Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What careers sound good on paper nightmare in reality and what sounds nightmare on paper good in reality.

388 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 17/11/2022 16:05

On paper teaching sounds great, all those weeks off. Weekends off working in primary schools sounds fun secondary schools you can specialise in a subject you prefer. Reality grading lesson plans admin alot of work not enough pay.
Firefighters and police sounds fun reality dangerous.
In paper admin or reception jobs sounds boring and tedious paper work. But some have great hours and good work life balance.
In your opinion what jobs aren't worth the hype?

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 17/11/2022 23:51

Forensic scientist - in the mid 80s there was a series called Indelible Evidence featuring some really amazing stories. One where they caught someone from the bite of an apple comes to mind.
But I hear that about 1% is amazing apple stories (or that only the top 1% get to work on amazing apples) and the rest is wading around in blood, semen and other bodily fluids.

I'm being facetious obviously, but (like most jobs I suppose), much is routine and not particularly worthy of TV dramas or documentaries!

RosesAndHellebores · 17/11/2022 23:51

BIL was so sick of teaching after about 10/15 years. Sick of young people who didn't work, the stress of being accountable, acting as quasi social worker, marking, ten hour days and little appreciation.

He jacked it in to become his own master and opened a toy shop where he could provide educational toys and never worry about work at home. And then he realised that he needed to be open six days a week, if he shut the shop for a two week holiday it meant no takings for a week, lost custom or paying someone he didn't entirely trust to keep the shop open.

Then there were the difficult customers, over whom he had no authority, the orders to be made, the stock-taking, the VAT returns, the accounts, PAYE for part-time staff, difficult staff. It was hard work, stressful, turnover really mattered if there was to be any money left over, complaining customers, no sick pay, no generous pension, H&S regs, the council, etc, etc.

He packed it in after three years ........and returned to teaching. He is quite tight lipped about how hard it was and how teaching is easier. His wife spilt the beans.

Nod and smile.

XelaM · 17/11/2022 23:49

SeenAndNot · 17/11/2022 23:20

Working for a Church.

Church members think it’s a nice job, good recognition, must be very fulfilling spirituality etc.in reality it’s every hour under the sun for minimum wage with no work life balance and no separation from personal and professional life. Then everyone in the congregation has an opinion on what you should do and how.

Being a pastor is not for the faint hearted.

Surprised by this. It sounds like such an "easy" pleasant job on paper.

Namaste6 · 17/11/2022 23:48

@LadyOfTheCanyon 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

XelaM · 17/11/2022 23:48

Hyggerama · 17/11/2022 23:07

Dentist

Very good pay, well respected, smart and academic job, self-employed so can set your own annual leave.

The flip side
A very high risk of complaints from unhappy patients, even when you haven't done anything wrong. A lot of chancers who try to get money from you by complaining.

Very stressful, see above and below

Extremely hectic working days that extend into the evening when you do patient charting for all the 30+ patients you've seen that day, plus referrals and emails etc

Ungrateful patients who don't look after their oral health at all after all the work you've done for them

You have to work hard to keep up with new techniques and guidance, you're basically retraining constantly

Complete side note, but I find it so so hard to find a good dentist in the UK that I go to Germany for anything above a filling. I had so many bad experiences in the UK for very simple things. One accidentally injected anaesthetic into a nerve during a routine procedure that meant half my mouth was frozen for several months (thankfully no lasting damage); fillings put in kept falling out continuously; daughter had a milk tooth removed as it wouldn't fall out and the dentist left half of her tooth in requiring another dentist to remove the other half etc etc etc. I have never tried to get money from a dentist but there are so many terrible dentists around that I'm not surprised about the high level of complaints.

Longsight2019 · 17/11/2022 23:29

Architect

Yeats of expensive study.

Average pay.

High redundancy levels.

CPD and constant changes in legislation to keep up with to stay accredited by RIBA.

Too many products to familiarise with.

Dealing with Main Contractors and awkward clients.

SeenAndNot · 17/11/2022 23:20

Working for a Church.

Church members think it’s a nice job, good recognition, must be very fulfilling spirituality etc.in reality it’s every hour under the sun for minimum wage with no work life balance and no separation from personal and professional life. Then everyone in the congregation has an opinion on what you should do and how.

Being a pastor is not for the faint hearted.

oldbrownjug · 17/11/2022 23:15

@BuckarooBanzai - that's lovely to hear. My mum had some wonderful carers before she died and I valued them more than I can say. It's fundamental. Care is the absolute basis of humanity - we all need care sometimes - and if I find myself needing longer term professional care I hope it's from someone like you.

WhiteArsenic · 17/11/2022 23:11

mam0918 · 17/11/2022 19:09

My first and only proper 'employed' job was at a vets... I loved animals and had visions of saving them all, in reality being a vet is mostly killing things (either leaving them to die in the death room, PTS, abortions or animals dying on the table from surgeries they shouldnt have been put through) mixed in with lots gross body fluids.

My job was infection control so I got to clean and sterilse all those lovely bodily leakages and cart all the bodies out to the incineration pick up point during lunch break.

I left because I got sick of the death, when they where putting down newborn puppies I had just had enough but if someone was paying they didn't care (and if someone wasn't paying the also didn't care hense the 'death room').

I’ve been a vet for 33 years, and while I completely agree with most of the other negative comments about the unremitting workload, unreasonable owner expectations, etc, I have never worked anywhere anything like this description. Of course there’s plenty of death and sadness in the job, but this is an account of bad practices, not the norm!

Hyggerama · 17/11/2022 23:10

@Choppies are you in the NHS? Go private!

Hyggerama · 17/11/2022 23:07

Dentist

Very good pay, well respected, smart and academic job, self-employed so can set your own annual leave.

The flip side
A very high risk of complaints from unhappy patients, even when you haven't done anything wrong. A lot of chancers who try to get money from you by complaining.

Very stressful, see above and below

Extremely hectic working days that extend into the evening when you do patient charting for all the 30+ patients you've seen that day, plus referrals and emails etc

Ungrateful patients who don't look after their oral health at all after all the work you've done for them

You have to work hard to keep up with new techniques and guidance, you're basically retraining constantly

ToastAndJames · 17/11/2022 23:04

Modelling- not me but a friend did this for a few years. Schlepping about on the tube, getting changed in the loo, people being openly critical of your body and treating you like an idiot, huge pressure to stay very slim. Probably fun if you’re Kate Moss but for the average jobbing model (even one making a reasonable living as my friend did) it’s completely unglamorous.

par05 · 17/11/2022 23:04

Pharmacy dispenser minimum wage all the stress people say good clean job, it's stressful.

greenleader · 17/11/2022 23:00

Software Development

Sounds: Great if you are drawn to to programming, problem solving etc. Dull and geeky if you aren't.

Reality: Actually pretty good most of the time (if you stay out of crazy start ups and games companies). Punctuated with vile bits where a project delivers what was asked for but it turns out the customer/end user needed something different and only realised this way too late. The project team is then hung out to dry as a goat is required for scaping purposes.

1dontunderstand · 17/11/2022 22:54

This thread is so interesting

QS90 · 17/11/2022 22:52

Environmental Consultant. Sounds like it would be interesting, and you'd be doing your bit for the planet.

Reality is working 70 hour weeks, with such long and intense hours that people periodically get heart attacks on site. Tedious, relentless nonsense about health and safety, to cover companies arses, that takes so long you are driving back at 11pm after a 15 hour day, which genuinely IS dangerous. Putting equipment away in some dodgy, dark industrial estate at midnight for same reason. Knowing at the end of the day you haven't actually made a jot of difference to the planet (maybe you've actually made it worse with all that driving), you've just completed a box ticking excersize for some god awful multinational like Shell. Expectation that you pretend to love all of this, and "network" with dickheads in your spare time.

Seriously kids, just don't do it.

Fourfurryfeet · 17/11/2022 22:51

Psychologist - "oh it must be so interesting!"

Pros - can be interesting, very rewarding when people benefit, flexibility of nhs or private work

Cons - years and years of training, nhs is breaking down and private work has stress of self employment, pay not great considering length of training needed, and for some reason I never anticipated how draining it would be to listen to miserable, stressed people all the time.

SoTiredTodaySoNeedCofee · 17/11/2022 22:48

Psychologist sounds good. Reality is that it's quite boring, and very emotionally draining.

lightisnotwhite · 17/11/2022 22:47

For a just above MW job shelf stacking in a major supermarket is pretty good. You feel you achieved something every shift , keeps you fit and you get proper breaks with free food and drinks. Often food to take home plus staff discount.

Farming is an unbelievably hard relentless and often downright dangerous job/ life.

TicTac80 · 17/11/2022 22:45

Nursing can sound both good and a nightmare on paper...and be both good and a nightmare in reality! It really depends on the shift!

It's amazing though. I love it. Sure, you get crap days: Covid was hideous; I wish every day that we had more staff on my ward; it's horrible being yelled at/sworn at, spat/punched at etc; and I hate it when people think we're just stupid, or that we only plump up pillows. Sometimes the public/media think we just sit on our butts all day (I can clock 15-20K steps on a shift) or make Tik Tok vids, etc. Over the years, there have been blokes who think they can treat us like sex objects (and be really rude/inappropriate towards us). I hate that, and have had to give some very stern words towards people doing that. There are times when I just want to cry, because it feels like we're fighting an uphill and relentless battle.

But the good days and (in my case) the amazing team I work with, make it great. -when you walk on the ward, get handover and go see your patients, and they're happy to see you....that's wonderful.
-when you help people and it makes a real difference to them/their families.
-when you really get to know the patients you look after and their families, and they remember you. Today, I walked past a patient's room, and the patient saw me, called out my name and gave me a massive hug when I walked in (the patient was someone I'd look after many times previously).
-Some of the patients and staff have known me for over 20years! These are people I've laughed with, cried with, supported etc.
-No two days are ever the same. It's never boring.
-you never stop learning. You don't take things for granted.
-the people you look after often have the most amazing life stories. When I first started on the wards (late 90's), I was looking after people who had been alive (just!) when Queen Victoria was on the throne.
-I love the problem solving, speaking up for staff and patients, teaching the junior HCPs and getting things sorted.

elp30 · 17/11/2022 22:44

I was reading this thread to my husband and he'd like to add his own:

"Join the RAF and see the world, they said. The reality was that I spent seven years in underground bunkers in Wiltshire and Hertfordshire. When I finally got a job above-ground, there were no windows. I didn't see shit!"

😂

audeloquipalam · 17/11/2022 22:43

Spectre8 · 17/11/2022 17:09

Working in public sector...People said it'd be a nightmare, where people are lazy and if you go there you'd find it hard to come back to private etc. I've actually found work far more interesting and yes there is your share of incompetence but there are lots of talented people too.

How many people work at the Council? About half of them. Old but gold.

CarrotSoupwithCheese · 17/11/2022 22:42

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 17/11/2022 17:36

My DP is an architect which on paper (and for a very very small number) sounds glamorous and like you get to shape the world we live in.
In reality, takes ages to qualify, the pay given how qualified you have to be is shocking, and most of the work is pretty dull.

Agree with this. My husband is so much happier since quitting architecture!

ohwhatadustyanswer · 17/11/2022 22:30

In defence of journalism: depends who you work for. Many media organisations are an HR shambles, low pay, demanding content for clicks, exploit interns etc…but I have worked for several very very worthwhile outlets, writing things that matter, good-ish pay, long days but you can start at 10/10.30 and colleagues almost universally interesting, clever, full of anecdotes… good journo jobs do exist! Can’t imagine doing anything else.

Bitsadnow · 17/11/2022 22:30

astronewt · 17/11/2022 21:02

In defence of HR: training in one of the HR subspecialties like learning, talent, or reward can be a good career. Generalist HR is a slog, yeah.

But seriously: if you want good pay, good hours, lack of stress and a job market that makes you feel like a queen: go into tech. There are sooooo many talent shortages in tech that if you don't like a job or manager, you can have another one, quite likely fully remote, tomorrow.

How can you get into tech @astronewt ? I have just no idea how one would go about a career change in that direction (sorry to ask you but I'm really keen to know!!)