Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask MIL & FIL to stop co-sleeping with DD

167 replies

CanStopWillStop · 18/11/2022 14:34

My 1-year-old DD very occasionally stays at my MIL when we have a special evening event. When she first started a few months ago, I was explicit about her bedtime routine, including putting her in the travel cot to sleep, as I am quite paranoid about suffocation/SIDs. I could tell MIL wanted her in the bed with them but she said she'd put DD in her cot because that's how she sleeps at my mothers and our house.

I dropped her yesterday and she mentioned the last time DD slept over she was struggling to go back to sleep so MIL put DD in between her and her partner.
Obviously this is an adult bed with pillows, duvet etc. DD never sleeps in our bed, and even when she wakes up, she goes back down in her own bed.

I appreciate she is doing us a favour, so I didn't say anything at the time, but it's really bothering me, and I can't put my finger on why. I have a weird feeling that she didn't even attempt to put her back in the cot tbh. AIBU to ask her to stop doing it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thedogsmum · 05/04/2023 20:01

I think you need to tell her that you're not happy with co-sleeping rather than never ask her to have your daughter overnight. You didn't say anything when she told you, so you do need to discuss it with her.

Personally I don't think it's a problem, but up to you how you want your child to sleep.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 08/01/2023 01:52

You don't ask MIL, you tell her-and never leave your child with them again.

Gingernan · 08/01/2023 00:32

I'm sensing a lot of hostility to grandparents trying to do their best! My children almost never stayed with their grandparents,it would have been nice if they had been able to. I don't think sleeping with them would have been an option,though that would have been fine, if they were careful, but they were a bit strict and I was tolerant of their different ways.
Please realise often they are doing you a favour, may be getting on a bit,don't sleep well or have some health issues, if what they can't provide isn't up to your standards, get a young babysitter.

Gingernan · 08/01/2023 00:06

I've shared a bed with the grandchildren at their house,my house and on holidays, I suppose from the age of 2,with full approval ( pretty much at the suggestion) of their parents. Usually when there was a shortage of beds! Nothing weird about it, though I never get a wink of sleep. It definitely wouldn't happen if my partner was staying over,that wouldn't be appropriate and situation just wouldn't arise.

Rosie22xx · 04/01/2023 18:03

No one else should be co sleeping with your baby other than you or your partner. That isn't their child to do that with. If they cannot take simple instruction to look after baby and respect the parents wishes, I wouldn't be trusting them with my child if they're unable to do it properly. It's a safety concern for sure.

AutumnVibes · 04/01/2023 07:21

There is no doubt that an unrelated adult man should not be sleeping in the same bed as your child against your wishes and without full transparency.

OrlaCarmichael · 03/01/2023 19:46

Same here but hard to explain why.

I slept in the same room as my DGM whenever we slept at hers as a family. She gave the big bed to my parents and she and I slept in single beds in another room.

Waking up in early and climbing in with her to read whatever latest book she’d bought for us to read together is such a fond childhood memory.

Like many PPs I don’t have an issue with co sleeping. We did it with ours, it wasn’t a decision as such, started due to DC1 - the only way we’d have all slept, but I did see many benefits.

The issue for me, as others, is the secretiveness and the DGM’s partner in the bed.

Redebs · 03/01/2023 17:57

caramac04 · 18/11/2022 14:54

I genuinely don’t think it’s appropriate for gp’s to co sleep with baby dgc. I can’t even explain why, it just gives me the ick. I have occasionally shared a bed with a dgc when they were at least three years old and at the dgc’s request and parents approval. My dh wasn’t in the bed though so plenty of room.
I just have visions of them being hot and sweaty and feeling claustrophobic plus being breathed over. Ok I think I might be projecting how I would feel sandwiched in between two giants.
Ultimately you have made a logical and reasonable decision about how and where your dc sleeps and that should be respected.

Me too. I would be ok with just a grandmother, but not two adults

HuggsBosom · 03/01/2023 16:23

Changechangychange · 03/01/2023 16:16

Poor baby. One of the parents was also far above the car drinking limit, which may have made them less alert.

Changechangychange · 03/01/2023 16:16

metro.co.uk/2021/05/27/baby-died-sleeping-between-parents-who-woke-up-to-find-him-blue-14655412/amp/

Overlaying death in a 13 month old

Changechangychange · 03/01/2023 16:07

Badgirlriri · 18/11/2022 17:42

Is there even a risk of SIDS at this age when the child is able to roll by themselves?

There is a risk of overlaying, yes. Until the child is big enough to shove a grandparent off them independently.

Clairedelaplume · 03/01/2023 16:04

HuggsBosom · 03/01/2023 14:40

Of course she can ask MIL not to co-sleep with dd.

What do you mean she can’t have it both ways? That OP has to allow MIL to do whatever she wants?

Maybe it was convoluted reasoning but my point is that it's unreasonable to expect the GPs to stay up all night trying to settle the 1yo and therefore the 1yo is probably too young to be sent away for sleepovers.

OooScotland · 03/01/2023 15:44

Co sleeping with MIL and her partner is an absolute no-no. I’d be livid. If you ask her to stop she’ll just ignore you and carry on., because She Knows Best.

The only solution here is to stop the overnight visits at MIL’s house until dd is much, much older. If I were you it would be never again.

At a year old if its only for the odd evening event I think a babysitter with references would be the best option.

HuggsBosom · 03/01/2023 14:40

Clairedelaplume · 03/01/2023 14:38

I think YABU in that you can't have it both ways.

I do expect my M and MIL to respect our parenting principles but I wouldn't expect them to deal with my child overnight until (s)he was old/settled enough not to give my folks a sleepless night.

Also, incidentally, SIDs is massively reduced from 1yo.

That said, I don't co-sleep and I wouldn't want anyone else to co-sleep with my very young child, so I wouldn't be sending them for sleepovers aged 1.

Of course she can ask MIL not to co-sleep with dd.

What do you mean she can’t have it both ways? That OP has to allow MIL to do whatever she wants?

Clairedelaplume · 03/01/2023 14:38

I think YABU in that you can't have it both ways.

I do expect my M and MIL to respect our parenting principles but I wouldn't expect them to deal with my child overnight until (s)he was old/settled enough not to give my folks a sleepless night.

Also, incidentally, SIDs is massively reduced from 1yo.

That said, I don't co-sleep and I wouldn't want anyone else to co-sleep with my very young child, so I wouldn't be sending them for sleepovers aged 1.

ginexplorer · 20/11/2022 21:54

@Neanov so I don’t think you read it understood my post. I made a substantial allowance for any potential for a exceptional circumstances - I’m not going to list them all out- this is why I said it’s about a relationship of trust with the MIL

We also don’t know all of the facts and my point is that people are leaping to conclusions in the absence of these. We don’t actually know the request was ‘ignored’ perhaps it just couldn’t be complied with because the GC didn’t stop crying. We don’t know whether MIL just put the child in her bed out of desperation to help the GC feel secure and provide comfort- we don’t know how long they were crying for. Perhaps the default when she didn’t know what else to do so she did what most Europeans would do which is to comfort the child in her bed. That doesn’t make her incompetent or evil.It’s just her instincts. Hence why I said to sit down with MIL and understand. It’s alarming how mothers can put their trust in someone to look after their child for the night but not empower that person to make the right decision at the time for them when needed.

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 20/11/2022 21:27

The issue is them not listening. I spent most of my childhood between both sets of grandparents and always got into their bed if I couldn't sleep or an early morning cup of tea. I loved it. But I was older than that. Co sleeping isn't the issue. Its the not doing as asked as it ruins bed time at home at that age! But if she's not settling then maybe leave the sleepovers until she's a bit older?

1HappyTraveller · 20/11/2022 20:59

I’d be furious. That’s so dangerous!
If it were my DD I’d be having strong words with my MIL and possibly not having my DD stay there until she was older.

Your child, your rules.
I really don’t understand how people fail to grasp this very. simple. concept.

Neanov · 20/11/2022 20:26

amyds2104 · 20/11/2022 09:11

What I was basically trying to say is if that is how OP is feeling those thoughts and feelings are valid. However if she is uncomfortable because it’s her mother in law and not her mother then that’s unreasonable.

Its not unreasonable. MIL is not really OP family as such, it's by marriage unlike OPS actually mother if OP got divorced OP likely won't see her MIL but she will see her own mother.

You can't compare your MIL to your actually mother. I know some may be really close but this is not a given. I would not of been leaving my baby overnight at 1 years old with my MIL in the first place. However my own mother had DS overnight at around 3 months because she's my mother.

Plumnora · 20/11/2022 20:10

ginexplorer · 20/11/2022 12:41

@OleLadiesDrawers and @amyds2104 thank goodness for some common sense.
For others saying ‘no overnight or it’s dangerous’ without any other understanding of this situation…
It really IS sad that there is an automatic assumption that a one year old is at risk of having a sleepover at Grandparents. I mean consider .. didn’t they successfully bring YOU or your partner up without sexually abusing, suffocating or generally screwing you up? Appreciate of course they may have made mistakes, ( heavens above parents make mistakes!) but unless you have some clear evidence or suspicions for those types of statements I think adding to the already self confessed paranoia of the OP is not helpful.

OP - how exactly have you ended up feeling this way ? Apart from of course from reading posts from other highly paranoid new parents? I mean you mention paranoid about SIDS? Where did this come from exactly ? What triggered it?

That’s going to impact alot of how you see this situation potentially and it’s good you recognise it. I know I was terrified bringing my fragile premature baby home from SCBU as I couldn’t transition so fast from highly medicalised care one minute to suddenly no monitoring. I needed some knowledge and logic and funnily enough my very experienced Mum of 3 kids to actually show me that he was just a baby after all.

So I know it’s normal at times to feel this mum anxiety even if you don’t have a prem baby ( I know you have a healthy 1 year old) But it’s a good thing to explore it to see if it’s really based on fact. What you really need here is to develop a relationship of trust with your MIL. It doesn’t sound like you have that right now and what’s just happened has shaken that even more right?

Give her a chance to explain her rationale. Then tell her why your approach works for your baby. If she is kind and willing to work with you on it then great. If she is horrible dismissive and scathing then of course just tell her it’s better to wait until your child is a bit older and consistently sleeps through the night. Please do try to maintain a good relationship- in the end the children will decide for themselves anyway how close they are to Grandparents. They are very good judges of character! But give them the chance to do that.

The OP hasn’t said whether the MIL’s partner is her husband’s father or not. Not all grandparents are blessed with the wisdom of experience. I refer here to my own, Autistic mother, who my children (and I!) love dearly but who doesn’t always deal with situations appropriately and who I spent comforting and reassuring for most of my own childhood because she simply couldn’t cope with life very well.
The issue here is that that OP made a specific request which was seemingly ignored. And this isn’t her own mother. Of course there’s going to be some doubt.

HikingforScenery · 20/11/2022 17:30

pocketvenuss · 20/11/2022 17:21

There are things one certainly can insist on. Smacking/no smacking, vegetarian/meat or other food decisions, respecting (not believing necessarily but respecting) religious beliefs and co sleeping. If grandparents believe they can do what they want in these areas then they don't get to spend time with gc

As @alexdgr8 said, it’s up to OP to stop her child sleeping over.

HikingforScenery · 20/11/2022 17:29

Your MIL has made it clear that they don’t want the inconvenience of having to get up to resettle a 1 year old, who doesn’t sleep through. It’s up to you to stop sending your DD over there, if you feel so strongly about it.

Zanatdy · 20/11/2022 17:24

At 1 i wouldn’t be overly worried but I’d ask them to follow safe sleeping guidance for beds (I co-slept for years when mine were babies, grown up now). Least then she knows the rules, but ask her not to of course

pocketvenuss · 20/11/2022 17:21

alexdgr8 · 18/11/2022 14:53

you can't have it both ways.
presumably she provides free childcare.
she will do it her way.
she has brought up children and sees no harm in it.
you disagree.
so don't send the child there.
it is unrealistic to expect MIL to comply in this situation.
just make other arrangements.

There are things one certainly can insist on. Smacking/no smacking, vegetarian/meat or other food decisions, respecting (not believing necessarily but respecting) religious beliefs and co sleeping. If grandparents believe they can do what they want in these areas then they don't get to spend time with gc

ginexplorer · 20/11/2022 12:41

@OleLadiesDrawers and @amyds2104 thank goodness for some common sense.
For others saying ‘no overnight or it’s dangerous’ without any other understanding of this situation…
It really IS sad that there is an automatic assumption that a one year old is at risk of having a sleepover at Grandparents. I mean consider .. didn’t they successfully bring YOU or your partner up without sexually abusing, suffocating or generally screwing you up? Appreciate of course they may have made mistakes, ( heavens above parents make mistakes!) but unless you have some clear evidence or suspicions for those types of statements I think adding to the already self confessed paranoia of the OP is not helpful.

OP - how exactly have you ended up feeling this way ? Apart from of course from reading posts from other highly paranoid new parents? I mean you mention paranoid about SIDS? Where did this come from exactly ? What triggered it?

That’s going to impact alot of how you see this situation potentially and it’s good you recognise it. I know I was terrified bringing my fragile premature baby home from SCBU as I couldn’t transition so fast from highly medicalised care one minute to suddenly no monitoring. I needed some knowledge and logic and funnily enough my very experienced Mum of 3 kids to actually show me that he was just a baby after all.

So I know it’s normal at times to feel this mum anxiety even if you don’t have a prem baby ( I know you have a healthy 1 year old) But it’s a good thing to explore it to see if it’s really based on fact. What you really need here is to develop a relationship of trust with your MIL. It doesn’t sound like you have that right now and what’s just happened has shaken that even more right?

Give her a chance to explain her rationale. Then tell her why your approach works for your baby. If she is kind and willing to work with you on it then great. If she is horrible dismissive and scathing then of course just tell her it’s better to wait until your child is a bit older and consistently sleeps through the night. Please do try to maintain a good relationship- in the end the children will decide for themselves anyway how close they are to Grandparents. They are very good judges of character! But give them the chance to do that.