Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think my child is called a boy because of her race

588 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/11/2022 17:23

This may be petty to a few but this is really starting to get to me. I have mixed race daughters- and a mixed race niece- all of them have continually been mistaken for boys in their early years. It’s got to me more today as a woman approached me in a playgroup and apologised for calling my two year old a boy and said it was down to her clothes- light blue jeans and a cardigan with birds on it.
I don’t put her in dresses daily because we’re often in a park or soft play, but joggers and a T-shirt with a bunny or bird on it is pretty standard. I also see plenty of girls in leggings and jeans etc.

I’m now starting to think it’s unconscious racism- and it’s predominantly down to hair.
White/ Asian girls hair grows downwards. Black girls I know of have twists and plaits that are deemed “girly” hairstyles.

My daughters hair is in an Afro- it’s combed and oiled daily and well cared for but I don’t routinely plait it because it won’t hold.
My niece was always called a boy, and when her hair was corn rowed was called a boy.
Apparently if you don’t subscribe to the Caucasian aesthetic that makes you masculine.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Thisbastardcomputer · 19/11/2022 09:08

You can find racism in everything, if that's what you're looking for.

nightbulb · 19/11/2022 09:07

if we have this fixed idea that beauty and femininity is long and blonde - and having read this thread I don’t see how anyone can dispute this - then that’s a problem for black girls, isn’t it?

And it’s also a problem for anyone who isn’t long and blonde… including but not limited to Asian girls (both south and East Asian), Hispanic, any Caucasian who isn’t blonde and doesn’t have long hair, and many others.

I don’t see how the same problem is bigger for one group of people than another. You can claim white privelege and unconscious racism all you like but it doesn’t make it true.

Moonmelodies · 19/11/2022 09:06

Maybe their ideas of angels are based on visions? That would be awkward.

Rosieisposy · 19/11/2022 09:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You’ve read the thread but hey, fingers over eyes, not happening here is it?

Oh YOU said that, YOU must be racist. I’m not. I’m definitely not. It’s here and it’s in front of me but I don’t see it so I can’t be racist. You do, so you are.

That doesn’t work as an argument, @MuraRocker .

Its here. Pretending you can’t see it really doesn’t make you gloriously liberal.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 19/11/2022 09:03

And again, I'm sure there may be some racial factor to later angel imagery, but I imagine those evolutionary and social factors that predate mass racial mixing probably factor more in pre enlightenment imagery.

Those are the images people are imagining when they say 'angelic curls', pre Raphaelite etc.

Now when I was at school, the blonde girls were cast as fairies/angels in one school play and the two black girls as trolls. That actually was racism, because the casting teacher made the active choice to assert blonde=angels black=evil.

Thankfully, that has largely disappeared and in recent years have noticed 'angel' casting has largely been done on practical reasons like preference, lines given etc. The angels are a mix now. Hurrah.

But that doesn't mean you can easily erase people's archetypal ideas of angels which are built on thousands of years of images and text. These things take time to change, as they took time to evolve.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 09:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 09:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Rosieisposy · 19/11/2022 08:56

Is it getting upset, or is it noticing?

I see what the OP is driving at and other posters have, as others have said, reinforced this with their trills that it’s soooo silly and their angelic blonde boy was always mistaken for a girl.

I mean - if we have this fixed idea that beauty and femininity is long and blonde - and having read this thread I don’t see how anyone can dispute this - then that’s a problem for black girls, isn’t it?

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 19/11/2022 08:51

Again, whilst racism could be at the bottom of older (7 plus) misgendering, studies have shown that people are less accurate in differentiation outside of their own race, so you'd expect them to get it wrong more. Not racism, it's just evolution is slow and people generally only regularly saw people of similar origins around them till very recently.

And you are discounting the white people who said they were misgendered right up to their teens.

Fact is puberty is the force that removes all doubt. Not hair length, bows or colours. This is just something modern humans have added in because gender stereotypes are given breathing space and importance.

Which is interesting, because even in more supposedly sexist times boys and girls were both dressed in dresses and had long hair(see Tudor portraiture)

I believe this was because Tudor children were basically seen as lavae until they reached a certain age. Once that age was reached(no doubt when they'd more likely cleared infant mortality) did they start with the gender stereotyping.

Stereotyping starts from birth these days and you only have to look around at teens of today that it does massive harm to a significant amount of children. It limits the skills they gain, dents their self.esteem and even confuses them about their actual biology.

Which is why people should quit getting upset about people misgendering children who are largely too similar looking to make hard and fast rules.

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 08:43

As the mother of blonde(ish) white boys, one of whom still gets mistaken for a girl at nearly 12 because of his ringlets halfway down his back, I came on to say I've read through your posts OP and you - and other posters you've responded to or highlighted - have really opened my eyes.

I started reading thinking you must be wrong, largely because of my aforementioned experience (or so I thought), but I now think you're absolutely right about that pretty much unconscious association of Caucasian hair (in particular blonde) that grows downwards with being 'pretty' or feminine.

It was the poster referring to her son's 'angelic blonde' locks who unintentionally drove it home the most.

I guess it's such an embedded cultural racism that it's hard (and painful) for people to look into themselves deeply enough to acknowledge it. But FWIW you've made this middle-aged white woman think about her own privilege and prejudices.

Lndnmummy · 19/11/2022 08:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Says a white mother of white kids 🙄

BaileySharp · 19/11/2022 08:41

I got a strangers kid wrong around age 3 - he was a boy with long blonde hair! They don't really look very obviously male or female that young so it's all clues based on clothes and hair usually. I don't think it's racism just difficult!

starfishmummy · 19/11/2022 08:41

I'm Caucasian and had short hair when I was a young kid. I was always being called a boy if I was in trousers or shorts.

Jewel1968 · 19/11/2022 08:37

Dunno. My mixed race dd with natural hair was also mistaken for a boy wearing school uniform with a skirt. I had never considered the racial angle before. I had assumed some people were just a bit shit at identifying sex. DD has a very feminine face. DS was mistaken for a girl before because I thought his afro was big. Upset both of them a bit. Now they are older it never happens.

nightbulb · 19/11/2022 08:37

Plenty of parents on here have said that their child’s hair simply didn’t grow at all at that age (my DD was the same). It’s not like all Caucasian children have a choice either.

I dressed my DD in such a way that it was easy to see she was a girl (but not pink and frilly) because I didn’t like people mistaking her. That’s a solution that everyone can adopt, but no one should have to, regardless of colour.

00100001 · 19/11/2022 08:37

My 2yo niece is often called a bit/him, even once when she was dressed in a pink dress.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 08:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

nightbulb · 19/11/2022 08:36

@Lndnmummy

Why is it worse for a black or mixed race girl to be mistaken for a boy because of their hair (or for a boy to be mistaken for a girl), than it is for a Caucasian child?

liveforsummer · 19/11/2022 08:36

There are so many examples of white privilege but I honestly don't think this is one of them. Afro hair remains short for a long time therefore toddlers often mistaken for boys. Very fine hair on white children also remains short for a long time and these dc are also often mistaken for boys if not wearing very obviously gendered clothing (and sometimes even if they are)

cansu · 19/11/2022 08:34

Many people get the sex wrong when looking at babies and toddlers. It just isn't always obvious. I think to call it racism is ridiculous. How do we know if a child is male or female? Given that body shape is the same in children and facial features are similar, we use clues such as hair style and clothing. I am not sure how else anyone would guess?

HappyKoala56 · 19/11/2022 08:34

My Caucasian niece even while wearing hot pink was mistaken for a boy. I think all babies and toddlers if in neutral clothes can easily be mistaken for the opposite sex. I think here is not a case of racism but casual sexism, ie girls wearing jeans and joggers.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 19/11/2022 08:33

But the broadbrush rule people go by is short hair = boy.
So if hair appears short it is read as short even if it is long.
Again, when my white curly haired son has a trim it looks shorter, but wet it will be shoulder length. Dry it is read as boy because boys hair is assumed to be short.
When his hair is allowed to grow it appears longer eg: girly. That's when he is more often misgendered.
Although as we dress him in all colours all the time he is regularly misgendered because we don't colour code him. It is just that when his hair is long people feel more confident they've got it right and hedge 'girl'. There's often a little snooty comment about long hair on boys after, so it's definitely a factor.

But again, the only reason you should care is if you think that a)someone has deliberately identified correctly then gone for the opposite or b) you believe in misogyny rules about girls being a certain way and boys being another.

BeautifulDragon · 19/11/2022 08:32

The point clearly isn't being explained very well then is it. Always happy to learn.

More likely that people read the word 'race' and quickly respond to prove the person wrong, without taking any time to consider their point.

FWIW I'm mixed raced, with black children and haven't personally experienced what the OP has, but I still took a moment to consider what the OP was trying to explain.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 08:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 08:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread