Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fed up of businesses aligning themselves with politics!

661 replies

thehorsehasnowbolted · 18/11/2022 10:07

I was about to grab a turkey and cranberry sandwich yesterday at a major retailer when I noticed on the package that 5% of that purchase would go to Shelter.

Why are we being increasingly forced nowadays to contribute to causes we may not necessarily agree with in this way? Why don't businesses stick to selling goods? Why the constant virtue signalling? It's annoying

I do not intend to comment on this charity in particular, but I have seen my fair share of pensioners being out of pocket to evict problem tenants who were in a position to pay the rent and look after properties but simply didn't want to and just played the system.

The results of charities activities are not always 100% positive, so customers shouldn't be forced to contribute in this way.

Why do businesses assume that their customers agree with the charities they pick? The constant virtue signalling is patronising and insulting.

OP posts:
pointythings · 19/11/2022 20:09

@MarshaMelrose I do apologise for the exaggerated paraphrasing, but I get so tired of people expecting science to be 100% perfect, and to denounce it as 'guesswork and bluster' if it is not. COVID is also not a good example - it was a completely new virus that nobody had seen before. Market research has been around for many decades and its methodologies have been tested and refined over time.

And lastly I am more inclined to believe people trained in marketing and data than someone on the internet with a massive bee in their bonnet about Shelter.

Talcumpowderandturnips · 19/11/2022 19:56

I lost it at 'affiliated sandwich' PMSL
The horse has bolted and taken any kindness or humanity you ever possessed with it.
'Tis the season to be troll-y you heartless waste of space.
I'm very good friends with Jesus and he has, through a wee catch up tonight, told me that you are really not the sort of person he wants hanging out at his clubs. In fact he's banning you. You're not on the list so you're not getting in.
Go and munch on a raw brussel sprout you mean spirited Tory git.

MarshaMelrose · 19/11/2022 19:53

pointythings · 19/11/2022 19:19

@MarshaMelrose yes, that was aimed at you - you seem to think that experts got it wrong on COVID so now you doubt experts in general. Which makes me 🙄so hard.

You actually put in quotation marks that I said, 'but the experts all got it completely wrong on COVID'. Which I never said. So I don't know how believable anything you say is because you couldn't even quote me accurately.

My comment was that lots of experts over covid said a variety of things that were not true or that turned out not to be true, and there was often disagreement with other experts over so many different things. Sage and independent sage is one example. But there were loads of experts going on the news with their version of what was happening and prophesies of what would happen that turned out to be completely wrong.

There were loads of times that I read in newspapers, articles almost side by side that completely contradicted each other and both were fuelled by opinions of experts.

There many experts that were doing a great job with vaccines etc, but even then medical experts were producing information and publishing in journals articles that were completely wrong.

So I completely stand by my statement that it's hard to know how much experts actually know about anything and how much they just guess and bluster about. And if these experts were prepared to speak so forcefully - when they clearly didn't know because they were proven to be wrong later - when the country was so scared and panicking, it does make me cautious to automatically believe any expert now.

pointythings · 19/11/2022 19:19

@MarshaMelrose yes, that was aimed at you - you seem to think that experts got it wrong on COVID so now you doubt experts in general. Which makes me 🙄so hard.

KatherineJaneway · 19/11/2022 19:19

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:54

I imagine sometime in the last 16 years they've looked at the figures

You assume then

So you honestly think that at no time in 16 years anyone at M&S has looked at the impact of working with Shelter on their sandwich sales?

Come on.

Notonthestairs · 19/11/2022 19:13

Yeah I believe that given M&S are a significant UK retailer and public company they'll have looked at their costs in the last 16 years Grin food sales are up 5.6%.

They certainly ditch products that aren't cost effective - I miss their fresh ceasar salad dressing.

Miajk · 19/11/2022 19:12

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:40

Again, what's your education and line of work?

Can you explain to me how you would quantify the exact number of increased sales that this charity affiliated sandwich will generate for the retailer (vs. offering the same non-affiliated version)?

If I answer will you finally accept it? Or keep living in denial?

  1. 50/50 testing - they might be selling two variants at the same time
  2. Before and after testing - measuring revenue, but also specifically the CVR when looking at footfall and the specific item sale before and after the item has been amended
  3. Market research - asking existing customers about whether they felt more or less inclined to buy sandwich A or B, and why (qualitative data)
  4. Online consumer behaviour - evaluating analytics across multiple metrics for the sandwich, if sold online. 50/50 testing also possible in this case

These are literally just 4 of the most common approaches. Do you get it now?

Miajk · 19/11/2022 19:07

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:40

Again, what's your education and line of work?

Can you explain to me how you would quantify the exact number of increased sales that this charity affiliated sandwich will generate for the retailer (vs. offering the same non-affiliated version)?

Are you incapable of answering a simple question?

Seems like you're afraid of answering.

MarshaMelrose · 19/11/2022 19:07

And let's not get into 'but the experts all got it completely wrong on COVID' because that's just BS.

Was this aimed at me? I don't want to reply if that's aimed at a poster that actually said, "but the experts got it completely wrong on COVID'.

pointythings · 19/11/2022 19:02

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:54

I imagine sometime in the last 16 years they've looked at the figures

You assume then

Well, you can always go to their HQ and ask to see the evidence. While I'm on the subject, where's yours?

And let's not get into 'but the experts all got it completely wrong on COVID' because that's just BS.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:54

I imagine sometime in the last 16 years they've looked at the figures

You assume then

OP posts:
Notonthestairs · 19/11/2022 18:53

Notonthestairs · 19/11/2022 18:48

M&S have been selling sandwiches with donations to Shelter for at least a decade. I guess they've crunched the numbers at some point and decided it works for them.

My mistake they've been doing it since 2005 (and not just sandwiches! Items from the Christmas range)
I imagine sometime in the last 16 years they've looked at the figures.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:51

But I now wonder how much experts actually know about anything and how much they just guess and bluster about

The 'experts' on this thread haven't been able to answer my question

OP posts:
Notonthestairs · 19/11/2022 18:48

M&S have been selling sandwiches with donations to Shelter for at least a decade. I guess they've crunched the numbers at some point and decided it works for them.

MarshaMelrose · 19/11/2022 18:46

Or perhaps you should read the posts from the people who actually work in marketing. But hey, who needs 'experts' when we have your opinions to guide us?

I used to think sarcastically like this before covid. But I now wonder how much experts actually know about anything and how much they just guess and bluster about.

pointythings · 19/11/2022 18:43

OP seems to be of the belief that unless something can be proved to be 100% right, it must therefore be 100% wrong.

Also nice way to not answer the question, OP. We're all very interested in your experience in retail, marketing and data analysis.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:40

Again, what's your education and line of work?

Can you explain to me how you would quantify the exact number of increased sales that this charity affiliated sandwich will generate for the retailer (vs. offering the same non-affiliated version)?

OP posts:
Miajk · 19/11/2022 18:36

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:24

Businesses do not play Russian roulette with their customer bases, any decisions is based on market research and data analysis

Of course they do. I remember the recent outrage on MN about an ad from a major retailer showing a little child wrecking the home. Everyone talked about boycotts. never shopping there again, etc. That retailer undoubtedly spent millions on marketing research and the campaign itself. Still MN wondered how they could have got it so wrong (and they had engaged one of the top global advertising agencies - they must know their stuff, right?)

Spending millions is not a bullet proof recipe for success and you can upset your customer base.

It's also hilarious how some 'experts' on this thread keep going on about how retailers are able to measure every decision they make with equal ease (and cost). You know...because retailers can figure out how best to configure their retail space they can also, as easily, measure the exact increase in profits that a charity association of a festive sandwich will generate.

I've already said that in order to measure this properly they would have to display the same number of affiliated and non-affiliated sandwiches across all stores and measure sales of each, which obviously they are not doing.

But the bottom line is that 'forced' charity donations do not generate increased profits or brand loyalty and they can indeed send customers away

Again, what's your education and line of work?

pointythings · 19/11/2022 18:31

But the bottom line is that 'forced' charity donations do not generate increased profits or brand loyalty and they can indeed send customers away

And your evidence for this is... you not choosing to buy the sandwich. 😂

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 18:24

Businesses do not play Russian roulette with their customer bases, any decisions is based on market research and data analysis

Of course they do. I remember the recent outrage on MN about an ad from a major retailer showing a little child wrecking the home. Everyone talked about boycotts. never shopping there again, etc. That retailer undoubtedly spent millions on marketing research and the campaign itself. Still MN wondered how they could have got it so wrong (and they had engaged one of the top global advertising agencies - they must know their stuff, right?)

Spending millions is not a bullet proof recipe for success and you can upset your customer base.

It's also hilarious how some 'experts' on this thread keep going on about how retailers are able to measure every decision they make with equal ease (and cost). You know...because retailers can figure out how best to configure their retail space they can also, as easily, measure the exact increase in profits that a charity association of a festive sandwich will generate.

I've already said that in order to measure this properly they would have to display the same number of affiliated and non-affiliated sandwiches across all stores and measure sales of each, which obviously they are not doing.

But the bottom line is that 'forced' charity donations do not generate increased profits or brand loyalty and they can indeed send customers away

OP posts:
Sigma33 · 19/11/2022 17:18

M&S are missing a trick here. They don't need to spend millions on marketing, they could just pay @thehorsehasnowbolted a generous consultancy fee to tell them what their customers want.

Everyone wins!

KatherineJaneway · 19/11/2022 14:30

pointythings · 19/11/2022 12:26

@KatherineJaneway we live in hope that at some point, the lights will go on.

Agree 👍

Miajk · 19/11/2022 13:35

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/11/2022 11:25

OP's stance on market research is basically that if the outcome isn't in alignment with her opinion, it is therefore wrong. It must be amazing to have such confidence in one's own abilities. I hope OP doesn't work in the sciences, that would be scary.

Don't be scared. I'm surprised you haven't encountered this at 55 in your line of work. Biased research to suit funders' objectives and all that

OP please confirm your education and line of work? Something tells me you don't know much about anything.

Miajk · 19/11/2022 13:34

Florenz · 19/11/2022 12:00

I agree with the OP. I don't agree with chuggers either. If people want to give to charity, let them do it off their own back, not because it's being pushed in their face 24/7.

But you do get a choice. And it's not shoved in your face.

A company is affiliated with a charity and donates profits to it. You can choose if you want to buy or not. There are so many supermarkets you can really take your pick.

How many braincells need to be rubbed together for some people to get this simple concept?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 19/11/2022 12:37

thehorsehasnowbolted · 18/11/2022 23:34

What about customers who want to see the business buying from acting in a more ethical way by donating profits to charity. You have 2 customers with opposing needs, both saying “sod the customer” if their way isn’t granted.

Wouldnt it be easier if the business could just act how they like and then it be up to the customer to decide whether their interests are aligned and to purchase from them?

The problem (as I've explained upthread) is that businesses cannot quantify how many customers they are sacrificing and how many they are gaining as a result of them openly dishing out opinions. They are playing Russian roulette with their customer base. For some, it may end up being a very costly exercise

Seriously, how are you still not getting this?

Businesses do not play Russian roulette with their customer bases, any decisions is based on market research and data analysis.

I'm sorry you can't understand this but for the love of your God just accept you are wrong!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread