Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's going on with nations MH? *[Content warning: concerns suicide]

142 replies

Nuggetss · 18/11/2022 13:44

Another one of my friends when I was at school ended their lives yesterday. This is the third person in 2 years we are in our late 20s. AIBU to think the government need to invest more money in MH. 3 people with their whole lives ahead of them gone. It's very sad one leaving behind DC . Is suicide becoming more common after COVID ? I'm absolutely devastated.

OP posts:
carefulcalculator · 18/11/2022 20:59

Uncontrolled illegal immigration and the government is doing nothing to stop it. Bloody obessession with immigration is partly what is destroying the UK, we are short of workers, it's fucking our economy. Government failures to provide ordinary services being blamed on immigration. Sick of reading the same bollocks.

SirMingeALot · 18/11/2022 20:54

There was always liable to be a mental health drag once restrictions died down. The government deliberately pursued a policy of trying to increase people's fears, and this had an awful effect. No consideration at all for those with existing issues like health anxiety and OCD.

Zanatdy · 18/11/2022 20:49

I think it’s probably a combination of effects of lockdown (and just because restrictions have ended as someone said doesn’t mean people aren’t still feeling the long term effects of the isolation / worry), plus cost of living. Really sorry about your friends, there really isn’t enough money invested in MH in the U.K.

Namechangesoicanpostthis · 18/11/2022 20:47

Q2C4 · 18/11/2022 20:04

What I genuinely don't understand is that my Grandmother's generation lived through a war, as did the generation before that. Children were either evacuated to live with strangers or stayed behind to face the Blitz. My Grandmother had an evening volunteer role putting small bombs that landed on the roof into buckets of sand. Time it wrong & you'd at best get your hand blown off. Someone up thread mentioned The Somme. There are countless other war examples.

Why is anxiety such a problem now, when it seemingly wasn't when things were much worse?

There completely different situations. While the wars were undoubtedly horrific they also brought a sense of purpose and unity. Many young men were only too eager sign up and participate in what they believed would be a big adventure.

After the wars there was huge amounts of rebuilding to do again giving purpose.

My grandfather, for example, left school at 14, joined the war effort at 18, survived and secured a job as a mechanic on his return, this job allowed him to purchase a 4 bed detached home off the bat where he raised his family and progress through the company to a management position, which gave him a great pension when he retired at 60.

My father left school at 16, walked into an apprenticeship with British Gas and stayed their for his entire career, again progressing through the ranks.

His job allowed him to buy a starter home, upgrade to a family home when I came along, and again to a larger family home when my siblings came along. It also allowed him to support my mum through university, take us on holidays, and gave him good pension when he retired at 63.

I left school at 18 initially took a trade but retrained as there wasn't room for progression and now have a degree and a masters. I was only able to buy my starter home in my 30s, can't afford to upgrade from here, can't afford to reduce income to have kids, can't afford to support my partner to retrain from a job they hate and is slowly grinding them to dust, and despite progressing through the ranks a bit now I'm no better off than I was 10 years ago. Oh and have a shitty pension that means I'll probably have to work till I die.

As others have said its the relentless bleakness that crushes us and there is no light at the end of the tunnel, things are only going to get worse.

I have tried to end my life before and I'm only still here because someone spotted what I was doing by chance and alerted the police. I flick between just accepting the drudgery of life and thinking about flinging myself off a bridge to get it over with pretty frequently and if I slip into another proper depression again I don't think I'll survive it quite honestly.

SirMingeALot · 18/11/2022 20:47

EightChalk · 18/11/2022 19:46

I think in terms of Covid, it's a bit limiting just to look at it as "you had to spend some time locked down watching DVDs, and now it's over." The restrictions showed how quickly our normal way of life can be totally disrupted, and we all saw previously unthinkable things like people dying alone in care homes without being allowed visitors, grandparents having to stand in the garden to see their grandchildren through windows in winter, and so on. That's disconcerting on a deep level. The way that most people seemed to retreat into their little family bubbles and pull up the drawbridge then showed that in a lot of places, we don't have a community backup we can rely on if we were to need support; the culture in the UK seems to be by and large "look after me and mine", and that was both brought into sharp relief and probably also intensified by Covid.

