Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you cope knowing this about your grandmother?

158 replies

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 10:02

Grandmother lives in a different city and I haven't seen her for a couple of years. Always had a lot of love for her and she's always been wonderful to me. As I've gotten older though and as the adults in my family have started talking to me more about things a child would be sheltered from, I've come to learn that the reason my father and aunt are so messed up psychologically is because my grandmother abused them horrifically.

They were terrified of her. She would beat them with wood and belt buckles. If they spoke out of tone they would be put in a cold bath. Locked in cupboards, kicked, starved etc. Obviously as a child I did not know this, but I always knew my dad struggled with his mental health and was quite closed off emotionally (not all the time, he's NEVER been abusive, he's a wonderful father).

I really struggle now having learnt that she abused someone I love so much to the extent that he still struggles a lot as an adult, and my aunt who I also adore is very psychologically damaged.

Suddenly feel a but numb to who was once my lovely grandma who could do no wrong.

OP posts:
FingersInTheBin · 18/11/2022 13:44

Doubtmyself · 18/11/2022 13:38

My parents are from the West Indies, and they were very strict with me, my Dad never touched me, but used to lecture me a lot and was very strict on going out as a teenager ( all of us went to University and got good jobs, grew up in a poor area) My mum used to beat me at least once a week, with broomsticks, tennis rackets, real abuse. I've forgiven her and she has a wonderful relationship with my DC, who haven't a clue.

I forgave my mother as she told me what her parents did to her back in the Caribbean, which was on another level. My gran once stripped my mother and whipped her with a piece of wire in the street at 14 when she went out partying and came home late when she should of been cooking and cleaning in the house.

Caribbean culture is matriachal where the mother uses beatings for discipline, all of the punishment (abuse) never came out of nowhere, it was for being rude, not doing house work, getting in trouble at school, etc.

Today we call it abuse. The beatings I got as a kid would be grounds for prosecution , and me getting taken into care today, the beatings my mother got would be grounds for imprisonment!

As a family we have all moved on, I forgive my mother and because she has forgiven my gran, so have I.

It was wrong, evil even, but it belonged to an old culture of voilence, Trinidad's voilent slave history and common ideas about spare the rod and spoil the child- an old English saying, remember we only banned corporal punishment in schools in 1986 here! Corporal punishment is still legal in many Caribbean schools, but that's the case still in 19 states in America, lets not forget.

Move on and forgive your gran if your Dad has. She misguidely thought she was doing the right thing.

Sending you love. Slowly, we are breaking the childhood traumas and doing better with every new generation born. It takes a strong person to forgive and even understand.

FingersInTheBin · 18/11/2022 13:42

Hello OP,

I’ve been where you are. I found out my grandfather used to abuse my grandmother. And another, even worse, awful family secret. It’s a shocker when you discover something like this out, it makes you evaluate then as a person and your relationship with them.

I don’t know all the details but the violence stopped and my grandmother forgave him, his DC, my parent and their siblings all forgave them and they went on and had a happy life and they loved each other and cared for each other.

Its not my place to start questioning that so I’ve never said or done anything, I’ve simply carried on as normal and I don’t think about it. It has taken some adjustment in my brain, but I think any other reaction would have upset the family.

I hope you find some closure. Xx

Doubtmyself · 18/11/2022 13:38

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 12:23

Not sure if it makes a difference that she's from Trinidad and was born and raised there. I know very little about the culture.

My parents are from the West Indies, and they were very strict with me, my Dad never touched me, but used to lecture me a lot and was very strict on going out as a teenager ( all of us went to University and got good jobs, grew up in a poor area) My mum used to beat me at least once a week, with broomsticks, tennis rackets, real abuse. I've forgiven her and she has a wonderful relationship with my DC, who haven't a clue.

I forgave my mother as she told me what her parents did to her back in the Caribbean, which was on another level. My gran once stripped my mother and whipped her with a piece of wire in the street at 14 when she went out partying and came home late when she should of been cooking and cleaning in the house.

Caribbean culture is matriachal where the mother uses beatings for discipline, all of the punishment (abuse) never came out of nowhere, it was for being rude, not doing house work, getting in trouble at school, etc.

Today we call it abuse. The beatings I got as a kid would be grounds for prosecution , and me getting taken into care today, the beatings my mother got would be grounds for imprisonment!

As a family we have all moved on, I forgive my mother and because she has forgiven my gran, so have I.

It was wrong, evil even, but it belonged to an old culture of voilence, Trinidad's voilent slave history and common ideas about spare the rod and spoil the child- an old English saying, remember we only banned corporal punishment in schools in 1986 here! Corporal punishment is still legal in many Caribbean schools, but that's the case still in 19 states in America, lets not forget.

Move on and forgive your gran if your Dad has. She misguidely thought she was doing the right thing.

RedHelenB · 18/11/2022 13:37

RambamThankyouMam · 18/11/2022 10:20

I wouldn't be able to continue having a relationship with her.

Why? She's been loving to OP and the person she wasn't loving to has forgiven her

Melonapplepear · 18/11/2022 13:32

@IrrelevantNameChange thank you 💐

latetothefisting · 18/11/2022 13:30

Devoutspoken · 18/11/2022 11:38

If the victims have forgiven then you should respect their choices, after all, it's about them, not you

I agree with this. If you love and respect your dad so much you should prioritise his wishes over yours if at all possible.

All the posters saying they couldn't speak to her, would let her rot etc are basically encouraging causing your dad stress and pain as he's going to be the one in the middle if you start refusing to see her when she asks to see you, not visiting him at Christmas if she's there etc.

I think you need to start considering what your hard boundaries are. For example if your grandmother needs care in the future and your dad and aunt provide it, will you help them out or prioritise your own feelings by letting them do it all alone? If you feel you physically would not be able to provide care to your gran herself would you be able to do the admin/finance elements or clean the house etc? Can you reframe this in your mind as helping them rather that her?

I'm not saying it's easy but you can't go back in time and help the little boy your dad was, all you can do is support your dad now, but to do this his wishes, whatever they need to be, should take precedence over your feelings.

Pinkittens · 18/11/2022 13:29

You say the abuse happened from being small to teens. It's possible that during late teens/early 20s/30s your GM changed, repaired her ways and the relationship improved. You say she's always been wonderful to you so she didn't carry on the abusive behaviour beyond a certain point, or in a way you were aware of.

Your dad sounds a wonderful man who has worked hard to be a loving parent himself despite his childhood experiences. Perhaps he has found some healing through seeing your GM be a wonderful grandparent, even if he didn't experience that himself from her as a child. Perhaps with the passing of time he is aware of pressures on her life at the time which partly made her act how she did. Perhaps he has actively chosen to forgive and move on. Perhaps she had experienced the same in her own childhood and had no clue how to be different. People's pasts can be littered with tragedies unknown to others.

Possibly he talks with your aunt about their childhood and shared experiences, and doesn't need to share with anyone beyond that and he gets some peace from things being loving and settled now. Sometimes people really don't want to go deep into their past, especially with their children, but can find that a word or two that shows someone understands something wasn't all sunshine and roses, without forcing any details, very comforting.

IrrelevantNameChange · 18/11/2022 13:28

thats kind of you @Melonapplepear . I’m sure your awareness of your experiences will ensure you don’t repeat the patterns, you sound very insightful and that’s half the battle xx

Melonapplepear · 18/11/2022 13:21

IrrelevantNameChange · 18/11/2022 13:13

Without going into detail, when I found out something similar, I just withdrew from my Nanna. My heart breaks for my mum, and even though I can see that my Nanna had as tough a time from her own mother, I just can’t forgive her. My poor mum suffered so much, but she tried very hard to do her best by her children, she isn’t perfect but she did break the cycle of generational trauma.

This is what I am trying to do myself. I'm not abusive but I know my abuse has lead to certain emotional responses. Like I know I'm not good at outwardly expressing emotion etc. Well done to your mum I know how tough it is 💜

Melonapplepear · 18/11/2022 13:20

I had a very abusive mother, I haven't forgiven her and I don't think I will. Tbh lots of things in life can be forgiven for me but not a campaign of abuse. I've not seen her in many years. So I appreciate that I'm not impartial here as it's so personal to me but I wouldn't be to have a relationship with a history of abusive behaviour.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 18/11/2022 13:14

You say you haven't seen her for a couple of years so it doesn't sound like you're very close anyway.

Just leave it. You can reduce contact (what little there is) without explaining why.

This isn't your story or your experience. If your Dad has managed to forgive her, then don't make it about you and drag it all back up again.

IrrelevantNameChange · 18/11/2022 13:13

Without going into detail, when I found out something similar, I just withdrew from my Nanna. My heart breaks for my mum, and even though I can see that my Nanna had as tough a time from her own mother, I just can’t forgive her. My poor mum suffered so much, but she tried very hard to do her best by her children, she isn’t perfect but she did break the cycle of generational trauma.

Whydidimarryhim · 18/11/2022 13:11

Yes your father has done a remarkable job on himself to forgive his mother - her behaviour was insane and cruel. Yes it will be linked to how she was parented or not.
However, your father will have been damaged by his upbringing. My siblings and I experienced a traumatic child hood. We are certainly all damaged in some ways from psychosis to alcoholism to suicide. I most certainly blame my father. We where taught not to trust and not to feel. You could not need in that environment. I’ve done well considering but I struggle with relationships mainly men.
I could not have anything to do with your grand mother unless she has made amends to your Dad and sought therapy or attended a 12 step group such as Adult children of alcoholics AND dysfunctional families. You will be in shock - the grand mother you loved treating her own child in that way.
My father was pleasant to most adults he engaged with - the family secrets where kept with the don’t talk don’t trust and don’t feel.
Your dad has broken the chain of abuse - how wonderful.- You need time to process this and come to your own conclusion.🌺

Doodadoo · 18/11/2022 13:06

LemonDrop22 · 18/11/2022 13:04

Could you maybe ask your grandmother about this?

Yeah, don't do this.

She either have convenient amnesia, or deny or minimise or justify or say "I did what I thought was right at the time". "It was normal at the time".

The most soul destroying thing to hear as the survivor.

LemonDrop22 · 18/11/2022 13:04

Could you maybe ask your grandmother about this?

Yeah, don't do this.

She either have convenient amnesia, or deny or minimise or justify or say "I did what I thought was right at the time". "It was normal at the time".

beastlyslumber · 18/11/2022 13:03

That's tough, OP. It sounds like if you said anything to your gran or broke contact with her, it would hurt your dad.

I might be tempted to ask her about what kind of a mother she thought she was. She might be sorry now for how she raised her children. You could make an opening for her to talk about that, if you felt so inclined.

Ultimately, you can't forgive her or condemn her on your dad's behalf. But you can decide what kind of a relationship you want with her, how much you trust her, and how much access she has to your and your children's lives. You don't have to be unkind, but you can withdraw as much as you feel appropriate.

Softplayhooray · 18/11/2022 13:00

That must be a horrible shock OP, I'm so sorry. It must shake the view of everything you've known.

Can I just say what an incredible father you have. To be a wonderful father himself and to have completely insulated you from the truth for all these years makes him a really special man.

If it were me (just my own opinion), I'd cut her off on the spot and never speak to her again.

SayMumOneMoreTime · 18/11/2022 12:55

Hi OP, I have had basically the same experience. It's shocking and disorientating to find out this kind of thing.

I have had many years to process this about my family, and my perspective now is that my Grandma must have had an awful time of it as a child too, and certainly a frustrated life as a housewife and mother. I even suspect she was sexually abused by her uncle. She did the best she could in her specific circumstances, and my dad and uncles had a terrible childhood with far reaching consequences.

I think finding compassion for all involved is the best way to make peace within yourself. Your Grandma was a wonderful grandmother to you, and an abusive mother to your dad. She is both of those people. We are all complex products of our whole experience, no person is wholly good or wholly bad.

Your dad has managed to break the cycle of abuse which is admirable. How amazing that you have had no idea until now what the family history was. It's right and appropriate that you feel so sad for your dad as a child, but he is a grown man with a happy life - he has saved himself, and you do not need to save him or be on his 'side'. He is also a product of his experience.

In a nutshell, never judge a person until you have walked a mile in their shoes. Forgive Grandma, it is the way to peace.

butterfliedtwo · 18/11/2022 12:52

No confrontation but also no relationship. I'd not confront out of respect for your father's desire not to talk about it. It's not fair on him or your aunt to drag this up. That kind of action would have to come from them, in my opinion.

nokidshere · 18/11/2022 12:47

@nokidshere , people are different, cultures are different and there's no one binary generic answer anyone here including me and you can give here with absolute certainty... I know in the UK there's the stiff upper lip mentality and keep calm and carry on. I do understand it, but am not like that, and one should accept many others aren't either. Where I'm from people would prefer bringing out in the open by default and that's also not always the best way. Some people may prefer not to open up old wounds, others may feel talking helps.

I disagree. This isn't about culture it's about her dad having not told her and making it clear to people he knows that he doesn't want to talk about it.

It doesn't matter if he's from somewhere that discusses such things or somewhere that doesn't, if he had wanted her to know he would have told her already. The decision to bring it up is his alone, it's not for his daughter to force him to remember or talk about.

My children have a sanitised version of my childhood. They do not need to know that as a 7yr old I was dragged out of bed in the middle of the night and made to sit and watch my mother being beaten and kicked half to death (and that was one of the less traumatic bits) why would they need to know that? What are they going to do with that information? They know my dad was horrible and that's all they need to know. If they came and said 'we have heard x from x tell us more' I would still not give them details, it's my trauma not theirs and there is no value in them knowing the details, ever.

I don't disagree that these things sometimes need to be out in the open but that's for the person who suffered the trauma to decide if and when, not anyone else.

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 18/11/2022 12:36

Usernamesarboring · 18/11/2022 11:50

By your logic all the racist things people did in past was all ok because it was accepted in the society?

Every violent person has a history of problem themselves. Gm here belted her kids, if they spoke in wrong tone put them in cold baths, not given food, locked in cupboard. How much anger a person must have to inflict this on little children. I am sure kids must be crying, screaming, and she continued. I dont think I would see Gm in the same light as before. I may not confront her but i would have a less affectionate relationship with a person like that.
There is no need for us to use our imagination to create a picture in order to justify abuse, especially towards helpless children. There were plenty of parents back then who didnt belt or starved their kids.

The abuse must be out of the norm even for those times that both children had serious mental health issues as adults.

@elephantonacid i would not confront, rather have a non emotional relationship with her.

Yes I agree - I am slightly older than OP's father and do not recognise much of this background. There was contraception, just not the pill (till later) - my mother told me they had to take "double precautions" which I assume would be condoms and a contraceptive cap or similar. Physical punishment in the home wasn't the norm, certainly where I lived, although it did exist in schools.

Whatever the reasons she had for behaving like this, I agree with PP that to question her or make a point of ignoring her now would only make things worse for your Dad, but I certainly wouldn't be looking to see her separately from him or from the usual family occasions.

CatJumperTwat · 18/11/2022 12:32

I was incredibly close to my nan. She looked after me when I was little so my (single) mum could work, and she was like a second parent.

My mum is quite messed up because of her childhood. She was one of eight children raised in a three-bed house and didn't get an adequate share of love and attention. She can't show physical affection and has literally never hugged me, took until I was in my 30s for her to say she loved me.

I had a fairly messed up childhood because of it. I don't hold it against either of them; they both did the best with what they had.

Your situation is different. Beating and starving a child takes deliberate thought, rather than being physically unable to give enough time or emotionally unable to show affection. I'd find it a lot harder to forgive that.

Usernamesarboring · 18/11/2022 12:30

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 10:49

What reason could anyone possibly have for getting their 7yo son to choose between holding his 4yo sister down whilst she's beaten with a belt buckle or refusing and both being beaten?

Op, I agree with you that it was horrible and there is no justification.

Your father has a big heart to be able to forgive this and not carry resentment. You should not force yourself to behave in certain way, do what you feel naturally. There is no right or wrong here.

Doodadoo · 18/11/2022 12:30

elephantonacid · 18/11/2022 12:23

Not sure if it makes a difference that she's from Trinidad and was born and raised there. I know very little about the culture.

It possibly explains it somewhat if she came from a long line of slavery generations back (the gift that keeps on giving), but it doesn't excuse it.

Having come from abuse myself, I knew enough to know NOT to do what was done to me. I think people can just simply be cunts.

Muu · 18/11/2022 12:29

I’d probably put my dads feelings first.

he wanted to give you a shot at having a “lovely grandma” which you did, until you learned the truth. That was big of him.