Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should have watched DS

132 replies

BearySilly · 19/11/2022 09:16

On holiday with in-laws and we are all taking it in turns to cook dinner. On me and DH's night I cooked and he was watching the kids but then FIL asked him to help with something around the house that really couldn't wait. Everyone else was out or busy so I asked SIL to watch 10mo DS. She did for a while but then when I looked round he was crawling around the kitchen by himself and she was on the sofa playing video games. She totally ignored me as I cooked, laid the table and minded DS and DD.

I think she was very rude but DH thinks that she's just one of those people who thinks "your kids, your problem" and, as she and BIL had cooked a couple of nights before she felt like she'd done her bit.

I'm biased against her as she and BIL (she's his gf) stayed with us for 10 days and she was the laziest most ungrateful house guest I've ever had. My cooking was not up to scratch, she never helped clean up after dinner and she just generally made everything more difficult despite insisting she was staying with us to "help out".

OP posts:
Sonervousimgonnathrowup · 19/11/2022 18:13

*YOU should.

Sonervousimgonnathrowup · 19/11/2022 18:13

I should aim your anger towards your husband, not the SIL.

NumberTheory · 19/11/2022 17:43

YANBU at all.

I think your DH just going off instead of finding someone to watch the kids first was out of order. But given the designated child watcher was busy trying to get the generator working, which was necessary for everyone, SiL should have stepped up to watch the kids while DH was doing that. Also, since you asked and she said she would do it, she should have bloody done it and just stopping and playing video games is really selfish and irresponsible.

UsingChangeofName · 19/11/2022 17:33

I haven't voted as, although it is a bit annoying, there is, presumably, an understandable element of the gf thinking that she came on holiday to relax and not look after other people's dc.

I mean, I would have helped if I were her, but I know what it's like to try and do things with a crawling baby in a non-baby-proofed- place and I would just do what I could to help, but, if she felt she had done her turn at cooking, and presumably no-one helped her, I can sort of understand the resentment at then being asked to look after someone else's baby when potentially it probably wasn't her ideal situation to spend a holiday with all her bf's extended family.

The responsibility here lay with your dh, who should have responded "I can only come and help you if someone is able to look after dc, as Beary is cooking and he can't be left on his own" then made sure she either volunteered, or one of the other adults volunteered or someone said Beary can and I'll hold the fort in the kitchen, or whatever worked. The issue is you told him to go and "assumed".

BadNomad · 19/11/2022 17:16

Equally, if she wanted to help, she would have offered. But she didn't. It was the OP who asked her, putting her in the position of looking like a dick if she said no. She might not have realised the OP expected her to keep the child entertained and out of the way. She might have thought she just needed to keep him safe when he was out of his mother's vision.

It's foolish to assume other people who have never had children have the same instincts or knowledge of children just because they are adults (and female?).

Heck, half of the fathers posted about on MN don't have a clue about their own children, yet this unmarried, childless woman is expected to take on responsibility for a baby she barely knows.

KVick · 19/11/2022 17:04

If I'm understanding the scenario correctly: SIL was asked to mind the kid for a bit while DH sorted out an issue with the generator, and Op cooked the family meal. SIL apparently agreed to do this, and watched DS for a while, but then abandoned the task in order to play video games - without letting anyone know that she'd left the baby to its own devices.

So the issue is - if SIL (who really isn’t an “SIL,” just some girlfriend, right?) didn’t want to be bothered keeping an eye on the child then she should have just said so when Op asked for her assistance, in which case Op could have worked something else out.

Rinatinabina · 19/11/2022 16:51

YANBU keeping an eye on a crawling baby while everyone else is doing something useful isn’t a big ask tbh. I’m also very anti expecting family childcare etc but in these circumstances I would be a bit annoyed. Most people who aren’t keen on babies and small kids would still keep an eye to make sure they don’t get hurt (i.e. me).

jazzybelle · 19/11/2022 16:44

Does BIL help with anything?

PAFMO · 19/11/2022 16:40

Labnehi · 19/11/2022 15:56

That's hardly the point, which is what could easily happen to a baby who is not being minded.

If I go out drinking in town for the evening, leaving my baby alone in the house, is it just fine as long as he's ok when I get back? Or is it a huge problem because you can't leave a baby unattended because anything could happen?

Your example is irrelevant and incomparable . Obviously.

diddl · 19/11/2022 16:35

I'd have looked after the kids until husband was back & then carried on cooking.

Sonervousimgonnathrowup · 19/11/2022 16:21

Ugh, YABsoU.

I agree with your husband, your kid - your problem. If only all parents were this sensible.

I think it’s unfair to SIL lazy or whatever, you brought your kids, it’s not right to call her selfish for not wanting to deal with them.
It’s like if someone would bring their pet on a family holiday - and the call ither people lazy and be upset no one else is taking it for a walk, picking up poop or have to make arrangement around the pet.

I think it’s selfish of you to assume your kids should be other people’s problem.

You said your keeping score and think that you will help the other SIL since they been usefull to you, but that’s always easy to say, since you don’t have to stand behind your words.
And honestly, the way ypu talk about people, really doesn’t put you in a good light.

Ponderingwindow · 19/11/2022 16:07

This is a situation where your DH, not you, should have asked the SIL to be fully responsible for the child until his return. He was handing off child duties and should have made sure they were handed off properly.

Kitcaterpillar · 19/11/2022 16:05

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 14:36

She did for a while but then when I looked round he was crawling around the kitchen by himself and she was on the sofa playing video games. She totally ignored me as I cooked, laid the table and minded DS and DD.

Why did you not say anything - was martyrdom preferable?
"Oi - SiL! - I thought you were minding your nephew! - Can you focus on him while I finish up here, or do I need to ask somebody else to take over while you look at your phone?"

I think I'm a pretty nice person and if someone said this to me, I would tell them to crack on with finding someone else.

Sceptre86 · 19/11/2022 16:04

She's a lazy bugger. If I could see my sil was struggling with her kid and cooking I'd either keep an eye on the kid or pass the kid to her and set the table. She is on a family holiday after all, that means interacting with the family and not being antisocial playing video games. Who actually does that?

Lullabies2Paralyze · 19/11/2022 16:03

I think YABU given you know her personality and already think she’s lazy and unhelpful

however I do think majority of people (myself included) would happily watch family or friends kids for a short amount of time if parents were doing something urgent, or have offered to takeover task so you could attend to your child

PorridgewithQuark · 19/11/2022 16:02

MistyFrequencies · 19/11/2022 14:10

Surely you cook and mind your kids at home? So why do you need help on holiday?
I think probably the fact that you dont like her makes this more annoying to you than it might be to anyone else.

Here speaks someone who's never stayed in a big holiday let with a crawling baby.

We stayed in a huge holiday house with a big group of friends when dc1 was ten months old, as the only ones with a small child. You suddenly notice that there are completely open stone ataircases and drops in big open plan kitchen diners, glass doors on rooms and cabinets, furniture that can easily be pulled over by babies who pull themselves to standing, sharp edges, glasses and china stored at floor and baby cruising hight, sharp cooking knives in draws babies can reach, endless dangers you've naturally removed from your own home.

Northernparent68 · 19/11/2022 16:00

Yes, she’s rude, but this is now the second time she’s been a guest and behaved badly. Perhaps it’s time to stop inviting her and going on holiday with her.

Delatron · 19/11/2022 15:59

You say you enjoy going on holiday with them but she sounds awful. She’s already shown herself to be rude and disrespectful in your house. I wouldn’t have agreed to go away with her. Holidays are too precious to spend a lot of time annoyed with someone.

She basically doesn’t care does she? You’ve had words. She’s ignored you. You have more patience than I do spending a holiday with her.

Tiani4 · 19/11/2022 15:59

Even my 10,12 year old DCs know you need to constantly watch and intervene / care for a 10 month old crawling baby whose until then parent comes back if you've been asked and have agreed to do it. She's an adult and a lazy one at that

Moveoverdarlin · 19/11/2022 15:58

If she doesn’t have children of her own, she probably doesn’t realise what ‘watching a ten month old’ involved. If she saw her crawling around the kitchen whilst you were cooking or you juggling her on your hip, she probably thought you had it covered. She doesn’t see the baby as her niece, just her boyf’s sister baby. I wouldn’t have had a clue how to entertain a ten month old baby before I had kids, especially with the Mum in the room too.

Tiani4 · 19/11/2022 15:57

As a number of other posters have said if she agree to watch baby then decides to stop without telling anyone and sit playing on her phone then she's an a-hole.

I'm biased against her as she and BIL (she's his gf) stayed with us for 10 days and she was the laziest most ungrateful house guest I've ever had. My cooking was not up to scratch, she never helped clean up after dinner and she just generally made everything more difficult despite insisting she was staying with us to "help out".

Also this doesn't paint her in a good light . Don't invite her again , she goes after first night. One night sleepover only ever for her. Life is far too busy and short to have entities lazy people take advantage and use your home as a hotel

Labnehi · 19/11/2022 15:56

PAFMO · 19/11/2022 15:53

But what happened to the child apart from him crawling on the floor?

That's hardly the point, which is what could easily happen to a baby who is not being minded.

If I go out drinking in town for the evening, leaving my baby alone in the house, is it just fine as long as he's ok when I get back? Or is it a huge problem because you can't leave a baby unattended because anything could happen?

ChampagneLassie · 19/11/2022 15:55

MistyFrequencies · 19/11/2022 14:10

Surely you cook and mind your kids at home? So why do you need help on holiday?
I think probably the fact that you dont like her makes this more annoying to you than it might be to anyone else.

Ha! I've got one 7 month old and I rarely attempt it. Your SIL sounds lazy and selfish. I like to think I'd have pulled her up on this re the baby and that you're cooking for everyone.

PAFMO · 19/11/2022 15:53

But what happened to the child apart from him crawling on the floor?

Mylakk · 19/11/2022 15:52

Of course she should've looked after your DS under those circumstances - I would have thought any adult/teenager who was around at the time would've been happy to help.

However, she has already shown you who she is when staying at your house previously for 10 days so...it couldn't have been a surprise. I'm not sure how you can tolerate houseguest for 10 days let alone ones like that AND then chose to go on holiday with them!