Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think my child is called a boy because of her race

588 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/11/2022 17:23

This may be petty to a few but this is really starting to get to me. I have mixed race daughters- and a mixed race niece- all of them have continually been mistaken for boys in their early years. It’s got to me more today as a woman approached me in a playgroup and apologised for calling my two year old a boy and said it was down to her clothes- light blue jeans and a cardigan with birds on it.
I don’t put her in dresses daily because we’re often in a park or soft play, but joggers and a T-shirt with a bunny or bird on it is pretty standard. I also see plenty of girls in leggings and jeans etc.

I’m now starting to think it’s unconscious racism- and it’s predominantly down to hair.
White/ Asian girls hair grows downwards. Black girls I know of have twists and plaits that are deemed “girly” hairstyles.

My daughters hair is in an Afro- it’s combed and oiled daily and well cared for but I don’t routinely plait it because it won’t hold.
My niece was always called a boy, and when her hair was corn rowed was called a boy.
Apparently if you don’t subscribe to the Caucasian aesthetic that makes you masculine.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Redkettle · 19/11/2022 07:45

I remember being 10 at a fireworks night and some woman said to her child, let the little boy through lol. Also got confused when I was 15 for a teacher . I'd cut my own hair . Both times short styles. It's all in the hair I reckon. My friendbhas a little boy with long hair gets called she all the time

Squirrelsnut · 19/11/2022 07:39

I teach a white child of 10 with long blonde hair worn in a ponytail with an undercut. He's a boy and wears the 'trouser uniform' but is constantly assumed to be a girl, even with his boyish features.
It's hair length and style more than anything.

Lndnmummy · 19/11/2022 07:36

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 19/11/2022 03:57

Just to be clear. By racial bias do you suspect they are doing it to be unkind because of your child's race? Or do you think it is more like a bias of ignorance. Such as they don't understand black beauty and femininity vs black masculinity? Or perhaps a mix of the two?

Also not to dismiss your concerns in any way but if it is merely a factor of ignorance I'm not sure it does much good to focus on it. But if it's because they are being lowkey racist I suppose I could understand you might want to steer clear of that person.

Just to be clear. You'd want to steer clear of the person that was 'unconsciously' racist too.

This thread is really tiring and a perfect example of why it is so damn hard to advocate for your children when people denying them their experiences.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 07:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 19/11/2022 07:32

Agree with PP that most children look pretty androgynous when they are young. My DD was constantly mistaken for a boy when she was young because I didn't dress her in pink.

Sleeptightnightlight · 19/11/2022 07:28

My UK experience is that people go entirely by hair length.

So my daughter who's hair didn't grow for ages was always called a boy even in 'girly' clothes, and my now long haired son is called a girl even head to toe in black/blue with dinosaurs.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 19/11/2022 07:23

My dds hair is lovely and straight and blonde.. she is never mistaken for a boy, but how is that anyone's fault?? Short hair will always be mistaken for a boy.. if it bothers her, put a bow in it You have very concisely proved my
point so I thank you.

OP posts:
rosyroses · 19/11/2022 07:21

My DD was often mistaken for a boy when her hair was short even wearing feminine clothes.
My DS is often mistaken for a girl as his hair is long even if wearing a jumper with trucks on it!
I think it's really hard to tell at that age what sex they are. In the park I usually say it's not your turn let that child go first as I don't want to make a mistake

ohlookout · 19/11/2022 07:18

Yes you are being unreasonable.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 07:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 07:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BEAM123 · 19/11/2022 07:08

I honestly think it's more about hair....as you say, your daughter has an afro and other black girls have braids...which in the same way as a ponytail or bunches on a white toddler, look like a girls hairstyle.
Up to 10 years old I was mistaken for a boy because my mother made me keep my hair short, and I wore jeans.
My grandson had beautiful ringlets and lived in a place where boys hair isn't cut until they are 3....if it's in their eyes it's clipped back or tied up....over there nobody made a girl /boy assumption as they were used to that, but when he visited the UK if he had a clip in his hair people would say 'what a beautiful girl, look at her ringlets'.

I don't want to minimise your concerns about racism, but I really do think it's more about gender assumptions based on indicators on clothing and hair. We don't have much neutral gender language in English, so people have to refer to a he, her or they, and make their best guess based on clothes and hair accessories to try not to offend the parent, as toddlers look basically genderless. If your daughter had a clip in her afro, people would identify her as being a girl.

Lurknessmomstar · 19/11/2022 07:06

Mumtobabyhavoc · 19/11/2022 06:19

Yes, I agree. However, I think when you are a person of colour and a white person comments on gender, hair etc it can be a bit murky due to the history of race relations. I don't disagree with you, I'm just offering a view to ponder. Parity has yet to be achieved. Also interesting is the number of posts describing white, blonde, blue-eyed children having had similar situations to OP. I am suggesting the difference is that there is no perceived sub-text that the child is needing to conform in any way, or is "lesser than, which is not always the case with people of colour.
I would invite those more informed and eloquent to elaborate - I'm not expert and I'm trying to tread carefully and sensitively. The white stereotype of beauty is constantly reinforced and, whether consciously intended or not, serves to oppress those who don't meet that standard. I think that is the flip side that gets ignored snd discounted.
I'm struggling here with sleep deprivation, so excuse my clumsy and wordy reply...

No I completely understand your point of view, though I do think that in those instances as well that there are subtexts that the child is not conforming to the persons view of how a child of a certain gender to look like, which might not necessarily have to do with race. In my experience, my son with his ‘vertical’ Afro was still mistaken to be a girl. OP genuinely feels that her experience has to do with racism so have to respect that as well though, even though I don’t strongly agree.

Lurknessmomstar · 19/11/2022 06:56

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:26

@phishy tbh blue eyes and blonde hair are pretty spectacular looking, especially in girls. Always makes them look like little models.

Um, no. Do ‘pretty spectacular looking’ little models all have blue eyes and blonde hair. Nope. Silly statement

Tandora · 19/11/2022 06:52

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:26

@phishy tbh blue eyes and blonde hair are pretty spectacular looking, especially in girls. Always makes them look like little models.

🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think you’ve just perfectly demonstrated OPs point about racial bias and beauty standards.
👏🏻

nightbulb · 19/11/2022 06:51

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I’ve RTFT and the reason I’ve said YABU is because there’s nothing to suggest that it is racIST for people to mistake their gender because of their hair.

Just that one of the reasons that one of the reasons their m/f characteristics are less immediately identifiable is possibly racIAL.

As people have said, anyone with hair that doesn’t conform to gendered norms is at risk of being mistaken for the wrong sex, the experience is not unique to people with afro hair. So YABU, unless you can actually articulate why it is racist.

Lurknessmomstar · 19/11/2022 06:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Mumtobabyhavoc · 19/11/2022 06:19

Lurknessmomstar · 18/11/2022 23:21

I don’t think these type of scenarios can strongly be classified as racist, it’s something that happens to babies and children of all races

Yes, I agree. However, I think when you are a person of colour and a white person comments on gender, hair etc it can be a bit murky due to the history of race relations. I don't disagree with you, I'm just offering a view to ponder. Parity has yet to be achieved. Also interesting is the number of posts describing white, blonde, blue-eyed children having had similar situations to OP. I am suggesting the difference is that there is no perceived sub-text that the child is needing to conform in any way, or is "lesser than, which is not always the case with people of colour.
I would invite those more informed and eloquent to elaborate - I'm not expert and I'm trying to tread carefully and sensitively. The white stereotype of beauty is constantly reinforced and, whether consciously intended or not, serves to oppress those who don't meet that standard. I think that is the flip side that gets ignored snd discounted.
I'm struggling here with sleep deprivation, so excuse my clumsy and wordy reply...

Josette77 · 19/11/2022 06:17

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:26

@phishy tbh blue eyes and blonde hair are pretty spectacular looking, especially in girls. Always makes them look like little models.

No it really doesn't. You seem quite proud of your dd's hair and eye colour, but being blond and blue eyed doesn't make anyone automatically look like a model. It's no more spectacular than other combos.

lucywho123 · 19/11/2022 06:06

My DD. 19 months. Blonde, brown eyes, wears pink a lot. ‘Oh hes gorgeous ’ at least twice in the last month. She doesn’t have a lot of hair so I can only assume it’s that? I think she has a girlie face but I do dress her casually so who knows. I voted YABU as I just don’t think ppl care enough to properly look before making comments

Smallonesaremorejuicy · 19/11/2022 06:01

custardbear · 19/11/2022 04:37

My blue eyed blonde hair DD was constantly called a boy, even when wearing pink tops and jeans because her hair wouldn't grow much as a toddler, I don't think she had a hair cut at all til she was 4 or 5.
I think it's more about shorter hair and androgynous faces. It's probably more unconscious sexism/stereotyping.
I saw an interesting programme a few years ago about how our brains function to recognise people, apparently if you put someone e into a country with people of different races (the example was a European going into Japan or china from memory), it would take years for our adult brains to learn the mapping of face constructions and the other attributes of recognition of people to be as good at facial recognition of the new race of that country compared to their homeland. I don't personally see this as racism, it's more about brain mapping and function

Her eye colour doesn’t matter a jot in reference to if she is female or male .

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:37

@Accoucheuse07 well it's obviously in a style looks masculine..? My dds hair is long and blonde and feminine.. but saying that is not racist..

Accoucheuse07 · 19/11/2022 05:32

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:23

If your daughters hair makes her look like a boy... how is that anybody else's fault?? Sorry but I have long straight hair, should I be offended that it doesnt make me look manly?? My dds hair is lovely and straight and blonde.. she is never mistaken for a boy, but how is that anyone's fault?? Short hair will always be mistaken for a boy.. if it bothers her, put a bow in it.

She doesn’t have short hair- It is a type of hair- and the OP is pointing out that many people seem to perceive her hair as boyish.
She is a girl with natural hair (not short) who is often mistaken for a boy.

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:26

@phishy tbh blue eyes and blonde hair are pretty spectacular looking, especially in girls. Always makes them look like little models.

Sliversprings · 19/11/2022 05:23

If your daughters hair makes her look like a boy... how is that anybody else's fault?? Sorry but I have long straight hair, should I be offended that it doesnt make me look manly?? My dds hair is lovely and straight and blonde.. she is never mistaken for a boy, but how is that anyone's fault?? Short hair will always be mistaken for a boy.. if it bothers her, put a bow in it.