Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and aligning in-laws

138 replies

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 12:02

You read a lot on MN about sons not bothering about their aging parents and I seem to be married to one. DH's parents are elderly, his father is bed bound and his mother had a breakdown and has been in a mental hospital for the last six months. DH's sister lives with his parents and is caring for the dad while holding down a full time job. Initially when MIL went into hospital DH would go over for a day or two per week to help out the sister but then it stopped being practical and he has now only been once every month/ every other month. He has only visited his mother in hospital once back in the summer and hasnt bothered since.We live in the same city as them though it does take over an hour and half each way to get to them from our place.

I know it's his family and I leave him to it. But it feels rather heartless and very uncaring. He would say that he loves me and the kids etc and we are definitely 50/50 when it comes to raising them. It just feels like he's basically abandoned his family and it has sort of impacted on how I see him. I just feels weird reconciling this image of him as a caring family man to us who has simultaneously given up on his parents and effectively sister when they are all really struggling. Not sure what the AIBU is here - but perhaps it's whether or not I am unreasonable to feel that his attitude has impacted on my image of him, I guess.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 20:40

No one here can guess what your DH's motivations are, you know him best, but the account of his experience growing up provides some context to his response. I'd also question whether he's seen his Mum, and now his sister, sacrifice their lives inch-by-inch for decades to support his Dad's wish to remain living at home and perhaps he doesn't want to enable that situation to continue, and with it sacrifice his (and by extension, your) own?

This. And the fact that FIL did similar to his dad, then he's had decades of care from MIL and SIL, I'm not sure I'd wade in judging your DH.

And how did SIL end up shy, not able, not tech savvy, bound to them? It seems like PILs have made very particular choices.

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 20:27

His own dad did something rather similar to his own parents but fast forward to now and he is totally reliant on SIL doing everything for him
Suggests to me that he thinks men should be free to pursue thier own interests and women have to put up & shut up, he appears to have trained his daughter to align herself with this mindset😒

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 19:45

@Forgotthebins he is definitely still that same angry 16 year old, well they werent there for me so why should I be there for them. But they were and especially his mum to the best of her abilities. And honestly he did get his A'level grades and he did move away so he was 'fine so to speak.

OP posts:
Forgotthebins · 19/11/2022 19:38

It sounds as though he is still angry with his Dad for becoming disabled and his Mum for de-prioritising him. Which for a 16 year old is understandable, that their first reaction would be “why has this happened to me?” But you see things in a more sensitive and rounded way, and don’t really like seeing that aggrieved 16 year old in your DH. I wonder if he would be open to counselling, it might help him process the past. If not, perhaps just find a quiet moment to share your own empathy for his parents and sister, to see if it provokes any reflection from him.

LisaJool · 19/11/2022 19:35

@jhfs8979 he'll be totally reliant on you and your dc! Prepare your daughter from now that he will view her as a carer and expect her to give up her life to live with him in his frailty.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 19:30

@LisaJool you are absolutely right. DH basically now has his new family i.e. us, we take up some of his time and so he's done so to speak. I wonder how he'll feel when he gets older. His own dad did something rather similar to his own parents but fast forward to now and he is totally reliant on SIL doing everything for him.

OP posts:
jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 19:28

@FloozingThePlot I think they've had social care teams and interventions but the reality of the current system is that it requires someone very articulate and capable to present everything, follow it through and keep up with it all. All the virtual wards, crisis teams etc somehow assume that people they are talking to or about are able to follow it all. The post austerity, NHS/social care governance model is not only so complex but also so decentralised with neither of the different service properly communicating with the other nor updating each other that I have no idea how the elderly manage it. My impression is their main goal is to tick you off their list. It's insane and I totally get why MIL has stopped being able to properly manage FIL's care in the last few years. It's impossible especially for someone who is not very able, very shy, rather confused, not tech savvy etc. Honestly, the system is shocking.

I would absolutely go over and help but FIL and SIL would hate it, they would feel put upon, they think the house is in a terrible state plus I couldnt do any of the personal care for FIL and he would never want me to see him in that state. That's why I offered for her to come and stay with me and the kids and DH goes there.

Tonight I asked DH how he thinks it will end but he said SIL is not ready to think about a home. Personally, I think they are twenty years overdue but there is not much I can do. Will try to see whether DH could offer more practical help to SIL

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 19/11/2022 19:17

It is heartless. If he doesn't want to help his sister with his presence he should offer her some money to pay for a carer some days so she isn't always taking on the burden.

LisaJool · 19/11/2022 19:10

YANBU to feel differently about him, what a disgrace he is. I don't know why so many posters are giving him excuses, he's basically said he's happy with you and the kids so why should he bother himself... what's that saying about a son being a son until he gets a wife? That's your DP. OP in your shoes I'd be very concerned how he'd behave if you got sick, he might say you didn't take him skiing or help him move up in the world Hmm And don't get me started on his poor sister.

aloris · 19/11/2022 19:07

Do you think that your FIL wanted to avoid going into a home because he was worried it would absorb all of their savings? Was he trying to ensure he could leave an inheritance for your DH and his sister?

FloozingThePlot · 19/11/2022 17:57

OK - your original question was AYBU to feel differently about DH because he is not responding to his family of origin's changed circumstances in the way you expected? You feel as you feel, OP, but it's worth trying to keep communication open with your DH about it as this sort of thing festers IMO.

No one here can guess what your DH's motivations are, you know him best, but the account of his experience growing up provides some context to his response. I'd also question whether he's seen his Mum, and now his sister, sacrifice their lives inch-by-inch for decades to support his Dad's wish to remain living at home and perhaps he doesn't want to enable that situation to continue, and with it sacrifice his (and by extension, your) own?

Unsolicited advice - this extremely complex situation needs a social work led, multi-disciplinary needs assessment (and a carer's assessment for your DH's sister) before your DH's Mum is discharged from hospital. 4 visits a day aren't likely to meet the complex needs of a couple like this.

BankseyVest · 19/11/2022 17:34

*You don't see the difference between parents and his children?!

He has so far been a good father but because he doesn't want to be thrust into servitude for people he has a negative relationship with he's a bad father and husband?*

Of course I do, but giving his sister some restbite and spending an evening a week with his dp isn't servitude. It's about having empathy for both his sister and dp, and caring for the people he loves. I find it difficult to understand someone who can simply switch off and appear to not care about his family. Is it because of the relationship he had wIth his family, or because he simply can't be arsed

WhatNoRaisins · 19/11/2022 17:32

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 16:38

DH has checked out
perhaps he sees it like this
option 1-engage and be completely consumed, have his life taken over & ruined
option 2-disengage and avoid all that
in a way it's a 'rational' choice, the situation seems very far gone😥

I think this is very true sadly. He's probably scared that more and more will be asked of him if he seems too willing.

Parker231 · 19/11/2022 17:27

If you’re DH is ignoring the help and support his parents and sister need, can you go over there and help - perhaps stay at the weekend?

MatildaTheCat · 19/11/2022 17:24

His poor sister.

It sounds as if your FIL needs 24 hour care. If it’s left much longer it may be very difficult to find anywhere willing to take him ( bitter experience). FIL may not want this but his illness has at the very least contributed to his wife becoming extremely sick and his poor daughter trapped in a house with no life outside it.

Honestly I’d have no respect for a man that refuses to engage in this. They aren’t estranged or abusive. His sister is suffering even more than is necessary because he won’t help.

Id have a meeting with him and explain how upset and concerned you are. It doesn’t bode well if you got sick does it? He needs to man up and get properly involved.

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 17:22

I think he's doing it because he knows he can get away with it, his sister has been trained to obey her parents, he hasnt, she feels a calling that she cannot ignore, he feels nothing....I suspect.
I'd be wondering when/if he might wash his hands of me too!

gottachangeforthisone · 19/11/2022 17:21

OP can I just ask you why YOU aren't doing more ? You seem to be running all questions / suggestions through your pretty useless (in this regard ) husband . Except YOU find this pretty appalling behaviour (as do I )

In your situation I would absolutely of been taking my MIL grandchildren to visit her regularly if it became obvious after a week that he wasn't going to step up. I would also ask my sister-in-law DIRECTLY if there was something YOU could do to help her - not relating messages via a completely uninterested husband .

And before people pile in with 'oh I see man to lazy this is wimins work' No not at all. I would do this because I am I hope a caring human being and would offer respite to anyone if I was in a position to do it. Husband ring an arse ? Leave HIS kids with him to care for and go and spend a couple of hours with your sister in law. Invite her over yourself .. just be the decent human being to your Childrens grandparents that he is not able to be.

It's not a competition. Just cos he is being an arse . Doesn't mean you are not allowed to be a better person .

Arrivederla · 19/11/2022 17:07

Maybe. But any family that produces one child who never leaves the house at 30, stuck at home since 9 caring is NOT a healthy one. And so any behaviour on his part is produced by that unhealthy place. Seeing his sister struggle and avoiding that for himself is not necessarily a fully conscious choice. The fear must be very real.

Yes, that's a good point about it not necessarily being a fully conscious choice. Rightly or wrongly though, I would still be disappointed in my dp in the same circumstances.

saraclara · 19/11/2022 17:02

Have you asked him why he thinks it's okay to leave his sister to do everything? To have no life, to never be able to leave the house?

He doesn't have to take over from her, but he DOES need to have her back, and to help her find alternatives to this life she has (and they have).

Has he researched options for her? Checked that they all get all the benefits and adaptations that they're entitled to? Checked to see if she's entitled to respite care? She is probably under such a heavy weight of responsibility that she has no headspace left to do all this stuff. He could at least help with that.

I'm the sibling that lives a distance away, and my brother is the one on the spot who has to deal with all my mother's issues. I can't visit her and deal with the practical stuff like as he can, but what I can do is the admin, research, emailing and phone calls about her care and finances (all of which he finds difficult). I have his back by supporting him in dealing with all the things that I can do from a distance. Your DH should at least be doing that.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 17:01

It's been 20 odd years though his dad's post stroke condition was stable ish - not great, he was disable but stable till it got a lot worse ten years ago - and we think thats when the Parkinsons took over. It's hard to tell. And yes I always thought they needed to move FIL but MIL, SIL and DH were all dead set against it. They all just thought that MIL needs to soldier on and try harder.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 16:58

I think posters on here are being a bit too kind to your dh, op!

Maybe. But any family that produces one child who never leaves the house at 30, stuck at home since 9 caring is NOT a healthy one. And so any behaviour on his part is produced by that unhealthy place. Seeing his sister struggle and avoiding that for himself is not necessarily a fully conscious choice. The fear must be very real.

And I'm happy to judge feckless men so don't take on caring roles in my own family so I'm not blind to that.

Bigbadfish · 19/11/2022 16:57

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 16:55

No but it's also not his dad's fault for having a stroke in his 50s or his mum's for trying to take care of her husband and the kids. She probably should have moved his dad into a home a few years go but she was managing but was increasingly less and less able to do things or engage with the outside world. Until six months ago, SIL wasn't doing much of the care but was obviously on hand whenever MIL had to go out etc. The weird thing is that DH doesnt think his dad should have been moved into a home, he just thinks MIL should have managed it better somehow.

You said his health deteriorated when DH was 16? So how many years ago was that? How many years has his mother been aware that she is going to get old and her husband is not going to recover?

FIL stroke is not his fault but their failure to prepare for the inevitable was. We get old. That's not ground breaking news.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 16:57

And that his sister needs to manage until his mum comes back and takes over again. DH is firmly of the opinion it can all be managed at home - by MIL and if not by SIL. Seemingly he doesnt have to do much in this set up at all

OP posts:
jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 16:55

No but it's also not his dad's fault for having a stroke in his 50s or his mum's for trying to take care of her husband and the kids. She probably should have moved his dad into a home a few years go but she was managing but was increasingly less and less able to do things or engage with the outside world. Until six months ago, SIL wasn't doing much of the care but was obviously on hand whenever MIL had to go out etc. The weird thing is that DH doesnt think his dad should have been moved into a home, he just thinks MIL should have managed it better somehow.

OP posts:
Arrivederla · 19/11/2022 16:51

I think posters on here are being a bit too kind to your dh, op! I would be disappointed if my dh washed his hands of a difficult family situation like this and left his sister to shoulder the burden alone.

I appreciate that it's possible to become totally overwhelmed and consumed with this sort of thing - and that definitely wouldn't help - but there is a middle way between "consumed" and "doing fuck all".

I'm interested in knowing if you have actually talked to him about how his behaviour makes you feel?