Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect doctors to have basic people skills?!

112 replies

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 05:48

Ended up at the out of hours GP during the night with 2 year old. Soaring temp that wouldn’t come down. Called 111 for advice, they booked in a callback which we got 4 hours later. DS asleep by this point. 111 booked him in with out of hours and asked us to attend as they were concerned about his breathing rate when they listened in on the phone. 45 min drive from us. So of course, we got him in the car and headed straight there just to be safe.

The doctor was awful. Walked in and sat down with DS - doctor didn’t even speak to us, just grabbed DSs ear to look inside it. DS started screaming and pulled his head away. Doctor barked at me that I need to “play my part and hold him”. My bum had literally barely hit the seat before he grabbed his ear. Of course if I’d known he was going to examine him I’d have held him properly! Then asks “why’s he so sensitive about his ears? Doesn’t seem normal for his age”. Asked me a few questions about other symptoms - barely let me get 2/3 words out each time then just talked over me in a horrendously patronising way. Eg, “how’s his appetite?” “He gave me back half...” “well you’re probably feeding him to much!”

Took DS temperature and muttered “it’s not even high”, walked out of the room, came back in with a bottle of Amoxycillin and handed me it, held the door open for us while he said “paracetamol and ibuprofen, which you do actually have to give regularly. Give him that (the amoxycillin) if you want or wait 48 hours and see how he is. Put him to bed in a nappy with a loose cotton sheet and a fan on”

And that was that. Not even a hello. Didn’t want to listen to a single thing that I felt I should be telling him regarding symptoms etc. Consultation probably lasted 2/3 minutes if that.
When 111 called us back they gave us our pick of appointment times, literally every 15 mins, and commented how quiet our out of hours was that night. So it’s not as if he was rushed of his feet with a waiting room full. I know services on the whole are ridiculously stretched and there are much bigger issues but AIBU to expect GPS to have some basic people skills?! All DS has said since is “mummy, please no doctor again!” 🙄 so that’ll be him kicking off next time he has to go for anything.

OP posts:
nicslackey · 18/11/2022 09:23

To take money from refugee for holiday 29
2greenroses · Today 08:36

I have taken in many refugees over the years, and have kept in touch with some of them. This relates to a young man, an asylum seeker, 18 years old when he stayed with us, a refugee from a hell hole, where he had been separated from his parents, denied education and nutrition, and his siblings killed. ( Yes he crossed the channel in a small boat, I know that question is going to come up...)

His parents and surviving cousin escaped separately, and he eventually rejoined them in another safe European country where they were granted refugee status.

Now, 6 years later, I have cancer, and the family have tried to send me money. I have turned it down repeatedly. But we have a chance to go on holiday, and this could be our last chance. And we are struggling to afford it.

I am doing the right thing to say no, and to potentially miss the holiday, aren't I?

It feels so wrong to say yes, but I have difficulty clarifying to myself why.

I already know I'm not taking the money, really, I suppose I am looking for a way of reassuring myself it is the right decision

YABU - accept the money from a refugee family, who are currently a bit better off that you

YANBU - no, don't accept it, it is wrong

I hope you are treated with more compassion and respect than you or the out of hours doctor showed to the op

Herejustforthisone · 18/11/2022 09:10

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:43

This is a GPs appointment....

And yes, people turn up at our of hours with any number of problems, all different levels of seriousness, and stages

For all the OP knows, there could have been an urgent ongoing situation in another room, that the doctor had ducked out of to see her son, before returning to.

You don't like his manners. My surgeon has few manners. I love it - he is straightforward, uncomplicated and doesn't wrap anything up or waste time on niceties.

If the complaint was about medical matters I would understand, but the complaint is simply about the OP would have preferred a different "bedside manner" - when the OP has no idea what else was happening during that shift, and a different patient might have liked and wanted that "bedside manner" anyway

I don't think there is any basis for a complaint here. What is the point? Just a load of faff and inconvenience for everyone. To what end? Maybe he will be politer in future, and annoy another patient by being too polite? Or maybe he would be exactly the same. Or maybe he would decide not to bother with out of hours shifts again, and everyone loses.

I think this complaint is unnecessary and self indulgent. The Op got the advice and medication needed for her son, but wants to quibble about the speed it was given to her. It was too fast????

I can well believe you’re a GP receptionist. Christ almighty.

You remind me of those women who fawn all over men in roles of responsibility, like doctors, surgeons and vicars. A family friend was a vicar and his wife was forever being bitched about by the women of the parish who were obsessed with him and thought she wasn’t good enough for him. 😆

Oxborn · 18/11/2022 08:45

serenghetti2011 · 18/11/2022 08:38

And gp receptionist you should be ashamed that you are advocating that this treatment is anything more than unprofessional and damaging!! Glad I’m not at your practice if standards are so very low. No mother gets terminal cancer diagnosis at 2am at out of hours and it’s not the next patient or any patients fault if the gp is stressed or upset it’s hard and it’s upsetting but that’s part of the job. With all your medical degrees and extensive gp experience you should know that? 🙄

Totally agree with you

namechange3394 · 18/11/2022 08:45

I can believe you get "opposite" complaints about bedside manner, too over-familiar, too formal etc. But too polite?! Surely people don't complain that their GP is too polite 🤔Can well believe @2greenroses is a GP receptionist with that attitude!

Oxborn · 18/11/2022 08:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Oxborn · 18/11/2022 08:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

serenghetti2011 · 18/11/2022 08:38

And gp receptionist you should be ashamed that you are advocating that this treatment is anything more than unprofessional and damaging!! Glad I’m not at your practice if standards are so very low. No mother gets terminal cancer diagnosis at 2am at out of hours and it’s not the next patient or any patients fault if the gp is stressed or upset it’s hard and it’s upsetting but that’s part of the job. With all your medical degrees and extensive gp experience you should know that? 🙄

Changechangychange · 18/11/2022 08:36

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 07:16

Its not crap - you get as many complaints about doctors being too diplomatic and polite as you do about doctors being too curt, often the same doctors, sometimes the same consultation!

By all means provide feedback, that is not the same as making a complaint, but don't think that just because you want him to act differently, that all patients do. Some might, some might not

I deal with a lot of junior doctor complaints (training program director), and in all my years I have literally never dealt with a complaint that a doctor was “too polite” Hmm

serenghetti2011 · 18/11/2022 08:35

So sorry this was your treatment op. There was no need. In that moment your son was his only patient he should’ve taken the time to be compassionate and caring as well as professional and he wasn’t any of those things.

I’ve been a paeds nurse for 18 years and have been in with families receiving devastating news in one room one minute and had to be cheerful and happy with the rest of my patients the rest of the shift, I don’t take my personal life to work with me. All are treated with kindness and patience, respect and dignity and it can be so hard when your heart is breaking for a family but that is the job. We reflect, we cry in the sluice etc but on a long shift you have to carry on.

with my own children, youngest has asd and bad asthma so lots of gp/consultant hospital exposure and the majority have been wonderful I certainly would have had something to say about the treatment of your son, good experiences with healthcare workers are important for children especially in primary care, it can be so scary to be prodded and poked kindness costs nothing!!

LaBellina · 18/11/2022 08:34

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

Your attitude is horrific and patronizing.

OP, please complain. My cat’s vet has better bedside manner towards her. This is completely out of line.

TeaCupLady · 18/11/2022 08:33

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

As a medical professional this is not an adequate examination of what the OP describes is correct.

OP, get onto PALS if you are concerned. Ignore this comment, yes there may have been someone in before who has made this GP's life harder, but he still should have listened to your concerns. It's well known kids compensate better than adults and drop quickly so need a good history to fully assess their symptoms.

Hope your DS is feeling better soon.

AnneLovesGilbert · 18/11/2022 08:31

That sounds horrible, you must all have been exhausted and he behaved appallingly.

I had the opposite experience recently, I’ve never met such a great GP, late in the evening at a very busy OOH treatment centre under a lot more pressure than the tosser you saw. She was delightful, asked loads of questions, listened, addressed DD like a person, explained what she was doing, made the odd joke and got us a script, useful advice and told us to go back if needed. Given the circumstances and how many people inc children were waiting I was amazed at how thorough she was. I told the receptionist how pleased I was as we left and have sent a thank you to the GP.

I’ve wondered since why I was so shocked by her humanity, efficiency and people skills but it’s because it doesn’t happen often.

Hope DS is much better soon.

RambamThankyouMam · 18/11/2022 08:27

I have absolutely no patience for behaviour like this from doctors.

When DD was a day old, a very snappy and rude consultant came to our bedside in the ward and said "She needs a lumbar puncture" and tried to wheel DD away in her bassinet. So cold, not even an explanation why. I wouldn't let her take DD away until she sent another, more civil doctor to come and tell me what was happening.

Appalling.

mrsjoyfulprizeforraffiawork · 18/11/2022 08:26

I have only read page 1 of this thread but read the gp receptionist pp's contribution and wanted to say I have been a medical secretary for, so far, 45 years and the out of hours gp's attitude was appalling and I would be complaining for sure. I have, as a patient and in my work, met a (very) few like this - it is usually younger, junior doctors in hospitals, who need to ditch the ego, have some basic manners and actually listen to the patient (or they will miss some very important pointers to their condition). I have also met a very few GPs who are definitely in the wrong career as they appear to really dislike dealing with their patients. As a hospital patient, my red flag is when they fail to tell you who the heck they are when they turn up at your bedside.

BakedRightOff · 18/11/2022 08:26

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

Don’t know if you’re aware that other people in society have really stressful jobs and stuff going on in their personal life. If I spoke like that when I was at work (snr exec) I would expect to be pulled up on it as that is not acceptable ever.

Of course we all understand the situation with the NHS. That’s not a get out of jail free card to behave like this.

Qazwsxefv · 18/11/2022 08:25

Sounds like the Gp did not communicate well and if you want to complain you should.

I don’t think all doctors have to be great communicators- if I’m having plastic surgery all I care about is them being very good at fixing noses neatly or whatever but a GPs job involves a lot of communication- they should be good at it

On the delayed antibiotics- giving a prescription but advising you to wait 48hrs is in the NICE guidelines. Most ear infections resolve by day three without antibiotics, those that don’t benefit from antibiotics on day 3-4. It both decreases antibiotic overuse and resistance by not giving every ear infection antibiotics on day one and saves another appointment - parents understandably don’t want to be told that their kid may or may not get better and if they don’t they have to call up again and do the whole rigamarole of getting an appointment

OoooohMatron · 18/11/2022 08:24

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

What bollocks.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 18/11/2022 08:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

wtf Shock

DeathMetalMum · 18/11/2022 08:23

No excuse, however some people don't have people skills, and some people just can't learn them.

I work in a healthcare and my boss regularly sees paitents. He can be very blunt and harsh when he's talking to some of the members of staff, seometimes a bit huffy and puffy when we are extremely busy. However he always turns on his charm for paitents, and has a very good manner, particularly children no matter what type of mood he is in.

PearlclutchersInc · 18/11/2022 08:21

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

A GP receptionist......ah right.

Your doctor was definitely lacking in social skills but I've found over the past few years so many have. Is it a generational thing?

I sometimes wonder though, with the behaviour of some of the general public if it's a decline as a reaction.

heartbroken22 · 18/11/2022 08:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DWMoosmum · 18/11/2022 08:16

@olympicsrock I'm sure she isn't. I've seen so many doctors over the past few years and absolutely all of them have been incredible. Thank you for what you do, we do appreciate it. x

Flairmaine · 18/11/2022 08:13

In a sonographer and have worked with a number of GPs in surgeries and in hospitals. Most are wonderful, but as in all workplaces, some are not. You must complain as there is no reason for someone to be rude to you. GPs do have it tough, of course. Everyone knows this. Most are doing their best, and are also managing to still be kind to their patients.

AnImaginaryCat · 18/11/2022 08:00

nomoreflyingducks · 18/11/2022 07:14

Well not a great bedside manner. But I'm impressed he gave you a bottle of ready made up antibiotics. Round these parts you'd get a prescription and then have to go to the 24 hr pharmacy and then have a 10-20 min wait whilst they made up the prescription.

This is what I thought. In fact was quite distracted from the brusque behaviour of the doctor by the ready made bottle of antibiotics being handed out.

You can complain if you wish OP, choice is yours. Though I'm presuming your son is at the older side of two, seeing his speech is so well developed, so whatever you do make sure he realises that's not normal behaviour from.a doctor and there's nothing to fear.

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/11/2022 07:58

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

This is a perfect example of how administrative staff who work in a healthcare setting feel like they "know medicine".

No GP (OOH or not) would be able to pinpoint someone's symptoms as "terminal cancer"! That is something that would require significant consultation with a specialist and a load of diagnostic tests. So your analogy is ridiculous and melodramatic.