Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be utterly devastated about this...

128 replies

daisydove · 17/11/2022 15:58

When I look back on my childhood, I have nothing but happy memories. I had 2 parents who were happily married that gave me a really privileged life. I was privately educated, went abroad on holiday every year and always had the latest toys. I was happy and care free. I always said I wanted to create the same life for my children...

I was in a happy relationship, until I got pregnant and my partner turned abusive so I had to leave. I went ahead with the pregnancy as I have always wanted to be a mum but now she's here I just feel sad that I can't give her the life I had. The stable family unit. The holidays. I just feel like I've failed her already. She'll forever come from a "broken home".

I'm not saying single parent households are not happy homes, I just think I'm mourning the life I thought I would give my children.

OP posts:
Skyedart · 17/11/2022 19:25

You and your DD are a strong family unit. You don’t need mum, dad and DC to make a family unit. Every family is different and what matters is the love. You are a strong woman raising who I’m sure will grow to be another strong woman because she has you as her role model. I’m not saying it will be easy but you will be both be fine.

EerieSilence · 17/11/2022 19:25

I grew up in a "happy family", both parents, three children. For various reasons, my childhood was really crap.
You are well capable of providing your child a caring and loving home on your own. I wish you all the very best, it's obvious you want it for you and your little one.
Guilt is a very shitty manager. Don't let it rule you.

notanothertakeaway · 17/11/2022 19:23

OnlyFannys · 17/11/2022 16:47

OP I felt like this when DDs dad went to prison just after she was born. I felt like the family life I'd always wanted had been ripped away from me (I grew up in a horrible childhood with violence and poverty so my grief came from wanting to provide what I never had but totally understand your point nonetheless). When it happend I was on mat leave and made redundant then my landlord sold his house and I was totally lost and thought I'd failed her.
7 years later I own my home and earn 70k (which is a lot up north where i live). I have a wonderful relationship with a new partner and my DD has the childhood i alway dreamed of. You can turn this around and be everything your child needs and more, you have already shown how strong you are by leaving an abusive relationship. Give yourself time to heal and then dust yourself off and make your life what you want it to be.

@OnlyFannys that made me smile. Well done you. Glad it all worked out so well

NurseBernard · 17/11/2022 19:19

It’s important to remember that the only person who has the two childhoods to compare - is you.

She doesn’t.

She isn’t going to know any different from the childhood you give her.

So just focus on making it a happy one for the two of you.

When she grows up, she’ll look back on her own unique childhood, and she’ll remember feeling loved and cared for, and - with adult understanding - that she was prioritised above all else.

That’s pretty special.

Keep the memories of your own lovely childhood for you, and focus on creating your DD’s own childhood.

PixellatedPixie · 17/11/2022 19:15

@Lilgamesh2 antibiotics save newborns lives every day so what option did you have? In countries where they are not readily available the infant mortality rates are massively higher than in the West. You did the best for your child. Also, there is a genetic element to allergies so you’ll never know if it’s because of the antibiotics.

Favouritefruits · 17/11/2022 19:14

Your child will have a different childhood but by no means worse just different, your DC has a mum who loves them all to their self, what more could a child want? Different doesn’t always mean worse.

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2022 19:00

Do not underestimate what you've done for your child. You've left an abusive relationship; that's a brave act that requires phenomenal strength and insight. Not everyone manages it.

You've given her a mother who is whole and safe and happy. And you have the rest of your lives to do wonderful things together. In my eyes you're already doing a wonderful job. Be happy. Flowers

cosypeppermint · 17/11/2022 18:55

You did not break her home. You mended it.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/11/2022 18:53

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 17/11/2022 17:10

OP. I had an abusive father. I didn't realize the extent to which this had affected me throughout life, but a cPTSD diagnosis 3 years ago forced me to confront it. I'd lived with this until my forties.

My mother should have left him. The only answer I can give as to why she didn't was threefold: part boiling-frog syndrome, part that he was crafty and didn't go too far in front of her, nor did he tend to leave marks, and part because she thought divorce would be harmful to her children. Women are conditioned to think this, doubtless because it suits the convenience of men.

The bastard slammed my head down a door when I was fifteen and gave me concussion. He could have killed me. When I was in my 20s I discussed with my mum the gravity of my mum's error in staying with this man, and owned to my resentment. She admitted and grieved this failing, one done from the best of motives but very damaging nonetheless: what I received from her was heartfelt contrition and a real apology, not a non-one. We'd put all this behind us at the time of her death, and were always very close, so admitting that the mother I adored had failed me was far more difficult than confronting the fact of what an abusive, dangerous man my father was.

OP, you've freed yourself and your daughter from an abusive father - and it's at her impressionable age that these men do most damage - and freed her from a childhood like mine. That is the greatest gift any mother can give her child: worth all the material considerations, private education and holidays in the world.

You're an amazing mother. Don't ever tell yourself any differently.

Yes.

I too had the holidays, private education and the rest. It meant fuck all when forced to live with an abusive father because he and Mum thought divorce was Wrong. I wish she'd left.

Sunshineandflipflops · 17/11/2022 18:43

What your dd needs is a positive role model and a mum who loves her. The other things are nice but won’t influence the foundations of who she becomes.

I am a single parent to 2 after my exh had an affair. It’s not what I imagined or wanted but our home is not broken, it’s full of love and happiness and I love our little team of 3.

By all means grieve for the life you imagined but then pick yourself up and remember that you have all the tools you need to make your life with your dd happy and fulfilling.

Thisislifefornow · 17/11/2022 18:43

I grew up in a single parent household with just my mum. I can honestly say I had the best childhood any child could wish for. We didn't have lots of money or even a car but I had the best time. My mum put every ounce she had into me and my brothers and I'm forever grateful for the memories and feeling safe / loved.

EveryoneToHisOwnGout · 17/11/2022 18:42

Marbleeyed · 17/11/2022 16:08

You could be my mum, you’ve described yourself as her almost exactly and I couldn’t be prouder of her, or happier with the childhood she gave me. You haven’t failed your child.

This is so lovely to read, as I had the same childhood as the OP and feel that I have failed all my children by not giving them the same. Thank you!

ListeningButNotHearing · 17/11/2022 18:40

A broken home is an unhappy home.

Like everyone else on here, I admire your great strength and courage to not let your DD grow up in a broken home 💐

OldFan · 17/11/2022 18:36

I wish my mum had left my dad much earlier than she did.

OldFan · 17/11/2022 18:35

I think the idea of a 'broken home' is not a current one @daisydove .

Your kids can have just as nice a time as you did with their mum.

Mollyplop999 · 17/11/2022 18:31

You sound like an amazing person. My "Dad" left wheni was 9 and 8t was the best day of my life. I got my Mum back. I never felt as though I'd missed out, quite the opposite

AtomicRitual · 17/11/2022 18:28

Two things to remember:

  • your DD doesn't know how you grew up - she will never have a direct comparison, so, to her, her childhood will be as idyllic as yours because she will be surrounded by love and peace. The only alternative was to stay with an abusive partner, and that is absolutely not the way to an idyllic childhood.
  • you have to accept that the way you were brought up can't be replicated and adjust your expectations. I had what I consider to be an idyllic childhood with never a cross word said between my parents, so when I was in my first relationship and we had a row, I was devastated. I thought we were doomed to break up (well, I wasn't far wrong with that, to be fair) as perfect couples like my parents don't argue. When I realised that actually my parents did argue, just not in front of me, and that arguing was perfectly normal in a relationship, I manage to adjust my expectations of a "perfect" family. It's ironic that my parents didn't argue in front of me because both of their parents argued in front of them and they hated it and swore they'd never do it to their own children and therefore affecting me in a different way!

As I say, I consider myself to have had an idyllic childhood. I knew money was tight, but my childhood memories are full of fun times with my Mum particularly as Dad was at work so much. We played games, spent hours in the garden playing swingball and messing around on hammocks, having water fights, etc. I found some photos recently of those times and was shocked to see the background of some of the photos. They made me realise how much my parents struggled financially. The furniture was so tatty and clearly second or even third-hand. Looking at it now, it looks awful but at the time I didn't see it, didn't care and, as I say, had a very happy childhood.

You don't need a perfect family or a perfect home to have a happy childhood.

Be kind to yourself OP!

Softplayhooray · 17/11/2022 18:27

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 17/11/2022 16:45

It's not a broken home, it's a stable loving home free from abuse.

Exactly this! Don't waste a second longer thinking that it is a broken family. It's a horrible phrase and has no relation to reality. When I was young I'd have been so happy if my parents divorced as it was a toxic place and two separate households would've been a lot better for many reasons. Kids just want love, respect, care and affection, they don't care what that looks like. You're giving that already which means your DD is already luckier than a huge number of kids.

AnApparitionQuipped · 17/11/2022 18:27

You can still give your daughter a great life. You don't have to recreate your own childhood, however wonderful it was, to give your daughter equal happiness as she grows up. Wishing you both the best.

touchedout2022 · 17/11/2022 18:23

Thank you for posting OP . You have put it better than I ever could. Even 10 years later , I am still filled with regrets and anger at myself for choosing the right father for my dc . I have never forgiven myself but maybe one day I will Smile.

FacebookPhotos · 17/11/2022 18:19

I was privately educated, went abroad on holiday every year and always had the latest toys. I was happy and care free.

I had none of those things but was still happy and care free. Children simply do not need any of those things. They need a home where they feel safe and loved. In leaving the abusive relationship you have already ensured that your child will have those things.

The idea of a “broken home” is one I always find offensive. My home was not broken just because me dad didn’t live there. My home was awesome, and it is still a place a feel safe and loved.

TabithaTittlemouse · 17/11/2022 18:18

You are everything to your daughter! Happiness comes in different ways.

You could give your daughter all that you had and she could be completely miserable!

CoffeeLover90 · 17/11/2022 18:13

I understand what you're feeling. I wish I'd been as brave as you and left when pregnant. I wish I hadn't subjected my child to 2 years of shite. I wish I'd learned much sooner that I am the stable unit.
YOU are her family. With a mum as brave, strong and selfless as you she'll thrive. Read the comments here, come back to this if you ever feel like this again. Try not to wallow, this time will pass so quickly. You're amazing and you should be so proud of yourself.

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 17/11/2022 18:12

I completely understand where you are coming from.

I chose to leave my children's father, when they were 11 & 9 years old, as he was cheating continually. Up until that point they had only had the best of things and all that money could buy. Obviously they had less once we had separated, and I don't think my DD really got over the separation for about 8 years. For years they had to shuffle between 2 homes, and even now, obviously they can't just "come home" for Christmas, they have to factor in 2 family homes (they are adults now). I feel huge guilt and have wondered whether I should have stayed just to make their lives easier. For myself it was the right choice, as I am now happily married to a lovely man, but I feel selfish sometimes.

My parents stayed together, and theirs was quite an abusive relationship, and whilst I'm sure my Mum didn't leave my Dad probably for us children's sakes, I'm not sure that was right either, because even though we didn't ever have a "broken home", the home was often filled with anger and fighting.

I don't know what the answer is, but I do often feel drawn to "forgive yourself" type poems etc!

Lullabies2Paralyze · 17/11/2022 18:11

I think everyone who had a great childhood is sad that they can’t give their kids the same.

my parents were well off enough that my mam didn’t have to return to work until I (the youngest) was nearly finished primary. This meant she was always there after school, school hols (even when she went back to work she was as was a teacher), school trips etc.

im sad I have to return to work and some childminder /nursery will get to see most of my child’s developments.