Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you cope knowing this about your grandmother?

158 replies

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 10:02

Grandmother lives in a different city and I haven't seen her for a couple of years. Always had a lot of love for her and she's always been wonderful to me. As I've gotten older though and as the adults in my family have started talking to me more about things a child would be sheltered from, I've come to learn that the reason my father and aunt are so messed up psychologically is because my grandmother abused them horrifically.

They were terrified of her. She would beat them with wood and belt buckles. If they spoke out of tone they would be put in a cold bath. Locked in cupboards, kicked, starved etc. Obviously as a child I did not know this, but I always knew my dad struggled with his mental health and was quite closed off emotionally (not all the time, he's NEVER been abusive, he's a wonderful father).

I really struggle now having learnt that she abused someone I love so much to the extent that he still struggles a lot as an adult, and my aunt who I also adore is very psychologically damaged.

Suddenly feel a but numb to who was once my lovely grandma who could do no wrong.

OP posts:
Bentoforthehorde · 18/11/2022 11:55

My mother and I were both sexually abused by my grandfather, my mother's dad. I found out in my twenties that my grandmother knew what was going on. She was a very sweet grandmother, my grandfather was a 'pillar of the community' type, very well respected.
My dad is a violent alcoholic, has spent time in prison.
In the end relatives are just people, human beings with flaws sometimes carrying their own trauma or shame.
People change over time, things done in teens/twenties/thirties etc might not be reconcilable with the person you know now. Some things are unforgivable, some things are not yours to forgive, some things change your view of a person's character in a way that makes a relationship with them impossible.
In the end, as long as the person doesn't pose a risk to anyone, you have to accept that there probably will never be a reason you can understand to explain their actions and knowing that this is part of their life story you make a decision about how involved you want them to be in your life.

It's a headfuck for sure, and I wish you the best OP

Chattycathydoll · 18/11/2022 11:54

I often wonder this. I’ve cut off most of my abusive family but can’t quite bring myself to cut off my dad because I know he was abused himself, I feel sorry for him but equally know he made a choice to allow me to be exploited by his family and to be physically abusive to me. My Dad is a great grandad mainly because I supervise every interaction and DD is never alone with him or with him for more than a couple of hours. He has had counselling but it doesn’t undo the things he did. She adores him and doesn’t understand why she’s not allowed there for sleepovers. It’s because I don’t trust him.

I’ve said in child friendly terms that he wasn’t always kind to me when I was little so I just want to keep to nice visits where I can make sure he’s definitely learned to be better. But really I don’t know if he has, I can’t ever know or trust that.

Do you think it would have been better to never know your grandmother- never have that bond? Or to have enjoyed it when you were little even if you know things are more complicated as an adult?

silverbubbles · 18/11/2022 11:53

Your Dad has allowed you to build a relationship with your Grandmother - he wanted this relationship for you. If you know it would upset him to pry into his childhood then don't do it.

If you have not see her for a couple of years then its not like you are dropping in every week etc. I would just leave it and perhaps ask to speak to your father about his childhood.

Take a step back from granny if you need to and reduce contact.

nokidshere · 18/11/2022 11:52

It's a hard one. On the one hand you don't want to open old wounds for your dad, on the other hand you may feel this woman must be confronted. I'd try gently talking to your dad op, perhaps he needs the conversation with a safe, loved, trusted daughter and doesn't know it. I'd definitely not see her anymore, and I'm not advising you to, but I'd confront her, but that's just how I am...

It's not hard. If her dad wanted her to know then she already would. It's not anyones place to open things that someone wants left alone.

Melsuleenia · 18/11/2022 11:51

Actually let me be really clear. Abuse = trauma. Shame goes hand in hand with trauma. That is another trauma. Did I somehow encourage it? Am I a bad person? Yes, I must be and I am unlovable. IF the very first people who you tell about the abuse do not believe you = trauma. It then become less likely that when you have recovered that you will reach out again. Much better to keep quiet and men are incredibly bad for doing this because of the way society treats men and their emotional state. Do we keep putting our hands in the fire when we know we will get burned. A crying shame but understandable because the majority of people are kind, compassionate and caring.

When I told my mum what my dad was saying to me she did not believe me. I was 5.

