Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter says I’m ‘controlling’

192 replies

Menopau · 18/11/2022 12:36

I have 2 young adult children who live at home and both work.

preface is they never borrow money from me, they pay a small amount of rent, they don’t have mad house parties or anything and are pretty good sensible kids otherwise.

They help in they house but only really when asked or given instructions despite years of me getting them involved to be independent adults so I am not a total soft touch. The rest of the house is mostly kept tidy by me, but not ‘show home’ standard.

Youngest has a messy bedroom and this at times drives me mad. Her room is her business if she doesn’t change the sheets, but it does often affect everyone else. She takes all the glasses upstairs, leaves food and milk out, her room smells, the dog has got in by accident (the smell of food obviously tempting for a dog to jailbreak in) and eaten mangy food, she hoards smelly used towels, caked on food plates, charges phones on the bed etc. She is not depressed she just doesn’t really care about these things.

I will ask and ask her to sort it and she might take down the plates and glasses, but essentially I end up going in there and taking out the food and smelly damp laundry (mainly towels) when it’s smelling out the upstairs or I have run out and need to clean them.

She got cross with me today for going in her room and says it’s ‘controlling’ of me to take things out of her room, as I asked for the used towels and threw some of her damp dirty clothes in the wash as well. We are at a stalemate where each other is saying it’s disrespectful. She used to have her own towels but she does use the nice, new ones I bought. I also don’t really want her to be the smelly girl at work so I try to encourage her to wash her clothes.

How do other parents of adults manage this?
No I am not going to kick her out before people suggest this I just want to get on better with her.

OP posts:
CoffeeLover90 · 18/11/2022 18:09

My DM used to charge my Dsis a cleaning fee as well as rent. Her room was just how you described. She paid the fee too. She was given the choice to sort it herself first,with me and DM helping with the initial deep clean but she chose to pay.
May help to wrote her a cleaning rota, every day remove dishes and washing, polish on Monday, hoover Tuesday and so on. Offer to help deep clean it and follow that rota, if she'd rather not or fails to keep up then clean yourself and charge for it.
There's also not much excuse for continuing to eat upstairs if you no longer all eat at the same time. She could alone downstairs, keep the dog away and the TV off.

Disneygirl37 · 18/11/2022 17:25

Seriously at 18 she needs to buck her ideas up!
All washing brought down every day or at least put in a hamper, no matter what! If she doesn't, she buys her own towels and uses a laundrette. Stop doing her washing unless she does this.
All plate and cups taken down in morning and evening.
She opens the window once a day for 15mins & hoovers once a week. Tell her this is to stop damp and non negotiable. I wouldn't overly worry about her room otherwise though.
If I cook for my 19 year old I expect her to come and sit with me, not always at the table sometimes just in front of the tv.
If she can hold down a job she's completely capable of doing all this.
If she was living on her own and living like this she would soon realise she needs to step up as she would run out of clothes etc.

JacobReesMoggsSocialConscience · 18/11/2022 17:14

You have every right to impose reasonable rules in your house, even if she is over 18 and paying rent. If she wanted to smoke in a nonsmoking house or adopt a cat when another household member is allergic or run a crack den out of her room, no one would be defending that. You can't have a health or safety hazard in your house; it's not fair to you or the other daughter (or apparently the dog). And it's reasonable for you to make sure she's not doing perm damage to a room in your house. All of these things would apply if she were a lodger somewhere or in a share house, so she might as well start practicing.

Stop doing her personal laundry, ration the bedding and dishes if you have to (she only gets a new set when she's put the old ones in the wash, or she buys her own), put some kind of closure on her door so the dog can't get in (she pays). If her room smells or attracts insects/vermin, she gets one warning and (let's say) 24 hours to deal with it or someone else will. Otherwise let her keep the door closed and do her thing. It's perfectly possible to eat in her room without dirty dishes and food waste accumulating - maybe she needs some kind of handled carrier tray so she just puts/leaves everything in it when she's done eating and takes it down. Little kids learn good habits, she can too.

tedgran · 18/11/2022 16:52

I knew someone who had a big house, she installed a washing machine and dryer om the top floor where her four children had their bedrooms. Once they were sixteen they were responsible for washing their own clothes. I wouldn't do any of your daughters washing, if she wants to live in a tip let her, and stop her taking food upstairs, it's disgusting.

LocalHobo · 18/11/2022 16:48

The OP is far too soft for far too long. I'm appalled actually. This filthy behaviour doesn't happen overnight. It's going to be harder to set boundaries now when the OP has been such a soft touch for years.

Exactly. The Op is totally unreasonable to have raised an adult who thinks living like this is reasonable.

itsgettingweird · 18/11/2022 16:44

Up her rent.

Tell her the extras are for buying crockery etc when she takes it and it's not available for the rest of the family.

Tell her whatever isn't used because she takes its down and pin lid space equipment can be used publicly will be returned to her on payday.

If you don't want to ask her to leave the only way you can motivate her to act responsibly and public spirited is by giving her a motivation.

Currently she gets to do fuck all for herself, gets it done for her and gets to moan about it too.

She has no motivation to change because currently it's great for her Grin

Remagirl · 18/11/2022 16:42

I wouldn't allow this no matter what insult was aimed at me. I'd be more either you do it or I'll do it until you take responsibility. Currently have this battle with 12 year old son but he is beginning to sort it out.

WonderingWanda · 18/11/2022 16:39

Tell her to grow up, that's not being controlling it's called ground rules and respect. As others have said, invite her to leave if she doesn't like it.

DampSquid · 18/11/2022 16:34

Put mouse droppings or a fake dead cockcroach in her room. If she's at all squeamish that should fix the problem 😁

Nosleepforthismum · 18/11/2022 16:31

Ugh sounds vile and exactly like me at that age 😅. She’s lazy and she knows you will do it so you’ve got to be tough. First of all, tell her to stop behaving like a disgusting slob and give her a warning that if food is eaten upstairs, wrappers, plates, cups must be downstairs and washed that evening. If this rule is broken even once from this point on, you will ban food from going upstairs at all. Secondly, she can buy her own towels, she is banned from using yours. Get a door hook or similar so she can throw hers over there. Thirdly, you will never do her washing, she is responsible for it from this point on and let her live like a minger if she chooses. I promise she will grow out of it.

HundredMilesAnHour · 18/11/2022 16:22

TrashyPanda · 18/11/2022 13:25

And tell her that she is being the controlling one, and you have let her get away with it for far too long.

13 year olds do not get to decide they are eating in their room and leaving all their crap behind them.

This! The OP is far too soft for far too long. I'm appalled actually. This filthy behaviour doesn't happen overnight. It's going to be harder to set boundaries now when the OP has been such a soft touch for years.

Derbee · 18/11/2022 16:17

Menopau · 18/11/2022 12:59

She does have an understanding, it’s a choice

she does at least shower and she herself doesn’t smell, I think her clothes would smell. She also uses different towels, cups and plates so she knows about clean and dirty she just doesn’t want to do the cleaning!

She has a floordrobe and they all get mixed up so she gets annoyed if I wash the clothes as I just pick it all up and some of it isn’t really dirty and she wanted to wear it. The sheer size of her washing mountain shows me she does wear clean clothes 😑. Usually because I have barged in, washed them at some point

She sounds pretty gross.

However, i think you need to choose your battles, and not overstep boundaries.

Plates, glasses, cutlery - they’re your belongings and especially if you’re being left short, of course you can go and take them (although she should be bringing things down daily).

Towels, also your belongings - same as above.

I’d make her use her own bedding so that if it gets strained and wrecked from being filthy, it’s only her that it affects.

Laundry - none of your business. You might not like her lack of washing etc but if she smells, she smells. It’s not for you to protect her from being the smelly woman at work - when/if she smells, just tell her. Going into her room and collecting her clothes, doing her laundry is overstepping and babying her.

I couldn’t get worked up about charging her phone on the bed. Fair enough if you’re worried about it, but the fact that you know she’s doing it, means you’re going into her room which I can understand she’d feel weird about.

Simple solution to stop you going into her room is to stop hoarding plates, glasses, cutlery, towels etc

I wouldn’t kick her out. But I’d make it clear that there are other options for living, if she’d be prefer. It would cost her a lot more money though.

RobertaFirmino · 18/11/2022 16:08

At 18, she's old enough to be read the riot act.

Tell her, in no uncertain terms, that her room stinks, her clothes stink and that means she will stink. People will talk behind her back and say she's a dirty get. Nobody will want to hang out with her, let alone date her and all because she's too lazy to bring her washing downstairs.

Don't pussyfoot around any longer, this is for her own good.

Brefugee · 18/11/2022 15:51

She has all her own things and isn’t allowed to use the nicer communal stuff

agree. She gets the oldest, scratchiest towels, and one set of crockery & so on. She is not allowed to put other people at a disadvantage.
And I'd make her do her own washing.

jtaeapa · 18/11/2022 15:05

When my teens have accused me of being controlling, I say yes, I am and that's my job as your parent so suck it up.

Robin233 · 18/11/2022 15:04

@Oblomov22
I would just tell her that it does affect me and it's not acceptable because it's unhygienic.

I am so unlike you. I never would have allowed the above to happen. I just shout up, "I'm putting a wash on boys, anyone got anything. Strip beds please. Move your stuff off the floor, I'm coming to hoover in a minute".
^^^
THIS
We had 4 kids (weekends and 2 fir the week)
They weren't allowed to eat in their rooms until they were mature enough. And they would have to brings plates and cups down, or the rule would be reinstated.
They kept their rooms tidy - including hoovering etc when they were older.
All washing went in the laundry basket - no exceptions.

In return they got no rent, regular healthy meals , and treats ,laundry all done - they had an ironing rota between.
A comfortable, clean house and once 16 plus could come and go as they liked.

Greydogs123 · 18/11/2022 15:04

She has all her own things and isn’t allowed to use the nicer communal stuff - if nice stuff is missing you are going to go into her room. Otherwise tell her that you will leave everything to her and will no longer wash her clothes or in anyway clean her things. Also, if the dog gets sick from going in her room, she has to clear it up or pay any vet bills.
You sound like you are being too soft and she is taking advantage and being lazy. Make it all her problem and she might buck up.

Spellcheck · 18/11/2022 15:03

You're not being controlling. I totally hear you! I have a similar daughter, same age! Our dog adores her revolting bedroom. Dirty clothes, used cotton wool pads, sometimes even used pantyliners (boak), plates, dirty glasses, stuff absolutely everywhere, fake tan all over the bedsheets for weeks. It's so bad that I won't let the cleaner near her room, A. because I'm too embarrassed; and B. because I don't think anyone should clean up after her if she's just going to keep doing that. She actually loves her room clean and tidy but just can't seem to do it herself.

Luckily for us she's currently at uni, and it's bliss having all our towels, crockery, and cutlery to hand when we want it. All her housemates are so lovely but have the same attitude to basic cleanliness. You can imagine the state of her uni house. We're all dreading Christmas when she comes home...

We have a large family and have always had a rota for cleaning the kitchen and other household tasks which has worked really well. She used to try really hard but in the last couple of years it's really got bad. She'll do her bit around the house but is deaf to our calls to sort her own room out. Her siblings, even the 8 year old, are all on board with the rota and they all keep their rooms clean, if not exactly tidy. I do believe in 'their room, their choice' etc, but when you can smell it even with the door closed...! We all hate it. Apart from the dog.

So I don't really have any advice, except to think about why she's doing it. This may or may not be relevant but my daughter's recently been diagnosed with ADHD. She's always been a maelstrom of chaos in all aspects of her life and has to try so much harder than most to cope with the day to days of life. This is not an excuse by the way, but I think I can see why it happens. She gets incredibly angry/touchy when I mention her room and says anything hurtful that will move me away or change the subject, so perhaps I can see why your daughter said you were controlling!

Brefugee · 18/11/2022 14:53

my brother tried this stunt. My parents said: fine. We'll halp you pack. You have a month.

And magically, he stopped doing it and stayed.

Radiatorvalves · 18/11/2022 14:49

I thought my 15 yo DS was gross, but I think I’d better cut him some slack. You sound anything but controlling! She wouldn’t like me at all.

Menopau · 18/11/2022 14:48

Nanny0gg · 18/11/2022 14:29

On a mat on a table. Or on a table next to you when you are awake and there.

NOT on fabric or carpet.

Also check your cables and plugs so they are safe to use, if the cable starts playing up or breaks Chuck it immediately and get a proper one.

OP posts:
Girliefriendlikespuppies · 18/11/2022 14:47

You are definitely not controlling but you have basically created a nightmare housemate!!

Could you give her a list of expectations? So bring dishes and glasses down every day, put dirty clothes in wash basket etc.

Literally spell it out to her what she has to do.

I once told my dd if she didn't put her dirty clothes in the wash basket I would assume she didn't want them so would bag them up for the charity shop 😉 that worked.

Wibbly1008 · 18/11/2022 14:44

Tell her to comply with your standards or move out. Then she can be as stinky as she likes !

Menopau · 18/11/2022 14:41

The older one has ADHD and she’s chaotic sometimes but she is not disgusting. The older one is very H in the spectrum 😑 so she’s always ‘on the go’ and doing stuff, she’s like a Tasmanian devil.

The younger one was assessed for dyspraxia when she was younger and diagnosed with an auditory processing disorder! She can’t follow instructions very well and is forgetful which has allowed her to become quite self centred/self pleasing. We used to have to use picture stories to get her to do things in the right order at the right time (like get dressed, brush teeth).
in part she dislikes eating in a room with other people, the TV etc as it’s just a jumble of noises and she finds it annoying. She likes her room as it’s peaceful but I think she goes off into a dreamland

OP posts:
Mylittlesandwich · 18/11/2022 14:36

drkpl · 18/11/2022 14:30

@suzyscat ADHD is not an excuse - also you can’t diagnose someone you don’t know over one behaviour. ADHD is complex, and there’s a lot more to it than organisational issues alone.

My partner has ADHD and I have ADD, and we struggle so much with organising the house, it’s a cluttered, unfinished tip- but I don’t let it get dirty. When I lived at home with my mum I was tidier as it wasn’t my house, and I only had 1 room to look after. ADHD makes things harder, but it’s also not an excuse for everything. Also, describing an adult’s behaviour as not trying to be ‘naughty’ is ridiculous and infantilising, and it excuses her from the choices she’s making.

Nobody is trying to diagnose, I merely mentioned it as something to consider. You're right ADHD is complex and differs from person to person. For me it's a lot like the OP describes with her daughter. I have systems in place to help lessen this but it's a struggle. And that's without someone being upset/angry with me. I'm upset with myself plenty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread