Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect doctors to have basic people skills?!

112 replies

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 05:48

Ended up at the out of hours GP during the night with 2 year old. Soaring temp that wouldn’t come down. Called 111 for advice, they booked in a callback which we got 4 hours later. DS asleep by this point. 111 booked him in with out of hours and asked us to attend as they were concerned about his breathing rate when they listened in on the phone. 45 min drive from us. So of course, we got him in the car and headed straight there just to be safe.

The doctor was awful. Walked in and sat down with DS - doctor didn’t even speak to us, just grabbed DSs ear to look inside it. DS started screaming and pulled his head away. Doctor barked at me that I need to “play my part and hold him”. My bum had literally barely hit the seat before he grabbed his ear. Of course if I’d known he was going to examine him I’d have held him properly! Then asks “why’s he so sensitive about his ears? Doesn’t seem normal for his age”. Asked me a few questions about other symptoms - barely let me get 2/3 words out each time then just talked over me in a horrendously patronising way. Eg, “how’s his appetite?” “He gave me back half...” “well you’re probably feeding him to much!”

Took DS temperature and muttered “it’s not even high”, walked out of the room, came back in with a bottle of Amoxycillin and handed me it, held the door open for us while he said “paracetamol and ibuprofen, which you do actually have to give regularly. Give him that (the amoxycillin) if you want or wait 48 hours and see how he is. Put him to bed in a nappy with a loose cotton sheet and a fan on”

And that was that. Not even a hello. Didn’t want to listen to a single thing that I felt I should be telling him regarding symptoms etc. Consultation probably lasted 2/3 minutes if that.
When 111 called us back they gave us our pick of appointment times, literally every 15 mins, and commented how quiet our out of hours was that night. So it’s not as if he was rushed of his feet with a waiting room full. I know services on the whole are ridiculously stretched and there are much bigger issues but AIBU to expect GPS to have some basic people skills?! All DS has said since is “mummy, please no doctor again!” 🙄 so that’ll be him kicking off next time he has to go for anything.

OP posts:
TabithaTittlemouse · 18/11/2022 12:47

It’s probably worth seeing if you can get an appointment with your own GP today @Isthatmcormac if he’s not any better.

The doctor was rude. No excuses.

You get rude people in all jobs but he was unprofessional.
As a HCP we deal with horrible situations sometimes but part of the job is plastering on the smile and moving to the next person. We have to actively listen to each person in order to be able to help them. Your doctor didn’t do this.
We all have bad days but our patients come first.

dragonbreaths · 18/11/2022 12:40

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

bullshit. theres never an excuse for rudeness.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 18/11/2022 11:58

NHS staff who clearly think that because the patient isn't paying "per treatment

There has always been a too-prevalent attitude that patients should feel lucky and accept anything, and grovel on bended knee almost. Whether it's getting worse I couldn't say because it is only in the past few years that I and my family have had large amounts of contact with them. Many many wonderful staff and situations that they've done their absolute best even when staff and resources were overstretched. Too many like this above though.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 18/11/2022 11:55

Grabbing your child was an assault.

I’ve become that patient. I will not stand for this behaviour. I don’t care if they’ve studied medicine for 7 years and have a god complex, anyone who try’s to manhandle my child without asking or being polite is going to get a rather curt response from me...staff are worn out but there is no need to take it out on the patients.

This. Ditto nurses, carers... We all need to try to be that patient, parent or carer, as much as we are able to. It's happening too often.

Badbadbunny · 18/11/2022 11:21

We really do need to tackle this "put up and shut up" and "take it or leave it" attitude from some NHS staff who clearly think that because the patient isn't paying "per treatment" they don't deserve any kind of professional service.

Same with the blase attitude of appointments, again, the "take it or leave it" and threat of being taken off the list and referred back to the GP if you are brave enough to ask for a more convenient appointment.

I've had to have an MRI and CT scan recently. On both occasions, each radiographer barely spoke and just grunted, no "people skills" at all, and gave the clear impression they were bored and couldn't be arsed to answer questions or give any reasurrances. When I questionned why he tried to give me the dye/marker after I'd told the consultant I didn't want one, and the consultant agreed to put it down as no dye/market, the consultant just grunted and walked away, leaving the nurse/assistant to tell me that I'd have to get back to the consultant to get him to re-refer without the dye/marker. Lots of patients are nervous about MRI scans at the best of times, to have a neanderthal radiographer doesn't help at all. That ended up a wasted appointment because of the NHS, not because of me!

taliaG · 18/11/2022 11:12

He should have asked for consent before touching your son. He may have been having a difficult day, but he shouldn't have behaved like that.

TrashyPanda · 18/11/2022 10:18

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

In contrast, busy A&E, doctor dealt firmly with drunk and abusive patient.

then came over to us, knelt down and took my elderly DMs hands in his, and told her compassionately that her DH was dying.

he had to switch over at a moments notices from defending his staff to giving the worst news possible in a very tender way.

because he was a professional and put others first.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 18/11/2022 10:14

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

Your standards are so low. You basically will be a door mat and take whatever shite someone pushes your way. Good for you.
OP complain ! Do not let this slide. Your poor child

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 10:09

@Doughnutmum Thank you. Still a high temp this morning unfortunately and not coming down much at all. Hopefully it’s just his body doing what it needs to do and fighting it off 🤞🏼
It really didn’t feel like an adequate consultation at all. My son is 2 and while he’s a great communicator for his age, he’s still 2. He just knows he doesn’t feel well. Surely it’s important for the parent/caregiver to give the history and any symptoms that may not currently be showing in order to allow the doctor to do their job? And he just didn’t let me do that at all. As well as giving medication with no clear clinical reason or instructions.

I know he’s in the minority, most medical professionals that we have encountered have been absolutely fantastic 😊

OP posts:
Powersout · 18/11/2022 09:57

YANBU.

I've seen a GP in the past who said absolutely nothing to me, just sat and looked at me as an opener. I'm always amazed at how many of the male doctors seem to be awkward, nerdy types - obviously very intelligent and academic but not suited to a patient facing profession. A lot of doctors are middle class twats in my opinion, they have no idea how to talk to anyone from a different background to themselves (I'm feeling very bitter about lack of social mobility in the UK at the mo, can you tell).

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 09:57

@AnImaginaryCat yeah I’m sure the last time I was given an antibiotic and told to delay it (for myself) I was a prescription so that I could go and collect it if needed. But I was handed a bottle there and then last night 🤔🤷🏻‍♀️
He’s actually just turned 2 this month 🙈😂 Hes just relatively ‘advanced’ in his language skills. He talks a lot more and more clearly than some of the 3 year olds at groups we go to 🤷🏻‍♀️ They all have something that they pick up faster don’t they 😊 I liked to believe it would make the ‘terrible twos’ a bit easier as he’d be able to communicate his needs better and maybe be less frustrated but in reality I just have one more (very loud 😅) opinion in the house 🤣

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 18/11/2022 09:52

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

It's really not acceptable at all. It doesn't matter what has gone before, he's a professional. An OOH GP will not be telling anyone they have terminal cancer!

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 09:50

@olympicsrock Please don’t think I was tarring you all with the same brush - I have complained about one other medical professional in my life. Most of you do the most amazing job under obscene amounts of pressure. As a family we’ve received so much amazing care over the years and our local GP is fantastic 😊

@WeWereInParis That’s exactly the issue I have. He wasn’t even clear what it was being given for. According to his muttering, DS didn’t have a high temp, I was handed an antibiotic and told to use it if I wanted. I wasn’t actually given any advice or guidance. (Completely get the post about NICE guidelines and delaying antibiotic use btw 😊 sorry, I can’t find the post again to quote you!!). I was also advised to continue paracetamol/ibuprofen and strip him off with a fan on for sleep when the doctor clearly didn’t think he had a fever which was just odd.

OP posts:
bloodyplanes · 18/11/2022 09:50

When i got to the stage of rolling my eyes and thinking here is another neurotic, entitled time waster i knew it was time to leave the NHS!!! I couldn't do that job for another second longer and this Doctor shouldn't be doing it either if he shows such little respect to his patients!

raffegiraffe · 18/11/2022 09:49

We all have bad days at work when we aren't as good as we can be. I agree that the main focus of this should be on the actual medical care. I know ooh is difficult to cover so maybe he was covering and was knackered.

MrsSkylerWhite · 18/11/2022 09:46

cansu · Today 06:50
2greenroses everyone understands stress. We all experience it. I don't doubt for a minute that being a gp is stressful. Patients are also under extreme stress. They deserve respect and compassion. If you can't give this then you need to take a break.“

This. How difficult the doctor’s day may have been had nothing to do with the current patient.

nicslackey · 18/11/2022 09:43

2greenroses · Today 09:28

I hope you are treated with more compassion and respect than you or the out of hours doctor showed to the op
@n@nicslackey

Well good for you but it is clearly not what the 2 year old or their mother or most people on the thread want in a medical professional

Jaybird43 · 18/11/2022 09:40

@Isthatmcormac what a horrible man! Honestly, some medics are horrendous when it comes to face-to-facet interaction with a patient. Please do report him! I recently had to report my son's surgeon as she sat us down and went through the risks of the operation in front of my 9 year old, who could understand the "risk of stomach rupture / bleeding / death" - just what I needed when DS was already wound up about the op! The hospital said they were grateful for my feedback as some of the docs become complacent - IME I wish the surgeon had asked if we wanted DS to hear the risks or if either my DH or I should take him away for a few moments. I would definitely report it to PALS x

WalkingOnAcorns · 18/11/2022 09:38

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

As someone who's worked clinically and non clinically in the NHS for years, I couldn't disagree more.

Treating people - especially children - with kindness and empathy is a basic tenet of good healthcare.

As for your scenario, how often does an out of hours service tell a young mum she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I'd say that almost never, it's not a conversation that service would (or should) be having.

OP, please do complain, that doctor needs feedback.

PearlclutchersInc · 18/11/2022 09:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Guff. My experiences have been with home grown regardless of culture or creed.

TheRookie · 18/11/2022 09:31

I doesn't matter what has happened before, basic kindness is needed. I work in health care and get constant abuse and we still need to be nice. There's a difference between an emotional doctor and a c#&t!

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 09:28

I hope you are treated with more compassion and respect than you or the out of hours doctor showed to the op
@nicslackey

My surgeon is plain speaking to the point of being curt. My feedback has always been that I love it, and this is exactly what I want

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 09:26

Herejustforthisone · 18/11/2022 09:10

I can well believe you’re a GP receptionist. Christ almighty.

You remind me of those women who fawn all over men in roles of responsibility, like doctors, surgeons and vicars. A family friend was a vicar and his wife was forever being bitched about by the women of the parish who were obsessed with him and thought she wasn’t good enough for him. 😆

I'm not a receptionist now, I was in the distant past.

Emmacb82 · 18/11/2022 09:25

It doesn’t matter what the doctor was dealing with previously, the whole point of being professional is not letting your patients know what stress you are under! I have had to deal with the death of a patient and then go and triage someone that is relatively well straight afterwards. Does that mean that I can be rude and miserable to the new patient? No, it means that they are there because they are concerned about something, and it is my job to ensure they feel safe, cared for and are given the appropriate treatment. The best people to speak to are PALs as a pp has already mentioned. Things don’t change unless feedback is given. Hope your little boy is feeling better soon.

Doughnutmum · 18/11/2022 09:25

GP here. YANBU. This sounds like a really poor consultation from what you describe (and possibly overprescribing antibiotics!)

hope your little boy is feeling better soon.

I also teach medical students and we spend a lot of time teaching them communication skills - which don’t come naturally to everyone but they’re all pretty good by the time they finish. In contrast I had 2 sessions on communication skills when I was at medical school and that was it… so hopefully things are improving.

Swipe left for the next trending thread