Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What careers sound good on paper nightmare in reality and what sounds nightmare on paper good in reality.

388 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 17/11/2022 16:05

On paper teaching sounds great, all those weeks off. Weekends off working in primary schools sounds fun secondary schools you can specialise in a subject you prefer. Reality grading lesson plans admin alot of work not enough pay.
Firefighters and police sounds fun reality dangerous.
In paper admin or reception jobs sounds boring and tedious paper work. But some have great hours and good work life balance.
In your opinion what jobs aren't worth the hype?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anonmousse · 13/12/2022 19:41

cakewitch · 13/12/2022 19:12

Being a cake maker.. lovely on paper... sounds like fun..yes?? But when all and sundry can't understand why you would make them an incredibly detailed bespoke confection with handmade sugarpaste figures that takes you hours of your time for a pittance, cos "I can get a cake from Asda for a tenner for that , hun" That's why I work for someone else now.

I think a lot of creative or practical, skilled jobs are undervalued and sometimes not even feasible to make money on (I mentioned this in my own post) and some people seem not to understand the difference between something handmade and bespoke and something factory/machine made and mass produced.

On a local fb page people are often asking for "reasonably priced " cake makers to make a (very elaborate) cake as if charging for your labour as well as ingredients and fuel is unreasonable. Another person was complaining that a carpenter was charging x for a handmade item . When you worked out the price of materials and how long it would take to make, it was not outrageous but on the face of it looked expensive

cakewitch · 13/12/2022 19:15

Oh yes... running a pub too.. fun on paper but hours of slog for nothing.

superplumb · 13/12/2022 19:14

Detective. Sounds great esp if you watch all th etc dramas. In reality you have to sit exams, do another qualification, get no more money for it, still work shifts including nights, often at very short notice. The number of 24 hur shifts I've pulled is stupid and you are expected to make critical decisions when you've not slept for over 35 hours. Public and politicians hate us. Some bad officers mean we are all tarred with the same brush
Good points are locking up really bad evil bastards.

cakewitch · 13/12/2022 19:12

Being a cake maker.. lovely on paper... sounds like fun..yes?? But when all and sundry can't understand why you would make them an incredibly detailed bespoke confection with handmade sugarpaste figures that takes you hours of your time for a pittance, cos "I can get a cake from Asda for a tenner for that , hun" That's why I work for someone else now.

Justjoinedforthis · 13/12/2022 18:36

Is anyone a hotel reviewer? That used to be my dream job.

My friend owns and runs a tattoo shop, good on paper, pretty great in real life!

XelaM · 13/12/2022 18:20

HappyPeaPod7 · 06/12/2022 20:03

Ohh @XelaM 😀sounds intriguing (I'm a private client solicitor) ...tell me more about this!!

Sorry, just saw this. PM me if you like 👍

Greenfairydust · 13/12/2022 18:11

Working for charities: sounds like a rewarding and interesting sector on paper, the reality:

  • poorly managed and disorganised
  • meeting-heavy and bureaucratic
  • chronic lack of investment in staff and infrastructure
  • poorly paid unless you are a CEO/Director
  • high staff turnover as a result
  • some dodgy practices when it comes to safeguarding and staff/clients/volunteers safety
  • incompetent Trustees/CEO/senior management who would not last a day in the private sector.

I have really grown to hate it...

Dixiechickonhols · 13/12/2022 18:10

Oysterbabe · 13/12/2022 17:56

Thanks for the ongoing support everyone. I had a meeting today and basically said it's not them it's me, I want a new challenge and to move away from PI and there's basically nothing they can offer that will tempt me. I hope that's the end of it and I can just gradually handover during the next couple of months.

I honestly think that’s best decision. Good luck.

Oysterbabe · 13/12/2022 17:56

Thanks for the ongoing support everyone. I had a meeting today and basically said it's not them it's me, I want a new challenge and to move away from PI and there's basically nothing they can offer that will tempt me. I hope that's the end of it and I can just gradually handover during the next couple of months.

Dixiechickonhols · 13/12/2022 15:10

Oysterbabe · 18/11/2022 10:26

Those of you who have escaped law, how did you do it and what do you do now? It's the only thing I'm qualified and experienced in but I hate it with the power of a thousand suns. When I'm walking to the office I fantasise about being hit by a car so I can have a nice stay in hospital instead. Anything else is going to involve a massive drop in salary which has been the main barrier. But I can't do this for another 25 years.

Found your first post! Remember this if you are tempted to stay.
Honestly there’s a world outside Litigation.

Dixiechickonhols · 13/12/2022 15:08

Oysterbabe · 13/12/2022 09:17

Thanks.
It's really not about the money so they can offer what they like and it won't change my mind, if anything it will make me feel pretty awkward, as I'm already on more than most of my colleagues. It's about being unable to keep up with the workload and feeling constant stress and anxiety as a result. They could reduce my caseload to a more reasonable level but where will those cases go? To my team, who feel the same as I do. They are seriously struggling to recruit people with the right experience. I really can't imagine sitting there like the Queen with my special low caseload with everyone else struggling. I also don't trust them not to hold it over me if they make me stay. Like next time something goes wrong I can imagine the meeting and them talking about being disappointed after they went to such lengths to keep me. I'm excited about the prospect of getting out and doing something different.
I have a meeting today on Teams to discuss it and another in person tomorrow with one of the directors. I need to stay strong. I feel like they might kidnap me and keep as a litigation version of a handmaid at this point, they seem so desperate.

If you are excited to try something new I’d keep that in mind.
It sounds like existing firm would make a few temporary changes then you’d be back to square one.
If you’ve met new firm and they seem fine I’d definitely give it a go. You said you knew someone there?
Worse case scenario you can always go back to similar role.
Start handover early then you can handover in best way for clients so your conscience is clear.

astronewt · 13/12/2022 14:49

The data shows that the vast majority of people who accept counteroffers end up leaving within the year anyway, @Oysterbabe . They rarely work. If you've got to the point of accepting another offer, the issues that have driven you to do so won't have gone away.

Oysterbabe · 13/12/2022 09:17

Thanks.
It's really not about the money so they can offer what they like and it won't change my mind, if anything it will make me feel pretty awkward, as I'm already on more than most of my colleagues. It's about being unable to keep up with the workload and feeling constant stress and anxiety as a result. They could reduce my caseload to a more reasonable level but where will those cases go? To my team, who feel the same as I do. They are seriously struggling to recruit people with the right experience. I really can't imagine sitting there like the Queen with my special low caseload with everyone else struggling. I also don't trust them not to hold it over me if they make me stay. Like next time something goes wrong I can imagine the meeting and them talking about being disappointed after they went to such lengths to keep me. I'm excited about the prospect of getting out and doing something different.
I have a meeting today on Teams to discuss it and another in person tomorrow with one of the directors. I need to stay strong. I feel like they might kidnap me and keep as a litigation version of a handmaid at this point, they seem so desperate.

HappyPeaPod7 · 13/12/2022 07:57

Dixiechickonhols · 12/12/2022 19:39

I’d think about your reasons for going. Realistically if it’s pi it’s not going to improve it’s only going to get worse in current climate.
I suspect nothing will change and you’ll kick yourself.
I’d listen to offer and say you’ll consider it and get back to them by x date.

It speaks volumes @Oysterbabe that your current employer is willing to go to great lengths to retain you. But why have they not done everything possible to make you feel valued or looked after your work life balance until now? I think that is their problem. And I agree with @Dixiechickonhols comments.

XelaM · 12/12/2022 22:15

Dionysiana · 12/12/2022 20:03

Nobody’s mentioned translation yet. The only preconception I’m aware of is that everyone automatically thinks of novels, and I don’t know if people would generally think it was an awful or a good job.
I translate academic research in quite a niche area. I get sent mainly interesting stuff, although there are some howlers too, obviously. It’s a bit like playing word games all day, plus learning random facts along the way, with the added bonus of (hopefully) keeping dementia at bay. Self-employed but not too much paperwork or stress. Lovely, appreciative clients. It’s my third career and the only one I’ve stuck at happily for more than 10 years. WFH is very compatible with having a happy dog, too!

My mum has been a translator her whole life (now in her 60's - German/Russian mainly). You have to have a lot of patience and attention to detail. I couldn't do it. I speak German and Russian fluently as well, but could never have the patience to ensure that translations are exactly correct like my mum does.

Sillybanana · 12/12/2022 21:09

😂😂

Dionysiana · 12/12/2022 20:03

Nobody’s mentioned translation yet. The only preconception I’m aware of is that everyone automatically thinks of novels, and I don’t know if people would generally think it was an awful or a good job.
I translate academic research in quite a niche area. I get sent mainly interesting stuff, although there are some howlers too, obviously. It’s a bit like playing word games all day, plus learning random facts along the way, with the added bonus of (hopefully) keeping dementia at bay. Self-employed but not too much paperwork or stress. Lovely, appreciative clients. It’s my third career and the only one I’ve stuck at happily for more than 10 years. WFH is very compatible with having a happy dog, too!

Dixiechickonhols · 12/12/2022 19:39

Oysterbabe · 12/12/2022 17:57

I handed my notice in on Friday and they are losing their minds. They've asked me what I need from them to stay, said they have a blank page and anything will be considered. They have suggested a salary increase, a lump sum bonus, smaller caseload, a change of teams if I'd prefer a different one, anything else I can think of. They've scheduled a meeting for Wednesday.
I'm just not convinced any good will come of staying because they talked me into it.

I’d think about your reasons for going. Realistically if it’s pi it’s not going to improve it’s only going to get worse in current climate.
I suspect nothing will change and you’ll kick yourself.
I’d listen to offer and say you’ll consider it and get back to them by x date.

Wherediditallgo · 12/12/2022 19:34

Oysterbabe · 12/12/2022 17:57

I handed my notice in on Friday and they are losing their minds. They've asked me what I need from them to stay, said they have a blank page and anything will be considered. They have suggested a salary increase, a lump sum bonus, smaller caseload, a change of teams if I'd prefer a different one, anything else I can think of. They've scheduled a meeting for Wednesday.
I'm just not convinced any good will come of staying because they talked me into it.

Years ago I was given a major pay rise to convince me stay in my job which consisted of eat, sleep, work, repeat. I thought the money would mitigate the stress. It didn’t. I left a year later and took a pay cut in doing so. When it’s time to go, it’s time to go.

Oysterbabe · 12/12/2022 17:57

I handed my notice in on Friday and they are losing their minds. They've asked me what I need from them to stay, said they have a blank page and anything will be considered. They have suggested a salary increase, a lump sum bonus, smaller caseload, a change of teams if I'd prefer a different one, anything else I can think of. They've scheduled a meeting for Wednesday.
I'm just not convinced any good will come of staying because they talked me into it.

minipie · 08/12/2022 12:07

@XelaM I would also like the details please (ex litigator of many years, currently SAHM but could do with a bit of work)

Hoppinggreen · 08/12/2022 12:07

I know a few funeral directors.
They are lovely people, quite jolly and not short of money either

Janieread · 08/12/2022 12:06

Vet. Awful work load and dealing with very sick animals and often clueless and aggressive owners.

Buteverythingsfine · 08/12/2022 12:03

@MadameSzyszkoBohusz presumably seasonal, sounds great fun!

SleeplessInEngland · 08/12/2022 11:41

Enjoyable thread, although it's making me realise how few professions I ever thought sounded good in the first place. Surely no-one still thinks teaching seems like an easy, well-paid career?