Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy Christmas presents then ask for the money?

42 replies

Balloontshirt · 18/11/2022 08:44

Is this a normal thing that people do? Buying a present for their child and then texting you asking for the money for it as it’s from you. Without any prior notice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RubiesandRose · 18/11/2022 10:42

To be fair if it's a similar price to what you bought last year she may just think she's been super organised and helpful but in general, it's polite to suggest it first or wait to be asked for suggestions!

JoelyJoe · 18/11/2022 10:37

I do a version this with my mum, sister and a very good friend. They might ask "what does DD want for Christmas?" and I'll offer to get something on their behalf and they'll pay me back. I'd never do it without a prior conversation... and only if they bring it up first. Anything else is incredibly presumptuous.

MrsToadflax · 18/11/2022 10:36

You should have said you'd already bought something.

Brightstarowl · 18/11/2022 10:32

Weird and inappropriate.

ChessieDarling · 18/11/2022 10:29

encantorerun · 18/11/2022 10:16

That is SHOCKING! I can't believe they did that. Did your jaw hit the floor??

I expect my expression said a lot. We’ve had a lot of issues between us in the past but we’ve always been so fond of their children, spent a lot of time and effort on our relationship with them all and have bought them lovely presents the last ten years so it really felt like a slap in the face. I was, still am, so hurt that they think so little of our DC.

mondaytosunday · 18/11/2022 10:28

What? Half the joy is choosing just the right present, the second half is watching them open it! I don't want the child thinking I'd bought them X when I was planning on giving them Y. Next year tell her/him that you've already bought the gifts (even if you haven't yet).

Y7drama · 18/11/2022 10:26

I would definitely tell her you’ve already bought something to nip it in the bud.

takeasadsongandmakeitbetter · 18/11/2022 10:23

My parents and in laws request that I choose gifts for our DSs and they give us the money and wrap the gifts. I always check the budget and also check they are happy with the gifts before I buy them. In laws are older and struggle with getting to shops and online shopping and my parents would rather the kids have something they really want and worry they will duplicate. Works for us but always with prior discussion and set budgets. All grandparents pick up little bits for the kids aswell which they choose themselves, I do find it a bit more work for me but definitely better than getting loads of presents the kids don't want!

encantorerun · 18/11/2022 10:16

ChessieDarling · 18/11/2022 09:51

Sounds like my BIL/SIL in a way. Sent us a list of gifts to choose from for their three children, minimum £35 each, so we spent over £100… we got a card for our DCs first birthday, and a tenner pulled from BILs wallet in front of us. So cheeky.
I mean, you’ve already said yes now so don’t know what we can really say but I wouldn’t just transfer them money in the future unless it suits you to do so and the gifts are in your budget.

That is SHOCKING! I can't believe they did that. Did your jaw hit the floor??

satelliteheart · 18/11/2022 10:14

It's pretty rude to just announce it like that. I do always buy my kids gifts from my parents and they give me the money, but this is at their request and we have a set budget so I know I'm not over spending on their behalf. For other family, if they ask for ideas, I send them my kids Amazon wishlists which always have a large price range so they can pick something that fits their budget without an awkward conversation. But lots of people will just choose a gift and that's fine too. Some parents can be super entitled about their kids gifts though so sounds like your sil is one of them

bloodyplanes · 18/11/2022 10:11

Wow that is seriously rude! I would refuse to pay for it out of principle! OP you are making a mistake by letting them get away with it this year because they will keep doing it!

Typo22 · 18/11/2022 10:09

No, I think that's rude.

I don't have any problem with being given a specific thing to buy (I always ask for a direct link to something that the kids actually want) but would be majorly put out if someone had already bought something without my agreement.

I might ask my mum what her budget is (I know normally how much she spends) and then send a link to something I'd seen that mine have asked for. I wouldn't order it until she had agreed she was happy to buy them it and she sends the money over to me (she's in a different country)

MugginsOverEre · 18/11/2022 10:05

I actually did this last night with my mum. We'd been discussing what the kids wanted and she asked me to send her links. I emailed them so she could buy the things herself. I came across a perfume my girls want and it was on a half price offer ending midnight kinda deal so I quickly bought it without checking as it was too late at night. I've told mum that if she wants to give it to the girls then she can transfer me the cash or I'll give it to them. I'm not fussed either way. THAT is okay, only because it was sort of discussed earlier, there's no obligation to pay and I know I've saved mum £20.
But to just buy something and demand the money? I wouldn't be paying. It's bloody rude!

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/11/2022 10:03

If the thing she has bought seems reasonable and costs about what you were planning to pay, I would be fine with it (more than fine, I would be delighted). If it was something I would never buy or more than I wanted to spend, I would say "Oh no, too late! We already have something for him."

But I must say, every year DS gets a lot of well meant gifts that he has no interest in, and doesn't get some things he would love to get, and it always strikes me that the resources could be better used if I had the brass neck to say "Please no more snap circuits or anything STEM as birthday gifts - actually nothing educational. He would love a Fortnite banana pickaxe."

FourTeaFallOut · 18/11/2022 09:58

I think I'd be fine with that, so long as it's in budget. Anything that cuts down on Christmas hassle is fine by me.

SalviaOfficinalis · 18/11/2022 09:56

I’d say “thanks for sorting, are you okay to wrap it too, cheers” 😂
One crossed off the list at least.

CurzonDax · 18/11/2022 09:54

(Apologies for mis-tying a few ' to ; in my above!)

BMW6 · 18/11/2022 09:51

If it cost around the amount I budgeted for I'd go along with it. If it was quite a bit more I'd frankly reply no, I am not spending so much I'll get a present myself within my budget.

ChessieDarling · 18/11/2022 09:51

Sounds like my BIL/SIL in a way. Sent us a list of gifts to choose from for their three children, minimum £35 each, so we spent over £100… we got a card for our DCs first birthday, and a tenner pulled from BILs wallet in front of us. So cheeky.
I mean, you’ve already said yes now so don’t know what we can really say but I wouldn’t just transfer them money in the future unless it suits you to do so and the gifts are in your budget.

CurzonDax · 18/11/2022 09:51

Yeah, my sister does this all the time - she sends me specific items to buy. I put my foot down this year - she sent me a message at start of October with Amazon links, saying, "Not sure if you were thinking about Christmas yet, but this is what I'd like you to get DNs."
I sent her a message back stating that we had;t considered any presents at that point, and therefore hand;t worked out our budget yet. These presents were outside of our budget anyway, but only by a few pounds, but still a few pounds adds up for each individual when both DH and I have large families, which is why we always set a budget for how much we'll spend on individuals. My sister always sends me individual links, and I've had to send her many messages in the past saying, "Sorry, I wasn't expecting to pay that much." (Especially before I met DH, and was living off a single wage, and she has four children.)

Last week (when I was ready to start buying presents), I sent her some ideas, of, "I'm thinking of getting them XYZ - which of these do you think they would prefer/don't already have?" (So essentially my compromise was sending a few suggestions of my own, for each child, and DSis chose from my options).

But yeah, it's annoying. She's the only person I know who does this, and she's done it for years - ever since her first child was born, so she's not going to change now - it's not just me she does it too, she sends our mum/other family members direct links too.

Bottleup · 18/11/2022 09:47

My SIL does this. I find it so rude and it makes me resent giving her DC anything. Ironically if she was less of a CF I would probably spend more on them!

MichelleScarn · 18/11/2022 09:42

Send her note saying you've bought X at £250 for someone, transfer cash please
(Am not childish at all......)

But in reality what a CF!!

Raspberryjamsandwich · 18/11/2022 09:39

have you seen a copy of the receipt? Or has she just told you how much it cost her?

TellMeWhere · 18/11/2022 09:36

It's a mistake to go along with it this year. Unless it's something you might've bought him anyway/within budget/doing you a favour. Even then, you still need to establish ground rules. They'll do the same for his birthday too if you act as though this is OK.

If he's tiny then it's much more enjoyable buying your own gifts - although if this is how she acts now, chances are she'll bin/give away/get passive aggressive about whatever you buy, then cry if you complain 😅(sorry, I'm projecting).

Out of interest. Why did you ask her what to buy last year and not your sibling?

MinnieGirl · 18/11/2022 09:35

You’ve agreed to pay it, but I would say that you won’t do that again as it feels that you are being told what to buy instead of being given a few ideas…. That you like to buy gifts for your nephew and being asked for payment of a gift they have chosen and bought doesn’t feel the same. Smile sweetly as you say it and I’m sure no one will be offended.