Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be utterly devastated about this...

128 replies

daisydove · 17/11/2022 15:58

When I look back on my childhood, I have nothing but happy memories. I had 2 parents who were happily married that gave me a really privileged life. I was privately educated, went abroad on holiday every year and always had the latest toys. I was happy and care free. I always said I wanted to create the same life for my children...

I was in a happy relationship, until I got pregnant and my partner turned abusive so I had to leave. I went ahead with the pregnancy as I have always wanted to be a mum but now she's here I just feel sad that I can't give her the life I had. The stable family unit. The holidays. I just feel like I've failed her already. She'll forever come from a "broken home".

I'm not saying single parent households are not happy homes, I just think I'm mourning the life I thought I would give my children.

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 17/11/2022 17:10

OP. I had an abusive father. I didn't realize the extent to which this had affected me throughout life, but a cPTSD diagnosis 3 years ago forced me to confront it. I'd lived with this until my forties.

My mother should have left him. The only answer I can give as to why she didn't was threefold: part boiling-frog syndrome, part that he was crafty and didn't go too far in front of her, nor did he tend to leave marks, and part because she thought divorce would be harmful to her children. Women are conditioned to think this, doubtless because it suits the convenience of men.

The bastard slammed my head down a door when I was fifteen and gave me concussion. He could have killed me. When I was in my 20s I discussed with my mum the gravity of my mum's error in staying with this man, and owned to my resentment. She admitted and grieved this failing, one done from the best of motives but very damaging nonetheless: what I received from her was heartfelt contrition and a real apology, not a non-one. We'd put all this behind us at the time of her death, and were always very close, so admitting that the mother I adored had failed me was far more difficult than confronting the fact of what an abusive, dangerous man my father was.

OP, you've freed yourself and your daughter from an abusive father - and it's at her impressionable age that these men do most damage - and freed her from a childhood like mine. That is the greatest gift any mother can give her child: worth all the material considerations, private education and holidays in the world.

You're an amazing mother. Don't ever tell yourself any differently.

SarahSissions · 17/11/2022 17:09

Holidays are lovely, latest toys etc. but the absolute best thing for any child is having someone strong and determined to look after them and give them the best they are able. You have done something incredibly brave, that means your child will grow up in a safe environment, you can’t do more than that. Well done and hopefully one day you can recognise what a gift you have given your baby

Derbee · 17/11/2022 17:06

It’s so easy to beat yourself up as a parent. But you should remember that a “stable family unit” can be you and her - you are her stability and security.

A “broken home” would have been living in an abusive environment

Haffiana · 17/11/2022 17:05

I was in a happy relationship, until I got pregnant and my partner turned abusive so I had to leave.

This is what a good childhood gave you - the ability to identify an abusive relationship and to leave immediately.

SO many women cannot do either of these things because their childhoods did not equip them with the self esteem and self reliance that your parents gave you. These womens children in their turn grow up thinking abuse is normal, and understanding and internalising that their actual value is to be a poor second to their mother's need to keep a relationship going at any cost.

You will in turn be passing your strength and sense of self on to your children. Happiness is not in the external things but in a sense of self confidence and self worth.

Guitarbar · 17/11/2022 17:04

Honestly, you are enough. No her childhood won't be the same as yours (it wouldn't anyway as you are not your parents) and there's nothing wrong with that; times change, things change, she will still be blessed with an amazing mum who wants the best for her and does what she can to achieve that. Honestly it sounds cliche and twee but there's a lot to be said for providing a safe home full of love, that's more important than the stuff inside it.

CallieApricot · 17/11/2022 17:03

I gave my kids the happy family with a good dad, but he died when they were 11 and 13. It's devastating what happened and obviously they too haven't grown up in the situation I'd have hoped for, but they've had plenty of love from me after he died and we get on well. I grew up in a comfortable but unhappy home, so don't have that comparison, but I think you should be very proud of not keeping them in an unhappy home. I wish my dad had had that courage to leave my abusive mother. Your kids have grown up in a loving home with you like mine have. Thats a lot and many don't have that. Be proud of what you've given them. I am.

BlackForestCake · 17/11/2022 17:01

My dad was abusive. I'm proud of my mum that she left when she did. You do what you have to do.

DarkShade · 17/11/2022 16:58

You are her stable family unit!! You're amazing, look how well you're already doing by her. You have protected her from your abusive ex and you get up everyday and do your best for her, despite it being a very difficult time for you and despite everything that you have been through. She will be so proud of you, and will look back and admire your courage and determination.

When you look back at your own childhood, you remember being happy about the holidays and the toys. But let me tell you, you were really only happy because your family was loving and safe. Children who grow up without love and security are not happy, even if they go to good schools and have nice things. The things that really matter - love, security, joy - you are perfectly positioned to give her. In fact, you already do give it to her, and started doing so when you left your ex before she was even born.

Freshmind001 · 17/11/2022 16:52

Firstly you should be incredibly proud of yourself for having that courage to leave. Secondly, you are your daughters stable and safe family + environment, and I am sure she will grow up to have a very happy childhood also.

StuffYouAllInTheCrust · 17/11/2022 16:50

I was the child in this scenario and I am forever grateful to my mum for removing us all for an abusive situation. No, we didn’t have the big holidays and the latest toys, but we didn’t miss what we never had.

My mum still beats herself up about things years and years later and it breaks my heart to see. I adore her and I’m so thankful for having such a strong, caring mum as a role model in my life. I’m so proud of her.

i wish I could make her realise that.

bloodywhitecat · 17/11/2022 16:48

Family units come in all shapes and sizes, she will have a strong parent who made the right decision and put her first, that is what she needs for a secure future.

WeAreAllSpecksOnARock · 17/11/2022 16:48

You have not failed.
Your home life may not look how you hoped it would, but it doesn’t mean that it makes it worse.
You have a future ahead of you with your child that you have the power to shape yourself. Your baby won’t remember the stuff, but will remember the person and mum that you are.

OnlyFannys · 17/11/2022 16:47

OP I felt like this when DDs dad went to prison just after she was born. I felt like the family life I'd always wanted had been ripped away from me (I grew up in a horrible childhood with violence and poverty so my grief came from wanting to provide what I never had but totally understand your point nonetheless). When it happend I was on mat leave and made redundant then my landlord sold his house and I was totally lost and thought I'd failed her.
7 years later I own my home and earn 70k (which is a lot up north where i live). I have a wonderful relationship with a new partner and my DD has the childhood i alway dreamed of. You can turn this around and be everything your child needs and more, you have already shown how strong you are by leaving an abusive relationship. Give yourself time to heal and then dust yourself off and make your life what you want it to be.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 17/11/2022 16:45

It's not a broken home, it's a stable loving home free from abuse.

readingismycardio · 17/11/2022 16:45

Let me put it differently, OP. You were extremely BRAVE and responsible and left at the right time so your DD will never know how living in an abusive home is. You have been blessed with a healthy little girl and you are FAMILY. Family is not about numbers, is about love. And she does have that.

tunnocksreturns2019 · 17/11/2022 16:44

FlorettaB · 17/11/2022 16:20

’I just feel sad that I can't give her the life I had. The stable family unit. The holidays. I just feel like I've failed her already. She'll forever come from a "broken home".’

You can give her a stable family unit. It just won’t look like the one you imagined. Let the image you had go and focus on you, her and your extended family.

This is great advice. I feel the same, my DH died and I’m doing it alone too, so far from how I wanted to. But we’ve got this 🙌

littleburn · 17/11/2022 16:42

Oh OP you haven't failed her and your home isn't broken. You might not be able to provide your DD with all of the material benefits of your childhood, but you're raising her in a happy, loving home. The alternative would have been raising her in an abusive home, so she (and you) are already winning.

shieldmaiden7 · 17/11/2022 16:42

Don't beat yourself up! I came from a similar back ground. I thought I was doing similar for my kids, was married to their dad, for 14 years. but he was a functioning alcoholic who was constantly getting us in debt who later became extremely abusive. I left eventually when my mental health was at rock bottom. I was single for years and eventually met my DH, my ex gave up the children and my DH took them on as his own, we had a baby together last year and bought our home, we are financially stable which for me has been the first time in almost 20 years. The life my children have now is way better any life they had when I was with their dad. Things can turn around for you too.
Congratulations on your dc and well done for walking away x

AriettyHomily · 17/11/2022 16:39

Rather a single happy parent than a shit alcoholic parent and the other one trying to pick up the pieces op. You are the family.

Naimee87 · 17/11/2022 16:35

I had the same upbringing as you! Im a single mum to my DS whose now 13, it hasnt been an easy ride but its definitely been a happy one. Just be careful your view of your situation doesnt transfer to your DD, they can pick up on things very easily and if you arent happy with your situation she will be able to tell. Its hard to describe but i think you will thoroughly enjoy so many life stages with her. And sounds like you made the best decision leaving your ex too.

SeenAndNot · 17/11/2022 16:33

The way you are talking and thinking is very much working on the assumption that there’s only one way to have a happy childhood. It’s not true.

My upbringing was very like yours, holidays, latest gadgets, private school etc. But I suffered a barrage of abuse.

DH grew up so poor because of a botched business deal that his parents had to go round the house pawning stuff to afford simple Christmas presents for them. No holidays abroad. Everything meticulously saved for.

Guess who had the happier childhood?

talkingmorenonsense · 17/11/2022 16:28

Good for you for getting out of an abusive relationship. You've done the very best for yourself and your child. I personally detest the term "broken home" . Families come in all shapes and sizes, it really doesn't matter. What matters is that you love your children unconditionally. Some of the very happiest children don't have endless toys and posh holidays, they have love and attention from their parents and that's what is important.

FlorettaB · 17/11/2022 16:20

’I just feel sad that I can't give her the life I had. The stable family unit. The holidays. I just feel like I've failed her already. She'll forever come from a "broken home".’

You can give her a stable family unit. It just won’t look like the one you imagined. Let the image you had go and focus on you, her and your extended family.

Livingtothefull · 17/11/2022 16:19

It sounds like you have been through a really traumatic time and so it is no wonder if you are feeling low and vulnerable now. But you won't feel like this for ever, & I am quite sure that better times are ahead for you and your lovely new baby.

You did the right thing and were really brave to leave an abusive relationship whilst pregnant. With courage like that I am sure you will manage fine and your little one will thrive because she will be loved by you.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2022 16:10

now she's here I just feel sad that I can't give her the life I had. The stable family unit

You ARE giving her a stable family unit by not bringing her up with an abusive parent; just one loving mother who wants the best for her.