Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What careers sound good on paper nightmare in reality and what sounds nightmare on paper good in reality.

388 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 17/11/2022 16:05

On paper teaching sounds great, all those weeks off. Weekends off working in primary schools sounds fun secondary schools you can specialise in a subject you prefer. Reality grading lesson plans admin alot of work not enough pay.
Firefighters and police sounds fun reality dangerous.
In paper admin or reception jobs sounds boring and tedious paper work. But some have great hours and good work life balance.
In your opinion what jobs aren't worth the hype?

OP posts:
Bingbongy · 01/12/2022 20:12

Crew in Live Music industry. Everyone thinks it’s a non stop party full of groupies and drugs but in reality it’s 20 hour shifts, lots of sitting around waiting and terrible job security.

you do get to travel a lot but usually too tired to enjoy it much.

Frenulumetta · 01/12/2022 19:46

Deathraystare · 01/12/2022 18:39

People do look at me and do a shudder when I say I am a receptionist in a Mental Health Unit.

It is fine most of the time, but obviously some of the clients are difficult/their families are and we get individuals who come in with conspiracy theories and expect me to agree with them all. Did you know you could cure Covid by putting a spoon in a glass and stirring backwards???.

We never get involved with agreeing with anyone on the state of a patients' care as it is not our business and we are not qualified.

Worse are the ones that keep wanting to chat to you about rubbish!

Also some come in with a bee in their bonnet about various things.

On the whole though it can be enjoyable and most of the patients/visitors are lovely!

I think I would love your job are you a specialised health secretary or can you get receptionist job in mental health without that? This sounds ideal for me.

Deathraystare · 01/12/2022 18:39

People do look at me and do a shudder when I say I am a receptionist in a Mental Health Unit.

It is fine most of the time, but obviously some of the clients are difficult/their families are and we get individuals who come in with conspiracy theories and expect me to agree with them all. Did you know you could cure Covid by putting a spoon in a glass and stirring backwards???.

We never get involved with agreeing with anyone on the state of a patients' care as it is not our business and we are not qualified.

Worse are the ones that keep wanting to chat to you about rubbish!

Also some come in with a bee in their bonnet about various things.

On the whole though it can be enjoyable and most of the patients/visitors are lovely!

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 01/12/2022 12:53

mam0918 · 01/12/2022 10:26

I considered going into Phlembotomy (but doesnt currently fit with my preexisting responsabilities so on hold, it is on my list for future jobs though), wondering if your just making a pun or if you have a reason why its terrible?

It was just a pun - I hope it wasn't in-vein.

mam0918 · 01/12/2022 10:26

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 30/11/2022 19:45

Canine Arborist - turns out one has to remove bags of dog poo that have been hung on trees.

Phlebotomist - just bloody awful, you'd be a clot to even consider it.

Pirate - the Jolly Roger is not as much fun as it sounds

I considered going into Phlembotomy (but doesnt currently fit with my preexisting responsabilities so on hold, it is on my list for future jobs though), wondering if your just making a pun or if you have a reason why its terrible?

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 30/11/2022 19:45

Canine Arborist - turns out one has to remove bags of dog poo that have been hung on trees.

Phlebotomist - just bloody awful, you'd be a clot to even consider it.

Pirate - the Jolly Roger is not as much fun as it sounds

biscuitbadger · 30/11/2022 17:36

Self-employed gardener - amazing job!

Flexible hours, lovely customers, good exercise and good for mental health too. The weather is not as much of an issue as you'd think - most days I'd rather be outdoors than sat in an office. Love seeing the difference I've made, feels like a really helpful and wholesome sort of thing to be spending my time on. And there's always loads to learn. Huge demand for my services. And was very easy to get into.

Downsides - I won't be able to do this forever, it takes its toll on back/knees! Never going to make a fortune, no sick/holiday pay. Little work in Jan/Feb.

AlfredBasedman · 30/11/2022 17:18

WondrousWinger · 30/11/2022 15:23

Working in a call centre.

