Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter says I’m ‘controlling’

192 replies

Menopau · 18/11/2022 12:36

I have 2 young adult children who live at home and both work.

preface is they never borrow money from me, they pay a small amount of rent, they don’t have mad house parties or anything and are pretty good sensible kids otherwise.

They help in they house but only really when asked or given instructions despite years of me getting them involved to be independent adults so I am not a total soft touch. The rest of the house is mostly kept tidy by me, but not ‘show home’ standard.

Youngest has a messy bedroom and this at times drives me mad. Her room is her business if she doesn’t change the sheets, but it does often affect everyone else. She takes all the glasses upstairs, leaves food and milk out, her room smells, the dog has got in by accident (the smell of food obviously tempting for a dog to jailbreak in) and eaten mangy food, she hoards smelly used towels, caked on food plates, charges phones on the bed etc. She is not depressed she just doesn’t really care about these things.

I will ask and ask her to sort it and she might take down the plates and glasses, but essentially I end up going in there and taking out the food and smelly damp laundry (mainly towels) when it’s smelling out the upstairs or I have run out and need to clean them.

She got cross with me today for going in her room and says it’s ‘controlling’ of me to take things out of her room, as I asked for the used towels and threw some of her damp dirty clothes in the wash as well. We are at a stalemate where each other is saying it’s disrespectful. She used to have her own towels but she does use the nice, new ones I bought. I also don’t really want her to be the smelly girl at work so I try to encourage her to wash her clothes.

How do other parents of adults manage this?
No I am not going to kick her out before people suggest this I just want to get on better with her.

OP posts:
awaynboilyurheid · 19/11/2022 09:27

A friend told me that once they get their own place (which are usually then kept pristine! ) when you stay over take YOUR food and cups into your room and leave wet towels on their floor just as a reminder to them of the good old days! 🤣

CuriousMama · 19/11/2022 09:24

justasking111 · 19/11/2022 09:08

I once opened bedroom window and threw all teenagers clothes I found on the floor out into the garden. Then hoovered.

With another I videod the mess all of it. Then said it would be sent on social media to various places FB etc. He cleaned the room.

Mine are only allowed water in the bedroom no food.

Chargers, buy her one of these for Xmas
www.amazon.co.uk/iBlockCube-Universal-Extension-Electrical-Accessories/dp/B0855SN2V7?pd_rd_w=o1Lqk&content-id=amzn1.sym.7e1aba63-f32a-4d3d-8a78-f7fbbae425e1&pf_rd_p=7e1aba63-f32a-4d3d-8a78-f7fbbae425e1&pf_rd_r=8M5G8RMNF7XCMQCP7GT0&pd_rd_wg=kkWMW&pd_rd_r=b7126a23-babf-468e-b3b5-5bdecf979be0&pd_rd_i=B0855SN2V7&psc=1&ref_=pd_basp_bia_rpt_ba_s_1_sc

OH and put the rent up and stop washing her clothes. At university she'd have to wash her own

You sound appalling.

awaynboilyurheid · 19/11/2022 09:22

Having had this mess previously with daughters I would say just keep on reminding her but it’s probably not going to change that much!
Pick your battles, she is doing well in all other areas so you just have to lower your standards, I don’t get all the talk about making her leave she’s your daughter you want a good relationship with her.
Unfirtunately from my experience and loads of friends children then when they move into being adults this is another stage that many go through and those with younger children might not realise in the late teenage years we can’t just kick them out or lay down the law it’s part of normal development and maturity.
Just keep reminding her praise when she does it and don’t let it become a battle and you’ll get through it, relationship intact.

Menopau · 19/11/2022 09:22

Onlyforcake · 19/11/2022 09:18

How is it not depressed yo not care about the state she lives in? That is a very detached mental state

I worry too much about this and it’s why I started getting anxious about it myself as I felt like it was a symptom of depression. She really isn’t bothered by it though and seems otherwise fine, unless you talk about her room then she gets annoyed

OP posts:
autienotnaughty · 19/11/2022 09:18

@Fleurdaisy you obviously haven't read all the replies so I will repeat. Do not charge phones on the bed. It's fire risk

Onlyforcake · 19/11/2022 09:18

How is it not depressed yo not care about the state she lives in? That is a very detached mental state

Menopau · 19/11/2022 09:18

Lots of questions sorry ok..

I will have to replace the carpet in her room, yes. She likes art and it’s covered in paint, spilt food stains etc. I do make her clean it and she paid for her room redecoration.

The ‘rent’ is a small amount for utilities mostly. I supply an evening meal. They are meant to buy snack food for themselves, DD1 keeps this downstairs. DD2 keeps it in her room. 😑

I worry about pests and it might help to lay down some rice as poo although she would think mice are cute 🙄. She doesn’t like spiders and if there has been one on the floor she won’t move anything for a few days hoping it goes away

She is still like a sulky child. She is also the most stubborn person Ive ever met. Even as a toddler I couldn’t bribe her to do anything she didn’t want to do.

I’ve tried all of the advice here at one point in the last few years since it’s got like this. It started to get bad when we moved house then got much worse in lockdown. I do get cross about it but she’s my daughter I still love her, I wouldn’t want this to ruin our relationship, life is too short and I hope it doesn’t in the long run but I wish she would try harder.

I am out at work most days. I am not always home to nag, or she’s worked a shift and she’s asleep when I leave home or I’m asleep when she gets home so we are not always physically seeing each face to face. I will ask on text or wait till I see her but we can’t really get a daily routine of nagging to work as she works lates on a shift pattern.

I will try to talk to her like an adult and not a child as otherwise I can’t expect things to change!

OP posts:
Cbtinfoplease · 19/11/2022 09:12

Hi.
I went straight to your replies to work out if anyone has mentioned adhd. Because it sounded familiar! I see she has siblings who are adhd. … it runs in families ! Please consider this may be ( inattentive) a potential part of the issue xx

Fleurdaisy · 19/11/2022 09:11

Menopau · 18/11/2022 12:49

I hate her charging the phone on the bed, it is a hazard. She will not listen to me about this though

she has made me feel IABU so I feel a little less now!

Pick your battles.
Tell both dc house rules are no food left in rooms, all crockery and cutlery to be washed at the end of each day.
Only use your own towels. If they get fetid enough she’ll soon wash them.
I’d ignore the phone charging.

justasking111 · 19/11/2022 09:08

I once opened bedroom window and threw all teenagers clothes I found on the floor out into the garden. Then hoovered.

With another I videod the mess all of it. Then said it would be sent on social media to various places FB etc. He cleaned the room.

Mine are only allowed water in the bedroom no food.

Chargers, buy her one of these for Xmas
www.amazon.co.uk/iBlockCube-Universal-Extension-Electrical-Accessories/dp/B0855SN2V7?pd_rd_w=o1Lqk&content-id=amzn1.sym.7e1aba63-f32a-4d3d-8a78-f7fbbae425e1&pf_rd_p=7e1aba63-f32a-4d3d-8a78-f7fbbae425e1&pf_rd_r=8M5G8RMNF7XCMQCP7GT0&pd_rd_wg=kkWMW&pd_rd_r=b7126a23-babf-468e-b3b5-5bdecf979be0&pd_rd_i=B0855SN2V7&psc=1&ref_=pd_basp_bia_rpt_ba_s_1_sc

OH and put the rent up and stop washing her clothes. At university she'd have to wash her own

maryofthevirginkind · 19/11/2022 09:04

Print her out some house rules and bullet points as reminders. Offer to help her get her bedroom clean and tidy and ask her once a week to keep on top of it or you will go in there and sort it yourself.

I had this when mine were teenagers. The rule was that they had to go hoover and dust their room during the weekend and change their bed once a fortnight. Towels had to be hung back up in the bathroom and last a week.

Every six weeks I warned them I was going to go in and everything on the floor was going in a bin bag. If they could tell me what was in the bin bag they could have it back. They never bothered!

When the eldest left for uni he wrote and thanked us as he said he was the most organised one in their uni flat and used to do the ironing for the others and they paid him. All thanks to our "controlling" parenting!

Morestrangethings · 19/11/2022 09:04

charges phones on the bed
__
I can't see why this is a problem though.

Fire - charging batteries on beds can cause a fire.

doubleshotcappuccino · 19/11/2022 09:02

Perhaps a scalable charge of rent depending on tidiness of room..

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 19/11/2022 08:57

"Controlling" is now so overused and as a comeback for being called out on unacceptable behaviour.

It does such a disservice to those who really do experience it😡

Tell the dirty, disrespectful mare to shape up or ship out OP.

CambsAlways · 19/11/2022 08:57

One of my four AC where bit similar wet towels crisp packets cans , used to drive me potty, not nearly as bad as yours though, left home and has a beautifully kept home now, I know that doesn’t help but I’d be telling her I would be increasing her rent and if she didn’t want me in her bedroom then she needs to get her act together ,I’d put a stop to food being eaten upstairs too.

Moveoverdarlin · 19/11/2022 08:53

I was very similar to this when I was a teenager. My Dad would come in and look like a glass collector in a pub because he’d have three mugs in each hand which I’d left stagnant tea in. Often I would finish food and slide the plate under my bed. My bedroom was a tip. My personal hygiene was excellent though and I’d spend loads on good clothes which I’d then leave in a heap. Having said all that, my house now is immaculate and we all have a good laugh at how my bedroom in my parents beautiful home always resembled a squat. I can’t really remember them bollocking me, I just let them get on with taking plates and mugs and I’d have to tidy it and put away clean washing every few weeks.

encantorerun · 19/11/2022 08:52

Kafta · 19/11/2022 08:21

This was me as a teenager! I was so messy.

I kept leaving my hair straighteners on despite my step dad repeatedly asking me not to.

I remember he said for the 50th time, please turn them off, if I find them on again I'll cut the lead.

Needless to say....I had to buy a new pair!

Funnily now I'm very careful and I'm a complete neat freak. My home is a 'show home' type and I feel awful if it's a tip.

I had these moments too. Sometimes it's the only way to learn.

I don't think telling her to leave or telling her she could leave is the right answer (not unless it's said somewhat flippantly in a row like - 'well if you don't like it feel free to leave' type of thing in the way @KettrickenSmiled suggests, which is a good way of putting the point over in more of a 'if you think you have it hard then try X' - but without genuine threat) - not if you want to raise an adult who puts family first.

Hard to really argue that your adult child with her own children should put themselves out to visit, stay with you, spend Christmas with you, help you in old age - when you turfed them out at 17-18yrs old for being messy (even if it is extreme).

I'm sure, like me, you got over having your straightners cut, but you wouldn't get over your parents sitting you down to discuss you seriously moving out or handing you a suitcase.

But that's just me, I was still in education at 18yrs so perhaps different.

Sarahjaykay · 19/11/2022 08:47

Sounds exactly like my DS ...he hates the mess with a passion but gets total overwhelm when it comes to cleaning it, and gets very defensive about it. He's borderline asd.

Blinky21 · 19/11/2022 08:46

You should stop washing her clothes, that's not a health issue for anyone else, let her be smelly, she'll soon learn. I'd also tell her if she doesn't keep the house to the standard you expect, she should leave. Wherever she lives in the future, she'll find there are rules, so best she learns that now

CuriousMama · 19/11/2022 08:39

Dishwashersaurous · 18/11/2022 12:54

She's clearly got no understanding of basic hygiene.

If you don't want her to move out then the only alternative is that she has her things, glass, plates, towels, bedding and isn't allowed to use anyone else's.

That's what I was going to suggest.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/11/2022 08:35

She has a floordrobe and they all get mixed up so she gets annoyed if I wash the clothes as I just pick it all up and some of it isn’t really dirty and she wanted to wear it. The sheer size of her washing mountain shows me she does wear clean clothes 😑. Usually because I have barged in, washed them at some point
Why are you doing this?
I get that you need to go in & 'rescue' wet towels as the stink the top floor of your house out.
But why are you enabling her with her laundry & floordrobe?
You said you were worried her clothes will start to smell. Just let them. Her friends will soon tell her she whiffs. Her family can point it out too.

She got cross with me today for going in her room and says it’s ‘controlling’ of me to take things out of her room,
"ha ha ha nice try DD. You clearly don't understand what controlling behaviour consists of. It's manipulative of you to take MY things into your room, misuse them til you are stinking the place out, refuse to care for them properly & then complain that somehow I'm at fault. Maybe you need to move out, & start finding £800 for private rental? For that money it will be a shared place, so when you stink that place out too, let me know what your housemates think of your habits."

StClare101 · 19/11/2022 08:31

Start bagging up her dirty clothes in bin bags and leave them in the laundry. She’ll run out soon enough.

Sit her down and say if she chooses to live with you there is no food upstairs, wet towels must be washed/dried and that she must contribute to chores. If that’s too “controlling” for her liking she can move out.

My parents had to ask my parents to leave when she was 18. They gave her two weeks notice. She had a full time job and it was fine. Her first set of flatnates kicked her out within six months. She learnt fast.

Kafta · 19/11/2022 08:21

This was me as a teenager! I was so messy.

I kept leaving my hair straighteners on despite my step dad repeatedly asking me not to.

I remember he said for the 50th time, please turn them off, if I find them on again I'll cut the lead.

Needless to say....I had to buy a new pair!

Funnily now I'm very careful and I'm a complete neat freak. My home is a 'show home' type and I feel awful if it's a tip.

MsCactus · 19/11/2022 08:18

You are definitely not being unreasonable - but just to say this is probably quite normal for an 18 year old who has always had you cleaning up after them and has no experience of living somewhere else.

I was exactly the same when I was 18 - moving out did wonders for my relationship with my parents.

Though saying that, I've never really become tidy like my mum. Instead I married someone who is tidy, and he basically does all the household tasks.

So I'm not saying your daughter will drastically change, but after she's moved out she'll realise how difficult she acted and appreciate you and your help a lot more.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 19/11/2022 08:17

There is another thread on MN right now about a terrible lodger, and most of the advice is to get her out fast and change the locks. Anybody with a lodger like your daughter would have thrown her out ages ago. I'm not saying you should throw your own daughter out, but her cleanliness and hygiene standards are unacceptable, and you're not being at all unreasonable (or controlling) in demanding much better from her. Your house, your rules.