Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For those that comfort eat or managed to stop?

63 replies

ImHavingACrisis · 18/11/2022 20:55

I’ve had to name change because this is so embarrassing. I’m also posting here for traffic sorry.

I have two kids under the age of 2 and I’m unbelievably overweight. I’ve stepped on the scales to see I’m now 20 stone 4 pounds and I wear a size 18/20. The thing is, I’m aware of my weight. I started going to the gym three weeks ago and do a mixture of weight training and HIIT. I go three times a week and I’m as consistent as possible.

Here’s the issue. I just don’t know how to stop eating. I have a really unhealthy relationship with food and I comfort eat nearly every day. My youngest has a genetic disorder and was in NICU for 6 weeks. I can’t even tell you the amount of calories I assumed within that time. Since then I’ve been adjusting to having two kids especially one who has complex needs and has physio. I was recently diagnosed with PND and have been put on antidepressants to help with my anxiety.

I’m talking a lot but basically I need help! How, how, how do I stop eating junk food. Stressful/happy things will always occur in life so I really need a different way to deal with things. I don’t smoke, don’t drink and I don’t take drugs so food has always been my go too. Can someone please help? Does anyone have a motivational story on how they stopped eating such unhealthy food or any tips that I can use? I really need to work on my health because this can’t continue.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Salome61 · 20/11/2022 20:19

I've been overweight all my life and also comfort eat because of childhood trauma, but always managed to stay around 10/11 stone-ish. I love chocolate, cakes, sweets, biscuits - and don't have a 'stop' button. I can eat a whole packet of biscuits with ease.

Unfortunately I've got to the age when it's life threatening, I'm 65 and have just been diagnosed with 'high cholesterol' which has scared me into action. I'm being retested in three months.

The doctor recommended the Mediterranean diet. I do feel quite full after the meals, but it is a lot of cooking. I have removed all temptation, I gave my stash away to my neighbour.

Try and find an eating plan you and your family might enjoy and can stick to.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 20/11/2022 19:32

You need to figure out the reason behind why, I would urge you to seek cognitive behavioural therapy. Best of luck!

Whatsleftnow · 20/11/2022 19:13

I cut out chocolate, first by only eating small amounts of expensive chocolate and luxuriating in it, and then cutting out everything but 70% dark.

When the cravings subsided I moved onto processed sugars - just the obvious things, and I put all the fresh fruit and veg at eye level in my fridge (keep the condiments in the drawers instead) so that every time I opened the fridge there were healthy items.

Once you get sugar down, your palate starts to shift and you get drawn towards other food. Try and treat food as a lovely, luxury experience rather than focusing on deprivation. I think that’s so important as will power can only take you so far.

Twizbe · 20/11/2022 19:04

Noom. Alongside any other therapy and gym you do.

The course will help you unpack the food element and give ways to manage the emotional eating.

Crackof · 20/11/2022 19:00

I've been a 24. I'm a 16 now.

Crackof · 20/11/2022 18:59

I used to binge eat because the feeling of hunger caused so much shame and grief for me that I could never bear to even begin to feel a tummy rumble.
I knew why .... I knew that it was because my mother used to starve me when I was small because she thought I was fat. I remember hunger at bedtime and the feeling of being unloved. That there was something wrong with me and I was being punished.
She told school I wasn't allowed a pudding, so everyone at my table had pudding and I had a satsuma. This was primary school so I was 6? 7?
I've seen photos btw and I wasn't fat. I was well covered and not unusual really. At my home we didn't do much and I never got much chance to use my energy up, though I had a lot.
But knowing the story didn't help me. I think I got kind of attached to it. I used it not to change rather than to change, you know? Poor me.
Well I've had lots of therapy, and it's true that "Shame dies when stories are told in safe spaces", and therapy really helped. I lost weight, put some back on, lost more, put some on, but getting better over time.
What really helped recently for me was doing shamanic journeys with shamen like Cissi Williams, Sandra Ingerman and Christa McKinnon.
I did one journey where I met an animal helper who told me that I was using my stomach as a heart. She said my heart wasn't a child's heart anymore, that my woman's heart was strong, and I could use my stomach as a stomach and my heart as a heart.
I came out of that journey weeping. And smiling. I don't binge eat now. I've lost 50 pounds. I'm chunky I guess still, but I look good. I'm happy and strong.

ImHavingACrisis · 20/11/2022 18:26

Thank you everyone🥰 You’ve all been so helpful

OP posts:
Ellie1015 · 19/11/2022 22:30

Small steps that help me are

Drink plenty of water
Get 12000 steps (walk witha podcast is really enjoyable)
Fruit tea instead of regular (don't need a biscuit with fruit tea)
Bath or paint nails in the evening as can't snack while doing that.

LazJaz · 19/11/2022 22:16

Therapy, mindfulness, meditation, mindful eating
i struggle with this too but these methods rather than a strict diet or “just not buying it” work better for me. I binge eat to turn off the feelings in my body and make life bare-able - but actually it massively compounds the issues I’m facing.

Practice self compassion. Tune into the body, learn what it really really needs. Might sound a little nuts but look at Aryuvedic food systems, and try to eat only until satiety rather than “full”. Don’t have the view that you can never have XYZ again in your life, but when you do have XYZ see it as an indulgence. Really take your time over it, focus on it, savour it. Stop when sated with that thing.

OP, your situation sounds like it’s really tough. I don’t think binge eating is a sign of weakness. You have used it to keep you strong, now you are asking for help. This is brave, and shows resilience. It may not be a straightforward journey - give yourself grace.

good luck on your journey!

ShellsOnTheBeach · 19/11/2022 22:05

I can identify with what @SisterAgatha said. In my case, the reward is the feeling of empowerment that comes with lifting weights. I started working out with dumbbells 2 years ago, and it has been life-changing, both in terms of being motivational and changing my physique. I now have muscles instead of bingo wings, I have a strong core and I can do push-ups, and my body is lean and strong. No way am I going to mess this up by eating cr@p food! And whole, unadulterated, healthy food actually tastes way nicer once you get away from all the addictive sugar, salt and fat.

SisterAgatha · 19/11/2022 21:53

i managed to stop.

I started telling myself the REAL treat would be not to have the cake/biscuit/whole loaf of bread etc. The reward is AFTER. And it’s a feeling of accomplishment. I’ll do something else nice for me non food related like paint my nails. Go out for a walk. Distract myself by jumping DH. Anything that gets me away from the food when the urge is there. And then that turning the reward round to it being that I DIDNT eat it. That worked for me.

ImHavingACrisis · 19/11/2022 19:52

Whoops name change fail!😂🤦‍♀️

OP posts:
ForgetBarbie · 19/11/2022 19:23

Thank you SO much for the additional comments! I’ll be sitting down and really analysing every comment to look at the suggestions. I’ll be watching all the videos suggested and give all the books a read. I agree that I do have an eating disorder and that’s what needs to be addressed. Appreciate all the helpful comments xx

Justalittlebitfurther · 19/11/2022 19:00

Exclusion wont work it will likely make it worse. Look at intuitive eating and therapy. I’m not slimmer but I have a much healthier relationship with food and I don’t restrict any food groups. I did Michael Moseley and slimming world and the rest but ultimately you probably have an eating disorder that you need support with and no ‘diet’ is going to fix that. If you loose weight without dealing with the cause you will put it back on and gain more - believe me I’ve been there! PM if you want 😊

Sausagenbacon · 19/11/2022 18:45

I agree with whoever said upthread to totally exclude sugar and processed food.

MontyK · 19/11/2022 17:17

I've also been a comfort eater for a long time, unlike you I also used alcohol as a crutch. I've tried and failed a few times to change my ways.

However, I am currently on week 6 of cutting out booze and junk food. I've only had a couple of slip ups so far.

Honestly the only thing that has really worked for me is sheer willpower and there's no denying that is very difficult, especially if you have a 'fuck it' type attitude like I do!

Other things that work for me, just not having the food/drink in the house in the first place. Have your husband say no if you ask him to go to the shops. Weight watchers do some really nice brownie slices so you can still have a treat.

Merryoldgoat · 19/11/2022 17:08

And counting calories isn’t the long term answer. You can lose weight without counting calories; concentrating more on the type of food you eat will pay dividends. I can guarantee I probably eat way more calories currently that any diet would suggest and consistently lose weight.

The desire to comfort eat is still there but being pretty much always full helps me control.

For example I had mackerel and eggs for breakfast today and I haven’t felt hungry since so the cue that would normally send me to the chocolate hasn’t kicked in.

Merryoldgoat · 19/11/2022 17:00

I’m very fat and it’s taking a long time to make changes.

The only thing dietwise that works for me is keto with no processed foods because it stops my cravings so I can make better decisions in the moment.

Exercise is great but will not do much for weight loss in reality.

Ive lost about 18lb since August and I’m 2 stone down from this time last year.

When you weigh a lot (I weigh more than you) it’s a long journey with ups and downs and focusing on long term changes and shrugging off the blips is what helps me.

Generally speaking cutting processed food as a first step will pay dividends as you’ll feel better and more satiated and not being hungry all the time helps.

Also, with keto I don’t have to count anything so don’t get obsessed.

itsallmuch2much · 19/11/2022 16:53

I just want to echo what pps said. It's not needing a diet or to work out it's needing to stop overeating. Comfort eating is a symptom of a mental health issues or trauma that you are suppressing or trying to control or self harm with food.
Once your mental health is better and any trauma is dealt with the weight should melt off because your appetite will self regulate.
Get the Christopher Fairburn book, not a cookery or diet book. It's not a diet issue, it's a mental health issue.

Bogablob92 · 19/11/2022 16:45

No grand plans, just one day or even one hour at a time. The whole of the future ever can seem too big and overwhelming, but put your phone timer on for an hour or two as a small goal ie. don’t pick at things for that length of time. With time, good habits will replace bad ones, but you need to be kind to yourself and take baby steps. Someone who has not suffered the sort of problems you (and lots of other people) are suffering, might think this is silly but it does work. Small, achievable goals can do wonders. Good luck!

ShellsOnTheBeach · 19/11/2022 16:38

Look what just popped into my YouTube suggestions box - scary...:

Idbemonica1 · 19/11/2022 16:13

I listened to a podcast recently where Richard Osman spoke about issues with over/comfort eating, the most useful thing that i took away was this - we all have that voice in our heads telling us we deserve a treat etc. Sometimes listen to your other voice. Every little helps and the more i do it the less out of control i feel

OatFox · 19/11/2022 15:57

Obviously my post doesn't address the underlying cause of the emotional eating but it does help when you're filling up on lower calorie foods while you begin to address them. They still count as a binge but you don't feel like you're back at step one, so to speak.

In these instances, it really is about reprogramming your brain so you need to gaslight yourself a bit to success.

OatFox · 19/11/2022 15:55

The trick is to not stop eating but to replace what you are eating with better foods that have less calories and more nutrition.

Love crisps? Sugar snap peas are great. Love something sweet or salty? Popcorn is great. Need sweet and savoury? Try apple slices with peanut or almond butter. Biscuits? Dark chocolate covered mini rice cakes.

If you're like me and love chocolate, those 200 calorie or below slimming chocolate bars work wonders. They're large and dense enough to be considered a treat without all the calories. I have some by Exante I swear by and they're massive and dense but you can get cheaper ones in B&M etc.

Runworkeatsleeprepeat · 19/11/2022 15:41

Google The Weight Loss Academy and Anna Wallace the creator of that academy . It is brilliant and really reset my relationship with food. I still have the urge to comfort eat but also have the skills to stop myself now. It's not really a diet plan, there are meal plans but it's more around nutrition and support
There is a really supportive Facebook group that goes alongside with it. Like her Facebook page or look for her in Instagram as she'll probably do a new reset group in January. Usually for around £20 it's so good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread