Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To upend my settled family because I’m unhappy in the middle of rural nowhere?

381 replies

OpheliaPlum · 19/11/2022 06:33

We live in a rural area. Lovely house, space, big garden. No public transport, no shops, no amenities basically, and fast country roads with no pavements so we have to drive to get anywhere. We moved here 8 years ago because of DH’s then job and a lovely primary in the next village. I work in a creative industry and there is a shared workspace I drive to. I used to WFH but became so isolated in lockdowns after lockdowns I found a place to work alongside others, but it’s not an office, but shared space for freelance artists etc.

My eldest DC has just transferred to secondary school in September. We all wake at 6am every day and I drive DH to the station and the DC to their schools. Since the secondary transfer, I spend 16 hours every week on school runs. There is a Bus eldest DC could get but it is a 10 min drive from home (impossible to walk, country lanes, 70mph speed limits, no pavements) and in the opposite direction to the station and primary school. From the primary school there’s a backroad to the secondary so it makes sense for me to drive. At weekends my DC have different activities in different places and understandably want to see friends. My DH and I spend a lot of the weekend driving and hanging about in locations far from home. We do this separately so the other can get on with the endless laundry, maintaining the garden, all very practical, but increasingly we have very limited family time.

This June my DH got a new job so we don’t need to be in this area for his work any more. During covid I started doing some online uni teaching of my work. I visited the place I was teaching at in the summer for the first time in person and taught a special summer school. I felt so alive and connected to like minded people and it made me realise how isolated I am in the countryside.

There is a fixed term 3 year contract coming up at the uni. There is a possibility of a permanent job after that but the HE sector seems to be imploding and I am not sure how realistic the permanent contact would be. It would be 2 days teaching and studio space for my own creative practice. It is 3 hours from where we live.

My DH commutes to an office but has said he could transfer to work close to that town or change to a role with more WFH. He has very specialised skills and works in an industry that exists everywhere (like for an energy company, but not quite that).

I’d really like to apply for this job and if I get it, move the family. My children are adamant they do not want to leave. My eldest says he has just done secondary transfer, loves his new school, tells me I can move when the DC are all grown up. My younger DC love the countryside. We have a big garden, a dog, ducks, rabbits, and they love that life. I feel very selfish but also can’t get the fantasy of living in a buzzing town, being able to share my passion with the next generation, even walk to a cafe out of my head. I feel very tied to driving children everywhere and am under so much time pressure since the secondary transfer that it’s brought me to tears. It feels very melodramatic but I feel as if my needs have become crushed living here.

The deadline to apply is very soon. It isn’t a common opportunity at all, but I’m really not sure what to do as it is potentially just a three year role. I can imagine living in the town when the role comes to an end and my DH and I could both work from there. Also we don’t have any family close to where we live now but can visit family either side within a couple of hours. If we move it would be a half day journey to visit family.

Please help me think this through.

OP posts:
EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 11:13

Your life doesn't sound much fun. But I do think you are considering extremes. Is there nowhere closer? Does it have to be right now, or is there a period where your children will more naturally be able to move schools?

My dad was a diplomat so we moved constantly in my childhood. It was ok, but hard sometimes. Things that made it easier was moving to a school where others came and went (e.g. international school or in a big city, worst move was to a small local school where everyone (other than me) had known each other since preschool and friendships were firmly established and they weren't used to new kids with different backgrounds) or at a new school stage where other kids also moved (e.g. going from secondary to college). You might want to consider which of your children would be most resilient to change at a less opportune time.

TarquinOliverNimrod · 21/11/2022 11:05

Kennykenkencat · 20/11/2022 01:27

My children grew up in London. At 10 years old Dd was hopping on and off tube trains to get to school
She and her friends did have lot of freedom

Dd met a few people from all over the U.K. doing a particular activity competitively. Those that lived rurally really envied the lifestyle of those that lived in London. So much so that the ones who have remained friends with Dd on SM. Quite a few chose a London University or a University in a large City to go to
I don’t think she knows anyone who remained in their village. None have any intention of moving back.

If you don’t apply for the job or you apply, get the job then turn the offer down because of your children. In a few years time the dc who currently don’t want to leave will have left for University and you could be stuck in a place you don’t like having missed your opportunity to escape.

Nonsense. I grew up rurally and would have hated growing up in London! I felt privileged to have such an idyllic lifestyle, horse riding, mountain biking on my doorstep, fresh air, surrounded by beauty and wildlife, and I felt so safe! My childhood was a dream and I would hate to bring children up in London, crime, gangs, pollution, noise, crowds, ugh. All way too stressful. I lived there for 30 years so know the reality of London all too well. I continue to work there two days a week and it’s much worse now than when I lived there. So edgy, and not in a good way.

I would have felt utterly stifled living somewhere urban, I had a wonderful outdoorsy upbringing surrounded by endless space to roam. You just cannot replicate that lifestyle living in London. So, I have to object to your insistence that children living rurally would be ‘jealous’ of your kids living in London!! Utter nonsense 😂

BloodAndFire · 21/11/2022 10:56

TarquinOliverNimrod · 21/11/2022 10:42

I totally agree with this. I’ve done town and city living (lived in Central London for 30 years) and now, like the OP, live rurally, with no public transport or shops. We moved out of the city to start a family. I would never move back! For me, the benefits of country living to both our mental
and physical health hugely outweigh the ‘convenience’ of being able to pop to the shops.

OP, your children clearly love their current idyllic lifestyle and who can blame them! Do you really want to be amongst crowds, pollution, noise and crime when you have peace, tranquillity, cleaner air, beautiful surroundings, wildlife at your disposal. Think hard before moving your family to the burbs, the grass isn’t always greener and all that. A rural upbringing is a wonderful and privileged thing.

Everyone I met at university who had grown up in the countryside absolutely hated it throughout their teens. And who could blame them? Teenagers don't want 'peace and tranquillity and wildlife'. They want actual life.

TarquinOliverNimrod · 21/11/2022 10:42

Setyoufree · 19/11/2022 06:47

For balance, I live in a big town. I still spend all weekend and several evenings a week driving the kids around. Journeys that on paper should be short actually aren't because of the horrible traffic. I never go into the city centre itself because half the shops are boarded up.

Hard to know what the right thing to do is but having space and not being on top of people like rats in a barrel shouldn't be underestimated

I totally agree with this. I’ve done town and city living (lived in Central London for 30 years) and now, like the OP, live rurally, with no public transport or shops. We moved out of the city to start a family. I would never move back! For me, the benefits of country living to both our mental
and physical health hugely outweigh the ‘convenience’ of being able to pop to the shops.

OP, your children clearly love their current idyllic lifestyle and who can blame them! Do you really want to be amongst crowds, pollution, noise and crime when you have peace, tranquillity, cleaner air, beautiful surroundings, wildlife at your disposal. Think hard before moving your family to the burbs, the grass isn’t always greener and all that. A rural upbringing is a wonderful and privileged thing.

BloodAndFire · 21/11/2022 10:41

Toomuchtrouble4me · 20/11/2022 21:18

Apply - then decide if you get it.
I left london for only semi rural, near village and bus routes and 15mins from train that takes me directly into London. Family love it here. I hate it. I spend at least 2 days a week back in lovely London. Wish I’d never moved. I will stay until they’ve finished school, and then I’m going back.
I think the country life is lovely- if you are born to it. But it’s slow and small and dull and depressing if you’re used to city life.

I feel cold, muddy, wet, panicky, trapped, bored, cabin-fever-y and isolated after about 5 minutes in the countryside, and properly freaked out if I can't walk to at least 10 shops and several bus stops in under 5 mins. I also have never bothered learning to drive. Can you tell I'm London born and bred? ;-)

SirMingeALot · 21/11/2022 10:34

chicken12 · 20/11/2022 22:59

Get a grip your life is a fantasy out of reach for most

There are not many people fantasising about 16 hours a week on the school run and a rat run outside their house.

vix3rd · 21/11/2022 10:23

Apply & see if you get it first.
If you don't - Well it doesn't matter.

If you do - Then make the decision. You'll probably find that once the kids move & get used to the new place they'll be fine.

BloodAndFire · 21/11/2022 10:22

chicken12 · 20/11/2022 22:59

Get a grip your life is a fantasy out of reach for most

It sounds like hell on earth.

KimberleyClark · 21/11/2022 09:58

chicken12 · 20/11/2022 22:59

Get a grip your life is a fantasy out of reach for most

Rural living is not everyone’s fantasy. Growing up my grandmother lived in a rural village. While it was fun visiting her I was always glad to come home and always knew I never wanted to live in the country.

vickylou78 · 21/11/2022 09:52

spending so much time on school runs does sound a nightmare!

Living in a town where children could walk to local school and all to friends houses is so much easier! We live literall 5 minutes walk from primary school and 15 minutes walk from secondary school so all our children's friends live really close by and getting to school is so easy. Shops and amenities etc. We drive to the countryside when we want to get away from it all.

I think the new job and town living could actually work out better for all of you. When eldest is 16-18 and wants to be out socialising being in the country will not be fun for them as they'll always have to be asking for lifts and won't be able to drink if they are driving to the pub etc. Move now.

Or alternatively can you move closer to the secondary school your eldest is already in?

Laisydaisy · 20/11/2022 23:18

I would say move. It’s not going to get any easier and the loneliness and isolation you feel is really not ok. I lived on a country lane for years. The traffic was occasional but there were no pavements and it was incredibly dangerous at times. My dog was killed while I was walking him. So my DS could never walk out on his own or cycle. He didn’t want to leave the big garden or the countryside but loved it once we moved to a lovely, rural town where he had more independence. And I was much happier.

