Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect doctors to have basic people skills?!

112 replies

Isthatmcormac · 18/11/2022 05:48

Ended up at the out of hours GP during the night with 2 year old. Soaring temp that wouldn’t come down. Called 111 for advice, they booked in a callback which we got 4 hours later. DS asleep by this point. 111 booked him in with out of hours and asked us to attend as they were concerned about his breathing rate when they listened in on the phone. 45 min drive from us. So of course, we got him in the car and headed straight there just to be safe.

The doctor was awful. Walked in and sat down with DS - doctor didn’t even speak to us, just grabbed DSs ear to look inside it. DS started screaming and pulled his head away. Doctor barked at me that I need to “play my part and hold him”. My bum had literally barely hit the seat before he grabbed his ear. Of course if I’d known he was going to examine him I’d have held him properly! Then asks “why’s he so sensitive about his ears? Doesn’t seem normal for his age”. Asked me a few questions about other symptoms - barely let me get 2/3 words out each time then just talked over me in a horrendously patronising way. Eg, “how’s his appetite?” “He gave me back half...” “well you’re probably feeding him to much!”

Took DS temperature and muttered “it’s not even high”, walked out of the room, came back in with a bottle of Amoxycillin and handed me it, held the door open for us while he said “paracetamol and ibuprofen, which you do actually have to give regularly. Give him that (the amoxycillin) if you want or wait 48 hours and see how he is. Put him to bed in a nappy with a loose cotton sheet and a fan on”

And that was that. Not even a hello. Didn’t want to listen to a single thing that I felt I should be telling him regarding symptoms etc. Consultation probably lasted 2/3 minutes if that.
When 111 called us back they gave us our pick of appointment times, literally every 15 mins, and commented how quiet our out of hours was that night. So it’s not as if he was rushed of his feet with a waiting room full. I know services on the whole are ridiculously stretched and there are much bigger issues but AIBU to expect GPS to have some basic people skills?! All DS has said since is “mummy, please no doctor again!” 🙄 so that’ll be him kicking off next time he has to go for anything.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shortfatandangry · 20/11/2022 20:56

At the very least, he should have asked for consent before touching your ds. As a minimum.

Qazwsxefv · 20/11/2022 16:18

Out of hours after certain times and in certain areas all local pharmacies will be closed. In this case the out of hours service gives out the actual medicine - they have a small stock of commonly needed stuff for this reason. If you live somewhere where pharmacies are open 24-7 or have never seen an out of hours GP at 3am then you have likely never experienced this. It’s good practice as handing a prescription you can’t actually get filled is kind of useless

Isthatmcormac · 20/11/2022 11:38

Just to update, unfortunately DS isn’t much better - although his temperature now seems to be responding to medication so that’s old. It looks like Scarlet Fever so he’s feeling very sorry for himself 😓

I did put in a complaint. The consultation was definitely below the standard that it should have been and to be so dismissive and not allow patients (or the parent/carer of young patients!) to speak in order to get a full picture of what’s going on could have really serious consequences in some situations.

OP posts:
paintitallover · 19/11/2022 17:59

Absolutely, I know that well. But you wouldn't imagine that is the case, reading Mumsnet these days.

WalkingOnAcorns · 19/11/2022 17:47

paintitallover · 19/11/2022 16:18

The doctor really doesn't sound great. But it's sad that there's always such an anti doctor pile on immediately on these threads. And half of what's said is appallingly inaccurate.

It's not anti-doctor, it's pro-appropriate compassion and consideration for patients. Anyone who has worked in the NHS will know there are some doctors - and other healthcare staff - who have a reputation for not always treating patients with kindness and care. I think they've decreased over the years, and more time is spent on communication skills during training, and of course actors are often used to assess candidates at interviews these days.

paintitallover · 19/11/2022 16:18

The doctor really doesn't sound great. But it's sad that there's always such an anti doctor pile on immediately on these threads. And half of what's said is appallingly inaccurate.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 19/11/2022 13:51

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

So giving another patient bad news makes it acceptable to upset a toddler and not listen to your next patient at all? How is a doctor supposed to accurately diagnose if he doesn’t ask about the child’s symptoms? He wasn’t just rude he was clinically negligent.