Aside from that, the continuing financial impact of Covid/Brexit/the war in Ukraine means that other things we previously counted on as part of the fabric of our usual day-to-day lives, like local businesses, cafes, pubs, etc., are on precarious footing or already gone, and that's depressing to see day after day. Even if someone's not personally struggling, we all know that life is getting very hard for a lot of people, many of whom were already struggling and vulnerable and had just taken a kicking from Covid - it would take a hard heart not to be affected by that. So I don't think we should limit the impact of Covid on the nation's mental health by just looking at it in terms of numbers of deaths/cases. It did a lot of damage that we didn't have time to recover from before the war in Ukraine and the effects of Brexit started to bite.

This is a good description.

BooksAreSaferThanPeople · 18/11/2022 20:46

Q2C4 · 18/11/2022 20:04

What I genuinely don't understand is that my Grandmother's generation lived through a war, as did the generation before that. Children were either evacuated to live with strangers or stayed behind to face the Blitz. My Grandmother had an evening volunteer role putting small bombs that landed on the roof into buckets of sand. Time it wrong & you'd at best get your hand blown off. Someone up thread mentioned The Somme. There are countless other war examples.

Why is anxiety such a problem now, when it seemingly wasn't when things were much worse?

Anxiety and other mental disorders were a massive problem during and after the War. They just weren't discussed because it "wasn't the done thing"

This article is quite an interesting read:

www.theguardian.com/society/2020/dec/27/what-mental-health-impact-of-second-world-war-tells-us-about-post-covid-life?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

"In Hull, where a team of psychiatrists and psychologists studied why the populations panicked after heavy raiding, researchers found case studies that showed “people developed serious psychosomatic conditions, including involuntary soiling and wetting, persistent crying, uncontrollable shaking, headaches and chronic dizziness,” wrote Overy. “The government papered over the evidence of the physical and psychological effects of being bombed and focused instead on the stories of British resolve.”"

"“There were very few focused interventions for people who were suffering from really quite severe post-traumatic illnesses,” he said. “And it led to the idea that the British people actually managed the war without traumatic illness, that somehow we coped. And most people did, but that ignores the probably 10-15% of the population who were really quite unwell.”"

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 20:32

waitbutwhy.com/2013/09/why-generation-y-yuppies-are-unhappy.html

This is several years old but it’s a good read and explains very clearly why people are unhappy nowadays.

Secretusername3 · 18/11/2022 20:30

I’m really sorry about your friend. It must be devastating.

However there isn’t, as far as I know, an increase in suicide since the pandemic.

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 20:30

It's hard to be optimistic about the future of the UK now
Uncontrolled illegal immigration and the government is doing nothing to stop it. NHS is collapsing so it’s a struggle to get treatment and NHS dentistry is non-existent. House prices are unaffordable. People can’t afford to heat their homes. Public services like libraries are vastly reduced and slowly disappearing, and there’s no prospect of any future money to revitalise them. The threat of nuclear war, possibly WW3. And on top of that we’re being told that we’re heading towards a climate crisis, and as individuals there’s nothing we can do to avert it - even as a country we can’t make much impact on a global scale. I’m not optimistic about our future at all.

Also don’t forget that 20-40 something people have life goals that were formed in totally different economic circumstances. The things we planned to do simply aren’t possible now. It’s hugely depressing when your life can’t meet your expectations.

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/11/2022 20:27

Paracetamol · 18/11/2022 18:35

MH issues should by no means be taboo. However, I think the more 'open' we've become about MH has encouraged people to dwell on their issues and exist in echo chambers online which only exacerbates their MH issues. I personally know several people who fit this description

I agree actually. There’s a balance and I think we’ve now tipped into talking too much about MH and medical conditions. To the point where people with perfectly normal negative emotions are pathologising them and diagnosing themselves.

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/11/2022 20:17

I’m sorry 💐

Bad MH now seems to be so common I’m not sure if we can realistically fix it in terms of enough counsellors, enough support workers, enough inpatient units etc. Dishing out pills is a
cheaper and faster option.

I honestly blame social media, a lack of fresh air and the endless 24/7 bad news coverage for a lot of MH issues. I have (diagnosed, almost lifelong) OCD and depression, and I feel noticeably more stable when I get plenty of fresh air, exercise and stay away from doom scrolling/news or dr Google. I also have health anxiety about my DD and find the endless ‘raising awareness’ health campaigns to be a double edged sword.

But, what can we do? Social media is going nowhere, the news just gets shitter. I really think there will be a ‘movement’ (kind of Amish - like) in rebellion against all this at some point, that just reverts back to a simpler way of life.

Cornelious · 18/11/2022 20:17

@Q2C4
Like I wrote up thread. There was a sense of community. People were in it together. Now it's everyone out for themselves. Also things could only get better (as a nation) so there was hope.

shreddies · 18/11/2022 20:11

Q2C4 · 18/11/2022 20:04

What I genuinely don't understand is that my Grandmother's generation lived through a war, as did the generation before that. Children were either evacuated to live with strangers or stayed behind to face the Blitz. My Grandmother had an evening volunteer role putting small bombs that landed on the roof into buckets of sand. Time it wrong & you'd at best get your hand blown off. Someone up thread mentioned The Somme. There are countless other war examples.

Why is anxiety such a problem now, when it seemingly wasn't when things were much worse?

Certainly after WW2 there would have been a sense that things would get better, and they did, with the creation of the NHS etc.

It's hard to be optimistic about the future of the UK now

GoldenCupidon · 18/11/2022 20:10

How do we know it wasn't a problem during the war (or during any wars)? We see people fleeing war now utterly traumatised, I doubt we all think the people of Ukraine will be bouncing back and forgetting all about it even if the war ends - why would people in the past be unruffled by it?

Many people of my parents' generation grew up with parents who were obviously emotionally damaged by their wartime experiences.

I think it's in everyone's interests to tell their grandchildren that it was all dancing and heroism, and try their best to forget all about it. Honestly, the ability to forget horrible things is a huge blessing but many people cannot.

Covid taught us that relationships, institutions and principles we all assumed would last forever could be torn away in weeks. Women gave birth alone. People living alone went months without having a face to face conversation with someone they knew. I know several single people who didn't have a hug for more than a year. Weddings and birthdays and all parties were cancelled - these are the fun things that people both old and young look forward to when life is hard. We didn't know who would live and who would die, especially at the start. We didn't know how long it would all go on.

Q2C4 · 18/11/2022 20:04

What I genuinely don't understand is that my Grandmother's generation lived through a war, as did the generation before that. Children were either evacuated to live with strangers or stayed behind to face the Blitz. My Grandmother had an evening volunteer role putting small bombs that landed on the roof into buckets of sand. Time it wrong & you'd at best get your hand blown off. Someone up thread mentioned The Somme. There are countless other war examples.

Why is anxiety such a problem now, when it seemingly wasn't when things were much worse?

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 19:59

My psychiatrist said it’s usually around 27/28 that stress triggers a lot of things
I had a breakdown at 28. It was because I was approaching 30 and hadn’t managed to secure a well paid job or buy a house or find a committed relationship. I also didn’t earn enough to travel or enjoy my life either, and I definitely didn’t earn enough to afford to have kids. I was basically living the same life I’d lived since I was a teenager, with no prospect of anything changing.

So I agree with the PP who said there’s no hope. People want to progress in life and that’s just not possible when there’s a lack of decent jobs so you can’t buy a house or do any of the other stuff you want to do.

And now people are not only broke, they’re beyond broke and can’t actually pay their bills. It was in the news yesterday about a woman in her late 20s who took her 3yo to the train station and stepped in front of a train because she couldn’t pay her bills.

DeliaTookATumble · 18/11/2022 19:54

I would absolutely kill myself if I didn’t have my children relying on me. I work really hard and I’m barely covering my monthly finances. What’s the point? I don’t see any hope in my future now, whereas I used to. I’m not depressed, just tired.

EightChalk · 18/11/2022 19:46

I think in terms of Covid, it's a bit limiting just to look at it as "you had to spend some time locked down watching DVDs, and now it's over." The restrictions showed how quickly our normal way of life can be totally disrupted, and we all saw previously unthinkable things like people dying alone in care homes without being allowed visitors, grandparents having to stand in the garden to see their grandchildren through windows in winter, and so on. That's disconcerting on a deep level. The way that most people seemed to retreat into their little family bubbles and pull up the drawbridge then showed that in a lot of places, we don't have a community backup we can rely on if we were to need support; the culture in the UK seems to be by and large "look after me and mine", and that was both brought into sharp relief and probably also intensified by Covid.

Aside from that, the continuing financial impact of Covid/Brexit/the war in Ukraine means that other things we previously counted on as part of the fabric of our usual day-to-day lives, like local businesses, cafes, pubs, etc., are on precarious footing or already gone, and that's depressing to see day after day. Even if someone's not personally struggling, we all know that life is getting very hard for a lot of people, many of whom were already struggling and vulnerable and had just taken a kicking from Covid - it would take a hard heart not to be affected by that. So I don't think we should limit the impact of Covid on the nation's mental health by just looking at it in terms of numbers of deaths/cases. It did a lot of damage that we didn't have time to recover from before the war in Ukraine and the effects of Brexit started to bite.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2022 19:40

BooksAreSaferThanPeople · 18/11/2022 19:28

I remember when there was a report that came out shortly after lockdowns ended that stated that suicide rates had not increased. People on social media who had been calling for Chinese style lockdowns were positively gleeful because they felt it meant they could dismiss anyone that claimed that lockdown would have an impact on mental health.

Except mental health doesn't work like that. People don't generally experience a difficult event and immediately turn to suicide. I think it's only now that we are starting to see the impact, like a delayed reaction.

Plus reporting was delayed which is part of the dip

It’s all on ONS btw if anyone wants to see ages etc

It’s very much down from the 80s say so more is going on than just social media. Unemployment is likely a factor

Obviouslynotallthere · 18/11/2022 19:40

I work in MH. I am overwhelmed with the amount of work and level of risk.

GoldenCupidon · 18/11/2022 19:38

Sorry I think we are in the recession now, I guess I mean the constant feeling that "the worst is yet to come".

GoldenCupidon · 18/11/2022 19:37

I think the wider world is often very scary and depressing (worries about the recession we're not in yet, hearing about horrible crimes, reports from the war, climate change). The things that keep us happy are often those things that are very mundane and close to us (listening to music, sitting in the sun, eating something you like, having a good catch up with a family member or a friend, putting a picture on the wall, walking along a favourite place and looking at the river/sea/hills/shops and so on).

I think the way we live now means that the wider world stuff is always able to come at us, and we feel the need to know about it and be aware of the sufferings of others. We feel selfish or lazy sometimes if we do the smallscale close things that keep us happy, and the way our working lives are here in the UK a lot of us are expected to work crazy hours with no breaks or be available all the time. People used to work all hours but they often had a hope of a life after death where things would be better.

And then as a PP said we feel there is no hope in sight, because of the horrible things we're always hearing about, and because we have no time for or can't afford or don't allow ourselves small happinesses. It makes for a toxic cocktail for many.

BooksAreSaferThanPeople · 18/11/2022 19:28

I remember when there was a report that came out shortly after lockdowns ended that stated that suicide rates had not increased. People on social media who had been calling for Chinese style lockdowns were positively gleeful because they felt it meant they could dismiss anyone that claimed that lockdown would have an impact on mental health.

Except mental health doesn't work like that. People don't generally experience a difficult event and immediately turn to suicide. I think it's only now that we are starting to see the impact, like a delayed reaction.

Choconut · 18/11/2022 19:22

donttellmehesalive · 18/11/2022 17:27

I teach and the lack of resilience is truly shocking. Children who are unable to cope with normal levels of everyday 'worry' such as a spelling test or answering a question in class. Parents protect them from everything - does that make you worry a bit? Don't do it then. I am frightened for how they will cope at the next stage of their education, university, work. I don't know what the answer is but I feel that we should all be collectively concerned.

I have a friend at CAMHS - workload unmanageable due to parents exaggerating their child's MH issues, knowing what to say to meet the threshold for help, means many in genuine need can't access it.

I was unable to answer questions in class despite being very clever. It wasn't lack of resilience or parenting, it was undiagnosed autism and processing issues.
Supportive parents are not to blame for the MH crisis. If you read the Complete Guide to Aspergers it will educate you on ASD and will explain that parents huge support is often the only thing enabling their child to cope with school.
Maybe some of your students have ASD or other undiagnosed conditions rather than being the snowflakes you suggest.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2022 19:21

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 18/11/2022 17:33

I used to manage inductions in retail.... new starters from age 16

I agree with the teacher upthread

No resilience
No ambition
Anxious over everything
Common sense very thin on the ground
Little initiative

And absolutely addicted to their mobile phones

This doesn’t tally with the figures though

Highest suicide is for women, those aged 45 to 49 years had the highest age-specific suicide rate at 7.8 per 100,000 in 2021. Among men, those aged 50 to 54 years had the highest age-specific suicide rate at 22.7 per 100,000

So if there’s a correlation between low resilience and suicide it’s not higher for young people. Although I doubt it’s about that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread