Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What careers sound good on paper nightmare in reality and what sounds nightmare on paper good in reality.

388 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 17/11/2022 16:05

On paper teaching sounds great, all those weeks off. Weekends off working in primary schools sounds fun secondary schools you can specialise in a subject you prefer. Reality grading lesson plans admin alot of work not enough pay.
Firefighters and police sounds fun reality dangerous.
In paper admin or reception jobs sounds boring and tedious paper work. But some have great hours and good work life balance.
In your opinion what jobs aren't worth the hype?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 18/11/2022 13:16

My DH worked for EY and did his chartered accountancy exams, but worked mostly in mergers and acquisitions and never did any actual accountancy work in his career. It's a broad umbrella.

xogossipgirlxo · 18/11/2022 13:12

Wow, I am quite surprised how many of you find accounting jobs interesting. This was the worst choice to me.

blueshoes · 18/11/2022 12:48

XelaM · 18/11/2022 11:54

I really know what you mean! That's exactly how I felt at my old job. The way to escape law:

trainig rather than fee earning roles;
compliance roles;
HR (if you're an employment lawyer);
going in-house;
lecturing at university (although major pay cut, but can be done freelance in addition to another role).

All the above except lecturing can be extremely well-paid.

Great list. Completely agree, as an ex-fee earner who has stayed in the law and managed not to take too much of a salary cut.

IfOnlyOCould · 18/11/2022 12:23

I think it can depend with Civil Servant jobs. Some of my kids friends who are doing civil service graduate jobs seem to have it very easy compared with people in other graduate training jobs or similar. The pay can be good and the hours very reasonable compared with grad jobs in finance and engineering.

Obviously it varies massively though.

Farmageddon · 18/11/2022 12:20

mam0918 · 17/11/2022 19:09

My first and only proper 'employed' job was at a vets... I loved animals and had visions of saving them all, in reality being a vet is mostly killing things (either leaving them to die in the death room, PTS, abortions or animals dying on the table from surgeries they shouldnt have been put through) mixed in with lots gross body fluids.

My job was infection control so I got to clean and sterilse all those lovely bodily leakages and cart all the bodies out to the incineration pick up point during lunch break.

I left because I got sick of the death, when they where putting down newborn puppies I had just had enough but if someone was paying they didn't care (and if someone wasn't paying the also didn't care hense the 'death room').

As awful as this sounds, I think you were just unlucky to work in a horrible place. I worked in a Vets a quite a few years ago as an animal care assistant, and it was nothing like this.
Yes there were PTS, but they were very respectfully done, usually with the owner in the room.
The Vets were stressed out, as they only had a short time for each consult, and sometimes owners could be demanding and reluctant to actually pay for the care their pet needed, or blamed the Vet for not having all the answers. I left with a huge amount of respect for the Vets, who all seemed to care about doing their best in a difficult situation.

KimberleyClark · 18/11/2022 12:02

Onnabugeisha · 17/11/2022 17:53

Civil servant- everyone thinks it’s an easy job, boozy lunches, completely unsackable, low stress,

Reality- underpaid, high stress, politicians interfering, no private life, austerity/budget cuts mean rounds of sackings in which seniority matter more than performance for being kept on, a do more with less constant pressure until you shit diamonds. Scoffing food on the run (no lunches), lots of unpaid overtime and being on call. The feeling that the public hates you as incompetent and lazy when you’re neither.

Oh yes - everyone thinks you are a waste of public money if you are a civil servant.

Lollygaggle · 18/11/2022 12:01

Can't agree enough about dentistry.

Incredibly stressful on mind and body , doing microsurgery on a conscious patient to an exacting timescale as well as running a business , mentoring training staff and colleagues etc .

Funny how everyone has or knows a dentist who runs a Porsche and works two days a week , when every dentist I know works their socks off to detriment of health for less and less each year.

Vulture legal firms and patients looking to make big bucks when you are trying your very best but the smallest mistake can cost you everything .

General Dental Council out to get you for slightest mistake , often taking years for a hearing during which time you can't work but won't publish how many dentists commit suicide during this time.

Patients moaning about costs of treatment saying "well that's paying for your next holiday" . No it's paying for dentists £80,000 of student debt , the thousands of pounds a year in registration , indemnity ,regulation , cpd etc.

The fact that you cannot afford to be sick , you cannot afford to get pregnant , you have to pay your practice for days off .

The fact that after many decades in dentistry , many qualifications , I have never paid above above standard rate tax , despite the last decade being mostly private.

The very real thrills of the job , getting someone nervous through a course of treatment happily, rebuilding a shattered mouth , learning and using a new technique is massively outweighed by the British public and government outright hostility to a medical profession that works hard,efficiently and ethically but is held to far higher standards than virtually any other profession .

You are more likely to be sued in the U.K. as a dentist than in any other place in the world , we are thirty times more regulated than any other place in the world . Is it any wonder that more than 90% of dentists would not recommend the career to their children?

I am one of the last in my dental school year still working . Ill health, stress , death, bankruptcy and finally covid has done for most everyone else. Dentists were at the highest risk for covid , we had virtually no support and in my practice all the dentists had to keep on working as we had no virtually financial help despite all of us being high risk because of age, medical conditions etc. I lived in a caravan on my drive for 12 months to protect my loved ones.

XelaM · 18/11/2022 11:54

Oysterbabe · 18/11/2022 10:26

Those of you who have escaped law, how did you do it and what do you do now? It's the only thing I'm qualified and experienced in but I hate it with the power of a thousand suns. When I'm walking to the office I fantasise about being hit by a car so I can have a nice stay in hospital instead. Anything else is going to involve a massive drop in salary which has been the main barrier. But I can't do this for another 25 years.

I really know what you mean! That's exactly how I felt at my old job. The way to escape law:

trainig rather than fee earning roles;
compliance roles;
HR (if you're an employment lawyer);
going in-house;
lecturing at university (although major pay cut, but can be done freelance in addition to another role).

All the above except lecturing can be extremely well-paid.

BrioNotBiro · 18/11/2022 11:53

Local government; often wrongly perceived as time-serving, gold plated pension waitees (see previous poster's snidey comment).

In reality, a huge range of professional disciplines in which to be well trained, qualified and advanced in, with supportive colleagues. Great T&Cs and flexibility, good pension and comparative job security.

CaptainMalcolmReynolds · 18/11/2022 11:47

Independent jeweller. On paper I thought I'd be playing with sparkly stones and shiny metal, creating beautiful things that would be worn by film stars and royalty.

In reality I'm permanently burning my hands, cutting myself and giving myself perma blisters from pliers and wire twisting. I'm competing with mass produced and copied tat from China that costs pennies whilst stopping my own designs from being ripped off. I think I've made about a tenner in profit over two years 🤣. It's a good job I never left my day job to pursue my dreams really.

TheEponymousGrub · 18/11/2022 11:33

CherryRipe1 · 17/11/2022 17:27

GP according to my neighbour. She did all the med school training etc, qualified worked for two weeks and quit to run a post office. She said it was a dreadful profession.

OMG how did that pan out? - Thinking about the Horizon scandal.

(and now I know how to properly Quote PPs.)

TheEponymousGrub · 18/11/2022 11:30

GP ... did all the med school training etc, qualified worked for two weeks and quit to run a post office.
OMG How did that pan out?! Maybe they didn't all have Horizon.

mam0918 · 18/11/2022 11:26

And the reason I left was they where putting down puppies because the owner paid for it, just for not meeting kennel club standards... yes I fully agree thats dodgy and horrific (and I HOPE most vets wouldn't but don't know) hense me leaving because I had a huge argument with the head vet and even offered to hand rear them myself but was told its the owners choice and they had been paid to do a job.

mam0918 · 18/11/2022 11:22

Stillavetjust · 18/11/2022 06:46

This is deeply offensive and bears no resemblance to any practice I have ever worked in.

Out of curiousity for the few that are claiming my experiance is 'offensive' how do your clinic operate?

Do you work for a charity where you treating all the unowned pidgeons and headghogs old ladies bring in for free and all these sick animals rushed in get magically patched up and theres no death?

There where basically a handful of catagories when I worked there:

  1. animals being brought in to be PTS (100% death rate)

  2. animals coming in for surgery (spaying, tooth pulling, tumors/cysts, glands, abortions, very occasionally somthing like an amputation - spaying/abortions had the highest death rate, the rest where mostly pretty mild if surgery for those things was all being a vet was I would happily have stayed)

  3. wild/stray/feral animals (what do 'unoffensive' vet clinics do here?)

  4. REALLY sick pets and accidents (and usually they didnt live because they where in organ failure or badly injured/unclaimed)

There really wasnt a great deal of people coming in just for a prescription or check up, I mean lets face it if your going to the vets its usually because something is wrong.

As an animal lover it was awful but I didn't invent it, I wasnt even the vet so had zero control my job was a glorified cleaner so I got to follow the vets around moping up fluids and sterilising everything, the most hands on I got was handing over instruments during surgery and dragging the bodies out.

SafeMove · 18/11/2022 10:50

Haven't seen anyone mention being a travel agent yet?

TheKeatingFive · 18/11/2022 10:42

Is moving in-house an option? Most of my lawyer friends ended up doing that.

Oysterbabe · 18/11/2022 10:26

Those of you who have escaped law, how did you do it and what do you do now? It's the only thing I'm qualified and experienced in but I hate it with the power of a thousand suns. When I'm walking to the office I fantasise about being hit by a car so I can have a nice stay in hospital instead. Anything else is going to involve a massive drop in salary which has been the main barrier. But I can't do this for another 25 years.

hassletassle · 18/11/2022 10:20

I used to work as a stained glass maker / restorer, which was great initially when I had a cheap shared studio space and was young. More recently - working alone in expensive studio space as it was the only place available , materials (all imported) prohibitively expensive, people can't afford stained glass windows!, I'm getting old and my hands and feet have arthritis/RSI and are painful. I struggled to make running a business and studio work around my children. Mostly got sick of being in pain and feeling alone.

Retrained in bookkeeping. 20 years ago I would have though this the most boring thing on earth. Now... I LOVE IT. I get to work flexibly , there is work in every industry with my qualifications. Currently I work for a charity within school hours. Get to sit down and drink a cup of tea and hep a genuinely good cause.

meatyryvita · 18/11/2022 10:20

I'm in HR and bloody love my job and have done it for nearly 25 years. Whilst it can sometimes feel like you're shoveling shit, if you work for a decent, progressive company (as I'm lucky enough to), it can be a role where your work is transformative in making a good company great.

In fact, with many roles, it's not always the role that's rubbish, it's the company you do that role for.

TheKeatingFive · 18/11/2022 10:18

it's mostly agreed that about 50% of his books were fiction

Well I think this is the pertinent point. The long, dull boring days wouldn't have made for great entertainment, so wouldn't make it to ttr books.

astronewt · 18/11/2022 10:15

For the pp who asked about jobs in tech, it's such a big area that it's difficult to summarise, but here are a few useful starters:

www.prospects.ac.uk/jobs-and-work-experience/job-sectors/information-technology/overview-of-the-uks-it-industry

nationalcareers.service.gov.uk/job-categories/computing-technology-and-digital

There are bootcamps and apprenticeships available in a number of tech areas, especially shortage ones.

2greenroses · 18/11/2022 10:14

TheKeatingFive · 18/11/2022 09:13

Why can’t we be James Herriot or Mr Chips any more?

In fairness they were fictional characters so I'm not sure anyone got to be them.

Though I do think that conditions in certain jobs have deteriorated

James Herriot's book are autobiographical. They are great, such an insight into the northern men of the 1930s - tough, sure, but a lot softer and more sentimental than received wisdom would have you believe!

JosephFrancis · 18/11/2022 10:14

StillMedusa · 17/11/2022 18:08

TA... theory... little/no responsibility, pot washing and skipping round the playground with cute kids and lovely long holidays.
Reality... unbelievably shit pay, dealing with challenging behaviour and/or standing in for the class teacher.

Seconded.

Especially for SEN schools! Very stressful, huge responsibilities and beyond dreadful pay. No wonder schools are having a nightmare to recruit at the moment

TheOrigRights · 18/11/2022 10:09

TheKeatingFive · 18/11/2022 09:13

Why can’t we be James Herriot or Mr Chips any more?

In fairness they were fictional characters so I'm not sure anyone got to be them.

Though I do think that conditions in certain jobs have deteriorated

James Herriot was a real vet. All Creatures Great and Small was based on his books.
Herriot was his pen name, and (looking on Wiki) it's mostly agreed that about 50% of his books were fiction. Nonetheless, he was a real person.

TheOrigRights · 18/11/2022 10:06

The major downside is dealing with doctors always moaning about how skint they are.

How crass.