Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you how you manage childcare costs?

127 replies

Lalalalawhitenoise · 18/11/2022 21:30

Specifically with 2 nursery aged kids and both parents working.

my eldest has 30 free hrs but with the wrap around care and then the out of term costs, it is eye wateringly expensive, roughly £2k per month full time. I earn just shy of 40k and take home shy of £2300 per month and with the rises in everything (we’re expecting £500+ extra on our mortgage if things stay as is, mortgage is up end of next year). I’m freaking out. No childminders in the area with spaces either and this is one of the cheaper nurseries

OP posts:
Lalalalawhitenoise · 19/11/2022 09:36

Phineyj · 19/11/2022 08:19

I think @NorthernDuckling's advice is good.

Totally different situation but I'm stuck in the EHCP (SEN support) system with our one DC (would have liked more but IVF cost us thousands) and I am fully planning to take the local authority to tribunal to get what we're legally entitled to. Sometimes you have to - politely and persistently - force the issue. It won't make you popular, but hey ho.

I think that your salaries are on the low side for financial services. We are on similar in education. You might do better with the more ambitious of you really going for it and the other doing 3 days - that should bring one of you back into basic rate.

You need a massive spreadsheet!

im not being defensive but they definitely aren’t on the lower side for working in finance, it’s just like any other industry, we’ve climbed from entry level to middle management which is where we sit now, and no real chance to move or get a promotion (maybe a marginal pay increase ) because they’re new jobs.
hubs is applying for new roles but it’s a bit of an ‘if’ due to experience at this stage tbh. We’re early 30s

OP posts:
Teacoaster · 19/11/2022 09:02

My little one went into nursery at 11 months old, 3 days a week (£700 a month approximately). I was a full time student studying for my undergrad. I used my student maintenance loan to pay for the nursery fees. I wasn't entitled to the childcare grant as my partner earned more than £18,000 a year.

During my last year of uni, I increased his nursery days to 4 and continued to pay for this using my maintenance loan.

My son is three now. He goes to nursery 4 full days a week, and 1 day with granny. I work 30 hours a week and 2/3 of my salary goes on his nursery fees (approx £700 a month which includes the tax free childcare scheme help otherwise it would be £900). In January I'll receive the 30 free hours, spread over the year which brings it down to about £400ish a month with the free hours and childcare grant.

I don't want any more kids and honestly, I'm really looking forward to when they start school so there's only wrap around fees to pay. No idea how anyone affords more than 1 child on less than £50,000 a year (total household income). Tell me your secrets.

cptartapp · 19/11/2022 08:44

SmallestInTheClass · 18/11/2022 21:42

I accepted I was pretty much working for nothing but saw it as an investment in my future working life. I wanted to work at least part time for my wellbeing not just for money. I was also getting decent pension contributions from my employer.

This.
Worked for nothing for nearly three years. But it preserved my mental health and power balance in our relationship and my pension now looks great.
Twenty years on, never a single regret.

Zanatdy · 19/11/2022 08:38

I wouldn’t quit your job for the sake of a few years, career progression, lack of pension etc etc. especially for unmarried women

Rosti1981 · 19/11/2022 08:38

Meltingsocks · 19/11/2022 08:34

DO NOT DO THIS.

You're protecting your future earning potential, pension and financial independence

Agree as well. Unless one of you can career break and go back without penalty (some industries better for this than others). But definitely not giving up entirely!

Rosti1981 · 19/11/2022 08:37

I don't have any advice as my kids are now school age (and there wasn't a fully blown CoL crisis when mine were in nursery) but wanted to offer sympathy as it's really difficult.
It does get better at school age and breakfast club/ASC/wraparound is a fraction of the eye watering costs of early years.

Write a budget, cut what and where you can including being savvy about annual renewals/food shopping/meal planning (obviously all that stuff also takes time so spend some time together working it through), accept that it is short term rubbish but longer term (from sept 2024?) things will start to improve. Don't give up work!

Meltingsocks · 19/11/2022 08:34

FamKeNekson · 18/11/2022 21:35

Give up work for a bit? Career break? Ask family or friends to help or work opposite to your other half I.e one works nights and the other days?

DO NOT DO THIS.

You're protecting your future earning potential, pension and financial independence

KarokeandGin · 19/11/2022 08:25

I was going to suggest sending your oldest to a nursery school but I see you are already doing that. Once your eldest is in school no you don’t pay for lunchtime cover just any breakfast/after school club. Breakfast club is often much cheaper than after school but you can use the tax free childcare against these costs still.

in terms of what we do we are just riding it out until all are in school. I just got a new job with payrise which will obviously help, I see you just got a new job but maybe your husband could start looking too?

good luck OP, it’s a tough slog but you will get there

underneaththeash · 19/11/2022 08:22

NorthernDuckling · 19/11/2022 07:46

OP have you tried appealing the rejected flexible working requests? I’m not a HR expert but run a business and had a few over the years, according to our HR advisors it has to be accepted unless it can be rejected for one of the 7 statutory reasons.
A few won’t work for your employer like work can’t be reorganised between staff and they can’t recruit to cover hours. So they’d have to be relying on one of the others.
How we have done it in our business is said we have concerns about X reason but will allow a trial period and assess it in 3 months. Can you suggest a trial period to show their concerns won’t be affected, which reason did they give? Can you show it isn’t a valid reason? You could suggest working for 1 hour on your day off during a nap time to check message if it is about affecting quality and performance. You would only need to do it for 24 months and then revert back to 5 days after that. You need to make it as difficult as possible for your employer to reject the flexible working request. This is the link to gov website on statutory reasons for rejection and how to appeal www.gov.uk/flexible-working/after-the-application

I was going to suggest this too - they need to have good reasons for it.

Phineyj · 19/11/2022 08:19

I think @NorthernDuckling's advice is good.

Totally different situation but I'm stuck in the EHCP (SEN support) system with our one DC (would have liked more but IVF cost us thousands) and I am fully planning to take the local authority to tribunal to get what we're legally entitled to. Sometimes you have to - politely and persistently - force the issue. It won't make you popular, but hey ho.

I think that your salaries are on the low side for financial services. We are on similar in education. You might do better with the more ambitious of you really going for it and the other doing 3 days - that should bring one of you back into basic rate.

You need a massive spreadsheet!

girlmom21 · 19/11/2022 08:12

Are you using tax free childcare? It makes a huge difference.

Speak to the nursery about how they work the 30 free hours.

We get 3 'free' days a week in term time so pay £5 for meals on those days and then full price for the other two days.

We worked out how much we'd need to cover the school holidays so pay the same amount into tax free childcare every month so the extra to cover holidays builds up on there and we don't need to worry about it being extra expensive some months

PlantDoctor · 19/11/2022 08:02

I am self employed and work from home (always have), so I work either early on the morning or in the evenings. It means I have little free time and it cuts into time with DH. DD now goes to nursery 3 days a week, but it was a real slog when she only did mornings.

I appreciate that doesn't fit your situation, just answering the question of how we manage.

Starseeking · 19/11/2022 08:00

When I had 2 DC in nursery, and was still with my EXDP, our annual nursery bill was £30k. We earned a combined gross salary of about £180k, however the monthly cost of nursery was still double our mortgage.

If you and your DH have been in your current jobs for a while, is there any chance of promotion, or getting a new higher paid job outside your company?

Tohaveandtohold · 19/11/2022 07:57

It’s too late now but there’s almost 6 years age gap between my 2 children for this same reason and we were lucky there was no twins. I think If you look at it this way, it’s only till September and one will be in school and you only need to pay for wrap around care which is cheaper and only one in nursery so it’s short term loss.
I wouldn’t give up work but both of you can ask your employer again for the flexible work request. If only one of you gets accepted and you need nursery 4 days a week, the saving on one day will make a difference as well.

hoowhoo · 19/11/2022 07:50

You or DH will have to get a better paid job between now and mortgage renewal to cover the cost. Easier said than done but I don't see how less hours is viable - you need to the opposite and get paid more for your time

NorthernDuckling · 19/11/2022 07:46

OP have you tried appealing the rejected flexible working requests? I’m not a HR expert but run a business and had a few over the years, according to our HR advisors it has to be accepted unless it can be rejected for one of the 7 statutory reasons.
A few won’t work for your employer like work can’t be reorganised between staff and they can’t recruit to cover hours. So they’d have to be relying on one of the others.
How we have done it in our business is said we have concerns about X reason but will allow a trial period and assess it in 3 months. Can you suggest a trial period to show their concerns won’t be affected, which reason did they give? Can you show it isn’t a valid reason? You could suggest working for 1 hour on your day off during a nap time to check message if it is about affecting quality and performance. You would only need to do it for 24 months and then revert back to 5 days after that. You need to make it as difficult as possible for your employer to reject the flexible working request. This is the link to gov website on statutory reasons for rejection and how to appeal www.gov.uk/flexible-working/after-the-application

Metabigot · 19/11/2022 07:13

Husband gave up his career, basically

He's massively struggled to get back into anything like the type of work he was doing so we've lost 10 years of prime career age earning potential.

He's retraining now but will start at the bottom again if he can even get a job. So no childcare costs but massively missed out on income for 10 years if you call that a cost.

lucywho123 · 19/11/2022 06:28

Yea sorry OP I’m in the ‘I can only afford one because of this reason’ camp

We struggle paying even for one lot of childcare fees. We’re lucky that childminder is pretty flexible and therefore only does 3.5 days which we work around us wfh or finishing early on Fridays (I have one day off to balance also)

Lalalalawhitenoise · 19/11/2022 05:13

AloysiusBear · 19/11/2022 00:52

Dh and I also work in finance and we've been building in a return to long term interest rate norms for a while now!

Yeah there will for sure be a new normal interest rate wise but I’m not sure it’s 6-7% on mortgages was my point, it’s pretty unlikely we’ll see the 0.85-1/2% deals around again for a good long while imo

OP posts:
AloysiusBear · 19/11/2022 00:54

After 08 crash and massive recession which we are looking to replicate boe brought the br down, right down in a year, to get the economy going after a recession they will lower the br to get people spending again

It's not really the same against a backdrop of massive inflation, weak pound etc

Cheap money long term has had many negative effects.

AloysiusBear · 19/11/2022 00:52

Dh and I also work in finance and we've been building in a return to long term interest rate norms for a while now!

Lalalalawhitenoise · 19/11/2022 00:28

Ugzbugz · 19/11/2022 00:10

Depends on your husbands income?

50k

OP posts:
Lalalalawhitenoise · 19/11/2022 00:28

AloysiusBear · 19/11/2022 00:09

Op please don't budget on the premise that mortgage rates will reduce any time soon. The last decade has been a blip of unprecedented low rates. Its widely expected this is not a short term rise, its a resumption of normal rates so likely to stay at at least 5 or 6% for the foreseeable. If that won't be affordable you may need to plan to downsize etc.

I work in finance, the base rate within banking was never expected to get above 4 in our own internal forecasts with an understanding that it would be temporary.

nationwide was one of the first to hike them up to 6% but now as dropped them to under 5% on fixed rates.

we’ll have to play it by ear of course to see how stable things are over the next year and see how the mpc move re the BR; if it’s static but rates don’t reduce a tracker might be the best short term fix for us. After 08 crash and massive recession which we are looking to replicate boe brought the br down, right down in a year, to get the economy going after a recession they will lower the br to get people spending again

OP posts:
Ugzbugz · 19/11/2022 00:10

Depends on your husbands income?

AloysiusBear · 19/11/2022 00:09

Op please don't budget on the premise that mortgage rates will reduce any time soon. The last decade has been a blip of unprecedented low rates. Its widely expected this is not a short term rise, its a resumption of normal rates so likely to stay at at least 5 or 6% for the foreseeable. If that won't be affordable you may need to plan to downsize etc.