Sounds awful and I find that it's the main job people in general have no problem at openly sneering at and looking down on those that work in one.

In reality, starting on the bottom rung in a call centre for a good company - for example a bank - can be excellent in terms of opportunities, work/life balance and benefits.

For someone who is intelligent, motivated and driven you can scale your way up at lightening speed. There are so many opportunities for progression and free qualifications and lots of companies that have a fantastic benefits package.

I work in a call centre for a bank - well technically now, I WFH and don't do anything linked to incoming calls - but my base is still the centre.

I started 15 years ago with GCSEs as my only qualification, earning £15k. Taking incoming calls about accounts. I learnt my job inside out, I made myself indispensable to my department and I completed every NVQ and professional banking qualification they offered (for free, mainly in work time). Applied for other roles, had some promotions.

I now still work 'in a call centre', working 35 hours for £50k plus bonus but in a specialised project team. I could have pushed further and could probably be earning more but I've found my sweet spot where I am - I don't do a minute of overtime, I have free private healthcare, I WFH, I'm a management grade which means a higher annual bonus but I have no downline responsibilities and I have a fairly straightforward, interesting role. Great benefits, generous pension, totally flexible hours.

I'm pitied often by people who know where I work but not my salary or role. People who I know earn far less than me, just with a more respected job title...it tickles me to see the pity and vague smug look of superiority I sometimes catch. I feel like saying 'I'm OK hun, really' 😂😂

I'm by no means unique. I have lots of colleagues that started 3 or 4 years ago taking inbound calls for £20k and they're now on their way up and earning £35k plus in other roles.

There are also people who do 6 months, can't deal with being told to fuck off by a dick customer, leave before they get any chance to progress and then tell everyone else how awful all call centres are. It's not for snowflakes and you need a thick skin in the beginning.

I’m glad you’re having a good experience, and I’d never look down on someone who worked in a call centre, because I did the job myself for around four years.

I’m definitely not a ‘snowflake’ and consider myself pretty good at rolling with the punches.

That being said, I found the office politics toxic, petty tyrant team managers who seemed to get their jobs based on their ability to suck up, favoured call handlers who never got monitored, people being dragged into rooms because their face didn’t fit. The day I left (after working my notice) was one of the best in my life

Dixiechickonhols · 30/11/2022 15:45

Oysterbabe · 30/11/2022 14:58

I now have an interview on Monday so we'll see how that goes.

Good luck 🤞

WondrousWinger · 30/11/2022 15:23

Working in a call centre.

Sounds awful and I find that it's the main job people in general have no problem at openly sneering at and looking down on those that work in one.

In reality, starting on the bottom rung in a call centre for a good company - for example a bank - can be excellent in terms of opportunities, work/life balance and benefits.

For someone who is intelligent, motivated and driven you can scale your way up at lightening speed. There are so many opportunities for progression and free qualifications and lots of companies that have a fantastic benefits package.

I work in a call centre for a bank - well technically now, I WFH and don't do anything linked to incoming calls - but my base is still the centre.

I started 15 years ago with GCSEs as my only qualification, earning £15k. Taking incoming calls about accounts. I learnt my job inside out, I made myself indispensable to my department and I completed every NVQ and professional banking qualification they offered (for free, mainly in work time). Applied for other roles, had some promotions.

I now still work 'in a call centre', working 35 hours for £50k plus bonus but in a specialised project team. I could have pushed further and could probably be earning more but I've found my sweet spot where I am - I don't do a minute of overtime, I have free private healthcare, I WFH, I'm a management grade which means a higher annual bonus but I have no downline responsibilities and I have a fairly straightforward, interesting role. Great benefits, generous pension, totally flexible hours.

I'm pitied often by people who know where I work but not my salary or role. People who I know earn far less than me, just with a more respected job title...it tickles me to see the pity and vague smug look of superiority I sometimes catch. I feel like saying 'I'm OK hun, really' 😂😂

I'm by no means unique. I have lots of colleagues that started 3 or 4 years ago taking inbound calls for £20k and they're now on their way up and earning £35k plus in other roles.

There are also people who do 6 months, can't deal with being told to fuck off by a dick customer, leave before they get any chance to progress and then tell everyone else how awful all call centres are. It's not for snowflakes and you need a thick skin in the beginning.

Oysterbabe · 30/11/2022 14:58

Dixiechickonhols · 18/11/2022 21:33

Good luck with your chat Monday. That was what I used to do. You have lots of transferable skills. I don’t miss it at all.

I now have an interview on Monday so we'll see how that goes.

aoilily · 30/11/2022 14:37

Travel agent sounded fantastic to me. Talking about holidays all day, selling amazing trips and sampling a few yourself for research purposes 🤣
In reality it was day in day out hard sell, constantly expanding targets and spending most of my time pricing up holidays for people who at the end of it all were 'just looking'.

riceuten · 30/11/2022 14:29

A friend worked for the UK Border Force and absolutely hated it on TV, as he said that 99% of the job was sitting around and most migrants were entirely legal. He also said with customs officers find nothing in the vast majority of bags they search. This wouldn't make for good TV, so they only show the "exciting bits"

DarkShade · 19/11/2022 20:36

Hellothere54 · 18/11/2022 05:57

@DarkShade ooops definitely guilty of saying this! Not that I really think it would be easier just that I’ve consumed far too many fluffy novels and Hallmark movies where the ideal life is achieved by opening a small florist/bookshop/cafe in a small town (often near Christmas) and meeting a hot, but surly local man who turns out to be my soulmate. That’s what I mean when I say “I’d love to quit and open a bookshop cafe!” 😂

Ah I regret being such a grouch about this, now that sounds great, where do I sign? In fairness my career aspiration in high school was "be Vianne Rocher from Chocolat" so substitute 'hot surly local' for 'hot surly despised outsider' and we're in business.

blueshoes · 19/11/2022 20:04

XelaM · 18/11/2022 23:51

Another flexible low stress alternative to being a fee earner can be doc review lawyer. Slaughter & May pay £40 per hour for 8 hour days plus overtime and it's all completely remote from home and very little responsibility/stress. You can get a job almost immediately if you sign up with the agency they use.

@XelaM thanks for the idea. I never thought of that. For me, it sounds like an ideal pre-retirement job which is the next step once I leave a fairly pressurised senior inhouse legal role.

lindaha · 19/11/2022 19:27

'Forensics' wasnt even really much of a degree thing before CSI.
I studied Crime Science (thats the 'scene investigation' bit not the lab work) as my first degree before moving on to bio-med and my training was the professional training for the actual police investigators.
The people who work in the lab usually have other science degree with chemistry being the most common I believe.
Even on the actual CSI shows non of them have a forensic degree like Greg was Chemistry, Grissom was Entomology, Adam was Computer Science, Sheldon was Medicine etc...
Now we have an abundance of people with this modern 'specialised' degree (not actually needed for the job) for a field that actually has very few jobs

interesting, yes the guy in the interview said the csi shows made it look like the forensics people solved the whole case when this wasn't factual at all and they just had a part in it.

I also recall reading that in many cases forensics aren't used at all because police depts wouldn't have the money etc and yet many people have the misguided notion that everything is solved like CSI stories these days because of these shows.

I used to teach and would think films such as Dangerous Minds are totally misleading and inaccurate. I'd also say that behaviour mgmt books and ''experts'' who tell people how to control tough classes don't have a clue either and totally mislead people. The shows like educating Essex too are heavily edited and don't really accurately portray schools.