People like you rushing to justify poor treatment is the reason why nothing ever improves. You need to complain op. Stress or no stress this is completely unacceptable.

Dalekjastninerels · 19/11/2022 13:51

Surely being polite and tactful are basic skills for adults and it should be a no brainer for a Doctor to have these skills?

PortiasBiscuit · 19/11/2022 13:50

I know a woman who has bought four sports cars and a mansion on the back of a business that gets kids into medical school. Any kid as long as they have been hothoused to get the grades and Mum and Dad can pay. I’m sure one of the things that you can pay for is being taught to sound like you have empathy at interview.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 19/11/2022 13:45

Its not crap - you get as many complaints about doctors being too diplomatic and polite as you do about doctors being too curt, often the same doctors, sometimes the same consultation!

I'm afraid I don't believe this.

I'm sure you get complaints about doctors being indecisive, or not communicating clearly what the problem is, what the treatment is, etc., but that's not the same as complaining about doctors being polite or tactful.

NippyWoowoo · 19/11/2022 13:44

We really do need to tackle this "put up and shut up" and "take it or leave it" attitude from some NHS staff who clearly think that because the patient isn't paying "per treatment" they don't deserve any kind of professional service.

Say it again!

Dalekjastninerels · 19/11/2022 13:41

YANBU

Your poor little boy; feeling unwell and treated like that Sad

No excuse Angry

niugboo · 19/11/2022 13:38

@2greenroses actually he didn’t treat the child. He threw antibiotics at the parent with no explanation or confirmation that there was in fact a bacterial infection that needed treatment. This isn’t even subpar care and goes again NUCE guidance for prescribing antibiotics.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 19/11/2022 13:36

We need to stop canonising absolutely everyone that works for the NHS.

Law of averages, some will be arseholes, some not very good and some past caring.

Not everyone's an angel. Most are utterly brilliant and we're lucky to have them working for the NHS. Not all.

Hope DC OK, OP

MrsRonaldWeasley · 19/11/2022 09:18

The doctor was rude! Just because he is a skilled professional doesn’t mean that he gets to have no manners! If I acted like that in my job when dealing with people I would be disciplined (rightly so!). We all pay for the NHS, the service you received was unsatisfactory therefore you should complain. Simple as.

TeamPineapple · 19/11/2022 08:58

@2greenroses there is no defending this doctor's approach at all, and good communication skills and good bedside manner are part of being in healthcare. As an ex receptionist I would expect you to know about the NHS core values and how important they are (notice that Compassion is there!), plus how fundamental getting permission from the patient/guardian before doing anything is:

working together for patients. Patients come first in everything we do

respect and dignity. We value every person – whether patient, their families or carers, or staff – as an individual, respect their aspirations and commitments in life, and seek to understand their priorities, needs, abilities and limits

commitment to quality of care. We earn the trust placed in us by insisting on quality and striving to get the basics of quality of care – safety, effectiveness and patient experience right every time

compassion. We ensure that compassion is central to the care we provide and respond with humanity and kindness to each person’s pain, distress, anxiety or need

improving lives. We strive to improve health and wellbeing and people’s experiences of the NHS

everyone counts. We maximise our resources for the benefit of the whole community, and make sure nobody is excluded, discriminated against or left behind.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/11/2022 08:19

If the complaint was about medical matters I would understand, but the complaint is simply about the OP would have preferred a different "bedside manner" - when the OP has no idea what else was happening during that shift, and a different patient might have liked and wanted that "bedside manner" anyway

You don’t think a small child would be scared by an unknown adult touching him, particularly looking in his ears (which would be incredibly painful if he does have an ear infection). As a parent I’d be furious if someone tried to examine my child with no communication with me - consent matters even at that young age, and I’d be able to settle my child which would make the examination easier all round.

Part of any people facing job is to be able to adjust your manner and way of being to the needs of the patient. A child needs a different approach than an adult, a basic competency for any doctor is to flex their communication style to suit the needs of the patient. I’ve never come out of any medical consultation thinking “I wish that medic had been more curt with me”.

Talkingfrog · 19/11/2022 07:53

YNBU.
sounds as if there was very little meaningful communication if the doctor didn't want to listen explain symptoms, or even tell you what he diagnosed.

We had an out of hours with my daughter. As we thought it was tonsillitis and we were given antibiotics. The doctor ( who was very nice) asked could she take tablets. My 7 year old said she didn't think she would be able to swallow them, but the doctor said his 7 year old managed fine and gave them to us. We we given enough yo last a few days and a prescription for the rest).
Swallowing the tablets was a disaster. I ended up calling back the next morning ( bank holiday weekend). The nurse got the doctor to call back, which he did a few minutes later. He was surprised the tablets had been given instead of medicine, checked for the nearest pharmacy open that day and sent the prescription straight to them.
Not a major issue as we still got what was needed, but not listening to my daughter's concern about swallowing the tablet ( her tonsils were enlarged-she struggled to swallow anything), meant a waste of tablets, and extra phonecard to out of hours and an extra gp call back. ( plus my daughter will probably get anxious if she now gets prescribed tablets).

I have never been given actual medicine incase, but the surgery hp once gave a prescription incase. She couldn't see an ear infection, but didn't know if it was very early in developing. Gave advice re paracetamol etc, and gave the prescription to use 8f it didn't get better in a day or two ( otherwise we would have only needed to go back).

When little my daughter put a lot on getting a sticker at the end of a gp/dentist appointment. Little things go a long way with children.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/11/2022 07:37

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

No she isn’t. This could traumatise a child. My dd would not have been ok to be examined in this manner. She has a medical condition and needs kid gloves not to start it off. This doctor would have done so for sure. Then dd would have been in his room for over an hour and he’d have had a backlog of patients.

Sunbun19 · 19/11/2022 07:30

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

You wouldn't get a terminal cancer diagnosis at the out of hours gp 😑

Notforbeef · 19/11/2022 07:02

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 06:29

YABU. You have no idea what else was going on. You were seen, your boy was examined, you were given advice and medication. Who knows what the last patient was, maybe a young mum who had to be told she has all the symptoms of terminal cancer? I have worked as a GP receptionist, and the stress on GPs can be immense at times. Your son was treated, so medically, everything appropriate was done

Are you serious? Nothing about that was appropriate

bigbluebus · 18/11/2022 13:56

I have challenged attitudes of Doctors of all grades over the years both to their faces and through the appropriate channels. It may not surprise you to know that the powers that be often get multiple complaints about certain individuals and by you complaining they can build a picture about whether or not they wish to continue to employ the individual. I appreciate Doctors are in short supply but that doesn't mean they should get away with this sort of behaviour.
The way this Doctor behaved was unacceptable and as a minimum requires some retraining.

TrashyPanda · 18/11/2022 13:28

TabithaTittlemouse · 18/11/2022 12:51

@TrashyPanda that doctor sounds lovely. I’m sorry that you have had bad news but glad that it was handled gently.

Thank you so much.

it was nearly 15 years ago, but I have never forgotten that doctor.

TabithaTittlemouse · 18/11/2022 12:51

@TrashyPanda that doctor sounds lovely. I’m sorry that you have had bad news but glad that it was handled gently.

Fleurdaisy · 18/11/2022 12:48

It’s his job, it’s what he’s paid for. If you work in a call centre, on the bins or selling food on a market stall up you’re not entitled to be rude to your customers— why is he any different?
Please complain, your child should not have a fear of doctors because of one rude, ignorant one.
It takes seconds to say Hi I’m xxx, your little lad has xxxx? I’ll examine his ears if you’d like to hold him. And he is capable of talking while looking in a child’s ears.
Unfortunately I’ve met a lot of drs who think they’re God’s gift to the world and expect patients and other staff alike to fall at their feet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread