Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To upend my settled family because I’m unhappy in the middle of rural nowhere?

381 replies

OpheliaPlum · 19/11/2022 06:33

We live in a rural area. Lovely house, space, big garden. No public transport, no shops, no amenities basically, and fast country roads with no pavements so we have to drive to get anywhere. We moved here 8 years ago because of DH’s then job and a lovely primary in the next village. I work in a creative industry and there is a shared workspace I drive to. I used to WFH but became so isolated in lockdowns after lockdowns I found a place to work alongside others, but it’s not an office, but shared space for freelance artists etc.

My eldest DC has just transferred to secondary school in September. We all wake at 6am every day and I drive DH to the station and the DC to their schools. Since the secondary transfer, I spend 16 hours every week on school runs. There is a Bus eldest DC could get but it is a 10 min drive from home (impossible to walk, country lanes, 70mph speed limits, no pavements) and in the opposite direction to the station and primary school. From the primary school there’s a backroad to the secondary so it makes sense for me to drive. At weekends my DC have different activities in different places and understandably want to see friends. My DH and I spend a lot of the weekend driving and hanging about in locations far from home. We do this separately so the other can get on with the endless laundry, maintaining the garden, all very practical, but increasingly we have very limited family time.

This June my DH got a new job so we don’t need to be in this area for his work any more. During covid I started doing some online uni teaching of my work. I visited the place I was teaching at in the summer for the first time in person and taught a special summer school. I felt so alive and connected to like minded people and it made me realise how isolated I am in the countryside.

There is a fixed term 3 year contract coming up at the uni. There is a possibility of a permanent job after that but the HE sector seems to be imploding and I am not sure how realistic the permanent contact would be. It would be 2 days teaching and studio space for my own creative practice. It is 3 hours from where we live.

My DH commutes to an office but has said he could transfer to work close to that town or change to a role with more WFH. He has very specialised skills and works in an industry that exists everywhere (like for an energy company, but not quite that).

I’d really like to apply for this job and if I get it, move the family. My children are adamant they do not want to leave. My eldest says he has just done secondary transfer, loves his new school, tells me I can move when the DC are all grown up. My younger DC love the countryside. We have a big garden, a dog, ducks, rabbits, and they love that life. I feel very selfish but also can’t get the fantasy of living in a buzzing town, being able to share my passion with the next generation, even walk to a cafe out of my head. I feel very tied to driving children everywhere and am under so much time pressure since the secondary transfer that it’s brought me to tears. It feels very melodramatic but I feel as if my needs have become crushed living here.

The deadline to apply is very soon. It isn’t a common opportunity at all, but I’m really not sure what to do as it is potentially just a three year role. I can imagine living in the town when the role comes to an end and my DH and I could both work from there. Also we don’t have any family close to where we live now but can visit family either side within a couple of hours. If we move it would be a half day journey to visit family.

Please help me think this through.

OP posts:
Stravaig · 19/11/2022 09:33

Raising eyebrows at children permanently 'traumatised' by a single, well-facilitated move!

OP currently services everyone else's needs, and whims, at the expense of her own wellbeing. This setup does not create healthy attitudes in children. Girls will underachieve and place themselves second their entire lives; boys will always see women as less, and feel entitled to use them to further their own goals. No amount of ducks and rabbits and rural idyll can counteract that basic message.

AloysiusBear · 19/11/2022 09:33

The school transport situation is odd.

Councils are required to provide transport for kids who live further from school. Where there aren't busses available this can even mean taxis sent to your home.

Is it your nearest school? If you could get rid of the school run issue wouldn't that help you have more choice about where you work etc? It sounds like you do need face to face work but does it have to be 3 hours away?

ping78 · 19/11/2022 09:33

@SixDinnerSally exactly, you can't make assumptions, throwing words around like traumatic is ridiculous (I know that wasn't you). Millions of children move and whilst there will be varying reactions many will get on with it and move on fine in time. The younger you do it the better of course.

CarefreeMe · 19/11/2022 09:31

YABU

It’s not fair to uproot your entire family because of a fantasy you’ve got in your head.

You’ll spend a few weeks in a big, buzzing city and then the reality will hit - smaller homes and gardens, less parking, less down time, having to drive somewhere just to get some peace etc.

The grass isn’t always greener.

I would wait until the younger ones are in secondary school and then move closer to the secondary school.

But I wouldn’t jump to a city, I would go to a town so you have the best of both worlds.

gottachangeforthisone · 19/11/2022 09:30

What is this insistence that despite being extremely happy in their rural home - they will be 'thankful' when they are teens. ?

My seven dc/dsc have all been bought up in what sounds like an identical rural space. You could not get further from 'God forsaken' as described up thread. We would call it an idyll.

None of them once complained about 'being in the middle of nowhere' . They all became teenagers at some point but that just meant more driving /drop offs. We also had an open sleepover policy (any child could sleep over at ours with their parents permission) ... and I don't think we had a weekend without at least 10 kids in the house between 2008-2018.: They loved it and their friends loved it because it was different. When they wanted to go to Town we took them and as Teens they stayed over..

Please don't assume all Teens hanker after living in town.

On to the dilemma !

The ONLY person who wants to move from the country is you.

YOU are important. However you are torn between upsetting yourself and unsettling and upsetting the kids. So the key is compromise.

It seems obvious to me that this can be achieved by you 'working away' .

Why is this so incredibly common for men - how many threads on here EVERYDAY that start 'DH works away and comes home weekends' ? but the thought of a woman doing this is a MASSIVE deal. ? Your DH can move to a WfH role - so get him to do that. He can then take on the school run.

You stay away at least 3 nights a week and get your 'town fix' . The kids are at an age where there is no parenting that can't be done by a man just as well as a woman ..

Ultimately you don't know until you try and there are too many variables to go upending the rest of the families lives until more things are known.

You may not get the job
You may not like the job
You may find staying away is fantastic especially in a new job where you can focus entirely on that.
You may miss the kids/DH too much.
The kids/DH may miss you too much
They may change their minds and want to move to be together.
You might decide you would rather be with them back home.

Many many families (mine included) followed a parent around because of their jobs . Until my mother put her foot down and said no. Then he worked away . We only moved for the final time when he had been working away for three years and knew that it would e our last move.

SixDinnerSally · 19/11/2022 09:29

But then again @ping78 , a school move at year 9 was a disaster for my dc’s mental health (and they wanted to move) so you just can’t make assumptions. Although I agree that parental mental health is extremely important too.

HermioneWeasley · 19/11/2022 09:29

Your kids love the life now. Very soon they will be teenagers and living rurally will suck. They will want to be able to get to town with their mates on frequent buses, not play with the ducks in your big garden.

Glorified · 19/11/2022 09:28

SixDinnerSally · 19/11/2022 09:23

@thelobsterquadrille so the OP should just endure another decade of this , as long as she’s let off a bit of the driving?? There’s more to it!

IMHO she needs to move locally regardless of the job as life in that location with 3 teens with school, PT jobs, clubs, social life etc is logistically untenable even if the DH steps up.

SixDinnerSally · 19/11/2022 09:27

@Foofedifiknow i completely agree with you. People often underestimate the impact of moving in Dc. Another PP said that @OpheliaPlum should consider how adaptable their older dc are and how easy they find it to make friends. A small town/ large village within the secondary catchment could work, surely, if such a place exists.

ping78 · 19/11/2022 09:27

I wouldn’t move personally. Moving schools is traumatic.

It really isn't for most children, growing up with a depressed parent would have a much more enduring impact I can assure you.

AndEverWhoKnew · 19/11/2022 09:26

The eldest school bus is a ten minute drive from home. Your DH could drop them off and collect them. It would only take forty minutes from his day. He wouldn't need to work for 4-8 hours at the weekend to catch up. Part of the reason you ended up living in the middle of nowhere was because of his job. He has to put more effort into ferrying everyone about.

Tumbleweed101 · 19/11/2022 09:25

At the children’s ages I’d consider doing it now rather than waiting if you want to make a big move. It’s much harder when in the later years at secondary. A move now will give the children time to make new friends before the exam and teen years. Driving children about gets worse before it gets better.

I’m rural with a bus route so getting them to school isn’t a problem it’s evenings and weekends I have to take them places. My 16yo wants a job and the reality is I’ll have to at least pick her up depending on what she gets because of poor public transport. Until she is driving I’m tied to helping her and then her younger sister. If we lived in
town it would be less of
an issue.

Caterina99 · 19/11/2022 09:25

We live in a rural area. More than 3 miles from the school. My primary school age kids get the school bus from our front door every day so no school run for me!

For secondary school they will have to walk/bike to the nearby village for the secondary bus. Fortunately it’s about 10 min or a 2 min drive.

im fully aware I’ll be driving them around loads once they’re older, but I lived in a city growing up, and my parents still drove me around a fair bit. Also there are a lot of similar age kids in our area, so I’m really hoping we can share the lifts

Definitely apply for the job OP. I don’t know if I’d move the whole family or just work away a night a week

SixDinnerSally · 19/11/2022 09:23

@thelobsterquadrille so the OP should just endure another decade of this , as long as she’s let off a bit of the driving?? There’s more to it!

Foofedifiknow · 19/11/2022 09:22

Senseofsomething · 19/11/2022 07:05

As a kid who constantly moved due to parents jobs I became miserable and really struggled to make new friends. So I kids don’t always adapt easily. Fitting in in a new school can be a really tough thing to do.

So I would stick it out for 5 years then move.

DH had similar issues - he and DS adapted well to challenge of moving at sensitive ages however there were lifelong consequences to moving from a familiar environment with friends and a school he enjoyed. His 2 DBs fared less well emotionally with the moving Having seen how it impacted on them in profound ways and really continues to affect their whole emotional and working lives I have decided for us on balance it’s just safer and kinder to stay put til DC at uni. What would be a lifestyle choice for us may end up as an adverse childhood experience and even a trauma for DC.

Branleuse · 19/11/2022 09:21

You can have a great garden and space in a town. I think even moving closer to public transport links would make a big difference

Phos · 19/11/2022 09:21

I wouldn’t move personally. Moving schools is traumatic. You’ve no idea if the buzz you felt was just the novelty. When that wears off for you and the kids are still unhappy because they moved schools partway through and didn’t make friends, then what.

Xtraincome · 19/11/2022 09:20

We are in this quandary too OP. We live in a village of old people next to a deprived town and very poor secondary schooling forour DD7 and DD5. Regardless of their personal wants, this is not a sustainable place for them to be teenagers. We are looking but it's really hard to find good education in an area we can afford. I miss walking, nearby coffee shops and good public transport. We have been here 6 years and have been trying to make ourselves happy (me and DH) but it really is rubbish. Thankfully the primary, which is fine but not great, is across the road. The mums are nice for the most part and we have nice next door neighbours.

@MrsJephson where do you guys live?

AndEverWhoKnew · 19/11/2022 09:20

There's two issues - the job and you being unhappy in the rural location.
I'd separate them out - apply for the job if you can wfh and then travel in/stay in the city when you need to be there. I wouldn't uproot my entire family for a 3 year contract.
As for not liking living rurally, is the high school in a town? Can you move there? Then you have the benefit of the buzz of the city but the DCs don't have their lived upended.
I live in a similar place to you atm so I completely relate to having to drive bloody everywhere and feeling isolated. But I'm trying to find somewhere that fits what I want but lets DCs stay at their school because they're happy there.

oakleaffy · 19/11/2022 09:19

OpheliaPlum · 19/11/2022 07:03

Lots of good suggestions, thank you. I could try the job remotely myself and travel and see what happens and what it’s like.

For all those asking, when we moved there was a bus stop literally opposite our house. The rural bus routes were closed a few months later and have never reopened because of costs. That is why we now have difficulty with getting to secondary school. If I wasn’t dropping younger DC to primary I could drop the eldest to the (privately run) school bus in the other direction. I’m not weirdly anxious about roads. We’ve had adult deaths on the road. Cars use it as a bypass (again new since we moved, because of other road closures) and they drive very fast. My youngest is 8 so I don’t think waiting until the DC can all drive is an option!

I absolutely understand the ferrying about issue- Living in a City when DS was a teen was great- everything walkable and good bus/ train links.
Friend lives rurally 20 miles away and I have noticed so much fast traffic on the roads- It’s actually frightening how fast and close vehicles pass pedestrians/equestrians .

When friend’s DC got to teenage years, it was constant ferrying about.
The Countryside is beautiful, but fast country roads are a real issue.
@OpheliaPlum I hope you find a workable compromise.
Dogs and rabbits and ducks can be kept in London gardens- My old landlady kept chickens and ducks, and some people had horses if the property had victorian stabling ( No turnout though, so not ideal).

PantyMcPantFace · 19/11/2022 09:18

I spend 16 hours every week on school runs. There is a Bus eldest DC could get but it is a 10 min drive from home (impossible to walk, country lanes, 70mph speed limits, no pavements) and in the opposite direction to the station and primary school

I have just spotted this again properly. Surely, surely this needs to be shared more with your DH? He needs to pick more of this up - and then if he needs to make up the time for work do it at a family convenient time - not a time that "punishes" you (from what you said you feel if he works at the weekend it impacts negatively on you - is he doing this deliberately so you don't get him to pull his weight? Nobody likes the grind of the school run/commute - and it sounds like your DH is dodging his share.

Also - school transport - have you asked your county for help with school transport - you should get help with costs (eg taxis) "there’s no safe walking route between their home and school" www.gov.uk/free-school-transport

thelobsterquadrille · 19/11/2022 09:18

SixDinnerSally · 19/11/2022 08:57

@thelobsterquadrille I’d with you if it weren’t for the fact that the OP is the lynchpin in the lives that everyone else enjoys! Her mental health is suffering while she is their taxi driver and relied upon to enable everything they want to do. Your point would only be valid if everyone was more independent (taking their ages into account).

Yep - I completely agree - which is why all my other posts on the thread have been about getting the DH to do his fair share Wink

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 19/11/2022 09:16

Your kids might like living rurally now, but a lot of children hate it as they get older. I've taught in schools like the one I imagine your eldest goes to, and the older they get the more difficult it is- a lot get scooters at 16 to have some freedom, but that can be really dangerous on country roads even if they drive sensibly.

Does your eldest's school have a sixth form? If not, would he have to travel even further for sixth form? And if he wanted to do something that wasn't A-levels, would he have any options?

I totally get him not wanting to leave his school, and moving somewhere totally new would be difficult BUT in Y7 at this stage friendships are not fixed and he would easily make new friends. Your younger child would adapt.

If rural living is all they've known, then the idea of moving to a town will feel strange/scary- but they might actually really like it when they get there, and it's very likely your eldest would enjoy the freedom of e.g. being able to walk to see friends etc.

Passanotherjaffacake · 19/11/2022 09:15

Hmm, I think I would look at moving OP. If not for this job then for a location that works a bit better. I think a lot of PPs are pointing out the wisdom of having older children who can access stuff for themselves.

I both moved around alot as a kid (5 schools I think so not as bad as some kids have it) and ended up being rural for school years 8-13. Both were awful. We had a bus stop and a train station in our tiny village which was really lucky but the services were twice a day and it took 2 hours on the bus and an hour on the train to get to my friends. They never wanted to visit me and my df refused to be a taxi.

I remember lots of evenings and weekends with just my db kicking around and being a bit bored whilst my friends met up in town.

but I think as you are considering just the one move it’s not the same as moving regularly. I always found it fine making friends, just harder to keep them as kids don’t tend to keep in touch long term if they are out of area.

Summerfun54321 · 19/11/2022 09:14

Why not trying working away from home for a while? Loads of men do it and don’t bat an eyelid. Work away a few nights, work remotely the rest.