Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you cope knowing this about your grandmother?

158 replies

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 10:02

Grandmother lives in a different city and I haven't seen her for a couple of years. Always had a lot of love for her and she's always been wonderful to me. As I've gotten older though and as the adults in my family have started talking to me more about things a child would be sheltered from, I've come to learn that the reason my father and aunt are so messed up psychologically is because my grandmother abused them horrifically.

They were terrified of her. She would beat them with wood and belt buckles. If they spoke out of tone they would be put in a cold bath. Locked in cupboards, kicked, starved etc. Obviously as a child I did not know this, but I always knew my dad struggled with his mental health and was quite closed off emotionally (not all the time, he's NEVER been abusive, he's a wonderful father).

I really struggle now having learnt that she abused someone I love so much to the extent that he still struggles a lot as an adult, and my aunt who I also adore is very psychologically damaged.

Suddenly feel a but numb to who was once my lovely grandma who could do no wrong.

OP posts:
Janbohonut · 18/11/2022 12:28

OK, ok, don't know that contraception was being withheld, I will give you that, but if he's in his early sixties then we are talking about him being born in about 1960 and I'm not sure that women had quite so much control over their fertility back then, given that the Pill was first made available in 1960.

In terms of what women's role was expected to be and how they were expected to behave and what kinds of hopes they could have for their lives it was a very different time.

I'm not saying what she did was excusable. I'm saying that thinking about the world she grew up in might make it easier to empathise, if not forgive. As her father has done. I think that may be the most peaceful path forward for the OP.

Mirabai · 18/11/2022 12:27

Do not contact your grandmother full stop. But especially without your father’s knowledge.

BobDear · 18/11/2022 12:25

In terms of practically what I'd do, I'd probably write a letter. I'd not get too much into details but something along the lines of:

Dear Grandma

I recently found out some things about Dad and Auntie XXX's childhood which have shocked and upset me deeply. Whilst I understand that there may have been factors that influenced you and contributed to what happened, this is all new to me and I need some time to process it. I still love you very much but I don't yet know how or if I will be able to reconcile everything.

I would be open to talking to you about it but I don't want to upset my Dad who has never been anything than wonderful to me.

Best wishes
OP

Doodadoo · 18/11/2022 12:24

diddl · 18/11/2022 12:17

Sorry, just seen that your dad is early 60s.

Similar age to me!

I don't think that this level of abuse was commonplace.

The odd smack yes.

It wasn't commonplace and when people hear about smacking, they think of smacking a toddler's hand in fear, when they can see that they're about to run onto a road or something.

The type of abuse that the OP's lovely Dad experienced is very different to smacking. You don't have to have committed a crime. You live on your wits to avoid the next outburst.

The abuse of me was constant and brutal. Your entire life is lived in fear. You function on a primordial level of survival. Very often, divisions are made between siblings and the other parent. It's deliberate and horrendous. Some survive it, some don't.

While I know that you think your Dad wants you to have a relationship with your grandmother, if he knew that that relationship was causing you stress, he would not want you to.

People like that have a way of manipulating to their dying day.

IhearyouClemFandango · 18/11/2022 12:23

Not at all, but you said contraception etc was being withheld…which the OP hasn’t said at all. Not sure how pointing that out is ‘looking for a fight’ tbh.

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 12:23

Not sure if it makes a difference that she's from Trinidad and was born and raised there. I know very little about the culture.

OP posts:
Janbohonut · 18/11/2022 12:22

IhearyouClemFandango Bit nitpicky and don't know if you're just looking for fights but by definition if someone is being abusive they are not mentally well. Healthy people don't abuse others. She was also in an abusive relationship herself which would have made parenting a nightmare.

Secretusername3 · 18/11/2022 12:19

One set of grandparents were both abusive to one of my parents, so I know about the shock OP, although I found out as a teenager so still relatively young. I did still go to see my grandmother, as my grandfather had died before I was born, but only once a year when I was visiting other relatives. I went to her funeral, and basically kept my own feelings at bay and distanced myself emotionally. I chose to instead make everything a lot easier for my parent, and did not bring it up with my Gran ever, although I also did not pretend that I loved her, which I did not anymore. I was just polite and visited so as not to make it obvious and awkward for my parent.

I saw my job as 100% supporting the parent who had been abused, which included just listening to them, being there for them. My parent chose to understand and forgive, in a complicated way that I struggle to understand myself, they felt more anger with my grandmother who was not as bad as my grandfather for example. BUT I did not question their own reaction, and I always respected that it was THEIR abuse and their way of handling it. My parent did not abuse me, and broke the cycle, and I have told her a million times how great they are.

One thing I did find is that I did realize that my upbringing wasn’t as solid as I thought it was, not abuse or neglect but my parent struggled, and I grew up too fast and took on too much responsibility too young. However I can see my parent did the absolute best that they could, within their own circumstances, and so I will never bring this up, their life was hard enough. I do though bring my children up in a different way, hopefully finally completely breaking the cycle so that my kids didn’t even have to grow up fast, they could just be kids.

IveDroppedMiBiscuitInMiBrew · 18/11/2022 12:19

I'd have to tell her what you have found out and ask her what she has to say about it? I'd then tell her unfortunately you can't continue contact and walk away. I'd also be furious your dad let her have a relationship with you, were you ever left alone with her as a child? She should have been locked up for child abuse. She might be your gran and a cute old lady but she must be rotten to the core to do that to anyone, let alone her own children. Your poor dad and aunty.

diddl · 18/11/2022 12:17

Sorry, just seen that your dad is early 60s.

Similar age to me!

I don't think that this level of abuse was commonplace.

The odd smack yes.

IhearyouClemFandango · 18/11/2022 12:14

Agree with people above who have said to understand her context - not to forgive her but to understand that she was being abused in a very bad state mentally and unable to parent, but no choice as no contraception and no way out.

The OP didn’t say any of this though, just that her partner was abusive.

diddl · 18/11/2022 12:14

So she not only abused them both she involved the one in the abuse of the other.

I couldn't see her again tbh.

I'd also be quite upset that he had let her in my life.

How old is she?

sallywinter · 18/11/2022 12:14

I wouldn’t leave my child with her.

Janbohonut · 18/11/2022 12:12

Agree with people above who have said to understand her context - not to forgive her but to understand that she was being abused in a very bad state mentally and unable to parent, but no choice as no contraception and no way out.

Some people just aren't able to be parents - they don't have the emotional resources or the blueprint, i can see this in several women I know from that generation and it's easy to hate them but harder to try and imagine them as children and the kind of world they grew up in, in the aftermath of WW2. Sometimes they are badly parented themselves and unless some other parent figure steps in and shows them love they have nothing to pass on - it's not there. And they can't deal with anyone needing it from them.

If he has forgiven her that is incredible and would be just as healing for him as it is for her. I would try very hard to see if you can do the same.

Fifthtimelucky · 18/11/2022 12:11

I'm around your Dad's age, OP, and this wasn't normal then. Yes, smacking was common, but not this sort of abuse.

I loved my maternal grandfather (born in the 1890s) and only found when I was an adult that he had beaten my mother when she was a child. Nothing nearly as bad as what your poor father experienced, but it still surprised me hugely, because he always seemed such a gentle and kind man. She didn't tell me until some time after he had died.

I did wonder whether his experience in the trenches during the First World War might have brutalised him, but I have no idea. Perhaps your grandmother's behaviour was partly a response to the abuse she suffered herself. Of course that is not an excuse or a justification. Her behaviour was appalling; I would have said unforgivable if it wasn't for the fact that your father had forgiven it.

I think as it was many years ago and she has not shown any signs of abusive behaviour recently, I would try not to let it affect your relationship, especially as you don't see her often and your father clearly wanted you to have a relationship with her.

That won't be easy though. It's the sort of thing that once you know it will be impossible to forget.

Redbushteaforme · 18/11/2022 12:11

She presumably has changed if you haven't seen the abusive behaviour.

In my experience, some people are very good at keeping their abusive behaviour for certain people while being unfailingly charming to others.

OP: you don't see this woman often so it should be easy to continue not having much contact with her if you don't want to. Your dad sounds amazing. I would personally follow his lead and not discuss her with him unless he raises the issue first.

gogohmm · 18/11/2022 12:10

It is troubling isn't it. It is partly an "of the times" situation, my dp was hit with a belt and his mother was very absent emotionally, he struggles to this day, but her behaviour wasn't abnormal he's knows from his peers

IhearyouClemFandango · 18/11/2022 12:10

I think there is a difference between spanking/corporal punishment…which whatever our feelings was once deemed totally acceptable and good ‘discipline’ and abuse.

What you are describing is the latter, and I couldn’t forgive or have that person in my life. Your dad gets to make his choices about forgiveness etc, and you get to choose who is in your life. No song and dance, no dragging things up with dad/aunt, but I wouldn’t have any involvement with her.

Psychological cruelty and violence is not discipline, whatever era you grew up in.

Logsandcogs · 18/11/2022 12:08

@nokidshere , people are different, cultures are different and there's no one binary generic answer anyone here including me and you can give here with absolute certainty... I know in the UK there's the stiff upper lip mentality and keep calm and carry on. I do understand it, but am not like that, and one should accept many others aren't either. Where I'm from people would prefer bringing out in the open by default and that's also not always the best way. Some people may prefer not to open up old wounds, others may feel talking helps.

Others may not know and default to sweeping it under the carpet, and later find out talking actually helped. Only op can gauge her dad's reactions. Humans are complex...

Uninterestedfamily · 18/11/2022 12:07

SomePosters · 18/11/2022 10:32

Hi op

wothout going into all the grim details I know what you’re going through.

i am no contact with both my grandparents due to their treatment of my mum.
She has a relationship with one of them and is no contact with the other.
They are both beyond forgiveness in my eyes but she needs to believe in the one she maintains a relationship with.

Don’t stick your oar in, it’s you dad it will upset most.

But it’s ok to distance yourself and your family too.

Im not excusing your grandmother but before writing her off completely consider the context she was raising her children in.

No birth control. Can’t say no to your husband. Can’t divorce.
The wider societal attitude was that corporal punishment kept rowdy kids in line and those who didn’t do it were spoiling their kids.
She will have married young by todays standards and had little time to process her own childhood or to see examples of the more gentle parenting we have come to expect.
None of that makes your dads
experiences any less awful for him of course any more than the abuse my granny suffered excuses her treatment of her children but I do think it’s important to judge people by the standards of their time and not ours.

My granny’s trauma can be directly traced to the 2nd world war fallout and I suspect many of us struggling today can follow our generational trauma back to traumatised returning squaddies.

Still doesn’t mean you have to forgive.

I don’t speak to the parent my mum still does despite her wishes.

Your sense of time is way off. If Ops dad is early 60s, then he was born in the 60s, and a child still in the 70s. Divorce was legal (albeit with stigma), contraception was definitely available, and it wasn't normal to beat your children.

emptythelitterbox · 18/11/2022 12:05

Sadly this isn't uncommon in previous generations. I think more people are willing to speak about it these days.

I recall reading my grandmother's diary after she passed. She was locked in the kitchen cupboards.

On my father's side they lived as indentured servants in coal camps and abuse was rampant. Children left school around year 5 to work in the mines or girls worked in the stores or camp kitchens.
No labour laws at the time. Many employees were beaten and abused.

Very different times.
I'd say, if they are no longer like this, try to have some forgiveness.

ItsaMetalBand · 18/11/2022 12:04

If it's inter generational, then I can identify with that. My parents maintained that compared to what they got as punishment as kids, they were soft as fuck with us... still got beatings though when our own peers were getting pocket money suspended or getting grounded.

I struggle with a relationship with my DM (DF died some years ago) I struggle that she thinks she was a brilliant mum whereas my opinion was that mostly she was adequate but frequently poor in that role.

But it's not my son's fight. He has a minimal enough relationship with her. I'm sure if I ever told him the details he would be shocked and appalled at what granny did to us all but tbh it didn't happen to him, I'm doing everything I can to ensure that the poor parenting doesn't carry though to this generation.

Tigofigo · 18/11/2022 12:03

Mirabai · 18/11/2022 11:29

I understand your dad is very closed, mine is too. But in this situation I would talk to my father about it. I would say - this is what I have now learnt about your mother/childhood, and I’m having trouble processing it. How did you come to terms with it and you would you advise me to do?

I'm not sure this is a good idea.

The dad and granny could still be in an abuse dynamic where he fears her or is in some weird way still trying to please her.

Had the granny ever apologised or made amends?

Personally I'd go NC or very very low contact. I just couldn't look at them in the same way. This was extensive physical and mental abuse, and neglect, over a long period of time.

daisychain01 · 18/11/2022 12:02

I'd want to find out more, as this

Always had a lot of love for her and she's always been wonderful to me

is incongruous and at odds with the woman physically abusing her children to the extent you describe. Anyone who has the capacity to do that would have to have a personality bypass to be "wonderful" to other people. They can run but they can't hide, they'd be found out and the mask would slip.

it may be incredibly difficult to broach the subject with your grandmother direct, but somehow you need to find out the truth from her as to why she behaved in such a cruel way and can still live with herself.

PassThePringles · 18/11/2022 11:56

I can relate. The abuse wasn't as bad as yours but my parent went through similar. Yet my dgp was always so warm and loving towards us gc. It's hard... I want to resent dgp for messing my parent up, I'm nc with my parent now because those issues made it very difficult... But somehow I can't hate either of them. I wish with all my heart that dgp had raised my parent right, so then I'd have had a better, more stable upbringing too... I can't resent my loving dgp though, i believe it all happened but I have never seen that side so it's hard... I can only rationalise it in that my dgp had so many children and struggled to take care of them all so being super strict worked to keep the peace... Which breaks my heart. Sorry about your situation op, it's absolutely disgusting but massive respect to your df... It's so hard to break the generational curse, I suppose I'd focus on how amazing your df is to not repeat history. Unfortunately, mine is and can't even see it.