Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should have watched DS

132 replies

BearySilly · 19/11/2022 09:16

On holiday with in-laws and we are all taking it in turns to cook dinner. On me and DH's night I cooked and he was watching the kids but then FIL asked him to help with something around the house that really couldn't wait. Everyone else was out or busy so I asked SIL to watch 10mo DS. She did for a while but then when I looked round he was crawling around the kitchen by himself and she was on the sofa playing video games. She totally ignored me as I cooked, laid the table and minded DS and DD.

I think she was very rude but DH thinks that she's just one of those people who thinks "your kids, your problem" and, as she and BIL had cooked a couple of nights before she felt like she'd done her bit.

I'm biased against her as she and BIL (she's his gf) stayed with us for 10 days and she was the laziest most ungrateful house guest I've ever had. My cooking was not up to scratch, she never helped clean up after dinner and she just generally made everything more difficult despite insisting she was staying with us to "help out".

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 19/11/2022 14:46

Nobody has to help anybody, that's true but what a nasty, mean spirited attitude to go through life with.

Precisely, so odd.

VladmirsPoutine · 19/11/2022 14:46

I don't think yabu. A lot of people have said 'your baby, your problem' but that's not how families should work in my opinion. You already know what she's like given your previous experiences with her being lazy so just don't expect anything from her in the future. But don't judge by Mumsnet standards.

pigsDOfly · 19/11/2022 14:44

No, as so many pps have said, SIL didn't have to watch your baby OP.

But what a selfish, lazy attitude towards a family member who's actually cooking dinner that I assume, SIL is going to eat and, no doubt she (SIL) will also benefit from the generator being fixed.

Nobody has to help anybody, that's true but what a nasty, mean spirited attitude to go through life with.

SeasonFinale · 19/11/2022 14:41

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 14:36

She did for a while but then when I looked round he was crawling around the kitchen by himself and she was on the sofa playing video games. She totally ignored me as I cooked, laid the table and minded DS and DD.

Why did you not say anything - was martyrdom preferable?
"Oi - SiL! - I thought you were minding your nephew! - Can you focus on him while I finish up here, or do I need to ask somebody else to take over while you look at your phone?"

Yes this ^^ Speak up at the time.

BearySilly · 19/11/2022 14:41

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 14:36

She did for a while but then when I looked round he was crawling around the kitchen by himself and she was on the sofa playing video games. She totally ignored me as I cooked, laid the table and minded DS and DD.

Why did you not say anything - was martyrdom preferable?
"Oi - SiL! - I thought you were minding your nephew! - Can you focus on him while I finish up here, or do I need to ask somebody else to take over while you look at your phone?"

I should have done that! I guess even though I personally would not behave like that I do agree that he's my baby and ultimately my responsibility.

It's really not DH's problem. When I realised we were about to have no power I told him to go with FIL and fix it and I'd deal with kids/cooking. Noone else was around except SIL hence asking her. What they were doing I don't know. If she had gone and hidden in her room I'd have been none the wiser and just made do but she insists on lounging in full view while you work around her.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 14:36

She did for a while but then when I looked round he was crawling around the kitchen by himself and she was on the sofa playing video games. She totally ignored me as I cooked, laid the table and minded DS and DD.

Why did you not say anything - was martyrdom preferable?
"Oi - SiL! - I thought you were minding your nephew! - Can you focus on him while I finish up here, or do I need to ask somebody else to take over while you look at your phone?"

CurlyhairedAssassin · 19/11/2022 14:35

Actually I’d go further and say that on your next turn to cook for everyone you will just be making something quick and simple like you would at home. I think it’s very unreasonable to expect you to mind the children AS WELL AS cook a fancy meal for 8 or however many there are, as that means it’s harder for you than it would be at home. It is supposed to be a holiday, complicated big family meals are all well and good but it does require planning and all mucking in. Especially when you’ve got children on the mix.

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2022 14:33

she should have said no -

not said fine and then not done it - its a crawling baby, they can hurt themselves easily, very off to say she will do it and then not bother.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 14:33

On me and DH's night I cooked and he was watching the kids but then FIL asked him to help with something around the house that really couldn't wait. Everyone else was out or busy so I asked SIL to watch 10mo DS.

You're blaming SiL because it;s easier than addressing the fact that DH thinks childcare is still your job even when HE is ostensibly the parent "on duty".
If he wanted to go & help FiL instead, the onus was on HIM to ask his sister to take over. Why did you have to? Because ... uterus?

The fact that she chose to slack off is a different matter, & one you can address with her if you think it's worthwhile.
You blame her for the reason above, but also 'cos you dislike her for being lazy & ungrateful. And ... it's ok to dislike your SiL! - but don't use her as a scapegoat for your DH's inability to care for his own child without dumping the task on a woman.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 19/11/2022 14:33

What was BIL doing? And was there anyone else there?

Why was BILs GF the one chosen to watch DS?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/11/2022 14:31

Yeah shes being a shit. If someone asks you to mind their baby for a short time while they cook your dinner because your husband is fixing an unexpected issue with the generator, surely you'd do it? I'm not a pushover by any means but I wouldn't dream of saying or even thinking 'nope, your kids, your problem' or saying yes and then not actually bothering.

I think I'd have gone and said he needs to be watched, if you cant do it, then no worries I'll just have to wait til the generator is fixed but just to warn you dinner might be a bit soggy' or something.

I found it really hard to look after young kids and cook, adult dinner time is often at the witching hour where they are really grouchy and mine used to go mental and just want to be held, but were too big really for a sling and it was awkward using knives etc.

But from your update she sounds frankly like an entitled bitch anyway

shutthedamndoor · 19/11/2022 14:27

I think she was rude. It's a family holiday. You were making dinner for everyone including her. It's not hard to watch a 10 month old for half an hour. She could have offered to make dinner instead. To sit playing on her phone while everyone else was pitching in is just lazy and rude.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 19/11/2022 14:24

What strange answers you’ve got, OP? Sometimes people on MN are very cold. I don’t know what their lives must be like with the “every man for himself” attitude. Such a selfish outlook on life.

when I’ve been on holiday in a shared house with family there hasn’t been this drama. If DH was keeping an eye on the kids while I cooked and he got called away to do something for the good of the group he would just have asked his sibling to mind them for him, and if they didn’t want to do that then I’d just sit down and stop the cooking till they came back (or ask SIL to carry on chopping veg while I minded the kids)

the silly people implying that you’re incompetent for not being able to cook as well as look after a crawling baby have clearly never been in a holiday home with their baby, looking after them on their own while everyone else did something else. Most aren’t set up like your own house would be, all baby proofed or with a playpen etc. they require the family to muck in together and look out for each other.

so the only thing I’d say you were being unreasonable about, OP, is going away with them in the first place. Your SIL doesn’t sound like a team player so I wouldn’t want her on my “holiday team” - don’t go away with her again, simple!

NeverHadANickname · 19/11/2022 14:19

I don't think she HAD to watch him but if she agreed then she should have. It is not fair to agree then just decide not to without telling anyone.

BearySilly · 19/11/2022 14:16

MistyFrequencies · 19/11/2022 14:10

Surely you cook and mind your kids at home? So why do you need help on holiday?
I think probably the fact that you dont like her makes this more annoying to you than it might be to anyone else.

It's easier at home as I've got everything set up to be child friendly - locks on cupboards, stair gates, toys. Plus at home I only do quick meals for the 2 of us.

OP posts:
Thehonestbadger · 19/11/2022 14:13

I have a 2.5yo and 17mo so I’m sympathetic to the plight of trying to achieve anything with them In tow.

However, you can’t foist them onto her regardless of what DH or FIL were doing. In your situation it would have gone down like this.

FIL: DH can you come help with with this super important and urgent task.
DH: suree: HANG ON, I can’t watch both kids and cook so either someone else needs to help you FIL or we’ll be having toast/sandwiches for tea.
FIL: Only DH knows how to do this
Me: Well DS is DH’s responsibility tonight so either you take him with you or you find someone else to watch him, or we don’t get dinner…your choice

I’m sure they would then have tried to rope in SIL at which point I’d have been making very clear
Me: It’s great if you’re actually going to watch him the whole time but you generally don’t seem very keen to do that so please don’t say you will and then get bored and ignore him after 20 minutes because that’s no help, that’s worse than not helping.

Yes I do behave like this with my family/in laws I’m not popular for it but I think not being very up front and direct is to blame for most gender inequality issues

Justmuddlingalong · 19/11/2022 14:13

I don't agree with the "your kids, your problem" attitude, personally. But that's immaterial. If that's SIL's thoughts, then you can't expect her to muck in.

Zone2NorthLondon · 19/11/2022 14:10

X posts. I see you’ve answered it was an urgent fix. Fair enough he had to assist to maintain power

MistyFrequencies · 19/11/2022 14:10

Surely you cook and mind your kids at home? So why do you need help on holiday?
I think probably the fact that you dont like her makes this more annoying to you than it might be to anyone else.

Zone2NorthLondon · 19/11/2022 14:09

I can see the sil is probably irksome and complains unnecessarily, but nowt you can do, case of smile and grin I’m afraid. She’s probably trying to provoke you and/or get a reaction . Regard the childcare that’s up to you and your dp, however it’s a shame she didn’t offer to help. But she’s not compelled to. Your DH should have waited til you’d prepared meal before leaving the kids.

Blip · 19/11/2022 14:09

Does sil have kids herself?

BearySilly · 19/11/2022 14:07

Goldbar · 19/11/2022 14:04

Your DH should have said to FIL, "not now, I'm watching the kids. I'll help later". SIL sounds selfish and awful, but she wasn't the one who bailed and left the kids without supervision.

He could have done but we'd have very quickly been eating a half cooked dinner in darkness with no power left! I should have put what exactly he was doing in the OP really, I was trying to keep it vague but probably made it too vague!

Interesting most people seem to agree with DH that "your kids, your problem" is how they'd see it. I couldn't imagine treating someone like that!

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 19/11/2022 14:06

DH was supposed to be looking after the kids so he should have asked FIL to wait. I'm not sure why you're blaming her when he left the kids without even trying to get someone else to supervise.

Goldbar · 19/11/2022 14:04

Your DH should have said to FIL, "not now, I'm watching the kids. I'll help later". SIL sounds selfish and awful, but she wasn't the one who bailed and left the kids without supervision.

AmyDudley · 19/11/2022 14:02

I can't imagine not being happy to watch a family members baby for a short time while they were cooking a meal I was going to be eating. Do people really apply these 'your kids your problem' "rules" when on a family holiday? In my family we all muck in and happily help each other out. I find this kind of selfishness bizarre, it's not like OP was asking the woman for indefinite free childcare, just a helping hand while she cooked dinner so they could all eat and her DH helped sort the generater so they could all have heating.