Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect doctors to have basic people skills?!

112 replies

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 05:48

Ended up at the out of hours GP during the night with 2 year old. Soaring temp that wouldn’t come down. Called 111 for advice, they booked in a callback which we got 4 hours later. DS asleep by this point. 111 booked him in with out of hours and asked us to attend as they were concerned about his breathing rate when they listened in on the phone. 45 min drive from us. So of course, we got him in the car and headed straight there just to be safe.

The doctor was awful. Walked in and sat down with DS - doctor didn’t even speak to us, just grabbed DSs ear to look inside it. DS started screaming and pulled his head away. Doctor barked at me that I need to “play my part and hold him”. My bum had literally barely hit the seat before he grabbed his ear. Of course if I’d known he was going to examine him I’d have held him properly! Then asks “why’s he so sensitive about his ears? Doesn’t seem normal for his age”. Asked me a few questions about other symptoms - barely let me get 2/3 words out each time then just talked over me in a horrendously patronising way. Eg, “how’s his appetite?” “He gave me back half...” “well you’re probably feeding him to much!”

Took DS temperature and muttered “it’s not even high”, walked out of the room, came back in with a bottle of Amoxycillin and handed me it, held the door open for us while he said “paracetamol and ibuprofen, which you do actually have to give regularly. Give him that (the amoxycillin) if you want or wait 48 hours and see how he is. Put him to bed in a nappy with a loose cotton sheet and a fan on”

And that was that. Not even a hello. Didn’t want to listen to a single thing that I felt I should be telling him regarding symptoms etc. Consultation probably lasted 2/3 minutes if that.
When 111 called us back they gave us our pick of appointment times, literally every 15 mins, and commented how quiet our out of hours was that night. So it’s not as if he was rushed of his feet with a waiting room full. I know services on the whole are ridiculously stretched and there are much bigger issues but AIBU to expect GPS to have some basic people skills?! All DS has said since is “mummy, please no doctor again!” 🙄 so that’ll be him kicking off next time he has to go for anything.

OP posts:
Prescottdanni123 · 18/11/2022 07:56

@olympicsrock

I don't think OP is tarring you all with the same brush. She is just saying that she expects GPS to have basic people skills and this one quite clearly doesn't.

BellePeppa · 18/11/2022 07:46

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

What a silly post. The dr didn’t sound very empathetic so doubt he was reeling over some imaginary previous patient’s predicament.

PAFMO · 18/11/2022 07:36

Hope your son is feeling better now.
The poor people skills warrant a complaint, as does the willy nilly handing out of antibiotics without any kind of proper instructions other than "do as you see fit". He said the child's temperature wasn't high then said paracetamol/ibuprofen and antibiotics. Bizarre.

Zanatdy · 18/11/2022 07:31

I’ve got a long term medical issue and have been to many top london hospitals with it. So many doctors have zero people skills. One was extremely rude and I refused to see him again. I had an argument with a local GP a few months ago as I was sick of my teenage daughters health issue being ignored, she looked as white a sheet and she’s mixed race, so really shouldn’t be that pale, yet they said her iron was ok. I said she didn’t need seeing that day when he asked if I was an emergency as this had been going on for months. But I wanted bloods doing. After giving all her symptoms he said very rudely ‘don’t you think she needs to be seen by a doctor then, and listed off some symptoms id said’ so I got really annoyed and said ‘well you’re the doctor, you tell me’. He was nice as pie when we did see him, and of course it wasn’t an emergency. He did then try and suggest she had an eating disorder as she is thin. Won’t be seeing him again!

NippyWoowoo · 18/11/2022 07:30

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

Yes, I'm sure that test results for cancer are given out during the night 'out of hours' 🙄

I don't get this attitude, people can have all sorts of shit thrown at them and there'd always be one saying 'you should be grateful, you got what you needed'.

The bar is low.

Maybeonedayeventually · 18/11/2022 07:29

YANBU. I'm a stressed out nurse and was expecting to say YABU but this is really poor. Even when the ward is unsafely staffed/busy I say hello to patients and explain what I'm doing before I do it, and my patients are adults.

lollipoprainbow · 18/11/2022 07:28

Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer?

Hopefully not if their bedside manner needs major work.

lollipoprainbow · 18/11/2022 07:28

@2greenroses you sound like a typical GP receptionist to me.

cansu · 18/11/2022 07:26

No doctor has received a complaint for being too polite. That is bullshit frankly. There may be people who are happy with blunt but they do not complain that the doctor was too kind and polite.

WeWereInParis · 18/11/2022 07:26

What I'd find unacceptable (and maybe I've missed it in your post) is that he's given you antibiotics with no discussion on why? What infection does he think your son has, what are the antibiotics actually for? Surely you need to be told that?

My three year old had a temp for 5 days and so we took her to the GP on Monday who looked in her throat and said it was tonsillitis and gave antibiotics because it was lasting so long and her tonsils looked quite bad. That was all explained to me and only took about 10 extra seconds - surely letting the patient (or patient's parent) know why something is being prescribed is fairly basic.

thenewduchessoflapland · 18/11/2022 07:24

Isn't doesn't matter how busy the doctor was,the time nor how stressed he was or if he has a good bedside manner or not.

He simply needed to be a basic level of polite,not inappropriately manhandle a young child and not throw unwarranted personal insults at the OP.

Skodacool · 18/11/2022 07:19

DWMoosmum · 18/11/2022 07:00

You being a GP receptionist says a lot about your ridiculous comment.

This. I’m appalled that there are people around with such awful attitudes.

ChairOfInvisibleStudies · 18/11/2022 07:16

"Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done"

That is simply not true. Firstly, the doctor didn't listen to the patient/OP. A consultation should consider history as well as examination, and symptoms (what the patient/carer is reporting) as well as signs (what the doctor finds on examination) to build a full clinical picture and arrive at an appropriate treatment plan. Secondly, medicine practiced well considers the whole patient, which includes not scaring the shit out of a sick toddler, thus reducing their compliance with subsequent medical contact.

'Bedside manner' shouldn't be an optional extra, it's an integral part of being a good medical practitioner.

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 07:16

cansu · 18/11/2022 06:47

This crap about being straight forward has got to stop. Being a doctor is about dealing with people when they are low or sick. Yes being kind is important and the way staff defend this behaviour encourages some people to continue to think that their skills mean the rules don't apply to me.

Its not crap - you get as many complaints about doctors being too diplomatic and polite as you do about doctors being too curt, often the same doctors, sometimes the same consultation!

By all means provide feedback, that is not the same as making a complaint, but don't think that just because you want him to act differently, that all patients do. Some might, some might not

nomoreflyingducks · 18/11/2022 07:14

Well not a great bedside manner. But I'm impressed he gave you a bottle of ready made up antibiotics. Round these parts you'd get a prescription and then have to go to the 24 hr pharmacy and then have a 10-20 min wait whilst they made up the prescription.

Luncheonmeatsandwich · 18/11/2022 07:05

Not acceptable to treat a patient like that, even when stressed. As a HCP I would say that it's far from the norm though. If you're feeling up to it, you could feedback.

Pegasushaswings · 18/11/2022 07:01

He was a dick OP, I don’t understand why medical staff are always excused manners on MN, I doubt other professions are!

DWMoosmum · 18/11/2022 07:00

You being a GP receptionist says a lot about your ridiculous comment.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 18/11/2022 06:57

Op I would complain, I am sick and tired of this attitude that the NHS can do what they like and treat people like shit, I have been really battling in my own mind whether to complain about my own GP surgery after the way I have been seriously let down and I swing from feeling guilty to feeling angry then I read stuff like like this and know what I need to do.

They way he treat your ds is inexcusable!

On another note something that jumped out in your op was this Give him that (the amoxycillin) if you want or wait 48 hours and see how he is Is this now what GPs do? just hand out antibiotics just in case? Another poster said something similar the other day and no one believed her!

cansu · 18/11/2022 06:50

2greenroses everyone understands stress. We all experience it. I don't doubt for a minute that being a gp is stressful. Patients are also under extreme stress. They deserve respect and compassion. If you can't give this then you need to take a break.

CrystalCoco · 18/11/2022 06:49

Isn't the medical profession supposed to be about 'caring' for people fgs!?

There's absolutely no excuse to behave like this to a patient, regardless of what else is going on, it's about having professional standards adhered to and that doesn't JUST mean the advice given, but also the manner of the GP / service provider. Absolutely unacceptable to say that OP should just suck it up because who knows what else was going on.

Not overly surprising to hear that PP was a GP receptionist with an attitude like that tbh.

cansu · 18/11/2022 06:47

This crap about being straight forward has got to stop. Being a doctor is about dealing with people when they are low or sick. Yes being kind is important and the way staff defend this behaviour encourages some people to continue to think that their skills mean the rules don't apply to me.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 18/11/2022 06:47

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

Yeah with this attitude I can very much imagine you being a GP receptionist.

MolesOnPoles · 18/11/2022 06:46

What an awful attitude @2greenroses . If you really work in healthcare you should be ashamed of yourself.

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 06:45

@PronounsBaby @MiddleParking @Fucket Thank you. I’m not even sure what the point was in me posting, I was just feeling angry. I did tell the doctor himself when I was leaving that I thought his manner and the way he grabbed at my child was completely inappropriate, and that actually, he hadn’t even told me what he suspected was wrong. I assumed from the “examination” and what he did that he suspected an ear infection but he didn’t actually tell me! I also spoke to the ladies at the reception desk on the way out. I am going to complain this morning. DS saw doctors a few times when he was much younger and it was always a screaming battle then i had him at the GP a few months ago and he was AMAZING with DS. There wasn’t a single tear!!! And now this 🙄 he’s already mentioned “no doctor again” since he got up this morning 🙄

@2greenroses I’m under no illusion that being a doctor isn’t a stressful job!! And the pressure they’re under, particularly at the moment, must be immense. BUT, I’m not asking for him to be a children’s entertainer and make balloon animals for my child - all I’m asking for is a basic level respect along with his medical advice.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread