Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Talking to BiL about his parenting won't make any difference.

37 replies

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 10:08

Bil and the mother of his two children split years ago.
He has met and recently married a woman with two older children.
We think his children are neglected or ignored by him.
Is there any way you could ever have any conversation that would change life for the kids for the better. Or should we ignore, keep out?

And if you were a fucked up teen did another relative stepping in ever help in the long run?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Theunamedcat · 19/11/2022 20:09

Shampoo doesn't need to contain sulphates clothes can be washed in soap nuts pit Rock will take care of deodorant

Your bil is just as neglectful

ColonelRhubarbBikini · 19/11/2022 18:27

Are you the same poster who dog sat for the BIL at his recent wedding? Sounds familiar.

Blossomtoes · 19/11/2022 18:21

This thread’s unbelievable. Can you imagine social services’ or the police’s reaction if they got a call saying two teenagers smell? What planet do some of you live on?

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 16:55

Theunamedcat · 19/11/2022 16:18

Surely at family events he tells them to shower and change? If they are not allowed to at mums house they should jump at the chance of showers at dad's? No? And New clothes he buys them for his house they won't smell right?

Munchousan has been disproved hasn't it?

No, no shower, a toothbrush but no shampoo or conditioner due to sulphites, no anti perspirat/deodorant.....

Crazy, unwashed, Ill fitting clothes out of place. The step children looked amazing so no money or time excuses there.

A kind of weird, wider family acceptance that that branch are hippy soap Dodgers but that doesn't work for teens at state schools and it's been years ...

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 16:52

How will talking to him about his parenting now change the past? It won't.

I agree. I don't think there's any point.

The only think I would do is try to be as present in the girls' lives as possible. An unpaid, caring adult is an extremely important thing for teenagers in complicated situations. It can be lifesaving because they have another place, another example, not just their shitty parents. Act like a fairy godmother if there is space to do it.

These poor girls.

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 16:50

I want to shake my Bil, I'm angry that he makes a bare minimum effort with them and we are starting to really see the outcome of that.
Both girls are desperate for his attention, his approval.
It's not up to his ex partner, his new partner, me or granny to fix this. These girls have a massive dad shaped hole in their lives.
I think like all mums, like me, the girls one isn't perfect and has taken decisions that with hindsight weren't always with the best interests of the kids but her marriage was falling apart. My Bil regardless of where the kids sleep or old school gender stereotypes is just as responsible for them.

I don't think either of them have actually put the girls long term happiness ahead of their own.

It makes me very angry because we have teens and have played a positive active role in their friends lives when my niece's are falling apart 100 miles away. So probably quite a lot of guilt.

I think I need to do a lot of listening and just prompt with questions.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 19/11/2022 16:18

Surely at family events he tells them to shower and change? If they are not allowed to at mums house they should jump at the chance of showers at dad's? No? And New clothes he buys them for his house they won't smell right?

Munchousan has been disproved hasn't it?

Dutch1e · 19/11/2022 16:09

This is a really difficult thing to be grappling with, I don't envy your position. Personally I would say something to BIL. Even if it came out a bit bumbling it's better to speak up than stay silent where kids are concerned.

I'd frame it in the context of wanting to help BIL with anything he might be struggling with when it comes to the kids and their mum.

upfucked · 19/11/2022 15:43

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 10:32

By neglect I mean both kids smell, even at a big family smart event - clothes, stale sweat & hair. It would normally be flagged if at Primary in a building a pattern, kind of safe guarding.

He sees them every other weekend, pays I understand a generous amount but absolutely wouldn't want the hassle of anymore time. His parents are lovely, he's grown up with decent role models.

Really, we are outsiders so don't necessarily know the full story.

Then you need to make a ss referral. Child protection is everyone’s business.

MarshaMelrose · 19/11/2022 15:41

If my sister's children smelled and looked neglected, etc, I'd definiteky speak to her about it. But I would not expect my husband to speak to her. Surely this is for your husband to tackle his brother over.

BadNomad · 19/11/2022 15:37

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 15:23

Because there isn't much he can do to make teenagers wash EOW.

Well if he actually gave a shit he would have tried for more than EOW years ago. Wouldn't you fight for more care of DC that clearly need more care? So as much as this is the mother's fault, it's also his. They are both failing these girls.

How will talking to him about his parenting now change the past? It won't. Yes, he should have done more, but it's too late. Which is why I'm wondering why the OP wants to call him out on it now, rather than when it would have made a difference.

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/11/2022 15:23

Because there isn't much he can do to make teenagers wash EOW.

Well if he actually gave a shit he would have tried for more than EOW years ago. Wouldn't you fight for more care of DC that clearly need more care? So as much as this is the mother's fault, it's also his. They are both failing these girls.

WolvesOfTheCalla · 19/11/2022 15:22

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 13:56

This is not a case for social services, there's middle class money, forest school, muchausen by proxy from the mother.

But I still feel the dad has a responsibility but I'm conflicted because how would any of us react to our parenting being questioned.

At the heart of this are two girls, one out of education, employment or training. The other homework refusing. Both drinking alcohol looking for attention. It's not a happy teen life and although eow isn't much, that is his choice, it could me more. Should the wider family be ignoring this and pretending it is all happy families.

So because it’s a middle class family, they don’t need SS? Bizarre. If there is MPB, it 100% is a case for SS and the police, whether the family is on the dole or the new subset of ultra wealthy.

BadNomad · 19/11/2022 15:19

Do you mean he should be tackling their mother about her neglect? Because there isn't much he can do to make teenagers wash EOW. I'm wondering if your real issue is that you don't approve of him getting married to another woman and so you're using the children as an excuse to get at him. Because I can't see why the smelly teenagers are only an issue for you now.

Kalasbyxor · 19/11/2022 14:57

Crosstalk, the BIL's DC from his first relationship are the two daughters OP refers to in her most recent post. I think assumptions have been made about them being boys.

crosstalk · 19/11/2022 14:42

Munchausen from the boys' mother? And you're laying it all on BiL who has them every other weekend? And his new partner's apparently louche daughters?

In every 28 days they are spending 24 with their mum, I presume.

If you and your partner have any sort of relationship with the nephews, having them round/taking them out would be a possible first step. But not cross questioning about either parent - more a how's it going.

LolaSmiles · 19/11/2022 14:05

If you have safeguarding concerns then report them because safeguarding is everyone's business.

If there's not safeguarding concerns but you still want to be supportive then could you take an interest in the children, chat to BIL and ask how him and the children are and see if he needs any advice or support.

bellac11 · 19/11/2022 14:00

This is one of those threads that will end up being deleted. Its so ridiculous

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 13:56

This is not a case for social services, there's middle class money, forest school, muchausen by proxy from the mother.

But I still feel the dad has a responsibility but I'm conflicted because how would any of us react to our parenting being questioned.

At the heart of this are two girls, one out of education, employment or training. The other homework refusing. Both drinking alcohol looking for attention. It's not a happy teen life and although eow isn't much, that is his choice, it could me more. Should the wider family be ignoring this and pretending it is all happy families.

OP posts:
THisbackwithavengeance · 19/11/2022 13:15

I can't believe posters are suggesting ringing social services for smelly teenagers.

I honestly don't think social service are going to be interested in a stinky 17 year old unless there is evidence of actual abuse?

If you're genuinely concerned, why not speak to BIL, say you've all noticed that the kids are a bit whiffy, is everything alright at home?

If that gets you nowhere, surely you could raise it with the kids themselves, check they've got access to a bath/shower/hot water, buy them some deodorant, make sure they're ok.

Anecdotally. clothes often smell when they're dried indoors in a kitchen as they absorb all the cooking and oil smells. Could that be why?

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/11/2022 13:14

Definitely get involved op. Does your bil bother about their clothes / appearance? When they’re with him, he should be buying decent clothes.

Sceptre86 · 19/11/2022 12:53

It sounds more like maternal neglect tbh. I'm not sure what you can do other than voice your concerns to social services. How else would you want to get involved? The uncle could talk to his brother of course and say why do the kids stink everytime we see them, what's going on, why are you such a waste of space but that isn't likely to get you anywhere longterm.

Endwalker · 19/11/2022 12:50

Ring NSPCC and/or social services for your area, you can do it anonymously and it would not be overstepping. It might all be as simple as two teenage boys being scruffy and refusing to shower, it might be that their mother is struggling financially (e.g., can't run the washing machine or heat the bath water) and their father doesn't care enough to intervene, or it might be intentional neglect and abuse.

Either way, speak up. Your BIL won't know it was you and if there is something going on then those boys will get the help they need.

Holly60 · 19/11/2022 12:48

I'm not sure what can be done with a 17 year old who you see every other weekend. You could only really suggest that they have a wash but if they don't there isn't a huge amount you can do in that time frame.

Teenagers do smell a bit sometimes - I'm not sure I'd call it neglect in this case.

InterventionBlues · 19/11/2022 12:44

No I think they smell all the time. But I also think he can't just ignore it and should step up when he has a chance. And he needs to make that chance, not fill his responsible weekends by ignoring them whilst he gets on with chores.

OP posts: