Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think my child is called a boy because of her race

588 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/11/2022 17:23

This may be petty to a few but this is really starting to get to me. I have mixed race daughters- and a mixed race niece- all of them have continually been mistaken for boys in their early years. It’s got to me more today as a woman approached me in a playgroup and apologised for calling my two year old a boy and said it was down to her clothes- light blue jeans and a cardigan with birds on it.
I don’t put her in dresses daily because we’re often in a park or soft play, but joggers and a T-shirt with a bunny or bird on it is pretty standard. I also see plenty of girls in leggings and jeans etc.

I’m now starting to think it’s unconscious racism- and it’s predominantly down to hair.
White/ Asian girls hair grows downwards. Black girls I know of have twists and plaits that are deemed “girly” hairstyles.

My daughters hair is in an Afro- it’s combed and oiled daily and well cared for but I don’t routinely plait it because it won’t hold.
My niece was always called a boy, and when her hair was corn rowed was called a boy.
Apparently if you don’t subscribe to the Caucasian aesthetic that makes you masculine.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Lndnmummy · 19/11/2022 10:39

Comedycook · 19/11/2022 10:38

I remember one evening hanging my dcs clothes on the washing line outside...I could smell weed coming from one of my neighbours gardens...white, middle class people. We do not smoke weed or even cigarettes. I absolutely lost my shit....had to bring my washing indoors. Because if my dc go outside our house with the smell of weed on their clothes, what will happen? What will people think? Because there's one rule for middle class white people and another for black/mixed race kids. It's like stop and search...black kid is stopped and maybe a tiny amount of weed found... everyone exclaims that stop and search is working! ..why don't the police hang round expensive bars and stop and search the posho rupert types who spend their weekend shoving coke up their noses?!

I could have written that post. People have NO idea.❤️

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 19/11/2022 10:38

But again, you can't just make a sweeping statement of racism without looking at the facts.

Blonde boy bully:
What was the falling out about?
Was it investigated?
Was physical violence involved? Both sides? One side?
Were there any witnesses?
Was it part of an ongoing bullying issue or a one off?

And yes,.of course racism could absolutely be at the bottom of it. But not always. Again that broadstroke brush is unhelpful when applied without looking at the actual situation.

And the blonde girl picking on the other children, did she just pick on black children or did she pick on brunette white children as well?

Was it blonde privilege or white privilege?
Were there other factors?
Pushy or scary parent?
Sneaky child able to go under the radar without getting caught?
Friendship group and bullying issues to 'cover' behaviour?
Inadequate teacher?
Prejudice teacher?

It's not as simple as blonde girls get special treatment. My school bully was blonde and got away with it. It was not because she was blonde she wasn't tackled it was because she came from a violent gypsy family. The deputy head basically told me they were scared to tackle it.

It doesn't mean I assume all blondes are cunts or getaway with things because.of.their hair colour.

Comedycook · 19/11/2022 10:38

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 10:25

@Comedycook sadly that doesn't surprise me, given the adultification of black children that leads to teenage girls being brutally strip-searched at school. It's far more important than what society thinks pretty looks like.

I remember one evening hanging my dcs clothes on the washing line outside...I could smell weed coming from one of my neighbours gardens...white, middle class people. We do not smoke weed or even cigarettes. I absolutely lost my shit....had to bring my washing indoors. Because if my dc go outside our house with the smell of weed on their clothes, what will happen? What will people think? Because there's one rule for middle class white people and another for black/mixed race kids. It's like stop and search...black kid is stopped and maybe a tiny amount of weed found... everyone exclaims that stop and search is working! ..why don't the police hang round expensive bars and stop and search the posho rupert types who spend their weekend shoving coke up their noses?!

Comedycook · 19/11/2022 10:29

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 10:25

@Comedycook sadly that doesn't surprise me, given the adultification of black children that leads to teenage girls being brutally strip-searched at school. It's far more important than what society thinks pretty looks like.

Yes exactly!

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 10:25

@Comedycook sadly that doesn't surprise me, given the adultification of black children that leads to teenage girls being brutally strip-searched at school. It's far more important than what society thinks pretty looks like.

Comedycook · 19/11/2022 10:18

Oh and I remember the "angelic" looking blonde girl in my dds class...she was a nasty little bully but of course, this was never picked up on or tackled.

Realowlette · 19/11/2022 10:18

My blond little girl was always mistaken for a boy. I preferred blue comfy clothing to dresses and she had a weird comb over for ages! It didn't bother me when people referred to her as 'lithe boy' and I rarely corrected them if they were strangers.

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 10:17

@Rosieisposy is saying exactly what I want to, but far more eloquently.

This thread has made me think about my own prejudices and those of the society I am a product and part of Confused

Comedycook · 19/11/2022 10:13

No one is personally attacking anyone for their use of the word angel in relation to blonde children...but we are discussing the reasons why, in our society, blonde hair is linked to being angelic. Lets then look at the results of that. I remember my mixed race ds at primary school having a fallout with a blonde, blue eyed boy. Guess whose side the teacher was on? The imagery and stereotypes are so pervasive.

bananabug · 19/11/2022 10:09

My daughter with blonde hair was often mistaken for a boy as a toddler even when wearing pink flowery clothes! It's to do with hair length I think.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 10:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Comedycook · 19/11/2022 10:06

Bestcatmum · 19/11/2022 09:49

I cant believe how many people desperate to show off their right on credentials are slagging me off for my perfectly I innocent comments about my sons blond curly hair and angelic facebeing mistaken for a girl. I bet none of you have even set foot outside this country.
I am from mixed race family, my two sisters are mixed race and we were brought up in a tropical country surrounded by my step fathers family. We all got on just fine.
Here on mumsnet I am some kind of nazi. Get a life. Do a bit of travelling.

What a bizarre post. What's travelling got to do with it?! 🤔

Lndnmummy · 19/11/2022 10:04

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 09:38

Actually @Lndnmummy and @OnlyFoolsnMothers have helped me understand how it is different @nightbulb

❤️

WrongWayApricot · 19/11/2022 10:02

Pretty sure angels are supposed to have wheels and be on fire. Hopefully nobody's human child is literally angelic looking.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 19/11/2022 09:59

I mean, ultimately we recognise beauty similar to our own more readily. Partly evolutionary and partly because we are more likely to be able to emulate it.

Japan and Korea have the beauty standard of straight black glossy hair and beautiful natural glowing skin. Are the Japanese racist for preferring this over curly red hair?

Korean beauty skin standards have been exported to the UK and US. Ten step beauty regimes are big business throughout the world. Some women with good skin and able to emulate it, regardless of race and hence it has travelled far. Further than the smooth hair which is out of some people's reach, partly due to race and genetics.

But blemishes remain a problem for those with very pale skin, hence the minimal make up Korean healthy skin look will never catch on everywhere and things like heavy foundation and fake tan prevail in women who can't attain the same look.

This isn't racism, it's just recognising your limitations and what works best for you.

Rosieisposy · 19/11/2022 09:57

I don’t think travelling is what’s needed.

Angelic is a common adjective used when describing someone with blonde hair, so it is interesting considering why that is (while darker people often get ‘exotic.’)

Jewel1968 · 19/11/2022 09:55

@Bestcatmum don't travel much because of global warming but also fear of flying. Sad I know but there it is ...

I said before my mixed race DS with big afro was mistaken for a girl. But also my mixed race DD with smaller afro was mistaken for a boy. But only when they were young. Not mistaken now and they still have lovely afro although I wish my ds would look after his better - a subject for a different thread maybe.

chipshopElvis · 19/11/2022 09:55

I dont know. But I avoided dressing my daughter in pink and she was often mistaken for a boy. She is very pale (white) and her hair is ginger but was very slow to grow. I always thought it was a combination of short hair and non pink clothes, mostly trousers.

Bestcatmum · 19/11/2022 09:49

I cant believe how many people desperate to show off their right on credentials are slagging me off for my perfectly I innocent comments about my sons blond curly hair and angelic facebeing mistaken for a girl. I bet none of you have even set foot outside this country.
I am from mixed race family, my two sisters are mixed race and we were brought up in a tropical country surrounded by my step fathers family. We all got on just fine.
Here on mumsnet I am some kind of nazi. Get a life. Do a bit of travelling.

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 09:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

hopsalong · 19/11/2022 09:39

It might have something to do with unconscious racism, absolutely, but I think it's hard to be sure.

Both of my DSs had a period of (more mousy brown than golden, still) curls and before that a bald period. They wore the same neutral clothes. But DS1 was repeatedly taken for a girl while DS2 never was. As they've grown older I think it's to do with facial features. Only 5 and 7 now, but DS1 has regular but small facial features and a tiny nose. (Undoubtedly to change into a massive familial nose at puberty.) DS2 has a heavy brow and deepset eyes, and a squarer overall face. His face is recognisably a boy face. But I think a lot of children have essentially androgynous faces until puberty hits, and those children are (depending on hair and clothes) always somewhat liable to being misidentified.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 19/11/2022 09:39

Rosieisposy · 19/11/2022 09:19

I know Disney are more diverse now @TenPointsFromHufflepuff but I don’t think anyone can deny that what, seventy years of Snow White, Cinderella, Aurora and the like influenced little girls’ ideas of beauty.

Most under tens aren’t familiar with Greek and Roman gods (unless it’s MN.) They know who Elsa is, though.

A lot to dissect here.

Fact is little girls like to see themselves in characters. Elsa I imagine is popular with little blonde girls, just as belle is popular with little brunette girls and Ariel little red heads.

Now there may be something in how much Elsa and Ana were pushed as a separate line to Disney princesses and the motives behind that. Officially Disney say it's because Elsa is a queen and her colours were too similar to Cinderella to be included in the line up. That that film in particular was very popular is obviously a factor. But we'd have to know why it's popular to rule in or out racism.

So

Elsa was designed to look stereotypically white Nordic. Is this because steadfastness to the fairytales roots (like we see in Moana)?

Is it subsequently more.popular in countries where Elsa and Ana are more representing of the average girl.

Are characters like Moana more popular in countries where she is more representing of the general population?

It's a bit tangled, because yes western beauty standards do tend to prevail, but you would have to figure out who is pushing them. Because Disney do produce diverse heroines now. But is it active racism that makes one character more popular than another, or does it simply come down to 'yay this princess looks most like me'.

The other problem will be some Disney's are better than others. Elsa is basically a superhero. It's why she's more popular than Cinderella or snow white because they are largely passive in their own stories. To truly dissect it Disney would need to release identical stories with multi racial characters and then look at popularity amongst fans who do not resemble the heroines.

Anecdotally in my day jasmine was the beauty standard for Disney. Now there have been articles stating her features were westernised by Disney. That is more evidence of unconscious bias than someone misgendering toddlers imo. But again, where was the drive to westernise her coming from?

MuraRocker · 19/11/2022 09:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sleepthief · 19/11/2022 09:38

Actually @Lndnmummy and @OnlyFoolsnMothers have helped me understand how it is different @nightbulb

Cinnamonclove · 19/11/2022 09:37

I think it might be hair length (down the back) that's associated with girls rather than necessarily the colour of the hair? At least my DS, with long dark wavy hair, was often mistaken for a girl, even when dressed in typical boy style clothes. Older people made the mistake more often, I think because they were more likely to expect boys to have short, cropped hair.