Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and aligning in-laws

138 replies

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 12:02

You read a lot on MN about sons not bothering about their aging parents and I seem to be married to one. DH's parents are elderly, his father is bed bound and his mother had a breakdown and has been in a mental hospital for the last six months. DH's sister lives with his parents and is caring for the dad while holding down a full time job. Initially when MIL went into hospital DH would go over for a day or two per week to help out the sister but then it stopped being practical and he has now only been once every month/ every other month. He has only visited his mother in hospital once back in the summer and hasnt bothered since.We live in the same city as them though it does take over an hour and half each way to get to them from our place.

I know it's his family and I leave him to it. But it feels rather heartless and very uncaring. He would say that he loves me and the kids etc and we are definitely 50/50 when it comes to raising them. It just feels like he's basically abandoned his family and it has sort of impacted on how I see him. I just feels weird reconciling this image of him as a caring family man to us who has simultaneously given up on his parents and effectively sister when they are all really struggling. Not sure what the AIBU is here - but perhaps it's whether or not I am unreasonable to feel that his attitude has impacted on my image of him, I guess.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FloozingThePlot · 20/11/2022 13:20

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 19:28

@FloozingThePlot I think they've had social care teams and interventions but the reality of the current system is that it requires someone very articulate and capable to present everything, follow it through and keep up with it all. All the virtual wards, crisis teams etc somehow assume that people they are talking to or about are able to follow it all. The post austerity, NHS/social care governance model is not only so complex but also so decentralised with neither of the different service properly communicating with the other nor updating each other that I have no idea how the elderly manage it. My impression is their main goal is to tick you off their list. It's insane and I totally get why MIL has stopped being able to properly manage FIL's care in the last few years. It's impossible especially for someone who is not very able, very shy, rather confused, not tech savvy etc. Honestly, the system is shocking.

I would absolutely go over and help but FIL and SIL would hate it, they would feel put upon, they think the house is in a terrible state plus I couldnt do any of the personal care for FIL and he would never want me to see him in that state. That's why I offered for her to come and stay with me and the kids and DH goes there.

Tonight I asked DH how he thinks it will end but he said SIL is not ready to think about a home. Personally, I think they are twenty years overdue but there is not much I can do. Will try to see whether DH could offer more practical help to SIL

Yes, things are extremely difficult in H+SC at the moment. It doesn't change the position that these services owe legal duties to the 3 adults with vulnerabilities in this situation.

If you are in a position to, and want to, offer support, and are prevented from doing this 'hands on' because of PILs' concerns about their dignity / the state of the house, perhaps you could be the advocate, the articulate and capable person presenting this to services, to help get the right professional support involved? Or perhaps that's the bit DH might feel able to manage? From what you've written, it sounds like you have doubts about MIL's and FIL's ability to make their own decisions about their accommodation and care. If they cannot make their own decisions, unless there is a deputyship or power of attorney for health and welfare decisions in place, there has to be professional involvement for assessments / decision-making - it is not SIL's decision to make.

NumberTheory · 20/11/2022 02:20

Cameleongirl · 20/11/2022 00:04

@NumberTheory But her DH isn't ill though. Yes, he's resentful and probably frightened of getting involved, but with the OP's support, he can probably cope with the situation.

I've honestly been amazed at what I can deal with regarding my Dad, his mental and physical health problems, financial issues, being sworn at and accused of all sorts, bad mouthed to other people...the list goes on. But underneath it all, he's an angry and frightened elderly man and I feel sorry for his suffering. I can't imagine the OP's DH doesn't feel sorry for his Mum and sister, and he can probably help them at least in some ways. The OP is clearly ready to support him in this. Anyway, we'll agree to disagree. Flowers

If you get something out of helping your father even though he’s nasty to you, then that’s fine, I’m not second guessing what makes your life worthwhile. But I don’t think it means you should be encouraging others to put themselves in the same situation when they clearly do not want to or suggesting that people who don’t must be lacking compassion.

Cameleongirl · 20/11/2022 00:04

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 23:11

Not much compassion for DH in there. I’m not simply looking at it logically, I’m also thinking about the fear DH likely has about how getting involved will drown him too.

@NumberTheory But her DH isn't ill though. Yes, he's resentful and probably frightened of getting involved, but with the OP's support, he can probably cope with the situation.

I've honestly been amazed at what I can deal with regarding my Dad, his mental and physical health problems, financial issues, being sworn at and accused of all sorts, bad mouthed to other people...the list goes on. But underneath it all, he's an angry and frightened elderly man and I feel sorry for his suffering. I can't imagine the OP's DH doesn't feel sorry for his Mum and sister, and he can probably help them at least in some ways. The OP is clearly ready to support him in this. Anyway, we'll agree to disagree. Flowers

Getoff · 19/11/2022 23:34

Have you asked him why he thinks it's okay to leave his sister to do everything? To have no life, to never be able to leave the house?

Perhaps what he's doing is correct, and the sister should be resigning from her "job"?

It's not the law the children have to do anything for parents. There seem to be lots of people on this thread who assume there is a duty, then complain about the shirkers. Maybe they should question whether there is a duty, or at least explain why they think there is.

Maybe the reasons why he doesn't want to do anything don't matter? Because only people who actually want to, should. People don't need a reason not to. A hungry person walks to the kitchen, a person who cares about their parents does something, a person who feels nothing, does nothing. They aren't wrong not to have an emotion that causes them to do something, it's simply how they're constructed.

Namenic · 19/11/2022 23:12

OP I agree with you. I would discuss your feelings/disappointment gently with your DH. Essentially you can’t make him care though.

So you make the first move - call his sister directly - ask her if you can do anything to help (like sort out correspondence, research care providers, ask for advice from age U.K. or GP). Ring the hospital ward and find out if it would be suitable to bring your kids to see DH’s mum (even if it is not a regular thing, it would be nice) and visit her.

I would hope that my kids would be the type of people to help their siblings out if one of them was in the same position as SIL. And also the type that would visit people in hospital. Showing them that they can make a difference to how someone feels by just visiting and chatting is important. My parents used to take me to visit my grand aunts and uncles and I’ve tried to do the same with my kids (seeing my relatives and in laws)

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 23:11

Cameleongirl · 19/11/2022 22:58

@NumberTheory You're looking at this logically, which is fair enough. I personally think that compassion needs to play a role as well. His Mum's choices have made her so ill that she's had a breakdown and is hospitalized; his sister is trapped looking after his difficult Dad. Surely, he feels sorry for them? Perhaps if he stepped up and took charge of the situation, he could make some improvements to their situation. If he and his sister could get Power of Attorney for his parents, for example, they could help them make decisions when they're not able to (although his Mum would need to be mentally well before they could apply).

Even if he can't change the situation, I personally think he should give it a try - and I think the OP feels this way too.

Not much compassion for DH in there. I’m not simply looking at it logically, I’m also thinking about the fear DH likely has about how getting involved will drown him too.

Cameleongirl · 19/11/2022 22:58

@NumberTheory You're looking at this logically, which is fair enough. I personally think that compassion needs to play a role as well. His Mum's choices have made her so ill that she's had a breakdown and is hospitalized; his sister is trapped looking after his difficult Dad. Surely, he feels sorry for them? Perhaps if he stepped up and took charge of the situation, he could make some improvements to their situation. If he and his sister could get Power of Attorney for his parents, for example, they could help them make decisions when they're not able to (although his Mum would need to be mentally well before they could apply).

Even if he can't change the situation, I personally think he should give it a try - and I think the OP feels this way too.

CookieDoughKid · 19/11/2022 22:47

I'm with you OP. My dh hasn't seen his mother for over a year and a half. Dh hasn't even taken our children to visit his mum. His mum doesn't need care and although retired, is still active and does hobbies like gardening etc. We live a 2hr drive away. We are going to visit his mum for a day during Christmas this year but if I hadn't suggested, I don't think it would happen. I've learnt to not feel responsible. Difficult to know what the right thing to do but ultimately, my dh is lazy and can't be bothered. Nothing malicious, just can't be bothered. But he is very involved with his children so....I really do think it's about pecking order.

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 22:35

Cameleongirl · 19/11/2022 21:10

@NumberTheory i see your point, but not getting involved and abandoning his MIL/DS isn’t the right thing to do either, is it?

My Dad is a nightmare, tbh, sometimes I’d like to go NC, but I know it’s not the right thing to do.

I disagree. His DM let him and his sister down when she set this dynamic up decades ago. She may have been in a very difficult place and social conditioning (which we see in practice right here on this thread) might have made it difficult for her to see past the expectations for women to care for their husbands and put their needs above everything else. But in doing so she failed her son, her daughter and, it would seem, her self.

Being a part of that by going along with it and continuing the dynamic will provide a little relief for his DSis for a while, but it’s only prolonging the inevitable and at huge cost to himself. If his DSis was up for changing the dynamic and not having her DF’s needs dominate everyone else’s lives then it would seem a lot more uncaring. As it is it just seems like self preservation.

Floralnomad · 19/11/2022 22:35

I think I’d actually be quite concerned about my old age / becoming I’ll with a husband like yours @jhfs8979 , presumably at some point he loved his parents .

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 22:24

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 21:11

What I find cruel is his lack of compassion for his mum or lack of care. He knows that SIL cant visit very often but is basically not bothered. She's spent two decades looking after his dad and her health is now shot to pieces. But yes I guess I find it hard to emotionally connect with him on this thing. I think it's also because he seems to refuse to accept that nowadays she needs as much care as the dad, and cant be expected to just come back home and pick up where she left off

I think you’re failing to see how dysfunctional the family’s approach to his DF’s disability has been. He grew up in a family that couldn’t meet his needs and that is focused around everyone facilitating his not nice (nasty? Abusive?) father at horrendous cost. He can’t make them change their approach, but he can refuse to let it bring him down.

DisforDarkChocolate · 19/11/2022 21:52

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 21:40

He's allowing this erosion of all the women's lives
that's often how dominant people maintain thier power...by making sure someone else takes the hits!

I don't agree with this at all.

MIL made her choices here, as did FIL. These are the consequences. When MIL was admitted this was the crisis that should have changed things, SIL probably never had the tools to say no after a lifetime of being conditioned care.

The OP's husband has obviously been deeply affected by his parents choices, there is no obligation on him to support these choices as an adult.

Cameleongirl · 19/11/2022 21:41

@Soothsayer1 All the more reason for the OP’s DH to help them.

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 21:40

He's allowing this erosion of all the women's lives
that's often how dominant people maintain thier power...by making sure someone else takes the hits!

saraclara · 19/11/2022 21:14

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 21:06

I think you need a bit more compassion for your DH.

His mum has spent her life looking after his father and has ended up with not much of a life, unable to give her best to her children and now with a mental breakdown? His sister has taken over and is overwhelmed and barely leaves the house.

Do you not think that maybe DH has seen what this sort of approach to care does to people and is running away from it? I don’t think his approach is less sensible than his DM and DSil’s, he has other responsibilities and it sounds like his fathers’ needs suck the life out of those who make it their life’s work to care for him.

The idea that if the family just pull together it will be all right is what results in people losing their lives to drudgery. His DF clearly needs more care than family can provide, even with support. DH getting involved isn’t going to change that it will just paper over the cracks so DSil keeps at it for longer..

I would genuinely be happy not to see my mum again. But that doesn't stop me (occasionally) visiting her, and it absolutely doesn't stop me helping out my brother who carries more of the burden as he lives local to her.

I'm not even that close to my brother (not for any difficult reason, we're just very different people who didn't see much of each other for much of our adult lives). But there's no way I could leave him to shoulder this alone. When I visit my mum, it means he can miss a visit. If I make the calls or send the emails to the care company/social care/ and deal with finance stuff, then it eases his load as he finds that stuff hard. And frankly I see it as by far the easier bit to do as I don't have to see my mum to do it.

