Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to do secret santa with the in laws?s

38 replies

WineAndDontDine · 19/11/2022 11:04

We do it with my family. It works great because between the 10 adults we only spend £20 (on one person). Christmas used to be very expensive even spending a small amount on a token gift for everyone.

Only issue is, DHs family like spending obscene amounts on presents for the adults. There are only 7 of us when at theirs for Christmas eve (day of present exchange) but it all adds up. Sister and aunt/uncle are child free. And either living at home or with very good job. Parents are mortgage free and definitely stashing cash in the kitchen cupboard so they have plenty of money. We aren't well off (one income, 2 children). We all had a discussion about no presents last year, turned up, and everyone had spent loads of everyone else secretly. We obviously bought nothing for anyone else and it was incredibly awkward, you could see they felt hurt we hadn't "bothered".

How do I approach this? Clearly they value the gift giving part of Xmas but we just can't afford it.

WIBU to just put my foot down and say no gifts this year and have a frank convo about it or secret santa! Or let them get on with it and just buy nothing for them? Isn't that impolite?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chailatteplease · 19/11/2022 15:30

zurala · 19/11/2022 15:16

Yes, but in this situation the family clearly do appreciate and expect gifts, so OP would be unreasonable to get them nothing. A small gift each of £5 or less would cost £35. Christmas is not a surprise event so surely £35 can be budgeted?

What part of “can’t afford it” do you not understand?

zurala · 19/11/2022 15:16

EarringsandLipstick · 19/11/2022 14:32

@zurala

As you say yourself, it's very dependent on the person.

I love giving & receiving presents. I have often spent way too much on gifts, that others don't really expect or appreciate.

I really don't like getting cheap pointless gifts. Something meaningful that I'll use is great, and it doesn't have to be expensive but appreciating that is hard to get right, I am equally happy to get nothing & spend time with someone instead.

Baked stuff is great; I also love baking & giving to people. But the list of homemade gifts from another PP eg h/m bath salts. I'd hate any of that.

I suppose it's about knowing the recipient!

Yes, but in this situation the family clearly do appreciate and expect gifts, so OP would be unreasonable to get them nothing. A small gift each of £5 or less would cost £35. Christmas is not a surprise event so surely £35 can be budgeted?

Hemelbelle · 19/11/2022 15:14

I would take one box of chocolates or similar that all those present can share. I would thank them politely for any gifts that I and DC receive. I think people are aware how tight things can be for young families in a normal year and much worse this year. If you have told them you won't be giving presents, then any presents they give to you, will be giving them pleasure, not because they expect one back.

Alacarde · 19/11/2022 14:54

WineAndDontDine · 19/11/2022 13:41

😂😂

"This Morrisons turkey is delicious mum but 3 different supermarkets were selling them cheaper per kg if purchased between 2nd November and 13th December"

😂

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/11/2022 14:39

Eleusa · 19/11/2022 13:22

Honestly, I wouldn't faff about making random homemade stuff no one really wants. Just message saying "Looking forward to seeing you all at Christmas. We're not planning to do adult presents this year so please don't feel you should buy us anything. Can't wait for a Pictionary rematch though! [or whatever it is you all like to do at Christmas] Love from WADD and Mr WADD xxx"

Nailed it

MinnieGirl · 19/11/2022 14:34

I think it’s really awful of your in-laws. You had a conversation last year, and they clearly haven’t listened. Stick to your guns. They are clearly very well off, and you are struggling. Just remind them again that you will not be buying any gifts again this year. If you want to make some homemade sweets or biscuits do that, but honestly, families up and down the country are really feeling the pinch, and your in-laws need to be more understanding, and not get the hump because you haven’t bothered. I would be very cross indeed with that reaction..

EarringsandLipstick · 19/11/2022 14:33

OP, you are not UR at all not to buy gifts, and your DH needs to explain it to your ILs

EarringsandLipstick · 19/11/2022 14:32

@zurala

As you say yourself, it's very dependent on the person.

I love giving & receiving presents. I have often spent way too much on gifts, that others don't really expect or appreciate.

I really don't like getting cheap pointless gifts. Something meaningful that I'll use is great, and it doesn't have to be expensive but appreciating that is hard to get right, I am equally happy to get nothing & spend time with someone instead.

Baked stuff is great; I also love baking & giving to people. But the list of homemade gifts from another PP eg h/m bath salts. I'd hate any of that.

I suppose it's about knowing the recipient!

zurala · 19/11/2022 14:08

stuntbubbles · 19/11/2022 13:47

I’d rather have no gift than random cheap handcream bought as a token, tbh. Christmas has plenty of joy in it if you’re a joyful person, it doesn’t have to be the relentless exchange of tat that, say, my MIL enjoys.

OP, I came to say YABU based on the title because who WANTS to do secret Santa with in laws when there’s the option to do nothing, then saw the actual situation. Any awkwardness caused by them reneging on the “no gifts” agreement is caused by them, not you. The only trouble with secret Santa with them, I think, is that you’ll stick to the rules in terms of person and price, and they’ll carry on buying expensive gifts for everyone and making you feel awkward.

I specifically wasn't talking about that. A D decent handcream is a lovely thing to have if you use handcream and not expensive.
I was trying you suggest cheap items that could also be thoughtful and based on a person's likes. Gifts don't need to be expensive to be lovely.
I didn't suggest handmade because that's usually pricey and takes time, but OP seems to like that idea so that's another option.

I know some people just aren't into gifts, but those of us who are (because of our love language not because of materialism) get very hurt by being given nothing, but would welcome a thoughtful cheap gift. Personally I'm very pleased with a vegan chocolate bar, or a secondhand book someone knew I'd enjoy reading. It's about the thought. There's no thought in giving nothing.

stuntbubbles · 19/11/2022 13:47

zurala · 19/11/2022 11:51

YABU for not giving gifts. I think that's really miserable. You can always give token gifts like a nice handcream, or a book, or beer, or chocolates. All of those can be cheap.

I think Christmas without gifts is miserable and joyless and I can't see the point in it.

I’d rather have no gift than random cheap handcream bought as a token, tbh. Christmas has plenty of joy in it if you’re a joyful person, it doesn’t have to be the relentless exchange of tat that, say, my MIL enjoys.

OP, I came to say YABU based on the title because who WANTS to do secret Santa with in laws when there’s the option to do nothing, then saw the actual situation. Any awkwardness caused by them reneging on the “no gifts” agreement is caused by them, not you. The only trouble with secret Santa with them, I think, is that you’ll stick to the rules in terms of person and price, and they’ll carry on buying expensive gifts for everyone and making you feel awkward.

WineAndDontDine · 19/11/2022 13:41

BlackberryCat · 19/11/2022 13:33

Concentrate on your DC. Things are so difficult this year, even Martin Lewis said stop the madness!

Totally off topic, but can you imagine spending Christmas with Martin Lewis? I'd be so nervous!

😂😂

"This Morrisons turkey is delicious mum but 3 different supermarkets were selling them cheaper per kg if purchased between 2nd November and 13th December"

OP posts:
BlackberryCat · 19/11/2022 13:33

Concentrate on your DC. Things are so difficult this year, even Martin Lewis said stop the madness!

Totally off topic, but can you imagine spending Christmas with Martin Lewis? I'd be so nervous!

WineAndDontDine · 19/11/2022 13:25

pairofrollerskates · 19/11/2022 12:41

I think you should make them gifts and wrap them beautifully. Here are some ideas that I have used in the past:
Crochet little soap bags and put a soap in each one. 1 ball of crochet cotton = £3 and makes about a dozen bags! Soap can be as cheap or expensive as you like.
Cook something sweet - toffee, or chocolate truffles. £5 will make enough for everyone.
Jam in old glass jars with a pretty fabric cover on lid (no sewing!) I made Rowan Jelly one year. It looking amazing, and cost practically nothing.
Charity shop finds - our local ones often have single crystal vases/ glasses/ dishes. Wash in dishwasher to make them sparkle and fill with coloured sweets or pot-pourri.
Scented bath salt - buy a HUGE bag of bath salt from Tk Maxx or supermarket (£5), spread out on a tray and sprinkle with your favourite essential oil (£5). put in old jam jars and cover with pretty paper or fabric. If you don't have any bits of fabric lying around, a good source is charity shops (again) - by a couple of scarves or pillowcases, wash them and cut them up.
I made some delicious Christmas Gin one year by pouring a bottle of cheap gin over a bag of dried fruit, soaking it for 2 weeks, and then straining and decanting into smaller bottles which I then hand-labelled. You do have to have small bottle to decant into though! I had saved them up during the year.

Go on - give it a try! You can probably think up all sorts of ideas for yourself once you get started!

I love those ideas - thank you so much for taking the time to write them out. 😁

OP posts:
Eleusa · 19/11/2022 13:22

Honestly, I wouldn't faff about making random homemade stuff no one really wants. Just message saying "Looking forward to seeing you all at Christmas. We're not planning to do adult presents this year so please don't feel you should buy us anything. Can't wait for a Pictionary rematch though! [or whatever it is you all like to do at Christmas] Love from WADD and Mr WADD xxx"

UnicornMumcraft · 19/11/2022 12:58

You’re not unreasonable to state what you plan to do and stick to it. You would be unreasonable to dictate what the others do though. It does seem quite late to be having the conversation as by now many people will have started their Xmas shopping but maybe that’s not the case with this group.

pairofrollerskates · 19/11/2022 12:41

I think you should make them gifts and wrap them beautifully. Here are some ideas that I have used in the past:
Crochet little soap bags and put a soap in each one. 1 ball of crochet cotton = £3 and makes about a dozen bags! Soap can be as cheap or expensive as you like.
Cook something sweet - toffee, or chocolate truffles. £5 will make enough for everyone.
Jam in old glass jars with a pretty fabric cover on lid (no sewing!) I made Rowan Jelly one year. It looking amazing, and cost practically nothing.
Charity shop finds - our local ones often have single crystal vases/ glasses/ dishes. Wash in dishwasher to make them sparkle and fill with coloured sweets or pot-pourri.
Scented bath salt - buy a HUGE bag of bath salt from Tk Maxx or supermarket (£5), spread out on a tray and sprinkle with your favourite essential oil (£5). put in old jam jars and cover with pretty paper or fabric. If you don't have any bits of fabric lying around, a good source is charity shops (again) - by a couple of scarves or pillowcases, wash them and cut them up.
I made some delicious Christmas Gin one year by pouring a bottle of cheap gin over a bag of dried fruit, soaking it for 2 weeks, and then straining and decanting into smaller bottles which I then hand-labelled. You do have to have small bottle to decant into though! I had saved them up during the year.

Go on - give it a try! You can probably think up all sorts of ideas for yourself once you get started!

Tiredforfive45 · 19/11/2022 12:39

You’re not unreasonable to say no gifts. You have left it rather late though now.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 19/11/2022 12:30

YANBU
Concentrate on your DC. Things are so difficult this year, even Martin Lewis said stop the madness!
I would repeat the message by text now that you can't afford to give and don't want gifts this year... if they ignore this, don't feel guilty or awkward as they didn't listen to you

MargaretThursday · 19/11/2022 12:20

I think you shouldn't feel you have to keep up with them, and saying you'd like to opt out of giving and please don't give to us because I feel terribly guilty is fine.

Trying to insist they do a Secret Santa because you want to when there's 7 other adults involved is not your choice. My cousin's family had one person decide that, and he thinks it's miserable. They all pick one person and then that person tells them exactly what they want (down to catalogue number) and then they buy that. They know exactly what's in that one present.
So realistically they might as well all agree they'll buy something for themselves. The price of the one present has also gone steadily up so actually they're spending way more than they would if they'd put a limit of £10 a person.

My cousin has now opted out and says he'll buy a token present for all, and they get him something similar back. I have a suspicion that most of the others would also like to do that (they certainly don't sing it's praises), but know if they opt out then most if not all of the others will follow, so it'll cause hassle as SS with only one left in doesn't work! And the one left in will make a huge fuss about no one doing what they want.

WineAndDontDine · 19/11/2022 12:17

Tomorrowisalatterday · 19/11/2022 12:15

Stop trying to control what everyone else does. They like doing presents. YJust tell them that you can't afford presents for everyone this year so won't be doing it. If they then get you presents anyway, say a nice thank you.

Or if you prefer, you could make something - home made biscuits or fudge or something

Great idea, I am savvy in the kitchen

OP posts:
Tomorrowisalatterday · 19/11/2022 12:15

Stop trying to control what everyone else does. They like doing presents. YJust tell them that you can't afford presents for everyone this year so won't be doing it. If they then get you presents anyway, say a nice thank you.

Or if you prefer, you could make something - home made biscuits or fudge or something

Flossflower · 19/11/2022 12:14

For years and years, I have only bought presents for people under 21. All my family seem happy with this. This is less for them to buy in return. As my children, nieces and nephews have grown up, I now only buy for the grandkids. We spend quite a lot on them. I think Martin Lewis is right, all this obligation to buy presents is a burden on a lot of people and doesn’t make a happy Christmas for them. My husband and I don’t receive presents. we are very happy with this and this doesn’t stop us enjoying Christmas. We will also be giving some extra Christmas food to the food bank.

WineAndDontDine · 19/11/2022 12:10

BlackberryCat · 19/11/2022 12:06

Even if the presents we want to give = 0? A present worth 10 for each adult would add up to 70! That's a chunk of money we can't really afford

I think it is fine. Would you be offended if they bought for each other and bought nothing for you? Because I wouldn't care. If you said no presents and they bought presents, then it's on them. They shouldn't get offended by that. You just need a thicker skin. But, you can't sit and sulk because they bought for each other and not you.

So, if you buy nothing and they buy for you, just smile and say thank you that's very kind.

If they don't buy for you but buy for others just smile and say that's nice.

But, stay firm and don't buy for them if you can't afford it.

Couldn't care less if they bought for each other. In fact I love watching people opening presents, just not something we can afford to do right now.

You are right, thank you!

OP posts:
BlackberryCat · 19/11/2022 12:10

For what it's worth, my coworkers often buy little presents for each other but I'm not interested, so now they just buy for each other and we are all happy with this. It may seem a bit weird but I am happy with my boundaries, I also opt out of the work Secret Santa. I'm not a Grinch about it. They can do as they like and I do as I like.

balalake · 19/11/2022 12:09

Suggest the alternative of making a charitable donation instead of secret Santa. Think of those facing real struggles this year, better to do that and not have cheap tat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread