Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What careers sound good on paper nightmare in reality and what sounds nightmare on paper good in reality.

388 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 17/11/2022 16:05

On paper teaching sounds great, all those weeks off. Weekends off working in primary schools sounds fun secondary schools you can specialise in a subject you prefer. Reality grading lesson plans admin alot of work not enough pay.
Firefighters and police sounds fun reality dangerous.
In paper admin or reception jobs sounds boring and tedious paper work. But some have great hours and good work life balance.
In your opinion what jobs aren't worth the hype?

OP posts:
Iamthegatekeeper · 18/11/2022 09:35

GP Admin
On paper, low pay, dealing people often at their worried stressed sick worst, public image of powercrazed middle aged harrigans who diagnose over the phone and palm off sick people.
Reality, genuinely rewarding job, knowing that you are helping people when they really need it. Often advocating on patients behalf with clinicians. Most patients are grateful for our service and the few who are unreasonable are far outweighed by the good. Working in a supportive team (mainly)

The major downside is dealing with doctors always moaning about how skint they are.

astronewt · 18/11/2022 09:34

soulinablackberrypie · 18/11/2022 09:24

I never imagined for a moment that working in a library would be fun. Would be my worst job ever….mainly cos I’d have to be quiet and I love talking😁

I work in a library and it's a myth that you have to be quiet. That might have been the case once, but nowadays one of the main purposes of a library is to be a "community hub." We love it if people come in and have a chat with us or each other. We wouldn't encourage actual shouting, but that's never happened when I was around. Some bigger libraries have designated quiet study areas, where you are supposed to be quiet, but not necessarily silent - nobody would mind if two school friends were studying together and one said something like "how did you do question 3?" or "could I use your ruler?"! Incidentally I do like the job very much. The people are what make it lovely. Every single person who comes into a library wants to be there, and it shows.

Admittedly I've only heard this from librarians in the US, but I thought the public were quite keen on coming in to watch porn on the library computers.

soulinablackberrypie · 18/11/2022 09:24

I never imagined for a moment that working in a library would be fun. Would be my worst job ever….mainly cos I’d have to be quiet and I love talking😁

I work in a library and it's a myth that you have to be quiet. That might have been the case once, but nowadays one of the main purposes of a library is to be a "community hub." We love it if people come in and have a chat with us or each other. We wouldn't encourage actual shouting, but that's never happened when I was around. Some bigger libraries have designated quiet study areas, where you are supposed to be quiet, but not necessarily silent - nobody would mind if two school friends were studying together and one said something like "how did you do question 3?" or "could I use your ruler?"! Incidentally I do like the job very much. The people are what make it lovely. Every single person who comes into a library wants to be there, and it shows.

TheKeatingFive · 18/11/2022 09:13

Why can’t we be James Herriot or Mr Chips any more?

In fairness they were fictional characters so I'm not sure anyone got to be them.

Though I do think that conditions in certain jobs have deteriorated

rubbleonthedoub · 18/11/2022 07:19

Lawyer demanding. Competitive, stressful

Pros self employed determine own day etc, get to help people, fulfilling, well paid

DuncanBiscuits · 18/11/2022 07:10

This thread is depressing as hell. All these careers that should be wonderful, and probably were 40 years ago.

What changed? Why can’t we be James Herriot or Mr Chips any more? All the humanity has been sucked out of life. It’s sad.

Debsthegardener · 18/11/2022 07:07

Lawyer - enough already said

Agency recruitment/headhunting -

moved into legal recruitment after being a lawyer thinking how fulfilling it would be to help others find a job they liked. Reality is that it’s a hard-core sales job, duplicitous candidates, everyone hates you (sometimes it’s justified), impossible briefs to fill and listening to lawyers moaning about their job. On the other hand the money can be amazing and gave me lasting financial security.

Now work as a Gardener in a beautiful tourist hot spot. Lovely clients, paid for every hour I work and fabulous scenery. Downside - it’s also the wettest place in England 😂

Taillighttoobright · 18/11/2022 07:02

Teaching is The Best. You have to be fucking organised and prioritise the boring jobs (marking) otherwise it drags you down and affects your joy of lessons, but students (and their parents) are fascinating, real, raw, funny, human, unpredictable... And you will never, ever, be short of anecdotes (anonymised, of course).

McT123 · 18/11/2022 07:01

Wishawisha · 17/11/2022 18:49

I only ever hear people planning/ dreaming on buying a nice sprawling property somewhere picturesque and semi-rural and running it as a BnB. Obviously issue number 1 is that the purchase cost / mortgage would be insane and 2 that you’re probably just going to end up working as a cleaner / cook for very low pay.

Did exactly this. Bought a big house in a beautiful part of the country - much more expensive than we could have afforded in the usual way - and now run it as a B&B. Hard work - yes, lots of cleaning and laundry - but very rewarding in all senses. Most of the guests are absolutely lovely.

DH works from home and so is available to help if necessary but rarely needed.

Can't take summer holidays but do close for the whole of January and the odd mini-break here and there.

Having a business loan rather than a mortgage can be daunting and the pandemic was a challenge but so happy to have taken the plunge.

Stillavetjust · 18/11/2022 06:46

mam0918 · 17/11/2022 19:09

My first and only proper 'employed' job was at a vets... I loved animals and had visions of saving them all, in reality being a vet is mostly killing things (either leaving them to die in the death room, PTS, abortions or animals dying on the table from surgeries they shouldnt have been put through) mixed in with lots gross body fluids.

My job was infection control so I got to clean and sterilse all those lovely bodily leakages and cart all the bodies out to the incineration pick up point during lunch break.

I left because I got sick of the death, when they where putting down newborn puppies I had just had enough but if someone was paying they didn't care (and if someone wasn't paying the also didn't care hense the 'death room').

This is deeply offensive and bears no resemblance to any practice I have ever worked in.

Stillavetjust · 18/11/2022 06:26

BananaGrana · 17/11/2022 17:16

Vet…majority of practices corporate owned. Heavy, unrelenting work load. Deal with difficult members of the public all day.

I came on to say this.
Relentless days trying to juggle many cases feeling pulled in all directions feeling like you’re only just coping , being seen as the enemy when you’re using your knowledge to try and help, being called money grabbing when approx 10% of bills are actually profit, being blamed when things don’t go to plan despite the fact that animals aren’t machines and don’t follow an instruction manual, legal minimum holidays, legal minimum pension contributions, minimum sick pay, high suicide rate, poor pay compared with equivalent medical professionals, chronic shortage of staff because everyone is leaving and Brexit has affected the workforce.

And yet… I’m still here because I work with an amazing team, I love the actual work and most of our clients are nice, plus I’m too old to retrain!
If I was leaving school now I’d probably choose something else but hindsight is always interesting.

Mistletoewench · 18/11/2022 06:10

winperree · 17/11/2022 22:05

Nursing. People often complain about it but -

3 days of 12 hour shifts = full time hours. So I can fit a full time job into 3 days, giving me 4 days a week where I'm not working at all

Allows me to be present for school runs etc

Loads of Banking opportunities

Can easily change departments

Some real horrible people of course but some amazing members of the public that just make it all worthwhile

Lovely post❤️

Hellothere54 · 18/11/2022 06:06

One thing I would say about teaching is, yes its blooming hard work - I think most people will acknowledge that these days.
BUT I have done many different jobs before teaching and they were boring and unfulfilling. Every year I get a new group of receptive, funny, clever, amazing little souls who will grow, change and learn under my care, who will share their favourite books, their loves and their problems. It’s a massive privilege and I wouldn’t do anything else. The biggest problem is the lack of funding for support staff and lack of support for children with SEN and MH issues.

Hellothere54 · 18/11/2022 05:57

@DarkShade ooops definitely guilty of saying this! Not that I really think it would be easier just that I’ve consumed far too many fluffy novels and Hallmark movies where the ideal life is achieved by opening a small florist/bookshop/cafe in a small town (often near Christmas) and meeting a hot, but surly local man who turns out to be my soulmate. That’s what I mean when I say “I’d love to quit and open a bookshop cafe!” 😂

StartupRepair · 18/11/2022 02:54

Consulting at a big firm. Long long hours, rampant egos and office politics, realising your services have been sold for an impossible time frame which you have to deliver in.

GwendolenAbott · 18/11/2022 02:39

Fashion -

fashion design = debilitatingly exhausting

modelling = horrific

HMUA = soul destroying

the other job which seems somewhat rewarding is photography

Agapornis · 18/11/2022 01:23

Charity. Plenty of incompetent colleagues that have done the same job for years and won't ever move on because they'd probably get sacked. They don't make any changes that would permanently resolve problems for beneficiaries let alone work to eliminate the need for the charity's existence, because they'd be out of a job.
Senior managers aren't managed so bad behaviour isn't dealt with. On paper they are supervised by trustees, but the trustees meet 2-4 times a year, talk and decide fuck all, get their travel expenses paid and fuck off for another few months.

IfOnlyOCould · 18/11/2022 01:17

BuckarooBanzai · 17/11/2022 17:34

Carer, poorly paid with some eye wateringly long shifts. Although the pay and shifts statement is very true the reality is it's a beautiful job where you can form really strong bonds with your clients. Sometimes I can't believe I actually get paid to do something I love so much. I really get to make a difference to people's well-being and that's such a privilege.

What a lovely post.

audeloquipalam · 18/11/2022 01:13

memorial · 18/11/2022 00:38

GP (partner)
on paper...very high earner , 9 to 5, no nights or weekends, don't actually ever really see patients, easy, all you do is refer on to specialists
Reality .... Real income dropped more than 20% in 10 years while workload has rocketed, very long hours, "part time" as only way to survive often more than 50 hrs, high risk complaints, risk sink and dumping ground for ever service, beyond stressful, seem to be hated by all
(Shame really as I used to really love and be proud of my job now have steered both my DC away and would never advice someone to go into medicine)

I’m going to sound like a CF but genuine question: income down 20% but workload rocketed. Is this changing GP contracts, changing patient demands, a combination, something else? Just curious not trying to make any kind of point. My own work has pitfalls where badly framed contracts and the required workloads don’t match.

memorial · 18/11/2022 00:38

GP (partner)
on paper...very high earner , 9 to 5, no nights or weekends, don't actually ever really see patients, easy, all you do is refer on to specialists
Reality .... Real income dropped more than 20% in 10 years while workload has rocketed, very long hours, "part time" as only way to survive often more than 50 hrs, high risk complaints, risk sink and dumping ground for ever service, beyond stressful, seem to be hated by all
(Shame really as I used to really love and be proud of my job now have steered both my DC away and would never advice someone to go into medicine)

yphtutor · 18/11/2022 00:33

My son is desperate to do medicine. I keep asking him why? It’s terrible hours, terrible pay, a lot of stress and takes years to earn decent money. But it’s all he has ever wanted to do. He has a degree in bio medical science, a distinction in a masters degree in clinical neuroscience, despite having to change his path of study after 3 months in, because they decided to shut down the labs due to Covid and he has applied every year for 5 years but due to Covid has been really disadvantaged because he is a graduate entry. We have a shortage of doctors here is someone who is clearly academically proven, has worked in Covid and histology labs during Covid, is mature and motivated and can’t get a foot in the door. What the hell is going on?

audeloquipalam · 18/11/2022 00:14

RosesAndHellebores · 17/11/2022 23:51

BIL was so sick of teaching after about 10/15 years. Sick of young people who didn't work, the stress of being accountable, acting as quasi social worker, marking, ten hour days and little appreciation.

He jacked it in to become his own master and opened a toy shop where he could provide educational toys and never worry about work at home. And then he realised that he needed to be open six days a week, if he shut the shop for a two week holiday it meant no takings for a week, lost custom or paying someone he didn't entirely trust to keep the shop open.

Then there were the difficult customers, over whom he had no authority, the orders to be made, the stock-taking, the VAT returns, the accounts, PAYE for part-time staff, difficult staff. It was hard work, stressful, turnover really mattered if there was to be any money left over, complaining customers, no sick pay, no generous pension, H&S regs, the council, etc, etc.

He packed it in after three years ........and returned to teaching. He is quite tight lipped about how hard it was and how teaching is easier. His wife spilt the beans.

Nod and smile.

I know quite a few current and ex teachers. Never having had a different job seems to be a common characteristic of those who find it hard. Often goes hand in hand with never having wanted to be a teacher in the first place but drifting into straight after Uni because it seemed like the path of least resistance.

Buteverythingsfine · 18/11/2022 00:10

Fantasy academic: swooshing around in a gown, students all rapt with attention when you speak, bit like Hogwarts, don't work school holidays

Reality 1: work school holidays (have standard ones like everyone else), lots of form filling, students often disinterested and on phones, huge pressure to achieve, get money, be corporate without corporate pay

Reality 2: get to be called Dr or even Professor, can research anything you like (if you can get someone to pay for it), fascinating colleagues

Formerpupil · 18/11/2022 00:07

Lol at those mentioning auditing positively as it’s straightforward, I mean who doesn’t want to work 80+ hour weeks agonising over financial statements no one will read? 9 times out of 10 they get signed off even if you do find any differences.

Appalonia · 18/11/2022 00:04

I really enjoyed my last job, which is why I stayed there for 9 years! I was a trainer for a large charity in London. The course participants were volunteers, which meant they really wanted to be there and were eager to learn. The courses were interesting to teach and I felt that at the end of the courses the volunteers were well equipped with the skills and knowledge to go out and do their job well and help people. I always got great feedback at the end of the courses which was very gratifying and motivating and I felt I was really doing something worthwhile.

However, as with most things, to save money, these courses will now have moved online to save money. Such a loss and a shame. I wouldn't want to do it now in its current format. Hey ho.