Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fed up of businesses aligning themselves with politics!

661 replies

thehorsehasnowbolted · 18/11/2022 10:07

I was about to grab a turkey and cranberry sandwich yesterday at a major retailer when I noticed on the package that 5% of that purchase would go to Shelter.

Why are we being increasingly forced nowadays to contribute to causes we may not necessarily agree with in this way? Why don't businesses stick to selling goods? Why the constant virtue signalling? It's annoying

I do not intend to comment on this charity in particular, but I have seen my fair share of pensioners being out of pocket to evict problem tenants who were in a position to pay the rent and look after properties but simply didn't want to and just played the system.

The results of charities activities are not always 100% positive, so customers shouldn't be forced to contribute in this way.

Why do businesses assume that their customers agree with the charities they pick? The constant virtue signalling is patronising and insulting.

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 19/11/2022 23:57

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:48

What would you do if you owned a business and wanted to raise money for the church?

I would definitely keep both separate

Fair enough but that wasn't what I was getting at.

Would you listen to 5% of unhappy customers if the other 95% were happy?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:48

What would you do if you owned a business and wanted to raise money for the church?

I would definitely keep both separate

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 19/11/2022 23:37

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:29

You also bought the item anyway, so it didn't matter

No, I said I didn't. I've said it upthread. They have lost my custom

Your opinion doesn't matter.
It's because we don't care about the custom of some moody unhinged woman who doesn't understand data, science, or critical thinking.

You've definitely proved my point

But by the same token you must understand that you can't please everyone, don't you?

It hard to think that some companies don't care about your POV but as long as they're pleasing the masses, that's all that counts. What would you do if you owned a business and wanted to raise money for the church? If 95% of your customers liked what you were doing but 5% didn't, would you change your methods? I probably wouldn't but would listen.

Woopzies · 19/11/2022 23:34

Fact is, when you buy something that money becomes theirs. What they choose to do with it is none of your business. They've told you what they plan to do with 5% of it, but they didn't have to.

Their chosen cause, whether you agree with it or not, will not cease to exist simply because they didn't get your 5% of that sandwich. So your 'protest' in choosing not to buy it had no effect other than you had to find something else to eat...

Miajk · 19/11/2022 23:31

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:29

You also bought the item anyway, so it didn't matter

No, I said I didn't. I've said it upthread. They have lost my custom

Your opinion doesn't matter.
It's because we don't care about the custom of some moody unhinged woman who doesn't understand data, science, or critical thinking.

You've definitely proved my point

You didn't buy a sandwich because you were so upset they were trying to help homeless people? You sound like a great person.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:29

You also bought the item anyway, so it didn't matter

No, I said I didn't. I've said it upthread. They have lost my custom

Your opinion doesn't matter.
It's because we don't care about the custom of some moody unhinged woman who doesn't understand data, science, or critical thinking.

You've definitely proved my point

OP posts:
Miajk · 19/11/2022 23:23

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:07

It's interesting that so many marketing gurus on this thread are doing exactly the same as what some big retailers do.

Shout down your customer for wrong think and send them away, rather than listen and try to understand their point of view to secure their custom.

Is it part and parcel of the trade?

No wonder businesses get it wrong so often if they are being advised by such 'geniuses'

It's because we don't care about the custom of some moody unhinged woman who doesn't understand data, science, or critical thinking.

You also bought the item anyway, so it didn't matter. Your opinion doesn't matter. And as you can see most people disagree with you, so statistically it's still a better business decision to not listen to your whining.

Miajk · 19/11/2022 23:21

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 21:12

1.50/50 testing - they might be selling two variants at the same time
2. Before and after testing - measuring revenue, but also specifically the CVR when looking at footfall and the specific item sale before and after the item has been amended
3. Market research - asking existing customers about whether they felt more or less inclined to buy sandwich A or B, and why (qualitative data)
4. Online consumer behaviour - evaluating analytics across multiple metrics for the sandwich, if sold online. 50/50 testing also possible in this case

Good effort, but no

  1. No, they are not doing this
  2. No, this is a festive sandwich, so there is no 'before and after' instance or amendment of a pre-existing item
  3. We have already established that this is not 100% reliable
  4. The item is not being sold online

There is a before and after looking at previous years and years after?

And looking at sales trends for over sandwiches to see if the uplift for this specific sandwich was driven by other factors, or predominantly by the change. Even easier to measure if multiple sandwiches have had this change.

Something not being a 100% reliable doesn't make it invalid. Statistical significance is what you're looking for, and confidence intervals. But I assume you don't know much about data as you genuinely seem to be one of the most clueless people I've seen here recently.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 23:07

It's interesting that so many marketing gurus on this thread are doing exactly the same as what some big retailers do.

Shout down your customer for wrong think and send them away, rather than listen and try to understand their point of view to secure their custom.

Is it part and parcel of the trade?

No wonder businesses get it wrong so often if they are being advised by such 'geniuses'

OP posts:
Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 22:49

So, @thehorsehasnowbolted are you calling M&S on Monday morning to sell them your expertise?

Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 22:48

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:40

Again, what's your education and line of work?

Can you explain to me how you would quantify the exact number of increased sales that this charity affiliated sandwich will generate for the retailer (vs. offering the same non-affiliated version)?

All irrelevant, according to my brother who is a mathematician. The only proof he accepts is proof by logic.

Of course it is ridiculous to apply that standard of proof to any other aspect of life. It wouldn't allow for, e.g. testing of medicines.

Every branch of knowledge has to establish its own concept of testing and proof, over many years.

pointythings · 19/11/2022 22:12

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 22:10

Tesco does this too. But they also do charity donations on certain products in addition. Amazing, isn't it - it's not either/or!

Well, I assume by now you can appreciate the subtle differences of both methods in terms of customer experience and why one would be much preferable for a retailer than the other

Er, no. Because you're talking nonsense.

pointythings · 19/11/2022 22:11

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 22:07

Still with the 'if it's not 100% reliable it's therefore 0% reliable

I've already said that if an initiative has the potential to drive customers away it needs to be 100% reliable or very close, yes.

But that's nonsense. If the results show x% of customers likely to be more likely to buy and y% customers being less likely to buy, and y < x with a statistically significant reliability, then it's going to be worth doing. Because maths. You've already said you are not going to buy this sandwich. But if there are 5 people who would not have bought the sandwich, but who now will because of the charity link, then M&S are going to go ahead. It isn't about the potential to drive customers away. It's about assessing that a given course of action will attract more customers than it drives away. And that is what market research is all about.

Did you even pass GCSE maths?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 22:10

Tesco does this too. But they also do charity donations on certain products in addition. Amazing, isn't it - it's not either/or!

Well, I assume by now you can appreciate the subtle differences of both methods in terms of customer experience and why one would be much preferable for a retailer than the other

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 22:07

Still with the 'if it's not 100% reliable it's therefore 0% reliable

I've already said that if an initiative has the potential to drive customers away it needs to be 100% reliable or very close, yes.

OP posts:
pointythings · 19/11/2022 22:07

@thehorsehasnowbolted Tesco does this too. But they also do charity donations on certain products in addition. Amazing, isn't it - it's not either/or!

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 22:05

Waitrose had a much better approach with the 'green tokens'- at least prior to Covid, not sure if they have reinstated it.

Before leaving the store, the customer was presented with 3 charities to select from if they so wished. You could choose none or all 3.The selection of charities was changed regularly and I believe they were relatively local to each store and smallish.

The customer experience as a loyalty generator (which is presumably what retailers should be interested in) was completely different. You, as a customer felt in control of where donations went and were made to feel as if your opinion counted.

Miles away from the forced donation, 'shop elsewhere if you don't like it' method.

I think it's not difficult to understand.

OP posts:
pointythings · 19/11/2022 21:55

We have already established that this is not 100% reliable

Still with the 'if it's not 100% reliable it's therefore 0% reliable. You have very little comprehension of the sciences.

You also seem to have remarkable insights into how M&S does its marketing (and you do know the charity thing isn't just about a single product?) so are you already working for them?

Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 21:18

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 21:14

Bragging about donating to your church

I'm not bragging. I just wanted to say that I do donate but I want to choose who I donate to and do not appreciate being dictated to by the retailers I decide to shop at

Then decide to shop elsewhere. Or choose a different sandwich.

No dictators!

Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 21:17

@thehorsehasnowbolted so you'll be calling M&S first thing on Monday to offer your services? 😂

Re: 1 - maybe they sell the sandwiches in some areas with the charity tie in, and some areas without? Areas matched for demographic similarities perhaps?

Or do you know for a fact that this isn't the case, just as you know that 30-50% of their customers don't like their charity affiliations?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 21:14

Bragging about donating to your church

I'm not bragging. I just wanted to say that I do donate but I want to choose who I donate to and do not appreciate being dictated to by the retailers I decide to shop at

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 21:12

1.50/50 testing - they might be selling two variants at the same time
2. Before and after testing - measuring revenue, but also specifically the CVR when looking at footfall and the specific item sale before and after the item has been amended
3. Market research - asking existing customers about whether they felt more or less inclined to buy sandwich A or B, and why (qualitative data)
4. Online consumer behaviour - evaluating analytics across multiple metrics for the sandwich, if sold online. 50/50 testing also possible in this case

Good effort, but no

  1. No, they are not doing this
  2. No, this is a festive sandwich, so there is no 'before and after' instance or amendment of a pre-existing item
  3. We have already established that this is not 100% reliable
  4. The item is not being sold online
OP posts:
Bunnyfuller · 19/11/2022 20:51

I thought Jesus said ‘Don’t judge’. Bragging about donating to your church is the exact opposite of what Christianity is supposed to be.

what’s the problem with helping the homeless? If a pensioner has a home to rent out, they’re not doing too badly eh.

Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 20:22

MarshaMelrose · 19/11/2022 19:53

You actually put in quotation marks that I said, 'but the experts all got it completely wrong on COVID'. Which I never said. So I don't know how believable anything you say is because you couldn't even quote me accurately.

My comment was that lots of experts over covid said a variety of things that were not true or that turned out not to be true, and there was often disagreement with other experts over so many different things. Sage and independent sage is one example. But there were loads of experts going on the news with their version of what was happening and prophesies of what would happen that turned out to be completely wrong.

There were loads of times that I read in newspapers, articles almost side by side that completely contradicted each other and both were fuelled by opinions of experts.

There many experts that were doing a great job with vaccines etc, but even then medical experts were producing information and publishing in journals articles that were completely wrong.

So I completely stand by my statement that it's hard to know how much experts actually know about anything and how much they just guess and bluster about. And if these experts were prepared to speak so forcefully - when they clearly didn't know because they were proven to be wrong later - when the country was so scared and panicking, it does make me cautious to automatically believe any expert now.

You're right. I was going to go to my GP about my high blood pressure, but have just realised that the so-called 'experts' don't really know anything. I'll have a quick Google and see what's on offer for treating high blood pressure instead

Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 20:15

@thehorsehasnowbolted I must insist you contact M&S first thing on Monday morning and offer them your insights. They can close down their marketing departments and save millions, and also benefit from retaining those customers (was it 30-50% you said?) that they are playing Russian roulette with. Their profits will go up, and the senior managers will be raking it in with their bonusses.

I mean, even the general public might benefit from their prices going down.

Why are you so bashful? You need to step up and speak the truth, for everyone's sake.