Allsnotwell · 20/11/2022 23:14

Her life isn’t a fantasy! Who wants to spend 16 hours a week on school runs?

chicken12 · 20/11/2022 22:59

Get a grip your life is a fantasy out of reach for most

Lovetoplan · 20/11/2022 22:35

I think you should apply for the job and see whether you get it just in case you don't and this all goes away! If you do then I would have a really good look at where it is best to move to bearing in mind your kids will need to be independent at some point. Think really practical - everything in walking distance if possible and you can save on transport costs. We moved nearer to London as kids got older and it is great. Could not imagine being stuck in the country but then I don't want animals or gardening!

CaptainNelson · 20/11/2022 22:14

We moved our kids when they were 13, 11 and 5. 13 year was absolutely fine, although they were also happy at the 1st secondary. 11 year old struggled, but to be fair was struggling anyway so I don't know it made much difference. 5 year old doesn't even remember.
We moved to somewhere more rural, but nothing like what you're describing, OP. And my older kids constantly wanted us to move back closer to the city once they hit around 15. They like the country, but transport really is dire, I don't think people who live in cities fully appreciate how bad it is.
Get them involved and explore local schools and facilities where you're thinking of moving to. It will work out if you want it to. Good luck

DobbleBobble · 20/11/2022 21:55

It sounds like your kids are pre teen? As the parent of a fairly anti-social 14 year old I can tell you that in the last couple of years living somewhere where he can easily walk or cycle a short distance safely to meet up with his school friends is very important to him. We don't live in a big city but when we moved here one of my big things was easily being able to walk somewhere even if it is just a big village.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 20/11/2022 21:18

Apply - then decide if you get it.
I left london for only semi rural, near village and bus routes and 15mins from train that takes me directly into London. Family love it here. I hate it. I spend at least 2 days a week back in lovely London. Wish I’d never moved. I will stay until they’ve finished school, and then I’m going back.
I think the country life is lovely- if you are born to it. But it’s slow and small and dull and depressing if you’re used to city life.

Sooziewoozie · 20/11/2022 20:47

Definitely apply for the job, it sounds right up your street. You will end up running yourself into the ground if you do another five years of what you’re doing at the moment. It sounds as though your husband can adapt and your children will also adapt, hard as that may seem at the moment. Apply for the job, if you get it, then you can have a more serious conversation about the future.

4kids2cats · 20/11/2022 20:05

Definitely apply for the job. You might not get it - but you will always regret it if you don’t go for it.

AllNightDiner · 20/11/2022 19:44

Honestly, you may not feel like it now but I think this is a bit of a no-brainer. The entire family's needs rest on you being willing to dedicate your life to being their chauffeur and PA, and compromises don't really work because if you work away for some or all of the week, then you can't also be there to fulfil that role. To have so much resting on one family member's willingness and availability to be there and physically capable of picking up the slack for everyone else isn't just unfair but is also really foolish. What if you become physically ill from the drudge of it all (or just anyway) or mentally ill from the isolation or unhappiness? What if you become so utterly miserable that you end up going pop and walking out? This is not a sustainable arrangement when it relies so heavily on one person's self-effacement imo.

But the other thing is that your happy, settled son is going to do a volte face on you in the next couple of years. He'll want to be able to go to his friends' houses independently and walk home from school with them. He'll want to be able to go to the cinema or the football or parties or whatever. He won't want to be driven around by his mummy all the time and will be begging you to move somewhere with better access to amenities, and one by one all your children will feel the same. So you owe it to them to futureproof your arrangements for them just as much as they owe it to you (and you owe it to yourself) to make sure enough of your needs are met that you can be happy too. They'll moan now but they'll thank you in the end.

Apply for the job and if you get it, take it. This house in this location was great for the circumstances at the time, but your children aren't tinies anymore and it's time to make a new plan now.

Michelle1964 · 20/11/2022 19:21

"country lanes, 70mph speed limits” … really?
Read your highway code lately??

Puddywoodycat · 20/11/2022 19:06

Op ,make the move.

I do think it will be harder on the older DC but I think long term it's far better to move now.
Thinking about older age etc and When could wanted to go out independently.

Bite the bullet now.

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 19:03

I do have to say I know a few families with deeply troubled teens ( not due to moving house or school). The trauma it causes the families and the amount of time the DPs need to put into trying to sort things out, would make me extremely reluctant to rock the boat with a happy settled family, although moving within catchment seems like it could work.

Islandgirl68 · 20/11/2022 19:03

I would apply fir the job and then if you get it, look at options. Once your kids are teenagers they may feel frustrated by being so rural. It is hard work having to be the continual taxi driver, the may even love the freedom of a town. And for kis once they leave school they can losre contact with friends, it may be a good time to move when they are younger. Your needs are important too. Good luck with your decision.

juless77 · 20/11/2022 18:51

Don’t move your children my parents moved me and my brother when we were around your childrens age and we hated it never really forgave them for the trauma of putting us through moving house …a new school …leaving friends …and starting again