Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter says I’m ‘controlling’

192 replies

Menopau · 18/11/2022 12:36

I have 2 young adult children who live at home and both work.

preface is they never borrow money from me, they pay a small amount of rent, they don’t have mad house parties or anything and are pretty good sensible kids otherwise.

They help in they house but only really when asked or given instructions despite years of me getting them involved to be independent adults so I am not a total soft touch. The rest of the house is mostly kept tidy by me, but not ‘show home’ standard.

Youngest has a messy bedroom and this at times drives me mad. Her room is her business if she doesn’t change the sheets, but it does often affect everyone else. She takes all the glasses upstairs, leaves food and milk out, her room smells, the dog has got in by accident (the smell of food obviously tempting for a dog to jailbreak in) and eaten mangy food, she hoards smelly used towels, caked on food plates, charges phones on the bed etc. She is not depressed she just doesn’t really care about these things.

I will ask and ask her to sort it and she might take down the plates and glasses, but essentially I end up going in there and taking out the food and smelly damp laundry (mainly towels) when it’s smelling out the upstairs or I have run out and need to clean them.

She got cross with me today for going in her room and says it’s ‘controlling’ of me to take things out of her room, as I asked for the used towels and threw some of her damp dirty clothes in the wash as well. We are at a stalemate where each other is saying it’s disrespectful. She used to have her own towels but she does use the nice, new ones I bought. I also don’t really want her to be the smelly girl at work so I try to encourage her to wash her clothes.

How do other parents of adults manage this?
No I am not going to kick her out before people suggest this I just want to get on better with her.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 19/11/2022 08:13

Menopau · 18/11/2022 12:59

She does have an understanding, it’s a choice

she does at least shower and she herself doesn’t smell, I think her clothes would smell. She also uses different towels, cups and plates so she knows about clean and dirty she just doesn’t want to do the cleaning!

She has a floordrobe and they all get mixed up so she gets annoyed if I wash the clothes as I just pick it all up and some of it isn’t really dirty and she wanted to wear it. The sheer size of her washing mountain shows me she does wear clean clothes 😑. Usually because I have barged in, washed them at some point

Stop doing this - just collect the towels and leave all her crap on the floor!

underneaththeash · 19/11/2022 08:10

MissBPotter · 18/11/2022 13:10

That is not just a bit messy, that’s next level stuff. No one at Uni or anywhere I’ve lived has been that disgusting! The food thing for me would be a no-no, I think you have to have a rule of no food in her room and no leaving towels in there either. It doesn’t matter if she’s an adult, basic rules are still needed. My mum never ever let us have food upstairs even when we lived at home as adults for a while. Im the same with my kids.

And me - eating in a bedroom is disgusting.

Stop the eating upstairs and you won't have a dog issue (and you can ignore the mess!)

FOJN · 19/11/2022 08:08

The sheer size of her washing mountain shows me she does wear clean clothes 😑. Usually because I have barged in, washed them at some point

Why would you do that if she is old enough to know how to use the washing machine herself? Perhaps if you leave her to become the "smelly girl at work", which is the natural consequence of her behaviour, she would be motivated to up her game without all the strife.

encantorerun · 19/11/2022 08:06

OP I was like this, all I can say is that I did grow out of it. I don't think I was as bad as your DD but only because my Mum would have thrown me down the stairs along with the wet towels....

Things I think that helped me:

Every Saturday from me being a teen my Mum would bellow up the stairs 'WASHING'. It then became a very funny game (which we stil do now if she's staying with me) for me to throw washing over the bannister rail and for it to fall on her head, while she tried to catch it. She'd occasionally prompt - 'towels' or 'bedding'.

Pots had to come down whenever the dishwasher went on. It's not really controlling to just say - dishwasher going on - get your pots from your bedroom on a daily basis.

Also my Mum would be upstairs emptying the bathroom bins to take out and she'd come into my room and say 'rubbish please' and I'd have to stop whatever I was doing and throw anything in - usually with her pointing - pizza box, wrappers etc

Honestly though I'm not sure how much conversations actually work. If I was told to do something but with no real immediacy I would have forgotten. If I was told to do something 'now', it would get done.

Sometimes it's just about habit forming. I got used to bringing my mugs and cups down daily before the dishwasher went on. I got used to throwing my washing over the bannister rail on a Saturday morning. I also got used to jumping up from my bed to put my rubbish in a bin liner on a Saturday morning.

Beyond that - my Mum would always survey my room and say good grief before closing the door.

I did grow out of it. I'm nothing like my teenage self in that respect now.

MarrymeKeanu · 19/11/2022 08:05

Ah just read she’s only 18. I had presumed she was early 20’s. In that case I can see why moving out isn’t an option.

MarrymeKeanu · 19/11/2022 08:02

Times have changed so much.

If I had lived like this and was working my parents would’ve told me it was time to move out, find my own place and then I can live how I want. Why is that not an option?

You’re not being controlling, you just expect your adult daughter to live like an adult and not a young teenager.

Ellie1015 · 19/11/2022 08:00

She is playing you hy using words like controlling. I would say "i am not controlling enough as you are leaving your room in that awful state despite me 'controlling' you. Get the dishes in the dishwasher and the laundry in the basket now"

Every day stand her room and complain until she does the basics. You aren't being controling you are making her meet minimum hygeine standards.

mezlou84 · 19/11/2022 07:59

I honestly would try starting a routine with her. Dicuss with her washing arrangements and the fact no food must be left more than a day as it will attract more unpleasant creatures than the dog. At least twice a week you need dirty towels or her to leave the laundry basket outside her room whenever she has wet towels. Only one glass or plate in her room ad its not fair on everyone when there are no pots left for anyone else. You can also leave dark grains of rice or dried shrivelled raisins on her leftovers when she's not looking and in her clothes or around the edges of her room to look like rat and mice droppings it might make her clean up more often x

DIYandEatCake · 19/11/2022 07:41

I think living at home as a young adult is difficult - it’s hard to get out of the ‘child’ role (I used to regress to grumpy, messy teenager every time I came back from uni for the holidays, I hated that I did it but as soon as my mum started nagging it kind of flicked a switch in my brain). Does she want to be living at home or could you explore the possibility of her living in a flatshare with friends? I remember at 18 absolutely relishing the independence of living away from home (and managing surprisingly well). I would ask her what she’d rather do, whether she’d rather live independently (not as a threat but in a ‘I know it can be hard living at home when you want more independence’ kind of way). If she would rather stay with you, then it’s her choice to accept your house rules, as others have said, I’d have non-negotiables (like no food upstairs).

Victoriaplum81 · 19/11/2022 07:26

I wouldn’t have dreamed of doing this when younger. Sit her down and have a conversation about this. Tell her it’s your house and isn’t acceptable behaviour and is having consequences I.e the dog being poorly.
If she eats and drinks in her room and brings the stuff down when she’s finished and the same with towels. If she can’t manage this then she can eat downstairs! If she keeps disrespecting you I’d tell her she can’t life with you as she’s being rude and ungrateful!

Strawberrycream1 · 19/11/2022 07:26

She is being totally disrespectful to you and the rest of the household. You need to set rules like

  • no food upstairs - only drinks or water
  • glasses brought down every morning
  • towels and washing into a washing basket every morning

you could also get some black rice (uncooked) and scatter some about her room especially at edge of bed etc. OMG mouse droppings!!!!!!!
that might shock her into keeping it clean

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/11/2022 07:23

Posted too soon. I would also increase your dd’s rent to pay for a cleaner and buy her 2 towels of her colour choice. The cleaner will have the job of clean, tidying a bit, changing sheets etc. Also do the same with your other adult dc if needed. If she your dd doesn’t organise herself, the other option is to get the cleaner to do this if she pays. I would look at bullet proofing as much as possible. I really like natural consequences so in this scenario she then has no towels and loses money to pay for things she can’t be bothered to do.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/11/2022 07:18

Maybe you get a routine together for your dd?

I used to go into a dream world as a teen. I still clock out of conversations mid way through some of the time and struggle with following one thing, easily distracted etc. I also find a lot of sound overwhelming.

It took me until I had my dd and forced myself into a routine with her before I was good at time management. I was like your dd but not as bad in my teens. We didn’t have much, I had my specific towel, was taught to always hang it on my chair to dry and not many clothes so this helped.

I’m not the best at tidying now but I learned probably to pick up things as I go from one room to another so they aren’t left there - again since having dd and not wanting mess etc. Having dogs also helped as they’d pinch food scraps.

One thing, which would be useful is some kind of bullet point guide, maybe written and stick on her vanity mirror? So your dd does these things every day - brings all dirty washing down, brings all dirty dishes down, hangs her towel to dry in a specific spot and puts her clean clothes away. If she needs visual cues, what about a couple of collapsible crates that she puts them in when used? www.argos.co.uk/product/9610604?istCompanyId=a74d8886-5df9-4baa-b776-166b3bf9111c&istFeedId=30f62ea9-9626-4cac-97c8-9ff3921f8558&istItemId=plprtltmw&istBid=t&&cmpid=GS001&_$ja=tsid:59157%7Cacid:844-913-7556%7Ccid:16627503725%7Cagid:135140859016%7Ctid:pla-1644654608856%7Ccrid:588746567475%7Cnw:u%7Crnd:4901518026408838229%7Cdvc:c%7Cadp:%7Cmt:%7Cloc:1006867&utm_source=Google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=16627503725&utm_term=9610604&utm_content=shopping&utm_custom1=135140859016&utm_custom2=844-913-7556&GPDP=true&gclid=Cj0KCQiA99ybBhD9ARIsALvZavV0xmYg9nu4FDVGk8b8Kqkt6xYLQTNcxZdsiyp-X7rljI4zyA1cOlEaAjFZEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds

makenomistake · 18/11/2022 22:10

We live in the countryside and get quite a lot of mice.

My kids are therefore told they can't take food up to their rooms.

Just be a bit tougher with her. It's your house!

thenewduchessoflapland · 18/11/2022 22:06

My 17 year DD and 13 year old DS are like this;they are both also autistic.

I've had to take a seriously hard line on what they can and cannot do upstairs.

No food is allowed upstairs;no drinks aside from water in a water bottle is allowed upstairs;following on those rules no crockery,cutlery is allowed upstairs.

As soon as laundry is done it has to put away;my 13 year old I divide into sections eg pyjamas,underwear and give it to him section by section to put away.

Storage is really important;I've brought them both a 16 cube Kalax cube from ikea.The cubes are labelled eg T-shirts,jeans etc

They both have a laundry hamper in their rooms.

I remind them about towels after I know they've been in the shower.

I have to be strict with them both as they both share a room with a sibling of the same sex (said siblings are expected to follow these rules too);my elder son is 18.

I'd strongly suggest DD buys herself a set of her own towels and use of household towels is banned if she can't be trusted with them.

Also don't do her laundry;it's her responsibility;my 17&18 year olds do their own.

She might be 18 but her habits are disgusting and it's affecting the rest of the household.

LesleyA · 18/11/2022 21:40

I think it’s natural to think she’s being disrespectful but o don’t think it’s her intention or that it is deliberate. She seems to seek the instant gratification of say eating and leaving the plates there rather than effort to finish the process. Her mess defines her not in that she’s a mess but she has control over it so it’s become part of her space that she owns. As a mother it’s worrying frustrating and hard to break the stalemate ask her if u can have 3 non negotiables (wet towels, food/crockery and worn underwear ). Forget the phn etc etc. your attempts to control reflects your anxiety/fear for her sake. do u celebrate her positives? Get her to make u tea etc so u feel less resentful when doing stuff for her. Seems disorganisation is how her brain works and there is some emotional coping mechanism like avoidance at play. Surely she’s adhd?

Bonniegirlie · 18/11/2022 20:35

I wouldn’t be doing her washing. If it’s stinking the house out, just collect it up in a bin bag and put it outside or in the garage. You have had lots of other suggestions so I won’t repeat what you need to do.

schoolsoutforever · 18/11/2022 20:24

That was meant to say ‘Och…’ (I’m Scottish!)

nickytjj · 18/11/2022 20:23

If you don't want her to move out then the only alternative is that she has her things, glass, plates, towels, bedding and isn't allowed to use anyone else's

this could attract mice and there will still be a smell.

schoolsoutforever · 18/11/2022 20:23

O have - she’s 18! Not really a proper adult. I was a bit like your daughter I think up until was about 25. Just encourage her to find a flat, find her own way and you’ll get on fine and dandy.

suzyscat · 18/11/2022 20:12

drkpl · 18/11/2022 14:30

@suzyscat ADHD is not an excuse - also you can’t diagnose someone you don’t know over one behaviour. ADHD is complex, and there’s a lot more to it than organisational issues alone.

My partner has ADHD and I have ADD, and we struggle so much with organising the house, it’s a cluttered, unfinished tip- but I don’t let it get dirty. When I lived at home with my mum I was tidier as it wasn’t my house, and I only had 1 room to look after. ADHD makes things harder, but it’s also not an excuse for everything. Also, describing an adult’s behaviour as not trying to be ‘naughty’ is ridiculous and infantilising, and it excuses her from the choices she’s making.

Really great that your ADHD doesn't effect you in that way, that's nice for you. Hooray for your executive function.

nickytjj · 18/11/2022 19:59

OP YANBU your house your rules, you can do whatever the fuck you want and if she doesn't like that tell her to go, she's an adult, not 14.

BouncingJAS · 18/11/2022 19:42

itsgettingweird · 18/11/2022 16:44

Up her rent.

Tell her the extras are for buying crockery etc when she takes it and it's not available for the rest of the family.

Tell her whatever isn't used because she takes its down and pin lid space equipment can be used publicly will be returned to her on payday.

If you don't want to ask her to leave the only way you can motivate her to act responsibly and public spirited is by giving her a motivation.

Currently she gets to do fuck all for herself, gets it done for her and gets to moan about it too.

She has no motivation to change because currently it's great for her Grin

The problem with this thread in a nuushell:

  1. Because you made her pay "rent" she has rights now

She has paid for her room. That is hers. You have no right to intrude now without her permission.

  1. This is why I always tell parents making their kids pay "rent" is a bad idea. Contributing to utilities and other common expenses is fine, but do not fall into the trap of making them pay for their room.

Once you do, you cannot enter their room without permission.

Because by LAW, they have rights.

Stompythedinosaur · 18/11/2022 18:59

You don't have to kick her out, but this dynamic is why it is preferable for adults not to remain living in their parents home. Surely you'll all be happier if she moves on to live as an independent adult?

Handyweatherstation · 18/11/2022 18:14

I'm thinking about the carpet. If it gets too minging and needs cleaning, or replacing, does she know the cost of these and is she prepared to pay?

Swipe left for the next trending thread