Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and aligning in-laws

138 replies

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 12:02

You read a lot on MN about sons not bothering about their aging parents and I seem to be married to one. DH's parents are elderly, his father is bed bound and his mother had a breakdown and has been in a mental hospital for the last six months. DH's sister lives with his parents and is caring for the dad while holding down a full time job. Initially when MIL went into hospital DH would go over for a day or two per week to help out the sister but then it stopped being practical and he has now only been once every month/ every other month. He has only visited his mother in hospital once back in the summer and hasnt bothered since.We live in the same city as them though it does take over an hour and half each way to get to them from our place.

I know it's his family and I leave him to it. But it feels rather heartless and very uncaring. He would say that he loves me and the kids etc and we are definitely 50/50 when it comes to raising them. It just feels like he's basically abandoned his family and it has sort of impacted on how I see him. I just feels weird reconciling this image of him as a caring family man to us who has simultaneously given up on his parents and effectively sister when they are all really struggling. Not sure what the AIBU is here - but perhaps it's whether or not I am unreasonable to feel that his attitude has impacted on my image of him, I guess.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 15:39

I think it's trembly difficult and a very complex dynamic and you seeing him as cold and heartless is unfair.

What I'm hearing from his 'side' is that his mother was entirely focused on FIL's care from when DH was fairly young. She may have been emotionally fixed on that and not his needs. He is their child so adequate physical care and hobbies doesn't really cut it. He clearly found his very difficult and left as soon as he could. But always felt out of place and untethered as is really common with children who haven't had a good attachment to parents. He talks about this in terms of skiing and university but what he may actually be saying is that no one cared and parented and looked after him in the way that would have made him confident and happy. He still feels the lack of it.

He got out, made himself, is successful. However, addressing their care needs makes him avoidant because he has to then remember their lack of care of him. He's avoiding thinking about it, looking at it because it's painful.

His sister on the other hand went the other way and has a codependent, overly attached relationship, modelling mum's behaviour. Some of which is definitely about sex-roles and as a feminist that gets my back up. But I don't think your DH is just being a typical sexist bloke here.

All of the above might be bollocks but I'd lay money it's not. He needs support, love and space to process stuff. Probably someone trained to listen.

aloris · 19/11/2022 15:37

I have not seen a man do hands-on care. Almost always, it seems to be the women. What I have seen of men doing care is they basically visit for a short period, then after they leave, they give a verbal assessment of the quality of care provided by the other family caregivers, and usually give the sisters or other women caregivers a lot of instructions. They seem to consider that to be a form of "helping." Then they disappear for months or a year or more, content in the knowledge they've done their part. So your husband's unwillingness to provide care may or may not be down to his parents' failures when they took care of him as a child, or maybe it's just that he's a man and men can always come up with a rationale for not providing care.

I think there is a difference between having a boring or blah childhood, vs having a childhood with neglect or abuse. It's hard to say if your husband is being fair here: ski trips and guiding your child to the best universities or professional path isn't a marker of your fitness as a parent.

On the other hand, your husband's father would rather see his wife make herself sick caring for him, and would rather see his daughter spend her best years caring for him, than go into a home. I'm sure there are many elderly people who do the same, but I think it's a bit selfish. Your husband can certainly nudge his sister to tell his dad she can't care for him any more, so that he is left with no other choice but to go into a home, but I think his father's refusal to do so (unless forced) puts a pretty big guilt-trip on his daughter. It's going to be hard for your husband to work around that, and he probably knows it. It sounds like your husband has essentially taken the position that his sister should save herself, and if she chooses not to, it's not your husband's job to put himself in the same bad position as his sister just because she has chosen to enable her father's needy choices.

As to his mother: he should visit his mother in hospital.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 15:31

Yep, I've offered that once the kids are on holidays, DH can go and stay with PIL and SIL can come and stay at our house for a week to give her a break. Not sure if DH mentioned it to her not. I know she wouldnt want to impose etc

OP posts:
Lost2010 · 19/11/2022 15:27

@jhfs8979 not much of advice but you could reach out to your SIL and offer to do something nice for her? Even ordering food / groceries online (if you can afford to) if you can’t go to her. Any small gesture that shows her she has someone else she might be able to count on. Not necessarily for day to day but anything at all that provides her some relief ?

NoKnit · 19/11/2022 15:19

This is totally all relative to the relationship they have abd how close they are abd what was done in the past.

For example my in-laws are currently still fit and they do a fair amount of childcare for SIL (my husbands sister) and almost nothing for us because we live a lot further away. I'm clearly expecting my SIL to take more of a leading role in the care when they are older. My husband can't keep going home to care for them when they are older in the same way that they just couldn't come over every time we need someone to watch our kids. They do this for SIL and I think she gets my thoughts on this.

