Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 10:11

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 12:05

I wouldn’t be surprised if a lot of them are SAHMs whose partner earns too much for them to be entitled to claim benefits, but childcare costs too much for them to be able to work.

You are spot on with that! Not everyone has friends/relatives who provide free childcare. We’re lucky to have a night a year with a babysitter. Couldn’t utilise free childcare at 3 as there were no spaces and providers were closed for a time due to covid, if we paid, it was more expensive than my wage so the best option was to stay home with one wage pennies over threshold and no benefits. Now school age and it’s not much easier.

While I do believe the system should be a safety net and not a long term choice (with exceptions for health, disabilities and carers), I do see how this becomes the only option for some people. This country makes it too hard for many families to just exist. Ultimately, we shouldn’t be in a society where we still struggle to live on 2 wages, where kids miss out on much need time with parents etc. Nobody should be too poor to have a choice, we have progressed from all women staying at home to not being able to decide for ourselves and that isn’t good progress IMO.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 10:10

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 09:44

He’s a dentist. He isn’t going to be working shifts or nights. His job isn’t flexible. This is literally what I was talking about earlier - professional jobs aren’t offered on a flexible basis. Sharing childcare would mean him leaving dentistry and getting a shitty flexible job, in order to allow me to also get a shitty flexible job, and we’d be significantly worse off. If one partner has a professional career the other can’t, because professional jobs aren’t available on a part time flexible basis. And this is the major problem.

I meant you could work nights or weekends.

I work full time in a professional career. Dh also works full time. We make it work.

So no, its not true that if 1 parent works in a professional career the other can't. Your dh is choosing not to prioritise childcare or you working. Its a choice

Blip · 18/11/2022 09:56

I think the biggest issue is people who are too sick to work and the NHS is not sorting them out.

Thinking especially of Long Covid and CFS/ME.

KimberleyClark · 18/11/2022 09:46

Madamecastafiore · 18/11/2022 07:25

I don't need to work and have a full and active life (I do 5 hours a week hobby job) and when I did work got hideous amounts of grief from colleagues (in the NHS) who decided I didn't financially need to work and so was taking a job off of someone who did need to work!

You really can't win.

Many years ago I worked with a guy whose side hustle made him as much if not more money than his actual job. He said he worked for social reasons. I always thought good for him.

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 09:44

Topgub · 18/11/2022 09:31

Or their dh, who should also be responsible for childcare, works flexibly so they can do their share.

Or they do shifts/nights/weekends.

Suggesting it's impossible to work if you have kids in school is nonsense.

Especially as you've identified a gap in the market. Set yourself up as a childminder.

He’s a dentist. He isn’t going to be working shifts or nights. His job isn’t flexible. This is literally what I was talking about earlier - professional jobs aren’t offered on a flexible basis. Sharing childcare would mean him leaving dentistry and getting a shitty flexible job, in order to allow me to also get a shitty flexible job, and we’d be significantly worse off. If one partner has a professional career the other can’t, because professional jobs aren’t available on a part time flexible basis. And this is the major problem.

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 09:39

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/11/2022 09:29

What an odd question? DH can work because he has a partner (me) who picks up the kids. We could swap roles but I’d only earn half his salary and it wouldn’t pay the bills

Why would you only earn half his salary? What is the difference between your career path and his? Why is his unaffected, and his earning potential higher than yours?

Because some careers pay more than others? He’s a dentist and earns a fortune. Whereas I used to work with teenagers at the local college, which was rewarding but didn’t pay a lot. Even before we had kids he already earned double my salary. And it doesn’t matter how long or hard I work, it’s simply not possible for someone in my job to match the salary of a dentist.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 09:31

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 09:23

What an odd question? DH can work because he has a partner (me) who picks up the kids. We could swap roles but I’d only earn half his salary and it wouldn’t pay the bills.

I suppose millions of other families manage because they have relatives who pick up the kids, or the school has after-school clubs, or they live in an urban area with lots of childminders. There isn’t a single childminder who collects from my DCs small village school.

Or their dh, who should also be responsible for childcare, works flexibly so they can do their share.

Or they do shifts/nights/weekends.

Suggesting it's impossible to work if you have kids in school is nonsense.

Especially as you've identified a gap in the market. Set yourself up as a childminder.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/11/2022 09:29

What an odd question? DH can work because he has a partner (me) who picks up the kids. We could swap roles but I’d only earn half his salary and it wouldn’t pay the bills

Why would you only earn half his salary? What is the difference between your career path and his? Why is his unaffected, and his earning potential higher than yours?

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 09:29

Getoff · 17/11/2022 23:52

How can subsidising childcare do the state or the economy any good, when the premise of the question is that her time is worth less than the cost of professional childcare?

Subsidy won't make her labour worth more, and it won't make childcare cheaper. The only way subsidy makes sense is if your way of computing the benefit regards "subsidy" as money extracted from someone who doesn't matter, so it doesn't have to be counted as a cost.

It helps because it keeps her in the workforce until she no longer needs childcare. The cost is only crippling for 3-4 years until school starts. But that break from employment ruins her future prospects. Subsidising childcare for 3-4 years allows her to keep working for the next 30-40 years.

Schlaar · 18/11/2022 09:23

Topgub · 18/11/2022 08:24

How does your dh manage to work when he has kids to pick from school?

How do you think the millions of other families who work outside of school hours manage?

@Schlaar

What an odd question? DH can work because he has a partner (me) who picks up the kids. We could swap roles but I’d only earn half his salary and it wouldn’t pay the bills.

I suppose millions of other families manage because they have relatives who pick up the kids, or the school has after-school clubs, or they live in an urban area with lots of childminders. There isn’t a single childminder who collects from my DCs small village school.

PottyDottyDotPot · 18/11/2022 08:37

I think there are a lot of early retirees who think or feel as though they’ve earned their keep and thus the right to sit back and claim their pension, when the reality is that the tax and NI they paid during their lifetimes didn’t even cover the services they and their family used, let alone decades of a state pension. Which isn’t an attitude I’ve much time for
I don’t agree with this, my household have paid over 100k per year in tax and NI for many many years, money that has probably gone towards benefits and child benefits of other ‘workers’. My DH and I are living off private pensions that we have contributed too. There aren’t any early retirees living off a state pension.

Zanatdy · 18/11/2022 08:31

BakedRightOff · 18/11/2022 08:15

Problem with this thinking is define ‘paid enough in’? Someone like myself who paid higher band tax rates for years has already statistically paid in more than a low earner ever will or someone on benefits. I don’t have an issue with that but you can’t force people to work on the premise of having paid in. That’s not even how our welfare state works. The issue is what makes them
motivated to return to the workplace so the govt can continue collecting taxes off them beyond.

I think for pension it’s a defined number of years, 30yrs or so. As said the other services don’t work like that, but guess that’s what JH’s thinking here is that there’s a set amount of people not working, not claiming benefits that could be contributing to the country, but aren’t, for whatever reason. I don’t think he can or will do anything to get some of these people into work, as they aren’t dependant on rules around benefits etc

Stillthewrongsideof40 · 18/11/2022 08:31

I fall into this category, It doesn’t work out financially to work and pay for child care. Other half has a job that puts us above the threshold for help and we don’t qualify for any benefits due to his salary. I have a couple of friends and family members in the same position.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 08:24

How does your dh manage to work when he has kids to pick from school?

How do you think the millions of other families who work outside of school hours manage?

@Schlaar

smileandsing · 18/11/2022 08:21

My mum was part of that group for many years, she was a SAHM and didn't claim any benefits. Didn't mean she was work shy, far from it.
I don't think people who don't work or claim benefits as 'morally obliged' to work. Nor are they a drain on society, in fact quite the opposite

Tillow4ever · 18/11/2022 08:15

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 12:14

I would love a proper job! Could someone please point me in the direction of a decent job which allows me to work 9-2 only? Or work 9-2 in the office then make up the rest working from home? Thought not. How am I supposed to work when I have to pick up the kids from school and no employer will accommodate that?

I work full-time and so the school run in the morning and again at 3.30pm. There are lots of jobs working from home these days, so it absolutely is possible to get one that will allow you to do that. It may not be easy, as there might be a lot of competition, but it’s not impossible.

BakedRightOff · 18/11/2022 08:15

Zanatdy · 18/11/2022 07:35

Torn on this as first thought is that if people aren’t claiming benefits what’s the problem. But then if they haven’t worked for a few decades they likely haven’t paid enough tax / NI to justify all the services they use. I’ve no idea what JH thinks he can do about it though, it’s not like people will be told to stop using services if they’ve not paid enough NI

Problem with this thinking is define ‘paid enough in’? Someone like myself who paid higher band tax rates for years has already statistically paid in more than a low earner ever will or someone on benefits. I don’t have an issue with that but you can’t force people to work on the premise of having paid in. That’s not even how our welfare state works. The issue is what makes them
motivated to return to the workplace so the govt can continue collecting taxes off them beyond.

the80sweregreat · 18/11/2022 07:43

I couldn't work full time for years for many reasons , I did very part time to fit in with the children and elderly parents etc.
Lots of women I know were in the same boat too.
Not everyone has childcare on tap either ; the ones I know whose parents / grand parents did the heavy lifting have faired much better too. They could carry on with their jobs

user1487194234 · 18/11/2022 07:39

I enjoy my work and can’t imagine not working
My DH and I earn much the same which suits me
I believe I set a good example to my DC

JangolinaPitt · 18/11/2022 07:39

SofiaSoFar · 17/11/2022 22:18

Who do they think should be paying for people who can’t work

Anyone except them.

It's the same on any MN thread talking about the economy, incomes, etc. There are plenty of people who are certain that group X and group Y should definitely get more money but no one thinks they should be the one to contribute more to fund it.

This

JangolinaPitt · 18/11/2022 07:39

midgetastic · 17/11/2022 12:10

I suspect that in sone cases people are making a moral decision to quit the rat race , quit putting money into other peoples pockets and quit supporting growth that damages the environment

I very much doubt anyone is actually doing that!

DontMakeMeShushYou · 18/11/2022 07:36

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 12:14

I would love a proper job! Could someone please point me in the direction of a decent job which allows me to work 9-2 only? Or work 9-2 in the office then make up the rest working from home? Thought not. How am I supposed to work when I have to pick up the kids from school and no employer will accommodate that?

Me and most of my colleagues in academic support roles.

celticprincess · 18/11/2022 07:35

Well I work to live. I don’t live to work. I work part time and do get too ups but wish I didn’t have to. Single parent juggling work, childcare and a child with a disability.

I know quite a few on the school run who are SAHMs and who don’t claim as their partner earns a really decent salary. Another at my work gave it up because it was too stressful jiggling the childcare and she didn’t need the money.

But then we have people desperate to work who can’t due to the whole cost of childcare , inflexible jobs and travel.

Zanatdy · 18/11/2022 07:35

Torn on this as first thought is that if people aren’t claiming benefits what’s the problem. But then if they haven’t worked for a few decades they likely haven’t paid enough tax / NI to justify all the services they use. I’ve no idea what JH thinks he can do about it though, it’s not like people will be told to stop using services if they’ve not paid enough NI

Topgub · 18/11/2022 07:30

@bridgetreilly

I'm sure stats show that a fairly small proportion of economically inactive people volunteer. And almost as many people who work volunteer too.

And lots of people work and having caring duties too.

So, no. I don't think society relies on economically inactive people to fulfill these roles