So DH doesn't have to get involved in the same way that his sister is, or fear his life being taken over. He just needs to reach out to her to see what he CAN do for her. It's absolutely awful of him to let her deal with this alone, and have no life in order fro him to have one.

I don't see why we should feel compassion for him when he clearly has none for his sister - who presumably had an equally difficult time with his parents when she was young.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 21:11

What I find cruel is his lack of compassion for his mum or lack of care. He knows that SIL cant visit very often but is basically not bothered. She's spent two decades looking after his dad and her health is now shot to pieces. But yes I guess I find it hard to emotionally connect with him on this thing. I think it's also because he seems to refuse to accept that nowadays she needs as much care as the dad, and cant be expected to just come back home and pick up where she left off

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 19/11/2022 21:10

@NumberTheory i see your point, but not getting involved and abandoning his MIL/DS isn’t the right thing to do either, is it?

My Dad is a nightmare, tbh, sometimes I’d like to go NC, but I know it’s not the right thing to do.

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 21:06

I think you need a bit more compassion for your DH.

His mum has spent her life looking after his father and has ended up with not much of a life, unable to give her best to her children and now with a mental breakdown? His sister has taken over and is overwhelmed and barely leaves the house.

Do you not think that maybe DH has seen what this sort of approach to care does to people and is running away from it? I don’t think his approach is less sensible than his DM and DSil’s, he has other responsibilities and it sounds like his fathers’ needs suck the life out of those who make it their life’s work to care for him.

The idea that if the family just pull together it will be all right is what results in people losing their lives to drudgery. His DF clearly needs more care than family can provide, even with support. DH getting involved isn’t going to change that it will just paper over the cracks so DSil keeps at it for longer..

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 21:04

@MrsTerryPratchett his dad isnt nice but with all his myriad of health problems and mental issues, I am not sure that he can be IYSWIM. He is a disable, ill and angry old man who is also helpless and very very scared. I dont like him but it's not really about him but MIL and SIL. DH can simply check out and forget about them all. It seems harsh, very harsh

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 19/11/2022 20:58

I’ve only read your posts, OP. I can see that there are underlying resentments that are preventing your DH from reaching out to his family-but I think he needs to put this behind him now and help them through this challenging time. He’s an adult and part of being an adult is accepting our parents’ imperfections, because no parent is ever perfect and does everything right, IYSWIM. His parents weren’t abusive or cruel, they couldn’t provide everything he would have liked-but that doesn’t mean they’re “bad” people undeserving of his help now.

I do understand it’s hard. My elderly Dad is a very difficult personality and certainly hasn’t been the ideal father, but I’ve accepted that’s who he is. He needs my help now, practically and with emotional support, so I do it and just resolve to try and behave differently with my children…although I’m sure they’ll also criticize my parenting in the future. 😂

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 20:57

Apparently his dad also doesnt ask about his mum. It's so sad.

The more you say about his dad, the worse he sounds. He's allowing this erosion of all the women's lives, massively more than your DH.

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 20:56

LisaJool · 19/11/2022 20:49

None of that explains why he's only been to visit his DM in hospital once in 6 months?

It does. We become very avoidant of negative emotions. Think of it like a phobia almost.

I'm not saying I actually know any of this. I think he needs a trained therapist.

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 20:54

honestly not a clue. None. He says whats the point and he would have to book it in advance. He keeps mentioning how his dad's carers are so pleased that his dad has someone to look out for him but he's basically just abandoned his mum in a mental institution. It's almost as if now she cant serve her purpose of looking after the dad, she doesnt matter. Apparently his dad also doesnt ask about his mum. It's so sad.

OP posts:
LisaJool · 19/11/2022 20:49

None of that explains why he's only been to visit his DM in hospital once in 6 months?

jhfs8979 · 19/11/2022 20:46

@MrsTerryPratchett Oh no I meant MIL is shy etc and not very tech savvy, SIL is fine, she's just overwhelmed and fed up but feeling like she has no other choice. Not sure whether partly it's also because she feels like she has to hold the fort until MIL is back. But if I was SIL, I would be really pissed off at DH for not doing and helping more

OP posts: