Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fed up of businesses aligning themselves with politics!

661 replies

thehorsehasnowbolted · 18/11/2022 10:07

I was about to grab a turkey and cranberry sandwich yesterday at a major retailer when I noticed on the package that 5% of that purchase would go to Shelter.

Why are we being increasingly forced nowadays to contribute to causes we may not necessarily agree with in this way? Why don't businesses stick to selling goods? Why the constant virtue signalling? It's annoying

I do not intend to comment on this charity in particular, but I have seen my fair share of pensioners being out of pocket to evict problem tenants who were in a position to pay the rent and look after properties but simply didn't want to and just played the system.

The results of charities activities are not always 100% positive, so customers shouldn't be forced to contribute in this way.

Why do businesses assume that their customers agree with the charities they pick? The constant virtue signalling is patronising and insulting.

OP posts:
Sigma33 · 20/11/2022 10:45

So you wouldn't think anything of upsetting a large proportion of your client's customer base just because they don't agree with your personal beliefs?

@thehorsehasnowbolted you have asserted this several times on this thread. Please provide some evidence that M&S is upsetting a large proportion of their customer base by donating some money to Shelter when people buy a turkey and cranberry sandwich?

I understand they have lost your custom - how much were you spending at M&S that is would affect their profits?!

Are you claiming that you are a large proportion of their customer base?

This is a great thread! It reminds me of that one about charity shops with numerous amateur 'experts' insisting charities would make more profit by pricing cheaply and having high turnover than by being selective and having higher prices. Despite those involved in the industry explaining why that isn't the case...

Hours of fun 😁on a quiet weekend.

pointythings · 20/11/2022 10:43

@Notonthestairs a mere almost 2 decades! Pah! 'Tis no time at all!

pointythings · 20/11/2022 10:42

What does 'safe alignment' mean? How about just advertise the product and don't align yourself with anyone?xit

'Safe' in this instance means 'does not adversely affect profits'.

And while there has been an increase in retailers affiliating with charities in the last 5 to 6 years, the phenomenon is absolutely not new.

Your entire take on this seems to be 'the retailers are wrong because I don't like what they're doing'. And yet they're still here.

Which retailers have gone under because of their charity affiliations (and not, say, because of recessions, COVID, the Ukraine war, Brexit impacts etc.) and can you provide us with the evidence that it's the charity support that has led to their demise?

Notonthestairs · 20/11/2022 10:42

M&S have been doing it since 2005!

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 10:39

And yet numerous businesses have been doing it for years, and are still making profits

This is a relative new trend, so they haven't been doing it 'for years', no. I would say 5 or 6 years. Also some of them have flopped.

OP posts:
Sigma33 · 20/11/2022 10:36

That does not make good business sense and can prove fatal over a period of time. Best to stay away from politics and focus on advertising your products

And yet numerous businesses have been doing it for years, and are still making profits...

Lunar270 · 20/11/2022 10:31

Notonthestairs · 20/11/2022 10:24

Will nobody think of the climate denying, homophobic, pensioner landlords? Why shouldn't they get to buy a festive sandwich without giving 10p to the homeless?

Op I think you should write to the retailer. Twitter is excellent for contacting big business direct. Feel free to share their response.

Twitter is definitely the right platform for the OP.

All proceeds are going to the Elon Musk Twitter rescue fund.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 10:30

In the UK, same sex marriage is not controversial. So a retailer in support of the LGBT community can safely align themselves with a charity in this area and not lose business

You should know by now that the UK population is not a mass of homogeneous opinions. What does 'safe alignment' mean? How about just advertise the product and don't align yourself with anyone?

A retailer enabling an advertising agency to act as if the own the business, hijack marketing budget to push their own political agendas, and allowing them to say 'I will not cater for you because your opinion doesn't matter' is at best disingenuous and can cost them dearly.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/11/2022 10:29

Will nobody think of the climate denying, homophobic, pensioner landlords? Why shouldn't they get to buy a festive sandwich without giving 10p to the homeless?

You missed off "racist" and "disablist", Notonthestairs ... since landlords are so regularly demonised on here you might as well chuck in all the popular "isms" while you're at it Wink

Notonthestairs · 20/11/2022 10:24

Will nobody think of the climate denying, homophobic, pensioner landlords? Why shouldn't they get to buy a festive sandwich without giving 10p to the homeless?

Op I think you should write to the retailer. Twitter is excellent for contacting big business direct. Feel free to share their response.

pointythings · 20/11/2022 10:04

In the UK, same sex marriage is not controversial. So a retailer in support of the LGBT community can safely align themselves with a charity in this area and not lose business. In other parts of the world it's different, and that same retailer (if they are a global brand) will work differently. Not rocket science.

Overall, supporting charities makes retailers money - if it did not, they would not do it because they are about profitability. And if their charity support offends some people, the retailers don't care - because overall they are making more money from charity affiliations than they would otherwise. That's the reality of the world we live in. Moaning about it won't change it. Saying that charity affiliation doesn't positively affect profits without providing any evidence of that just makes you a laughing stock.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 09:42

The world is moving on and we're leaving behind catering to bigots

Who is 'we'? You are speaking on behalf of whom?

68million people in the UK? Do the 7billion people in the world see eye to eye with you on every topic?

You're really telling on yourself here

So are you. I didn't say I agree with these views. I just provided some examples of matters that could be controversial. There are people who, for whatever reason, could be upset by these affiliations and would not want to donate. They are still people and they are still customers that businesses need.

Businesses don't need to affiliate themselves with anybody.

It didn't take long for you to snap, start name calling and preach on behalf of the 'world'.

Does this also happen when your ilk go about designing impartial marketing research?

OP posts:
pointythings · 20/11/2022 09:34

OP, when you choose to be a landlord, that is the risk you take. Everything comes with risks.

TooHotToRamble · 20/11/2022 02:01

thehorsehasnowbolted · 18/11/2022 11:23

I don't think donating to a homelessness charity is particularly political

Charities can be (and often are) political. Most carry out a massive amount of lobbying.

What do you think is driving current uncontrolled rent rises? The demonization of landlords by some charities has probably driven a lot of the current landlord- hostile legislation which has caused the sell off of properties reducing available stock (and price increases)

  1. Can you show me a document Shelter have produced that demonises landlords?
  1. Why on earth do you think the Tory party would be swayed by a "all landlords are terrible" argument so much so that they would change policy/legislation? Unlikely. What's much more likely is that the Tories want everyone to be homeowners and we have a housing crisis. So they see legislation/taxation which discourages landlords may free up more homes for people who want to buy and live in them, rather than own them to rent out (or as second homes). This is an age old Tory ethos and has nothing to do with Shelter's lobbying. If this upsets you. Don't vote Tory, don't blame charities who are trying to support homeless people and provide housing advice often to very vulnerable people.
TooHotToRamble · 20/11/2022 01:50

"I do not intend to comment on this charity in particular, but I have seen my fair share of pensioners being out of pocket to evict problem tenants who were in a position to pay the rent and look after properties but simply didn't want to and just played the system."

What on earth has that got to do with the work that Shelter do?

And why does it mattered whether the landlord concerned is a pensioner or not? How is that relevant?

ToastedWaffle · 20/11/2022 01:24

Honestly OP, you are fucking tiresome. Do you really have so little else going on that you spend 19 pages complaining about a non issue and arguing with strangers.

Sod the customer? I'd ban you from every shop!

Miajk · 20/11/2022 01:14

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:52

There, fixed it for you

So you wouldn't think anything of upsetting a large proportion of your client's customer base just because they don't agree with your personal beliefs?

I'm sorry to say that the more you post, the more it becomes apparent why businesses appear to be ill advised by marketing agencies.

Large retailers have a huge customer base. For some topics a large proportion of these customers will not share the personal views of the marketing professional. You still have to cater for them and listen to their opinions. Or do you also dismiss their results coming out of the market research? Or do you on purpose not select them for your focus groups? It's rather alarming, but your attitude explains a lot. Maybe you should rethink what it means to work in marketing. Who are you working for, yourself or your client?

Homophobia is not some difference of opinion matter.

The world is moving on and we're leaving behind catering to bigots. It's not I'll advised that giant companies don't want to be aligned with homophobia, racism, misogyny, etc. It's common sense.

You're really telling on yourself here.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:52

There, fixed it for you

So you wouldn't think anything of upsetting a large proportion of your client's customer base just because they don't agree with your personal beliefs?

I'm sorry to say that the more you post, the more it becomes apparent why businesses appear to be ill advised by marketing agencies.

Large retailers have a huge customer base. For some topics a large proportion of these customers will not share the personal views of the marketing professional. You still have to cater for them and listen to their opinions. Or do you also dismiss their results coming out of the market research? Or do you on purpose not select them for your focus groups? It's rather alarming, but your attitude explains a lot. Maybe you should rethink what it means to work in marketing. Who are you working for, yourself or your client?

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 20/11/2022 00:49

@thehorsehasnowbolted

But you're not necessarily affiliated with a charity because you bought a sandwich. The company is. You're just buying something you wanted (or not in your case).

I guarantee most, including myself, would look and see that shelter is a good cause. Or they just won't even notice because they're hangry. Or they don't care.

Is it virtue signalling? Maybe and I get it can go both ways but can imagine the numbers of complaints are minimal given the UK is one of the most generous countries for charity donations.

Lunar270 · 20/11/2022 00:36

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:13

What if it was 60/40, or 70/30?

Would it still be the case of 'if you don't like it go and shop elsewhere?

Perhaps not. Business sense would dictate that you listen to see how you can improve customer satisfaction and their experience.

But that doesn't seem to be the case, from this thread at least.

In fairness I've definitely noticed an increase in businesses asking for charity donations but think this is a logical thing to do. I don't often give as I do other things but don't have an issue with it.

Ultimately companies are just giving a portion of the profits to charity. Not charging us any more. I'm not talking about rounding up purchases by 5p etc but things like your sandwich. I honestly don't see the issue unless you know the charity is suspect.

Miajk · 20/11/2022 00:36

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:31

What if it was 60/40, or 70/30?

Would it still be the case of 'if you don't like it go and shop elsewhere?

And the OP is just an example.

You can alienate different groups with different affiliations.

One day you associate yourself with a charity fighting climate change, you could perhaps upset farmers? Think about what's happening in Canada and the Netherlands currently

The next you associate yourself with a charity supporting same sex marriage, you could upset those with very conservative religious beliefs

The next you associate yourself with a tenants charity, you upset landlords

And so on

To add insult to injury, you force all these previously loyal (and now very irritated) customers to donate to causes they are against.

If you keep on ignoring your customers, thinking you know best and making a large enough number of wrong decisions you could end up upsetting 95% of your customers in total.

That does not make good business sense and can prove fatal over a period of time. Best to stay away from politics and focus on advertising your products

The next you associate yourself with a charity supporting same sex marriage, you could upset those with very conservative religious beliefs homophobic bigots.

There, fixed it for you.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:31

What if it was 60/40, or 70/30?

Would it still be the case of 'if you don't like it go and shop elsewhere?

And the OP is just an example.

You can alienate different groups with different affiliations.

One day you associate yourself with a charity fighting climate change, you could perhaps upset farmers? Think about what's happening in Canada and the Netherlands currently

The next you associate yourself with a charity supporting same sex marriage, you could upset those with very conservative religious beliefs

The next you associate yourself with a tenants charity, you upset landlords

And so on

To add insult to injury, you force all these previously loyal (and now very irritated) customers to donate to causes they are against.

If you keep on ignoring your customers, thinking you know best and making a large enough number of wrong decisions you could end up upsetting 95% of your customers in total.

That does not make good business sense and can prove fatal over a period of time. Best to stay away from politics and focus on advertising your products

OP posts:
Miajk · 20/11/2022 00:13

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:11

Would you listen to 5% of unhappy customers if the other 95% were happy?

If 95% of my customers were happy I would continue doing what I'm doing.

But as was discussed on the thread, it's not easy in the case of large retailers to establish those percentages for product charity affiliations with a reasonable level of certainty

But multiple people have explained to you that it is possible. You are the only person denying this for some reason, based on no knowledge or experience, just some random feelings.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:13

What if it was 60/40, or 70/30?

Would it still be the case of 'if you don't like it go and shop elsewhere?

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 20/11/2022 00:11

Would you listen to 5% of unhappy customers if the other 95% were happy?

If 95% of my customers were happy I would continue doing what I'm doing.

But as was discussed on the thread, it's not easy in the case of large retailers to establish those percentages for product charity affiliations with a reasonable level of certainty

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread