Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think it's ok to excuse aggressive behaviour because of special needs

35 replies

BelleMarionette · 18/11/2022 09:56

I have two autistic children, who are not aggressive. In fact, their disability makes them more vulnerable to aggression and bullying from others.

I have seen more than once though, that they have been attacked, and when the parent of the attacking child is found, they say 'Its ok, they are autistic'

AIBU to think this is not an excuse? If a child is known to be aggressive, then it's all the more reason for parents to supervise and manage there behaviour carefully, rather than excusing it.

I have seen these parents unwilling to correct their child when they are aggressive, or even supervise or remove them from the play area so they don't attack again.

I completely understand how difficult it can be to raise a child with additional needs, but this lack of parental boundaries and supervision, together with facilitating bad behaviour seems completely unacceptable.

It's for this reason that I do not take my children to special needs groups anymore, as they deserve to be safe. They are gentle and don't even hit back. I have had to work on their assertiveness, that it's ok for them to say 'stop' and to move away and speak to an adult.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BeanieTeen · 18/11/2022 16:59

YANBU. I have a nephew who is autistic and has ADHD, my DB and SIL are amazing with him. I think the general consensus and message they give out it is that he may find controlling his behaviour and impulses difficult, but that doesn’t mean he can’t. That’s unfair and unfortunate, he has to in many ways try harder than others, but that’s a fact of life for him unfortunately that he has to deal with and manage. Because as an adult he will have no choice!

SEND2022 · 18/11/2022 16:58

It's really difficult. I have two autistic children 6 and 8.

My 8 year old went through a very physical stage, luckily not with other kids but I certainly get the brunt of it and there was nasty incident involving an adult at school. I always viewed it as we can not excuse her behaviour but we absolutely needed to tackle it differently to how you would an NT child. I worked closely with school and obviously at home and we established what methods she needed. When she was so unpredictable she was always arms reach to not enable her to hurt another child because even though she doesn't, it was still a risk. She is much more of a flight risk so a lot of her behaviour support focuses on that but it still applies.

Having additional needs isn't an excuse, those kids grow into adults in the CJS. It does require different, very individual support to tackle.

My DD is also frequently on the other side. She is a highly vulnerable little girl who can't really keep herself safe with peers, this makes her a target. We had an issue about 18 months ago with one little boy and that has been resolved. We are in the midst of a much more serious one with another lad who targets her. He has assaulted her 5 times in 6 weeks in school, this week this involved deliberately smacking her bum. My DD is now scared to go to school, she is currently barely coping after doing so well for so long. This lad has special needs but the impact on my child has been devastating. Parents aren't working with school because he has special needs.

It's awful all round but excusing it and not tackling it does no one any favours

x2boys · 18/11/2022 16:43

Maybeonedayeventually · 18/11/2022 14:22

I think it's really hard.

It's not OK, but then for lots of parents 'correcting' the behaviour can take months/years/never, so the only way to eliminate the risk is to withdraw socially.

I don't think there is a good answer but asking people with a very profoundly autistic kid not to attend support groups doesn't feel like the right solution.

Tbf and i only speak for my child the special needs groups we have attendeed in.the past ,just cant meet my sons needs ,its not a one size fits all with autism despite s what the groups themselves think ,a lot of the groups put on great activities for children that could partake in groups indepedetly and can concentrate on games etc ,but offer little for my son who is never happier when hes playing with water or spinning to music

Season0fTheWitch · 18/11/2022 14:59

Special needs can be used to explain an attack like that, but not excuse it. Saying "It's okay" because the child is autistic is ridiculous.

IncompleteSenten · 18/11/2022 14:30

Excuse is not acceptable because when the behaviour of someone you are responsible for is a risk to others, you have a duty to step in.

What should be happening is the people whose role it is to support that person should be doing that effectively and anticipating issues as far as possible and managing ones they failed to anticipate.

My sons are both autistic. I took them out of situations the second I could see them going tits up. I didn't put them in situations in the first place if I risk assessed and determined the hazards were too much.

They are adults now. My elder son was extremely aggressive when young but if someone was injured as a result of that it was not my son's fault. It was my failure if I was the one with him, my husband's if he was or his 1:1 if it happened on their watch.

My younger son is currently very volatile. Would it be his fault if he had a complete meltdown, punched someone and ran into the road and got hit by a bus? No. It would be the fault of whoever was with him at the time who failed to understand his triggers, failed to see the escalation, failed to read his distress, failed to remove him from the situation and, ultimately, failed to restrain him.

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 18/11/2022 14:28

I have a young child with additional needs who lashes out physically and I in no way support or excuse this.
She's also been in a position of being regularly hit by another child with additional needs. His Mum in no way condones this.
Another parent whose child has additional needs in the class just shrugs when her child shoves or hits another child.
It's a mixed bunch, but most of us are actually mortified when our child hurts another.

bloodyplanes · 18/11/2022 14:23

I agree op some parents most definitely use it as an " excuse"! My ds has autism among other diagnoses and i have never and would never excuse any aggression like that! He has been aggressive in the past and been made to apologise once he has calmed down. He has now with extensive help learnt to control his behaviour much better and will either warn someone that he needs to be removed from the situation or he will remove himself from the situation!

Maybeonedayeventually · 18/11/2022 14:22

I think it's really hard.

It's not OK, but then for lots of parents 'correcting' the behaviour can take months/years/never, so the only way to eliminate the risk is to withdraw socially.

I don't think there is a good answer but asking people with a very profoundly autistic kid not to attend support groups doesn't feel like the right solution.

LaBellina · 18/11/2022 14:15

Every child, special needs or not, is entitled to a safe environment. Special needs is not an excuse to put up with that right being violated.

orbitalcrisis · 18/11/2022 14:11

My daughter was punched in the face by a 14 year old boy who told her, "My mum says I'm allowed to do that because I have autism." I did consider going and punching him myself (my daughter and I are both autistic but she was not diagnosed at the time) but I didn't see his defence working for me!

GreyTS · 18/11/2022 13:58

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 18/11/2022 11:14

I agree with this. I have 2 autistic children and one is violent. We are a split parent family and have gone as far as having one child in each home as the non-violent child needs to be protected from being attacked.

Oh god that must be so awful, how do you manage to support your angry child while still protecting the vulnerable one, I hope you have support and get a break occasionally

Wishiwasatsoftplay · 18/11/2022 13:53

FatEaredFuck · 18/11/2022 13:28

YABU, I highly doubt that any parent said "It's ok" after they hit your child.

I have 2 autistic children who are non violent. But I've worked in a special school and some children absolutely cannot help lashing out, eg Katie Price's son Harvey.

I don’t doubt, have had this on 2 occasions- I think probably they meant to reassure, rather than to dismiss, but of course, it is dismissive-! I think it comes from a place of stress and I try not to judge, I am also aware that some diagnoses can be hereditary, and would not assume I am dealing with a parent who finds the social niceties of a play park easy to navigate themselves- it’s a lot of assumptions, a lot of generosity in social interactions, and no one is perfect- I tend to teach my dc to move away if they are bothered by another’s behaviour- only once was that not possible- but it should be noted on that occasion the dm refused to stop her larger dc following my son and being violent and insisted that he was ‘just autistic’. Abdicating responsibility to this degree is uncommon, but does happen, in some contexts more that others- for instance I saw far more of this as a teacher than as a parent-!

BelleMarionette · 18/11/2022 13:49

FatEaredFuck · 18/11/2022 13:28

YABU, I highly doubt that any parent said "It's ok" after they hit your child.

I have 2 autistic children who are non violent. But I've worked in a special school and some children absolutely cannot help lashing out, eg Katie Price's son Harvey.

Honestly, this behaviour is pretty common. One mum even refused to remove her child or supervise her, when she was repeatedly hitting different children. She needed and extremely stern talking to and threats of involving the management. It was really difficult to even find her, as she was nowhere near her violent child.

OP posts:
FatEaredFuck · 18/11/2022 13:28

YABU, I highly doubt that any parent said "It's ok" after they hit your child.

I have 2 autistic children who are non violent. But I've worked in a special school and some children absolutely cannot help lashing out, eg Katie Price's son Harvey.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 18/11/2022 13:26

My youngest has autism and ADHD. He has form for aggressive behaviour when he was younger but is less like this now. Because he and those around him have worked hard on helping him make better choices and understand about actions having consequences. That’s what we’ve always taught him- yes, his impulse control isn’t always great but he can choose to not lash out like at others and hurt them.

When he was smaller and was more difficult to reason these things out with, he was watched like a hawk. I was on his arse constantly to jump in when I needed to. Not always successfully, I’m only human, but apologies were always offered and son and I would leave. I would explain to people where appropriate, my son’s issues but not really as an excuse as such, but an explanation as to why he did what he did.

BelleMarionette · 18/11/2022 13:08

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 18/11/2022 11:14

I agree with this. I have 2 autistic children and one is violent. We are a split parent family and have gone as far as having one child in each home as the non-violent child needs to be protected from being attacked.

Sorry to hear this. This must be so tough for you.

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 18/11/2022 13:08

Ohheythereitsme · 18/11/2022 11:09

Manage as much as you like but you can’t make humans stop doing things, other than just removing from society (which I think you’ll agree would be unfair). Yes you can shadow them but ultimately unless you know exactly what they are going to do at every moment there is always opportunity.

Over the years we’ve maintained a high adult ratio. Even so things slip through.

I'm not advocating for removal, just supervision and appropriately reacting if children are violent.

OP posts:
OneRingToRuleThemAll · 18/11/2022 11:14

I agree with this. I have 2 autistic children and one is violent. We are a split parent family and have gone as far as having one child in each home as the non-violent child needs to be protected from being attacked.

Ohheythereitsme · 18/11/2022 11:09

Manage as much as you like but you can’t make humans stop doing things, other than just removing from society (which I think you’ll agree would be unfair). Yes you can shadow them but ultimately unless you know exactly what they are going to do at every moment there is always opportunity.

Over the years we’ve maintained a high adult ratio. Even so things slip through.

x2boys · 18/11/2022 10:54

BelleMarionette · 18/11/2022 10:46

Yes, my children are verbal, but my point was that they struggling with vocalising that they need help. In fact, one of my children can often by non-verbal in situations where she isn't comfortable and regulated.

I totally appreciate there is a spectrum, but all the more important for parents to supervise appropriately according to their child.

Im not disagreeing with you on that point and i dont take my son to places where his behaviour might be unpredictsble ,just pointing out my child doesnt have the cognitive ablity to understand ,why he shouldnt do things

Hankunamatata · 18/11/2022 10:50

No it's not an excuse. It's an explanation but then it's more poor parenting than to do with sen. I helicoptered around mine when they were small as they couldn't be trusted. I still almost risk assess situations subconsciously to make.sure they are and those around them are OK.

BelleMarionette · 18/11/2022 10:46

x2boys · 18/11/2022 10:34

Your children csn say stop and move away and speak to an adult ,my son cant hes 12 and completley non verbal ,i dont take him to places where he might get frustrated and hit out at other children ,but people need to recognise that the autistic spectrum is huge its never an excuse for parents not to monitor their childs behaviour and intervene but it can be a reason for such behaviur

Yes, my children are verbal, but my point was that they struggling with vocalising that they need help. In fact, one of my children can often by non-verbal in situations where she isn't comfortable and regulated.

I totally appreciate there is a spectrum, but all the more important for parents to supervise appropriately according to their child.

OP posts:
DisappearingGirl · 18/11/2022 10:44

If I was to tell them off there and then, it would likely push them into a full meltdown which is going to be distressing for everyone involved, particularly my child. My most likely course of action would be to take them out so they can calm down

I think this is fine though - you're clearly taking your child out of the situation when needed. It's the parents that just let their kid carry on hurting someone else that are the problem, whether the kid has SEN or not

x2boys · 18/11/2022 10:39

KitchenDiscos · 18/11/2022 10:18

YANBU. DD was attacked at school by a child with additional needs and her teacher said this to me as a way of excusing what he had done. It was framed like, if I had a problem with that, then I was a bad person because the boy has special needs. It really pissed me off.

This is on the school ,why didnt they intervene

x2boys · 18/11/2022 10:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Well thats shit parenting nothing to do with autism 🙄