Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school have got this very wrong?

274 replies

anerki101 · 18/11/2022 12:04

Had an email from my child's school this week regarding the World Cup. The council have decided that they want to celebrate the World Cup so will be allowing the first game to be shown in school for every one to watch. They added that because of the human rights concerns with the host nation they would ask the kids to wear their football kits or team colours and bring in a donation for amnesty International.

AIBU to think this is wrong? If they are concerned about the human rights issues then surely boycotting the World Cup and NOT showing the game is the the best thing to do? Very happy to donate to amnesty but I still think allowing the game to be shown is a mistake.

I say this as a football fan who looks forward and watches the world Cup but won't be this time.

OP posts:
Hmm1234 · 19/11/2022 20:25

The statement from the school is shocking. I’m guessing there’s no Arabs that attend then!

Rubbishagain · 19/11/2022 20:22

Why is this such a big deal. FIFA have decided this. When cricket was held in India no one said about the untouchables who are treated so badly and the amount of rape cases. When tennis was held in Israel no said anything about the killing of children and land being stolen daily. Everyone was silent then. It seems cowardly to only pick on Qatar. When people are offered jobs with tax free earnings than these issues disappear

Mandyjack · 19/11/2022 20:06

So are you not going to watch at home?

Ineke · 19/11/2022 19:56

When I was a child I was sent to a Catholic Boarding School. (Army Parents stationed abroad)
I can clearly remember November 5th, bonfires, fireworks but NO GUY.
This was because Guy Fawkes was a Catholic and burnt at the stake. I don’t think it matters what religion but that point was made not to celebrate the burning at the stake of a human being. I think the message was a good one and it stuck with me. I feel that schools should send a similar message. If they do show the football, they could do some project work on slave labour and moral dilemmas. If you know the facts, you cannot ignore the injustice and human rights issues in this county. It is never too young to be made aware of injustice, and it’s consequences. Our freedoms will then be all the more appreciated and our children will come to learn how privileged and lucky we all are. An important life lesson ..

Bugbabe1970 · 19/11/2022 19:49

They should not be watching it

Reimu · 19/11/2022 19:39

People who do not have their own room and house in order should be very careful about trying to do anything to change the world. It is infinitely more important to teach children to live as good men and women before they even start to bother about activism. This will just teach kids to take life way too seriously and to be bidder about social problems by showing superficial "solutions" just to send a shallow message.

Ellyesse · 19/11/2022 19:33

I remember a similar situation when there was a National dispute as to whether one of our teams should go abroad to play against a country that had just clearly broken the International Convention of Human Rights. A Teacher in Assembly asked us this:
"You've been invited to a birthday party of one of the people in your year. It is going to be quite a party and everyone wants to be there.
Then on his way home, your little brother gets beaten up and has his pocket money taken by a gang of big boys who are the gang the Birthday Party Boy goes around with. After this you see them all together laughing, the birthday boy enjoying a joke with them.
Do you still go to his party?"

Zeezee82 · 19/11/2022 19:31

Ban them from watching the football and attendance will drop dramatically.
I think the school are being very clever with the right stance whilst encouraging children not to miss the other 4 hours of their education

TrashyPanda · 19/11/2022 19:16

A lot of schools will then use the World Cup interest to spark other work

how tedious for all the pupils who don’t give a toss about football.

onlythreenow · 19/11/2022 19:11

I say this as a football fan who looks forward and watches the world Cup but won't be this time.

And how is this going to help? For every person who does this there will be many, many others who will be watching, so what is the actual point?

onlythreenow · 19/11/2022 19:08

The school should not be trying to make a human rights statement.
They should just let kids be kids and enjoy watching the football with their friends.

I agree. There is a difference between talking to your kids about the wrongs of the world and expecting them to get involved. They are kids for a short time, let them have fun before they have to deal with the worry and stress of adulthood.

ThistleTits · 19/11/2022 19:02

@Rororowan
Good for you. There are thousands being abused for everyone like you. I also live in the UK and prostitution is still a crime.
There are many women being trafficked and you know it.

Try not to compare your life to that of others who have no choice.

Amnesty does support the trafficking of women, they publicly say it.
The only way forward for the protection of these women (and it is mostly women) is the Nordic Model.

Rosie22xx · 19/11/2022 18:47

Personally do not see the need for the kids to even watch football at school to be honest.

Rororowan · 19/11/2022 18:43

ThistleTits · 19/11/2022 18:29

^ this and a lot more besides. They are not the "human rights" organisation, they would like us to believe.
The teaching staff should educate themselves.

Oh come off it.
They say nothing about a human right to sex, it's all about the rights of the people selling sex. If someone is selling sex, if it's out of desperation for money or just hornyness, they deserve to be as safe as possible. They deserve financial support to avoid having to do it out of desperation, but the most important thing is the safety of sex workers.
The best way to keep workers safe is full decriminalisation, backed up by study after study on sex workers rights and safety in different countries.

I work in the UK, where it's mostly decriminalised, so I can advertise online, I can screen my clients using national blacklists, I have a lot of choice and freedom in how I work.
But I can't hire a bodyguard. I can't rent a hotel room with a friend and both use it for work. I can't have my bank account or my landlord find out what I do or I risk homelessness. How do any of these laws protect me?
If my work, the way I keep a roof over my head and food on my table, was made illegal, how would that protect me?

UndercoverDadCos · 19/11/2022 18:43

If the kid's five, that's a bit mad.
If it's a secondary school, gives the chance to understand the political element and discuss, but to also watch the football.
Not quite sure what else they could do. That sounds very sensible

ThistleTits · 19/11/2022 18:29

HermioneWeasley · 18/11/2022 12:33

Amnesty International says that sex is a human right and therefore prostitution is fine

Amnesty Ireland called for people who understand biological sex to be denied the right to vote

i would not be sending any money to AI, they are a misogynist organisation

^ this and a lot more besides. They are not the "human rights" organisation, they would like us to believe.
The teaching staff should educate themselves.

Kr1st1n37374 · 19/11/2022 18:29

Yellowdahlia12

I suspect the primary kids who suspect they might be gay will be concerned.

Lily4444 · 19/11/2022 18:26

They should boycott it if they want to take a stance

Missingpop · 19/11/2022 18:18

Bloody schools have double standards to suit their respective needs; they infuriated the hell out of me when my children were at school; what happens to the children who have absolutely no interest in football & is it really such a good idea sending children to school in football kits mid November? It’s cold; wet & I very much doubt any of the teacher will be slung out in the playground to freeze their tits off at lunchtime!! A very ill conceived idea me thinks 😂

DonnaBanana · 19/11/2022 13:40

I would actually be more likely to support banning the match because Iran is playing. Theological dictatorship torturing its own citizens as we speak. Worse than Qatar for sure.

Florenz · 19/11/2022 13:00

Puzzledandpissedoff · 19/11/2022 10:03

There is no such thing as a "significant" football match. People may like football. They may love football. It is neither significant nor education

Very well said, Quveas
Nothing at all wrong with enjoying the game - each to their own and all that - but the expectation that it'll disrupt so much else "because it matters" gets a bit much

The only reason why anything "matters" is because people think it matters. People think the world cup matters, therefore it does matter.

Florenz · 19/11/2022 12:58

By the first game I assume they mean England vs Iran. The actual first game is on Sunday. I don't see a problem with it. It's the one England game that is being played during school hours, all the others will be on at 7pm or at weekends.

JudgeJ · 19/11/2022 12:51

Fairislefandango · 18/11/2022 19:25

During the 2002 World Cup, the Headteacher of the secondary I worked at refused to televise the England vs Brazil game. Nearly 50% of the pupils didn’t turn up to school that day.

Heads often televise matches in order to make sure pupils attend school. Better they miss 90 minutes of learning than a whole day.

I disagree. Better that school goes on as normal and kids whose parents let them stay at home are registered with an unauthorised absence.

In 2002 the Brazil match was at breakfast time, I recall driving in and Radio bloody 4 gave out the 'latest score' England 1 Brazil 0 so by the time I got into school where a bacon butty party was taking place England were no longer winning and ultimately lost! I totally blame Radio 4, I should never, ever know a score of an event in which I have an interest! Very little school time missed and the children enjoyed watching the match together, other than the result.

Changemaname1 · 19/11/2022 11:12

Ah I see @melj1213 thankyou 😊

melj1213 · 19/11/2022 11:11

It's not a new phenomenon, it just happens so rarely that England games have clashed with school hours that every time it does and schools try to do their best to accommodate them people get up on arms about it.

A lot of schools will then use the World Cup interest to spark other work - looking at the different countries in Geography, finding them on maps and learning about the topography of the different countries; Maths using WC data - working out distances of stadiums/countries, "If an England fan travels to X, Y and Z to watch England group games, how far will they travel/how long will it take?" Etc, addition/subtraction/multiplication/division using game data, working out angles of passes etc); English - writing a match report, writing an article about a team in the WC using persuasive language to encourage people to support them, creating a poster to advertise a country in the competition; Art - creating new logos/mascots/kits for the teams, creating posters or drawing the flags of the different countries; RE- looking at the fact Qatar is a Muslim country and how that is different to England as a Christian country; PSHE for older kids, discussing the human rights issues in Qatar; Music - learning football songs/creating their own and adding the music etc ... There are so many ways to incorporate the WC into the classroom to keep kids interested and also tie in to what is going on in the wider world.

I worked in Spain during their reign of back to back Euro/WC/Euro wins in 08/10/12 and even though they were in the summer holidays (schools finish at the end of June), I worked for a teen summer language program and in Euro/WC years we always made sure to make arrangements for the kids to watch their teams games during the tournament because we knew that if we didn't then they would just try and sneak off to watch games on their phones/hide in a room with a TV etc and it was a much bigger risk than just suspending regular programming for 90 mins.

Swipe left for the next trending thread