CinnamonSodaPop · 18/11/2022 11:50

My granddad was physically and emotionally abusive to his kids. Now I'm an adult I can see the damage it has done to my mother and the whole family really. He was himself also horribly abused and perpetuated that cycle along with alcoholism. My mother seems to have forgiven him and has a lot of sympathy for the hard life he had. I take my lead from her. However that is just what works in my case, every situation is different. Give yourself some time to process it all.

Usernamesarboring · 18/11/2022 11:50

SomePosters · 18/11/2022 10:32

Hi op

wothout going into all the grim details I know what you’re going through.

i am no contact with both my grandparents due to their treatment of my mum.
She has a relationship with one of them and is no contact with the other.
They are both beyond forgiveness in my eyes but she needs to believe in the one she maintains a relationship with.

Don’t stick your oar in, it’s you dad it will upset most.

But it’s ok to distance yourself and your family too.

Im not excusing your grandmother but before writing her off completely consider the context she was raising her children in.

No birth control. Can’t say no to your husband. Can’t divorce.
The wider societal attitude was that corporal punishment kept rowdy kids in line and those who didn’t do it were spoiling their kids.
She will have married young by todays standards and had little time to process her own childhood or to see examples of the more gentle parenting we have come to expect.
None of that makes your dads
experiences any less awful for him of course any more than the abuse my granny suffered excuses her treatment of her children but I do think it’s important to judge people by the standards of their time and not ours.

My granny’s trauma can be directly traced to the 2nd world war fallout and I suspect many of us struggling today can follow our generational trauma back to traumatised returning squaddies.

Still doesn’t mean you have to forgive.

I don’t speak to the parent my mum still does despite her wishes.

By your logic all the racist things people did in past was all ok because it was accepted in the society?

Every violent person has a history of problem themselves. Gm here belted her kids, if they spoke in wrong tone put them in cold baths, not given food, locked in cupboard. How much anger a person must have to inflict this on little children. I am sure kids must be crying, screaming, and she continued. I dont think I would see Gm in the same light as before. I may not confront her but i would have a less affectionate relationship with a person like that.
There is no need for us to use our imagination to create a picture in order to justify abuse, especially towards helpless children. There were plenty of parents back then who didnt belt or starved their kids.

The abuse must be out of the norm even for those times that both children had serious mental health issues as adults.

@elephantonacid i would not confront, rather have a non emotional relationship with her.

nokidshere · 18/11/2022 11:49

From what I've been told, when people have tried to talk to him about it he just says 'she was young and lost' then shuts down the conversation. He doesn't like talking about it.

This is the only part of your post that matters.

If your dad hasn't told you himself then it's not your business to do anything at all. If he had wanted you to know he would have told you already.

If you distance yourself from his mum then do so without making a song and dance about it. Otherwise he will ask why, then you'll have to lie or tell him, then he would be upset and feel like he is the cause etc etc etc...

Children do not need to know everything about their parents.

54isanopendoor · 18/11/2022 11:49

In your shoes I woudn't try to talk to your Grandmother about it.
she will likely just deny it all. Your Father might feel upset about that too.
You could try to talk to him about it. Or your Aunt.
But they might still try to shield you from it (they have done amazingly well doing this so far & sound like extraordinary people).
But this leaves you with a lot of processing to do.
I'd find a decent counsellor if you can (keep trying if you don't like the 1st one).
You need time & space to grieve the loss of the Grandmother you thought you had. Whether you can '/ wish to preserve your separate relationship with her is something you need time to think through perhaps?

Blossomtoes · 18/11/2022 11:48

Devoutspoken · 18/11/2022 11:38

If the victims have forgiven then you should respect their choices, after all, it's about them, not you

This. And also respect their decision not to talk about it.

SafeMove · 18/11/2022 11:47

I was only slightly physically abused by my DP's so it's a bit different to your experience OP, but my DP's (due to the circumstances they exposed me to and the lack of supervision they chose in their parenting) meant that decisions they made directly led to me experience CSA for a long period of my childhood.

I don't know how your Dad would feel but from my POV I would really dislike my DC trying to talk to me about my childhood (I have fiercely protected them from the very adult themes of my childhood). It isn't really my DC's job to understand or sympathise or empathise with me. I am their Mum. My trauma is not theirs to deal with. I understand that you might have strong feelings on it OP but if you take away your Dad's autonomy and power on this it isn't the kindness you think it is. I understand you might want to defend him or show him that you have taken him seriously, but again from my POV, people who have found out, reacted and took it upon themselves to take up my 'cause' have done more harm than good. Often it felt that they were doing it to make themselves feel better and less shocked instead of thinking what was best for me. Dredging up painful memories and opening up old wounds is extremely difficult for people with trauma. I would not advocate doing that without express permission tbh.

Fleurdaisy · 18/11/2022 11:46

willingtolearn · 18/11/2022 10:19

I think it's amazing that your Dad has managed to forgive her and allow you a relationship with her. It's also fantastic that he has managed to break the cycle of violence and be a good parent. Please appreciate how hard that is to do, when your experience of being parented is so negative.

I would find it impossible not to draw back from a person who had done this. I would not be able to take their advice or allow them to make judgments about my life decisions without having this in my head.

Can you talk to your Dad about it? Has she apologised to him or explained what was going on in her life to make her act in this way (not that I can see any reason to ever treat children like this).

I think you should have all the time in the world for you Dad and do anything you can to support him.

This.
I think it would really hurt your dad if you questioned your gm but at the same time it’s hard for you to still see her as a loving, caring person.
Maybe distance yourself from her as much as you comfortably can.

BittenontheBum · 18/11/2022 11:44

My grandfather abused all but one (the intelligent child) of his children. My father passed that on. My grandfather also mentally (and maybe physically I don't know) abused my grandmother too. He was a nasty fucker. He didn't like me either 🤷🏻‍♀️ two of my siblings were ok to go there anytime. He treated me with contempt and I didn't understand it. I do now. I was suffering from abuse and was an angry child.
Still his problem, maybe he realised he'd passed that shit on.
If this is something you recently discovered and up until that point had a loving relationship with her then that will be a very difficult situation to be in. I really don't know what I would do. It's unfortunate you don't think your father is open to a conversation.
Very sad for you.
But your father sounds like a LEGEND 💪🌟

Logsandcogs · 18/11/2022 11:43

RandomMusings7 · 18/11/2022 11:12

This happened in a time where corporal punishment was common and seen as good practice, yes.

However, the abuse here goes much further than that. What context could there be to explain a mother locking a child in a cabinet? A mother forcing one kid to hold his sibling down while she was being hit with a belt?

Absolutely no context or previous trauma or mental illness can excuse such acts.

This. There is extent of abuse here that goes to cruelty and meanness beyond the times. Even if her husband abused her, taking it out on defenseless children shows evil character under the surface. There's no excuse here. She must've known what she was doing. I couldn't look at her or be near her. Has she ever been held accountable?

It's a hard one. On the one hand you don't want to open old wounds for your dad, on the other hand you may feel this woman must be confronted. I'd try gently talking to your dad op, perhaps he needs the conversation with a safe, loved, trusted daughter and doesn't know it. I'd definitely not see her anymore, and I'm not advising you to, but I'd confront her, but that's just how I am...

username8888 · 18/11/2022 11:43

I'd cut off contact. Nasty

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 18/11/2022 11:42

Without wanting to go into too much detail: I have had a similar thing. I strongly suspect my lovely granddad abused his children in some way - they all referred to having Upsetting Childhoods - and this is probably why my dad abused me. In my case I didn't find this out until after he was dead but I just wanted to say I've been there and it is really destabilising and awful.

RowanAspenOak · 18/11/2022 11:41

Mirabai · 18/11/2022 11:29

I understand your dad is very closed, mine is too. But in this situation I would talk to my father about it. I would say - this is what I have now learnt about your mother/childhood, and I’m having trouble processing it. How did you come to terms with it and you would you advise me to do?

I would do this too.
I also wonder about mental health, abusive behaviour in your Grandmother’s childhood etc.
I knew someone with an abusive mother, but her Mum had been sexually abused in childhood, and had serious mental health issues as a consequence. As your father allowed you a relationship with her, and that has been a kind one, I wonder if she deeply regrets how she treated her children. I have a friend whose father was like this, really terrible. As an adult he had a very good relationship with him, his father completely changed as he got older, possibly he addressed the reasons for his horrendous behaviour, but for whatever reason he became an easy going man, who was a nice grandfather. I was shocked, as I met my friend before this happened. My friend is a very forgiving man, and is happy that things changed.

Thereisnolight · 18/11/2022 11:39

I didn’t see the part about making him hold his younger sister down to be beaten or be beaten himself.
If this is true it goes beyond being young and tired and the spare the rod and spoil the child mentality that was prevalent at the time. Imo this is very nasty behaviour. She was trying to drive a wedge between the two children. If I knew that to be true about someone I couldn’t overlook it.

Melsuleenia · 18/11/2022 11:39

Cakecakecheese · 18/11/2022 10:51

When I was a teenager my mum worked in a care home for the elderly and I'd occasionally go in to help out. There was a couple in there who both had dementia, they seemed very sweet and had family who often visited. My mum told me that one of the daughters had said that the man actually wasn't very nice before he got old and was quite abusive to his children. It can be really hard to equate a sweet old person to someone who was horrible and abusive. Your grandmother is probably a very different person now to when your dad was growing up. Not that it makes what she did to your dad and aunt at all forgivable.

A good observation. I have heard of this as well. In my own estimation it can go one of two ways when someone who has NPD get's very old. They either go much worse (like my own Dad) or they appear to improve. That makes it very difficult to reconcile what's going on if you didn't have prior knowledge. I would say that the difference here between how my dad behaves and the man in the care home is how much access both of them have to other people. In a care home there are lots of people around which equals fuel or narc supply. My dad is actually very isolated and his behaviour is escalating. Again, it's fuel or energy.

OP. I am sorry. Must have been a tremendous shock to the system. There is zero point confronting your gran because you will be hit by the devils' pitch-fork. Denial or deflection. Essentially, you will never get a straight answer.

I really recommend H G Tudor's book, 'Fuel' to understand how and why certain people behave the way they do. NPD is now out of control in our society and is threatening everything. You sound to me like a decent and kind individual. It will not only hep you resolve the dynamic with your gran (ie NC or a very low NC) and also resolve why your father behaved the way that he did.

It does very much bare repeating that people who are abused are often more frightened of other peoples' reactions than the abuse itself. We are simply not believed by a very significant minority. Guess who don't believe us? The abusers.

Devoutspoken · 18/11/2022 11:38

If the victims have forgiven then you should respect their choices, after all, it's about them, not you

OldFan · 18/11/2022 11:37

She presumably has changed if you haven't seen the abusive behaviour.

My dad used to be a bit nasty but he's mellowed somewhat with age.

LizzieSiddal · 18/11/2022 11:36

My dh had a similar abusive childhood which he didn’t fully tell me about until we’d been married for twenty years! It was him going to therapy which allowed him to talk about the details to me (many which I found extremely distressing to hear).
Dh has a very complex relationship with them now, he is always there for them (Mil is recovering from cancer, FIL has Parkinson’s,) he’s even asked them to move closer to us so he can do more. I really don’t know how he does it, tbh I dislike them both very much for what they did to my dh, but I have in the past let him take the lead.
Recently though I’ve had to make him realise the effect it has on him, he often comes away for their home very angry with them, there’s things going on at the moment which mean they need more help, but I’ve persuaded dh to ask them to get paid help in, which they can easily afford, as the situation is really affecting him, and he has a good life to lead without being constantly reminded of his awful childhood.

Like your dad, my DH is the kindest person, he loves his DDs to bits, and they love him to bits, he’s definitely broken that cycle too.

StillTryingtoBuy · 18/11/2022 11:36

This must be so, so upsetting. Like some others on the thread I’m wondering who told you all of this? Were they also children at the time or adults? Was it is widely known this was happening, within your dad’s family? Whoever told you, what relationship do they now have with your granny?

I understand your preference not to talk to your dad but I really think it’s important that you do. For your own understanding of your family and to allow him to have a voice in all this too. And to deepen your understanding of his childhood and life, really.

Duchese · 18/11/2022 11:34

I am sorry for the little boy your dad was and the little girl your aunt was.

Duchese · 18/11/2022 11:32

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 10:49

What reason could anyone possibly have for getting their 7yo son to choose between holding his 4yo sister down whilst she's beaten with a belt buckle or refusing and both being beaten?

This is too cruel, I have an almost 7 and almost 5 years old and cannot imagine the scene you have set. It is too cruel. Stop talking to her, cut all contact and let her rot and die a lonely death. People like this don't deserve any sympathy.