Namenic · 19/11/2022 15:09

this would disturb me and I think I would lose some respect for DH over this. I would ask him if this bothered him. What would he want to happen to him if he was sick in hospital and I was unable to visit? How would he like his kids to treat him?

I would take the kids to hospital once per week or once per fortnight to see MiL (if she was able to interact with them and if they were allowed on the ward). I’d also try and visit FiL with them. I would want to teach my kids that it is a good thing to visit relatives to cheer them up if they are ill or lonely. In the right situation Care homes can be a positive thing - if there is help for the day to day physical care, sometimes relatives and friends can have more energy to put into the social side of things - chatting, looking at photos etc.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 15:08

@cptartapp SIL was definitely not the favoured child. But she's younger and basically never left home. The current set up is hard. FIL refuses to go into a home, MIL is out of the picture for the last six months and cant have a say. SIL is finding it extraordinarily hard but cant see another way because she's grown up with it. Quietly I think everyone is waiting for MIL to return and get back to it. But she wont be able to - not anymore. It is hard and very emotional. But FIL didnt ask to be disable, MIl didnt ask for her lot in life either.

My parents are in the same city as us, we usually see them every other week. DH is actually really nice with them. So it's seems odd that it's only with his folks that he is like that. However, I dont think his parents were bad parents or anything. They were nice in a way that was usual for their class and generation. No, they didnt teach him how to ski, he couldnt always bring friends home because of the dad but they took them on holiday, the kids had hobbies, a nice enough home, went to a standard school. Apart from his dad becoming disable, there was no other trauma and whilst his mum probably didnt support DH enough through that - she had a husband to look after, SIL who was still little at the time and I guess his mum just assumed he'd be alright.

OP posts:
Familydilemmas · 19/11/2022 14:58

Bigbadfish · 19/11/2022 14:40

But why is your mums lack of boundaries your uncles fault? If they abused her let them rot.

The support she needed wasn’t with physical care, it was decision making. And I said I suspect abuse however it has never been confirmed by anyone, they just say they didn’t have great childhoods. My uncle was still visiting but would go in for a few minutes then disappear for months after giving my Mum a list of jobs to do.

Zilla1 · 19/11/2022 14:57

@MrsDanversGlidesAgain indeed though some people feel deeply the priority of their own needs to the exclusion of anyone else. You might have felt deeply the rightness of your treatment of the second Mrs De Winter but that wouldn't necessarily have made that bad behaviour right.

cptartapp · 19/11/2022 14:47

Your PIL should free SIL to live her own life. I hope I don't put that on my adult DC in the prime of their lives. Dreadful letting her do that because FIL 'doesn't want' to go into a home. I would think a lot less of them prioritising themselves at her expense indefinitely.
Was SIL the favoured one growing up?

Chamomileteaplease · 19/11/2022 14:44

It seems the sister won't be helped so maybe your husband wants to wash his hands of it all. It sounds very messy.

Bigbadfish · 19/11/2022 14:40

Familydilemmas · 19/11/2022 14:25

I agree the concern from your husband needs to be towards his sister. As a family we’ve been through similar. My Mum has done everything whilst my Uncle has carried on with life. It’s caused a lot of resentment. My Mum and Uncle had difficult childhoods, their parents never really cared or nurtured them and i suspect there was some emotional and possibly physical abuse going on. My Mum felt very torn giving up so much of her life for parents who didn’t give much up for them. It was difficult. But she needed my Uncles support.

But why is your mums lack of boundaries your uncles fault? If they abused her let them rot.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 14:34

I am not actually sure DH wants his parents in a home. He says it's up to his sister. Mentions that his dad doesnt want to go and neither does his sister. He is definitely relying on her taking care of FIL. And kind of expects his mother to pick up where she left of once back from the hospital, this is totally unrealistic as apparently his mother is barely walking now. In the case of his sister, she seems to feel overwhelmed and sort of soldiering on like her mother. DH would actually be completely fine if the whole inheritance goes to her.

OP posts:
Fenella123 · 19/11/2022 14:27

I am tempted to say, ask him about his childhood. Ask him about how he feels now. And listen before you say anything back. Your advice and suggestions will be taken so much better if he has every reason to think you know the whole picture and have taken pains to understand his position.

If he was my friend, I might, might, carefully ask what his own hopes are for his relationship with the kids when he's old, and their relationship with each other, and point out that he's their role model - they're likely to do what they see him doing now.

He may well not be close to his parents, but how is his relationship with his sister? Does he feel she's determined on martyring herself and won't listen when he says they should both be in full-time residential care together?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/11/2022 14:26

Where are your parents,OP? How often do you see them? What sort of relationship with them does your DH have?

My DH moved ( al to further) away when he was 29, and has rarely been back to visit. He just doesn’t feel much connection.

he is very loving and supportive to the family he has created, and to many other people with whom he has no blood relationship.

Familydilemmas · 19/11/2022 14:25

I agree the concern from your husband needs to be towards his sister. As a family we’ve been through similar. My Mum has done everything whilst my Uncle has carried on with life. It’s caused a lot of resentment. My Mum and Uncle had difficult childhoods, their parents never really cared or nurtured them and i suspect there was some emotional and possibly physical abuse going on. My Mum felt very torn giving up so much of her life for parents who didn’t give much up for them. It was difficult. But she needed my Uncles support.

Chamomileteaplease · 19/11/2022 14:16

Your husband isn't close to his parents and therefore doesn't see why he should put himself out for them it seems.

However, I would be far more interested in the sister. Her life sounds bloody awful at the moment, soon to get worse.

However, you said that she is resisting the idea of a home for one or both of them and therefore to some extent this is a problem she has chosen not to sort out.

If I were you , I would put my energies into encouraging your husband to get your sister to agree to putting one or both into more suitable accommodation. This will be a task in itself. Maybe he would be more willing with that sort of task.

Hbh17 · 19/11/2022 14:16

But it is his choice, and he has no obligation to visit his family. Everyone is different, so his decisions need to be respected.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/11/2022 14:14

Also I think this can be general Male thing...but it can also be an elderly parents thing. I've heard of lots of people who need help and will ask their daughter for things they would never dream of asking their son for.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 14:14

His mum was the main carer for years and then had a breakdown. His sister has then taken over.
Great.
So when your SiL has her own stress & exhaustion-induced breakdown, DH can decide he won't visit her either.

His remarks about not being close because his mother didn't know how to help him navigate university life is bullshit. Just another man who thinks caring & support roles should be occupied by women, not men.
When his SiL can no longer cope, will he expect you to step in?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/11/2022 14:13

Hmmm it's a tough one OP. When I first read the thread I was thinking yes he sounds like a heartless selfish bastard.

But from the updates -

He has a strained relationship with his parents. Whether this is down to his father being disabled and his mum having to care for him when he was a teen, or not, it wasn't his mums fault but it wasn't his either and the result is they are now not close and your husband has some sort of self esteem issues arising from his upbringing.

It does sound as though he has broached with the sister ways of managing it, moving them into a home etc and the sister is saying no because of guilt. That isn't his fault either. Even if he wasnt so close to his parents he could help for his sisters sake...but it sounds like she wants things done her way.

I'm not saying he couldn't do more, but I think there might be more to it than him being a selfish bastard.

Why don't you speak to him and ask him how he thinks this will affect the relationship between him and his sister long term. What about his parents, how would he feel if they left everything (if there is anything) to his sister because she helped them out. What is this situation teaching your kids about caring for the elderly. And see what he says. Could you all go over for the day and one of you take the kids out somewhere, to give his sister a break?

Floralnomad · 19/11/2022 14:11

It sounds like he feels his parents have held him back which is a shame as it sounds like they did nothing wrong they just weren’t as well off and posh as he wanted them to be . Could you visit his mum , or sit with his dad whilst the sister goes .

Roocakes · 19/11/2022 14:10

From the outside it does look harsh of your dh to not help his family or visit them. But there maybe a whole aspect of his upbringing that he can’t or doesn’t want to discuss which has led to distancing himself from them.

I also think that there’s a far higher expectation on women to do the hands on caring in these circumstances and it’s easier to guilt a woman than a man into this role.

beachcitygirl · 19/11/2022 14:08

I have an extremely difficult relationship with my mother & would not & will not be there for her in her old age.
That said, from what you have said. I think your dh sounds lazy & I would be viewing him differently. It sounds as if he wanted something from his parents that they were unable to give rather than unwilling to give.
He sounds petulant. His poor sister.

I think a Frank and full conversation is the order of the day. Yoy need to know why he is behaving like this.

Is it a conscious decision based on spite from the past
Is it a conscious decision based on reasonable hurt from bad parenting
Is it laziness
Is it fear of being a cater
Is it because he thinks his sister will do it all as 'womens work'

I'm afraid the answers to this would be enlightening but may irrevocably damage your marriage.

Think of the potato the egg and the teabag story.

When they find themselves in hot water some will grow hard, some will turn to mush & some will be full of character & flavour & who they were meant to be.

I'd want to know which type my husband was.

TedMullins · 19/11/2022 14:06

It sounds like they’d be better in a home. His sister is choosing to be a martyr, doesn’t mean he has to.