was an emergency and you needed more staff? Theyll probably sill expect the poor 2 staff to work like dogs I bet

JCoverdale · 19/11/2022 19:43

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 19/11/2022 18:41

I’d tell them the full rate and ask if they would prefer to pay that instead of the already discounted rate you have offered. I’d also get a 50% deposit or payment in advance because I can see it coming a mile off that these CFs will try to stiff you at the end after you’ve done the work.

THIS ^^^

KenAdams · 19/11/2022 19:42

"Thank you for raising the issue of pricing. As you elude to in you message, the cost of living has increased significantly and as a result I have had to raise my pricing by 50%, payable upfront. I understand if you would prefer to cancel your booking do please confirm by X date as I have another family on the waiting list during your booking period."

Salome61 · 19/11/2022 19:41

I'm so sorry they have done this, and completely lost your respect. As you cannot trust them, I would also ask for the agreed amount in advance prior to commencing the job, and never work for them again.

NellesVilla · 19/11/2022 19:41

Thanks for all the replies; most of which are incredibly helpful. I think I am a bit of a mug and need more self-respect.

Over the years I’ve given so many discounts on services my little businesses have offered- almost as if I’m embarrassed to accept payment for work.

When it comes to pets I adore (and working for friends) I find it agonizing to set rates and accept money. Probably a big reason I still don’t have my own house!

I also think that many of my clients have not realised/cared that house and pet-sitting is a service. I love doing it and caring for their amazing pets, but they seem to think I’m privileged to do it. Well, it’s my income!

OP posts:
NurseBernard · 19/11/2022 19:40

FriedDuck · 19/11/2022 19:35

I do think it’s unreasonable expecting you to effectively pay board. However, I do think it’s fair at least asking the question if there is the possibility to make efficiencies in regard to the rate.

She’s already given them a discount.

’Efficiencies’ have already been made.

So, what - you think they can just keep asking and asking and asking - because it’s ‘fair’ to ask?

badbaduncle · 19/11/2022 19:39

DWMoosmum · 19/11/2022 19:38

You're house sitting their beloved pets. That's like asking a baby sitter to contribute to the nappies and food you might use. I would absolutely not offer them anymore discount and I'd them I won't be contributing to the house hold bills. They'll be very very lucky if they can find someone at short notice now. It's always the ones that can afford it that haggle everything.

My SIL once said to me that her Au Pair should pay for herself when she took 4DC under 10 to watch Minions because "she was seeing the film too"
This is how these people are.

badbaduncle · 19/11/2022 19:38

FriedDuck · 19/11/2022 19:14

This is a tough one. While I appreciate that this is income that has been agreed for a while, I do think everyone is having to look at efficiencies and ways they can save money while maintaining their lifestyle as far as possible.

We’ve had to reduce our cleaner’s hours given the current cost of living and I know a neighbour has asked their gardener to take a pay cut.

On a different scale, DH’s wealthy cousin rents a yacht every year for the winter and this year, they are having to run with just 2 crew members instead of 4 due to try and keep costs down.

This is comedy gold. BRAVO @FriedDuck BRAVO

DWMoosmum · 19/11/2022 19:38

You're house sitting their beloved pets. That's like asking a baby sitter to contribute to the nappies and food you might use. I would absolutely not offer them anymore discount and I'd them I won't be contributing to the house hold bills. They'll be very very lucky if they can find someone at short notice now. It's always the ones that can afford it that haggle everything.

FriedDuck · 19/11/2022 19:35

I do think it’s unreasonable expecting you to effectively pay board. However, I do think it’s fair at least asking the question if there is the possibility to make efficiencies in regard to the rate.

Waterfalls39 · 19/11/2022 19:34

"I have had time to think over your offer, but thought I'd already made it clear that I was offering my services at a substantial discount given our previous relationship. I am a little surprised that you would ask, especially as I'm going to be earning a lot less than I could be given the time of year. So I am unable to offer even further discount and the fee will be that agreed originally. Please let me know if you still want to go ahead as I have several other options in reserve".

Alaimo · 19/11/2022 19:33

If you can afford to lose them as clients I'd message back "I have considered your request. On reflection, to be able to cope with the cost of living crisis, I have no choice but to increase my rate by 20%. Please let me know if you want to proceed by the end of the week."

If you do want to keep them as clients I'd message them a more polite sorry no can do.

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 19/11/2022 19:29

I have a house/pet sitter over Christmas and she’s so worth the cost. I can enjoy my Christmas break knowing that my house is safe and my pets are happy and well looked after in their own environment. It’s certainly money well spent and I even buy her a Christmas present as I’m so happy she’s here.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 19/11/2022 19:29

Let them know youve already given them a discount. Then ask them if they want to cancel so you can book yourself elsewhere. Let them know of a cancellation fee as well OP. They sound like pisstakers

Swipe left for the next trending thread