MsPrism · 19/11/2022 12:38

I love this thread and will show it to my DD (after I have removed the 'tramp wank' reference of course 😅). It's really interesting to learn what glamorous-sounding careers are like behind the scenes.
I have a very junior role in a University publications team which can sound a bit menial, but I really love being 'on the tools' rather than managing people and have no pressure or responsibility apart from doing my job well. I find in my fifties, that I can't cope with pressure or long hours like I used to.
Pros - very satisfying work, friendly environment, very flexible
Cons - not really at cutting edge of technology, could get paid more in the private sector

mam0918 · 19/11/2022 12:12

nickytjj · 18/11/2022 20:09

I recall the actress who played Liz Mc Donald in Corrie saying in real life she and her husband had run pubs but it nearly financially ruined them as they are so hard to make money in them. She then said it's nothing like running the Rovers Return as she was the landlady in it. Made me think she was so right in that so many of us have completely unrealistic perceptions of jobs/careers from watching tv and films.

I also recall reading similar when a forensics specialist was responding to the rise in people entering forensics because of tv shows and he said that many shows like CSI were totally inaccurate in presenting a career in forensics.

Bottom line is that there is no such thing as a perfect job whether you earn 200 quid a week or 2 million quid a week.

'Forensics' wasnt even really much of a degree thing before CSI.

I studied Crime Science (thats the 'scene investigation' bit not the lab work) as my first degree before moving on to bio-med and my training was the professional training for the actual police investigators.

The people who work in the lab usually have other science degree with chemistry being the most common I believe.

Even on the actual CSI shows non of them have a forensic degree like Greg was Chemistry, Grissom was Entomology, Adam was Computer Science, Sheldon was Medicine etc...

Now we have an abundance of people with this modern 'specialised' degree (not actually needed for the job) for a field that actually has very few jobs.

Gruffling · 19/11/2022 00:01

PicaNewName · 17/11/2022 17:34

Admin: on paper it sounds stress free and giving you a great work-life balance. In reality: it'd boring and tedious and you develop a crappy posture and eyes from staring at a screen all day. 😁

Depends on preferences, doesn't it?

Also found that many low level admin jobs have really high workload and no control over how work is done, which can be a stressful combination.

KnitFastDieWarm · 18/11/2022 23:57

BuckarooBanzai · 17/11/2022 17:34

Carer, poorly paid with some eye wateringly long shifts. Although the pay and shifts statement is very true the reality is it's a beautiful job where you can form really strong bonds with your clients. Sometimes I can't believe I actually get paid to do something I love so much. I really get to make a difference to people's well-being and that's such a privilege.

Thank you so much for what you do. It’s so important.

XelaM · 18/11/2022 23:51

Another flexible low stress alternative to being a fee earner can be doc review lawyer. Slaughter & May pay £40 per hour for 8 hour days plus overtime and it's all completely remote from home and very little responsibility/stress. You can get a job almost immediately if you sign up with the agency they use.

XelaM · 18/11/2022 22:55

@Oysterbabe I'm also in Civil Litigation, albeit mainly White Collar/Fraud litigation. I very much sympathise about the stress! Litigation is the worst for that and in-house roles for litigators are more difficult to find. Although with your clinical negligence experience I definitely think it's possible to find in-house roles. Maybe in an NHS Trust?

On a side note (as totally mental as this sounds) if you fantasise about being in hospital for a break - that means your files aren't in such a mess that you're afraid for anyone else to pick them up 😄so you're doing much better than some colleagues I know

Onlyforcake · 18/11/2022 22:08

Care. You get to really make a difference and its flexible right? You only work when you're needed?

Except you will be made the scapegoat by every business owner who will insist on increasing your hours and act like you're unprofessional when you're simply not available for hours you never agreed to.

Greengagesnfennel · 18/11/2022 22:04

Scientist- it's great. Everyone thinks dull, difficult, need to be clever, boring colleagues. Reality is international travel. Flexible working around childcare. Really family friendly. Interesting and diverse colleagues. Contributing to solving societies problems - so a sense of doing something worthwhile even if just a cog in the wheel.

Oysterbabe · 18/11/2022 21:59

Dixiechickonhols · 18/11/2022 21:33

Good luck with your chat Monday. That was what I used to do. You have lots of transferable skills. I don’t miss it at all.

Thank you.
It is an incredibly stressful role and mine in particular has an insane caseload. Hopefully I'll make my escape soon.